eagle_eye222001 Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 I really like the ideas coming out of the White House that you've posted in the OP, but I'm not sure how we're going to make that a reality. That is the million dollar question....what's going to actually happen?
Nihil Obstat Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 I doubt that Winchester and I disagree on this. I would have expected you to support generous, but strictly enforced border control.
God the Father Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 Real refugees fleeing war are the exceptions. Mexico is a warzone. The border needs to be opened because the country clearly and desperately needs hardworking but uneducated individuals to do its menial labor. Drug trafficking, violence, and intimidation are crimes and should be treated as such. Coming to America to escape violence and work for a living? Nah.
4588686 Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 I would have expected you to support generous, but strictly enforced border control. I don't have a problem with border control that is used to disrupt things like human trafficking. I have a big problem with Bill Clinton and the Mexican government government passing 'free trade' legislation that lets the heavily subsidized American agro-industry drive Mexican farmers out of business and then allowing the continuance of immigration law the keeps these immigrants and economically abusive conditions when they flee to America to survive. I wouldn't just abolish national borders tomorrow because I think that would have a lot of very negative unintended consequences but I think the elimination of national borders that do interfere with free travel should be a goal that we work towards. I think that migration should be a basic human right.
zabbazooey Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 (edited) I'm not debating, but my major has me feeling uneasy about requiring English to be learned to grant citizenship. I can't quite put my finger on it. Maybe enrolled in English courses, or require proof that they are working towards that goal. Who's going to pay for these classes if the illegals can't? Maybe a non-profit could be started? I will say though, I was at a Chinese restaurant on Christmas Eve and the waitress barely spoke any English. It was so frustrating. My fiance ordered COKE. When he needed a refill all she could say was, "You want Diet Coke?" "No, he is drinking regular Coke." "You want Diet Coke?" "NO, REGULAR COKE." "Diet?" "OH MY GOSH, FINE" Seriously, get out of the Unites States' service industry if you can't speak competent English, at least enough to perform the duties of your position. I dunno what my point was, lol. I'm trying to gather my thoughts. Edited February 1, 2013 by zabbazooey
Era Might Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 Below that cool green sea of money, millions and millions of people fight to live, search for pearls in the darkest depths of their dreams, hold their breath for years trying to cross poverty to just having something. The children are dead already. We are killing them, that is what America should be saying; on TV, in the streets, in offices, should be saying, “We aren’t giving the children a chance to live.†Mexicans are taking our jobs, they say instead. What they really say is, let them die, and the children too. –Jimmy Santiago Baca, 1977
4588686 Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 I'm not debating, but my major has me feeling uneasy about requiring English to be learned to grant citizenship. I can't quite put my finger on it. Maybe enrolled in English courses, or require proof that they are working towards that goal. Who's going to pay for these classes if the illegals can't? Maybe a non-profit could be started? There are non-profits all over the nation do that. I currently volunteer at one. I have a meeting tomorrow with a student of mine from Peru. It's hard. She's here legally and works two jobs and I work two jobs. That makes it difficult to coordinate and it means that she is really taxed for free time. Her English is fine but she wants to go to college and it's hard to get proficient in reading and writing when you don't have hours a week to study. I will say though, I was at a Chinese restaurant on Christmas Eve and the waitress barely spoke any English. It was so frustrating. My fiance ordered COKE. When he needed a refill all she could say was, "You want Diet Coke?" "No, he is drinking regular Coke." "You want Diet Coke?" "NO, REGULAR COKE." "Diet?" "OH MY GOSH, FINE" Seriously, get out of the Unites States' service industry if you can't speak competent English, at least enough to perform the duties of your position. I dunno what my point was, lol. I'm trying to gather my thoughts. That's a horrible story of the anguish that Americans face daily in dealing with people who have left an authoritarian state and are trying to make an honest living.
