Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Immigration Reform


Recommended Posts

brianthephysicist
Posted

I found this in my email today. Four principles from the president on reforming our immigration policy. From what I'm hearing, he's getting some bipartisan support on this one, which is an extremely good sign. I'm especially excited about parts 3 and 4, which are very much needed. I really like where this is heading 8{D

 

fb_520x989_immi_system_long.jpg

Posted

i haven't read up on this stuff, so bear with me.

 

how does this proposal stack up against laws that are already on the books? if they don't enforce the laws that are already on the books regarding immigration laws, what good is making more laws going to do ?

Posted

I'd be interested to hear that too, but share Brian's excitement on points 3 and 4.  A lot of "illegal" immigrants already pay taxes to an extent through their paychecks.  Also first generation immigrants, legal and illegal, are shown to be among the least criminal segment of society (well, other than the breaking the law coming here).  Plus, the current system is really murky on a number of things, such as people who were brought here at a young age, don't speak the language of their home nation, but if caught would be deported to a place they don't know and to a language they don't speak.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Should we bring this to the Debate Table before Hasan and Winchester get here, or should we just wait until they start posting?

Posted

I support free and unhindered immigration. :|

Posted

Payroll taxes...and illegal immigrants...taxation without representation.

 

I feel bad for illegal immigrants who

1) were taken here as young children, went to school and had NO idea they were illegal

2) people who legally entered and overstayed because they love America

3) mothers/fathers who leave their families to work for pennies a day and are coheresed to do so*

 

 

*this can be solved by moving more of our manufacturing and outsourcing to Mexico, Guatemala, over India and China.  Companies that knowingly hire illegal workers also usually abuse them.  They are often recruited, too.  Companies who do this should not only be repremandided but pay remediation and those employees should be granted amnesty.  Book to read----Enrique's Journey.

 

 

I know the plight of LEGAL immigrants and they have pity for illegal immigrants...I have a good friend from Indonesia who told me that she'd probably be an illegal immigrant if Indonesia touched the US.  Their lives are unimaginably bad.

 

Those who come here for criminal reasons, etc should be peanliezed by work houses.

Posted (edited)

I support free and unhindered immigration. :|

 

I don't think it has to be free and unhindered, but I also refuse to criminalize and villainize it. Immigration is a part of human life, whether people have papers or not...figure out a way to deal with the dangerous aspects without high horse legalism and nationalism. That's the goal, IMO.

Edited by Era Might
Posted (edited)

Payroll taxes...and illegal immigrants...taxation without representation.

 

I feel bad for illegal immigrants who

1) were taken here as young children, went to school and had NO idea they were illegal

2) people who legally entered and overstayed because they love America

I agree with you to a point, but:

 

- They have to pay payroll tax without being willing to do what it takes to be represented. Why is becoming a represented citizen not an option for them? Why does living and operating in this country without doing what it takes to be a citizen something that necessarily excludes them from paying taxes in a country that they reap the benefits of?

 

1. How can parents not know that they are doing that to their kids when they illegally enter the US?  This seems strange to me.

 

2. If they love America so much, why can't they respect it enough to respect our laws and go through the legal processes to rightfully be here.

 

I support pathways to citizenship, but we cannot completely disregard the law, and doing so is not fair to those of us who are legal.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

I second moving this to debate table ... it is a topic bound to become heated.  And due to the community that I am actively involved with, I really don't want to see the discussion here.

 

 

Posted

I agree with you to a point, but:

 

- They have to pay payroll tax without being willing to do what it takes to be represented. Why is becoming a represented citizen not an option for them? Why does living and operating in this country without doing what it takes to be a citizen something that necessarily excludes them from paying taxes in a country that they reap the benefits of?

 

Again, there are predatory "companies" that help transport and then employ illegals for substandard wages.  These are mostly men for fields and women for cleaning/manufacturing jobs.

 

 

1. How can parents not know that they are doing that to their kids when they illegally enter the US?  This seems strange to me.

 

 

Parents know it's wrong, but the kids who were 5 or under had absolutely no choice and sometimes don't even rememeber their "native land".  They grow up American, in school and with friends and build their whole life here.  Then they graduate high-school and find they can't go to college or get a job or a car, etc.  Should they go back to a country with a language they don't speak?  What their parents did was VERY wrong...but they had no control.

 

2. If they love America so much, why can't they respect it enough to respect our laws and go through the legal processes to rightfully be here.

 

Some try.  I know that my friend from Indonesia has friends who've disappeared into the US and get by hoping that they will not be found by ICE.  They did persue legal means, but there are so many people who prey on immigrants they sometimes find they are here illegally before they even realized it.  Immigration is rife with scams....turning people with the best intention into illegals.  The governemnt is no better.  My friend filed an extension of her visa TWO YEARS before it was due, she called once a month and was assured that it was fine and she would get confirmation "soon".  Two days before her visa expired she was informed she didn't have all the paperwork and due to being "late" had to collect letters from over 15 people.  They are much loved in our community and the Bishop was reached and wrote a letter.  But they were lucky that they had people willing to write all night and find notaries.

