Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Not really. Being an American isn't a sex scandal.

 

Wait until the media gets their hands on it.

Posted

Oh, why not?

Cardinal Burke

Day 3

John XXIV

Who knows, maybe I'll win $300, HA!

 


mind you it's  not $300 cash but $300 in cool prizes :) They have a $100 visa gift card drawing on top of that if you  follow/promote them on twitter.

Posted

Wait until the media gets their hands on it.


The media regularly attacks the Catholic Church on two things: the Pope's wealth (which he would still have even if he came from the poorest country in the world), and sex scandals. Those are flashy, pretty little things that sound great at the water cooler, but his nationality? Who cares?

Seriously, this is the first time I've heard anyone say an American couldn't be Pope for media reasons. If that's the real issue then that is entirely a construct within Catholic minds.
Posted (edited)

The media regularly attacks the Catholic Church on two things: the Pope's wealth (which he would still have even if he came from the poorest country in the world), and sex scandals. Those are flashy, pretty little things that sound great at the water cooler, but his nationality? Who cares?

Seriously, this is the first time I've heard anyone say an American couldn't be Pope for media reasons. If that's the real issue then that is entirely a construct within Catholic minds.

 

The Cardinals care, seeing as the Pope was almost always an Italian. This recent "let's select someone from outside Italy" thing is still only two Popes old. Nationality DOES matter, along with a whole bunch of other stuff...the Cardinals don't just select people based on their holiness.

Edited by Era Might
Posted


mind you it's not $300 cash but $300 in cool prizes :) They have a $100 visa gift card drawing on top of that if you follow/promote them on twitter.


Could I get free pizza from Papa Johns?

The Cardinals care, seeing as the Pope was almost always an Italian. This recent "let's select someone from outside Italy" thing is still only two Popes old. Nationality DOES matter, along with a whole bunch of other stuff...the Cardinals don't just select people based on their holiness.


I know that. Beyond that there's the idea that if the Church should serve the poor, the Pope should come from a poor country. These are all good arguments for why an American won't be elected Pope, but they are not media scandals as you were suggesting.
Posted

Could I get free pizza from Papa Johns?


I know that. Beyond that there's the idea that if the Church should serve the poor, the Pope should come from a poor country. These are all good arguments for why an American won't be elected Pope, but they are not media scandals as you were suggesting.

 

The sex scandals will absolutely be a factor in the election, and the United States is ground zero for the scandals...it was just a few weeks ago that Cardinal Mahoney was relieved of duties by his successor.

Posted

The sex scandals will absolutely be a factor in the election, and the United States is ground zero for the scandals...it was just a few weeks ago that Cardinal Mahoney was relieved of duties by his successor.


Your reading too much into nationality. Just because one American cardinal was involved in a sex scandal doesn't nessacirly mean they all are.

Oh, and Europe has had just as much problems with this. A recent scandal involving an Irish Cardinal immediately comes to mind.
Posted (edited)

Your reading too much into nationality. Just because one American cardinal was involved in a sex scandal doesn't nessacirly mean they all are.

Oh, and Europe has had just as much problems with this. A recent scandal involving an Irish Cardinal immediately comes to mind.

 

I didn't say they all are. But if there is any dirt on an American Pope, whatever it is, the media will dig it up. They will turn over every corner. If you think media scandal isn't an issue in the Vatican, you must have missed recent news...an American Pope certainly won't do anything to decrease the media pressure. There are also other issues with an American Pope (foreign policy perceptions, for example).

Edited by Era Might
Posted (edited)


I didn't say they all are. But if there is any dirt on an American Pope, whatever it is, the media will dig it up. They will turn over every corner. If you think the media scandal isn't an issue in the Vatican, you must have missed recent news...an American Pope certainly won't do anything to decrease the media pressure. There are also other issues with an American Pope (foreign policy perceptions, for example).


The media will try just as hard to dig up dirt on a Pope of any nationality. I really don't get where you're coming from. Edited by r2Dtoo
Posted

My guess is that it was uncovered more in the US.

Evangetholic
Posted

Winchester that Ole Lady you are using as your avatar challenges my chastity.

Posted

The media will try just as hard to dig up dirt on a Pope of any nationality. I really don't get where you're coming from.

 

Of course it will. But an American Pope will only add more fuel to any fire that comes up. Just as it was a HUGE deal in Poland to have a Pole elected to the papacy.

Posted

Winchester that Ole Lady you are using as your avatar challenges my chastity.

 


She ain't bad looking. I heard she's kind of got a mouth, on her, though.

Evangetholic
Posted


She ain't bad looking. I heard she's kind of got a mouth, on her, though.

 


<3 Who is she?

Posted


<3 Who is she?

 


Diane Rhem.

Posted


Diane Rhem.

 

Oh I thought it was Phyllis Diller.

Posted

ewwwww

 


 I have my reasons.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Cardinal Burke

Day 3

Pope Joseph



 


lol, i picked Pope Joseph. :)

 

I'm all for Burke. He personally supports Michael Voris, you know. ;)

DiscerningCatholic
Posted (edited)

Cardinal Abril y Castello

Day 8

Pope John Paul III

Edited by DiscerningCatholic

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...