zabbazooey Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 (edited) I appreciate her trying to make an honest living, I don't have the greatest job either but I work to make ends meet, but I am sorry, you should speak okay enough English to be wait staff at a restaurant. It takes proficient language skills to provide decent customer service, to properly take orders, and to take care of your tables. She could not because she didn't speak English. I am sure she would make a great waitress if she were at a restaurant where she could utilize her native language. But she wasn't, she was at waitress at a Chinese restaurant in Kansas. I'm sorry if I sound harsh, but there are other jobs in the restaurant that you can do if you do not possess proficient language skills for the restaurant and country that you work in. And that's cool that non-profits like that exist. Thank you for your hard work and dedication! Edited February 1, 2013 by zabbazooey
zabbazooey Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 For instance, I managed a place where a gentleman made sandwiches but could do everything else with ease. Even take orders. He was a fantastic employee. But he wasn't comfortable with cashiering because he couldn't articulate what he wanted to say to the customers in English. Is it fair? No. But it's business and places need to make money.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 For what it's worth, I'm kicking myself for not learning Spanish (or at least taking a few classes in high school). I'm starting to look for parish jobs, and SO MANY say "bilingual preferred" or "required" etc.
zabbazooey Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 Basilisa - me too. I thought my mom was soooo stupid when she tried to get me to take Spanish instead of French in middle school/high school. Oh mom what do you know, you've only been around twice as long as I have... I tried taking a class in college but it was so similar to French that it messed me up and it was really hard to learn. My cousin is a Spanish teacher and tutor. Too bad we can't stand each others company lol. Everything is bilingual preferred. I'm a barista and they even asked me during my interview if I spoke Spanish. And that's a minimum wage (+ tips) job.
Autumn Dusk Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 I appreciate her trying to make an honest living, I don't have the greatest job either but I work to make ends meet, but I am sorry, you should speak okay enough English to be wait staff at a restaurant. It takes proficient language skills to provide decent customer service, to properly take orders, and to take care of your tables. She could not because she didn't speak English. I am sure she would make a great waitress if she were at a restaurant where she could utilize her native language. But she wasn't, she was at waitress at a Chinese restaurant in Kansas. I'm sorry if I sound harsh, but there are other jobs in the restaurant that you can do if you do not possess proficient language skills for the restaurant and country that you work in. And that's cool that non-profits like that exist. Thank you for your hard work and dedication! But that immigrant was most likely legal....which really has little bearing on illegal activities. Most illegal immigrants will do anything to learn English including pay cash to community colleges in the tune of $300-$400 to make sure they aren't suspected of being illegal. We knew because they had no ID, no perminant address, etc. The legal immigrants who were going on the goverment's dime were typically much more laze-faire and would scrupously produce ID when asked the simplest things....and often took 5-6 years to complete the 30 month program.
Anomaly Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 How about Mexico fixing their corrupt government and society. No need, the population can leave and it's someone else's problem, leaving the wealthy and powerful free to do what they've been doing. Just let them come to the US where the Politicians will use them as a pawn to take over even more personal wealth. Of course, the Politicians get a great living and power out of it, while the "middle class" is paying the bill. It'll work for a generation or two. Ever notice that people migrate to get away from manipulation and control or to get free stuff? How many people can the US taxpayer support who can't work because there are few jobs that people can contribute to the economy. There isn't an endless pool of money that pays for all this. Visit the GAO and see wherre the money comes from. 82% comes from payroll and personal income tax. The uber wealthy and politicians aren't going to give up what they have because they don't have too and can't be forced to. If you feel morally moved to help the plight of the poor and you live here in the US, then why don't you and your family move to a small studio apartment, give up the personal car, iPhone, cell bill, eating at Red Lobster, vacation, the expensive college education that won't get you a paying job, cable TV bill, pleasure travel for vacation, and send them the money. Why force others who may not feel the same way so you can keep your iPhone?
Nihil Obstat Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 If you feel morally moved to help the plight of the poor and you live here in the US, then why don't you and your family move to a small studio apartment, give up the personal car, iPhone, cell bill, eating at Red Lobster, vacation, the expensive college education that won't get you a paying job, cable TV bill, pleasure travel for vacation, and send them the money. Why force others who may not feel the same way so you can keep your iPhone? Did you actually just use Red Lobster as an example of obscene luxury? :|
Anomaly Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 Did you actually just use Red Lobster as an example of obscene luxury? :| It's a luxury for me. I'm sure it's a luxury for immigrants and other poor as well. Since you support free and unhindered immigration, what are you going to do to help get food, housing, clothing, medical care, education. Propose that I pay for it while you scoff at Red Lobster being a luxury?