 

I support pathways to citizenship, but we cannot completely disregard the law, and doing so is not fair to those of us who are legal.

 

Fair is a funny word...becuase immigration is hard work...but if you are educated and have resources it's tangible and doable.  If you are poor, undeducated, even if your a hard worker, their is a huge chance you will be prey, and the goverment (again even if your self supporting) gives you a hard time.

Posted

Again, there are predatory "companies" that help transport and then employ illegals for substandard wages.  These are mostly men for fields and women for cleaning/manufacturing jobs.

 

 

Parents know it's wrong, but the kids who were 5 or under had absolutely no choice and sometimes don't even rememeber their "native land".  They grow up American, in school and with friends and build their whole life here.  Then they graduate high-school and find they can't go to college or get a job or a car, etc.  Should they go back to a country with a language they don't speak?  What their parents did was VERY wrong...but they had no control.

 

Some try.  I know that my friend from Indonesia has friends who've disappeared into the US and get by hoping that they will not be found by ICE.  They did persue legal means, but there are so many people who prey on immigrants they sometimes find they are here illegally before they even realized it.  Immigration is rife with scams....turning people with the best intention into illegals.  The governemnt is no better.  My friend filed an extension of her visa TWO YEARS before it was due, she called once a month and was assured that it was fine and she would get confirmation "soon".  Two days before her visa expired she was informed she didn't have all the paperwork and due to being "late" had to collect letters from over 15 people.  They are much loved in our community and the Bishop was reached and wrote a letter.  But they were lucky that they had people willing to write all night and find notaries.

 

 

Fair is a funny word...becuase immigration is hard work...but if you are educated and have resources it's tangible and doable.  If you are poor, undeducated, even if your a hard worker, their is a huge chance you will be prey, and the goverment (again even if your self supporting) gives you a hard time.

Those predatory companies should be punished if they are in the US. The government can no more be responsible for keeping them in the US than it is responsible for those citizen's who lost pensions from Enron or some other criminal business actions.

 

Each country has a responsibility to it's citizens. If a foreign nation has a lot of nationals getting preyed on for illegal work at lower wages, the best way to deal with is two fold. The US needs to punish such companies severely for breaking the law. Injustice can be dealt with to create laws against this that punish the criminals. Also, within that other country, the situations that lead to people falling for this and the ignorance of this needs to be addressed by the foreign governments involved (national, state, etc.) and by the people of that country who best understand and have the ability to communicate and educate within that country. If this is dealt with solely by the US, if our national bears all of the responsibility of the this, we cannot adequately protect the vulnerable.

 


Parents know it's wrong, but the kids who were 5 or under had absolutely no choice and sometimes don't even rememeber their "native land".  They grow up American, in school and with friends and build their whole life here.  Then they graduate high-school and find they can't go to college or get a job or a car, etc.  Should they go back to a country with a language they don't speak?  What their parents did was VERY wrong...but they had no control.

 
The California DREAM (Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors) Act is a package of California state laws that allow children who were brought into the US under the age of 16 without proper visas/immigration documentation who have attended school on a regular basis and otherwise meet in-state tuition and GPA requirements to apply for student financial aid benefits.[1] It and past similarly-named legislation have been authored by California State Senator Gil Cedillo. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_DREAM_Act [Legal residents' taxes pay for that financial aid. Their parents often don't pay taxes to support education. That is a state issue instead of a federal issue, but it is also not fair. They should have an opportunity to apply to a legal resident status to allow them to obtain employment and work toward citizenship, but they are entitled to more college education money (at least prior to being 24 years old) because their parents broke the laws than students whose parents simply withhold college money (again, prior to 24 when financial aid becomes independent of parents income).

 

One of the differences between your friend and some other illegal people here is that she tried to stay legal. That should be rewarded. Those who have not tried to stay legal and have dismissed the law should not be entitled to as much protection by the law that they dismissed.  I am not well educated on current legislation about this, but I do believe that this is an important distinction.

 

The funniest thing about fair is that as much as we strive for it, as much as we may achieve it in some  ways, we will never entirely have fairness in society.  Life will never be entirely fair.

Posted

I don't have it in me to argue, too tired.  But before this gets punted to Debate Table...I respect anyone who is willing to risk their lives to give their family a better life than they would otherwise have the option to attain.

Posted

When my grandparents came, they were poor and uneducated and looking for a better life. There weren't visas back then. They just got on a boat and came. I followed the rules to immigrate to Canada. There are rules and laws. I don't see why people can't follow them. Real refugees fleeing war are the exceptions.

