Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Cool. I joined. Cardinal Ouellet, as Benedict XVII, on day 3. I was a bit torn between Ouellet and Scola, but my guy tells me Ouellet has a better chance. ;)

PhuturePriest
Posted

Cool. I joined. Cardinal Ouellet, as Benedict XVII, on day 3. I was a bit torn between Ouellet and Scola, but my guy tells me Ouellet has a better chance. ;)

 


I voted Ouellet as well, but I voted on day six. Something tells me the Cardinals will take a while, especially considering that this time around it absolutely must be a 2-3rds majority. The other ways of electing a Pope if 2-3rds cannot be reached are not allowed to be used this time. I have a feeling we may have to tear the roof off that building...

Posted


I voted Ouellet as well, but I voted on day six. Something tells me the Cardinals will take a while, especially considering that this time around it absolutely must be a 2-3rds majority. The other ways of electing a Pope if 2-3rds cannot be reached are not allowed to be used this time. I have a feeling we may have to tear the roof off that building...

I suppose the 2/3 rule is relevant this time around. Still, conclaves in recent generations simply do not tend to last that long. I think six days is probably significantly outside what we will actually see.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I suppose the 2/3 rule is relevant this time around. Still, conclaves in recent generations simply do not tend to last that long. I think six days is probably significantly outside what we will actually see.

 

I have absolutely no experience in conclave elections, so I don't know how long they normally last. How long have the past three lasted?

Posted (edited)

Cardinal Ouellet, Day 3 (I really thought about going with Day 4), Pope Pius XIII



I have absolutely no experience in conclave elections, so I don't know how long they normally last. How long have the past three lasted?

 

Benedict and John Paul I were both elected on the 2nd day. John Paul II was on the 3rd day.

Edited by TeDeum
Posted

Benedict and John Paul I were both elected on the 2nd day. John Paul II was on the 3rd day.

When I was looking it up a couple weeks ago, I found that no conclave lasted even a full week during all of the 1900s, and obviously 2005 as well. Only a few of them lasted longer than three or four days. I did not check any further back than that.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Oullet, Day 2, John XXIV.  

 

My theory is that it's going to whittle down to two or three candidates the first day - I'd bet my next paycheck that all the cardinals have been thinking and praying about who they'd vote for since Benedict announced his resignation, and they've all got shortlists. 

 

Either that or it's gonna last six days and we'll get a complete surprise. 

 

And I just think John XXIII is ballin'.  :|

homeschoolmom
Posted

Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio

Day 2

Pope Francis

 

Posted

That is so cool. But I can't play because I'm not American or Canadian. :cry:

 

But anyway, Ouelett, day 3, Paul VII

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

I will vote tomorrow.

Posted

Just purely IMO, the regnal name Paul VII would at this point be a bad sign. Rightly or wrongly, and regardless of your opinion of Paul VI, picking that name would indicate an intent to roll back Pope Benedict's liturgical initiatives, and refer back to Paul VI's very aggressive renovation* of the liturgy.

All in all, I think "Paul VII" would send a message of backing away from Pope Benedict's pontificate. Again, this is just speculation on my part.

 

*more accurately, Paul VI's approval of the aggressive renovations proposed by Bugnini and the rest.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Just purely IMO, the regnal name Paul VII would at this point be a bad sign. Rightly or wrongly, and regardless of your opinion of Paul VI, picking that name would indicate an intent to roll back Pope Benedict's liturgical initiatives, and refer back to Paul VI's very aggressive renovation* of the liturgy.

All in all, I think "Paul VII" would send a message of backing away from Pope Benedict's pontificate. Again, this is just speculation on my part.

 

*more accurately, Paul VI's approval of the aggressive renovations proposed by Bugnini and the rest.

 

IMHO the regnal names of John, Paul, or John Paul are a little over saturated for the time being. I hope the next Pope picks one that hasn't been used in a while.
 

Posted

We should try to reconcile the SSPV really quickly, while we are both on the same page with the whole See of Rome being vacant thing. :| Might not have another opportunity of common ground like this for ten years or more.



IMHO the regnal names of John, Paul, or John Paul are a little over saturated for the time being. I hope the next Pope picks one that hasn't been used in a while.
 

I have been speculating for a while that Benedict XVII is most likely, and would indicate "business as usual". More likely for someone like Ouellet or Scola, who are very close to Benedict in all relevant respects.

 

Pius XIII would make me a very happy camper though. 

 

Of course, I will not be surprised if something comes completely out of the blue. I am just enjoying my time of speculating wildly.

Posted

We should try to reconcile the SSPV really quickly, while we are both on the same page with the whole See of Rome being vacant thing. :| Might not have another opportunity of common ground like this for ten years or more.


rotfl

Posted

Cardinal Sarr

 

Day 2

 

Pius XIII

Posted (edited)

Cardinal Sarr
 
Day 2
 
Pius XIII

Archbishop of Dakar. Marcel Lefebvre's old see (previously apostolic vicariate). :)

Apparently Archbishop Lefebver is still very highly regarded in Dakar and Gabon. He did a lot of really, really great work there. He was one of the best.

 

Why do you think it will be Cardinal Sarr?

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Posted

Archbishop of Dakar. Marcel Lefebvre's old see (previously apostolic vicariate). :)

Apparently Archbishop Lefebver is still very highly regarded in Dakar and Gabon. He did a lot of really, really great work there. He was one of the best.

 

Why do you think it will be Cardinal Sarr?

 

1. I just have a little feeling. 

2. He was my "adopted cardinal."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...