Era Might Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 How about Mexico fixing their corrupt government and society. No need, the population can leave and it's someone else's problem, leaving the wealthy and powerful free to do what they've been doing. Just let them come to the US where the Politicians will use them as a pawn to take over even more personal wealth. Of course, the Politicians get a great living and power out of it, while the "middle class" is paying the bill. It'll work for a generation or two. Ever notice that people migrate to get away from manipulation and control or to get free stuff? How many people can the US taxpayer support who can't work because there are few jobs that people can contribute to the economy. There isn't an endless pool of money that pays for all this. Visit the GAO and see wherre the money comes from. 82% comes from payroll and personal income tax. The uber wealthy and politicians aren't going to give up what they have because they don't have too and can't be forced to. If you feel morally moved to help the plight of the poor and you live here in the US, then why don't you and your family move to a small studio apartment, give up the personal car, iPhone, cell bill, eating at Red Lobster, vacation, the expensive college education that won't get you a paying job, cable TV bill, pleasure travel for vacation, and send them the money. Why force others who may not feel the same way so you can keep your iPhone? If we can't find a way to build positively with 11 million immigrants, how would we have accommodated the adults we would have if there were not 50 million abortions?
add Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 i haven't read up on this stuff, so bear with me. how does this proposal stack up against laws that are already on the books? if they don't enforce the laws that are already on the books regarding immigration laws, what good is making more laws going to do ? you mean besides sway the election?
Anomaly Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 If we can't find a way to build positively with 11 million immigrants, how would we have accommodated the adults we would have if there were not 50 million abortions? I guess at a point people would realize that the Government cannot do the job of feeding, clothing, housing, and providing health care for everyone if there aren't enough people in the economy to support the largess and will find that they are responsible to feed and clothe themselves and their children and would have had to face the hard decision to either not get themselves or others pregnant by abstaining or using contraception. If the Government and others can't feed them, and they can't feed themselves, I guess they would starve. Why can't the society in Mexico provide for them? Why have children that you can't or won't provide for? Why did God kick humanity out of Eden where we are required to work to live and eat? Unhindered immigration only deals with a societal symptom, it does not address the fundamental cause of the problems in Mexico or other countries that have problems. Why should the residents of Mexico (just using them as a convenience) revolt or rebel or change their society and government because it isn't working for them? It's easier to abandon their home, their society, their family, their neighbors, their culture, thier Government and move to America, essentially as a second class person, because the rewards are easier.
Era Might Posted February 1, 2013 Posted February 1, 2013 (edited) I guess at a point people would realize that the Government cannot do the job of feeding, clothing, housing, and providing health care for everyone if there aren't enough people in the economy to support the largess and will find that they are responsible to feed and clothe themselves and their children and would have had to face the hard decision to either not get themselves or others pregnant by abstaining or using contraception. If the Government and others can't feed them, and they can't feed themselves, I guess they would starve. Why can't the society in Mexico provide for them? Why have children that you can't or won't provide for? Why did God kick humanity out of Eden where we are required to work to live and eat? Unhindered immigration only deals with a societal symptom, it does not address the fundamental cause of the problems in Mexico or other countries that have problems. Why should the residents of Mexico (just using them as a convenience) revolt or rebel or change their society and government because it isn't working for them? It's easier to abandon their home, their society, their family, their neighbors, their culture, thier Government and move to America, essentially as a second class person, because the rewards are easier. I don't know who these leeching immigrants are you are referring to, but the illegal immigrants I know come here to work. I have a family member who has lived here illegally for more than 10 years. When she first came here she slept maybe 3 or 4 hours a night, worked herself crazy (I can't even work that hard, and wouldn't want to). She has a 10 year old son born here, a citizen of the country who speaks English, goes to school, goes to church, a very normal boy. She frequently sends money back home to help her family. Times are tough for her right now...work was a lot better when she got here. But if she is a problem in society, I don't have much interest in fixing it. As far as people trying to change their home countries, that is a need, but people ARE trying to change their countries. It ain't easy. At the end of the day, people just want to work, feed their family, and stay alive...whether they do it here or there, they just want to do it. That doesn't mean there aren't activists and people doing they best they can where they are. If it wasn't for people leaving their home, their society, their family, their neighbors, their culture, their Government and moving to America, there never would have been a Plymouth Plantation. Maybe if Europeans never immigrated here, we wouldn't have the problems we have now...but they did, and we do. Edited February 1, 2013 by Era Might
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now