Posted

When my grandparents came, they were poor and uneducated and looking for a better life. There weren't visas back then. They just got on a boat and came. I followed the rules to immigrate to Canada. There are rules and laws. I don't see why people can't follow them. Real refugees fleeing war are the exceptions.

 

It's not that easy anymore...there are reams of forms and even those fleeing persecution or war are not givens.

Posted (edited)

When my grandparents came, they were poor and uneducated and looking for a better life. There weren't visas back then. They just got on a boat and came. I followed the rules to immigrate to Canada. There are rules and laws. I don't see why people can't follow them. Real refugees fleeing war are the exceptions.

 

There are laws of nature as well, by that I mean human society follows certain predictable behaviors and phenomena. Human migration is one of them. The laws of civil society have to be accommodating to reality or else they're useless. The idea that invisible boundaries and rules is going to stop such a common human phenomenon is not realistic. So the idea, I think, is to be more creative rather than trying to just frustrate the phenomenon.

Edited by Era Might
brianthephysicist
Posted

My bad, guys, I didn't mean to start a debate.  I thought everyone would be happy about this one.  Shows how forgetful I am lololololol.

 

I feel genuinely bad for the people that tried to come to the US legally and were spat in the face by our broken immigration system.  That's why I want this reform so badly.  Make it reasonable to do legally and the only people we'll have trying to enter illegally are those coming here with ill intent (or possibly those seeking asylum from war, but that's a whole 'nother can of worms).

 

I'm not sure what to do about people already here illegally.  I don't believe it to be wise to "ship them back", but I also don't believe it does our society any good to go "bamf" and make them legal aliens.  There needs to be some kind of reconciliation, some way of saying yes, there is a punishment for breaking the law, but it is mitigated by our recognition that the law was not entirely just in its execution.  I honestly don't know where that line should be, but the fine proposed in the 4 bullet points above sounds like a reasonable starting point from which debate might glean a better option.  I'm interested in hearing what people think would be appropriate in this regard.

Posted

Constitutionally speaking, no one is allowed to bestow upon themselves citizenship in the US. That is an act only Congress can give. I've given the example a zillion times whereby a French diplomat is here, his wife gives birth here, but the child is a French citizen, not a US Citizen.

 

14th Amendment, Section I states: "Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."

 

The French parents are under the jurisdiction of the French government and so are their children unless this family became naturalized US Citizens.

 

So, illegal immigrants, who cross the borders, undetected, etc. with or without children cannot bestow upon themselves US citizenship. It is pretty darn clear.

 

Now we hear about those children who were born here or taken into the country unwittingly, etc. What to do about them? What hard ship is bestowed upon them. But don't we have prisons filled with men and women who also have children? Do we let their parents out so they can care for their children? 

 

Can an American run across the border to Canada or Mexico and do the same? Mexico's stance on illegal immigration is pretty amazing: http://factreal.wordpress.com/2010/05/08/mexico-vs-united-states-mexican-immigration-laws-are-tougher/ They treat illegal immigration as a felony. Take a look at how "extreme" their laws are.

 

Canada is no cake walk either http://www.canadaupdates.com/content/new-tougher-canada-laws-curb-illegal-immigration-15819.html

 

And what of those who apply to come here legally, waiting years, decades and that can actually contribute to the betterment of America, assimilate, etc. not for big government dole outs (welfare, medicare, etc.) but to advance this country.

 

Then you have to ask, how does it help the host country? Can localities that are border states afford the cost of illegals who are not contributing. Can you imagine going to another country, expect them to speak your language, give you free medical care, pocket money because you managed to walk yourself in without applying to that country.

 

Good luck trying to take up residence in France or Spain or Russia and get anything but a jail sentence.

Posted

Countries be damned. I am interested in what people are helped or harmed.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Well, there's a reason why half the office space at the USCCB is for migrant relief services.  

 

The fact is, much of the agriculture industry is incredibly dependent on migrant worker labor, many of whom are of dubious legal status.  There literally would be no one to pick apples in Washington State if you kicked all of them out, let alone other kinds of produce in other states. So in a very real way our economy depends on these people.  I like that word brian used - some kind of reconciliation is needed.  Our system desperately needs reform.  

 

My bible studies professor just became a citizen, and he's been here for ten years with a green card, obtained through working at my university.  It took him and his family a long time (this country is the only one his daughter has ever really known), and he had the equivalent of corporate sponsorship. I can't imagine what it's like for the people trying to do it on their own. 

 

I really like the ideas coming out of the White House that you've posted in the OP, but I'm not sure how we're going to make that a reality. 

Posted

Should we bring this to the Debate Table before Hasan and Winchester get here, or should we just wait until they start posting?

I doubt that Winchester and I disagree on this.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...