Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Cardinal Dolan And Vp Biden


Recommended Posts

Fidei Defensor
Posted

Of course it is if there is a God.  I'm not arguing that it shouldn't be done.  If there is no God and we just happened then why is common decency anything is my point?  BTW don't get me wrong either and try make a point that atheists have morality.  The book of Romans tells us they do.  Rom 2 says God put his laws on all men's hearts.  That is why it is common decency.

Really, I am under no obligation to anyone but myself. However, I choose to be decent, to be kind, to love.  I don't need a god to tell me to do that.  If the only reason you are a good person is because your god tells you, then I contend that it is I who is moral because I don't need incentives.

Debra Little
Posted

Article here.

 

 

 

I have a bunch of thoughts about this. First, how can clergy ever be 100% sure that a Catholic like Biden shouldn't receive? What if he had a "eureka" moment the night before and went to confession before Mass?

 

Furthermore, Biden's said that he's pro-life but as a politician he doesn't want to impose his faith on others. Assuming that he considers abortion a theological rather than humanitarian issue, what's everyone's thoughts on this? That the Joe Biden at St. Patrick's was Biden the man, the Catholic, there to practice his faith, not Biden the politician? For example, at work I've found myself in positions where I've had to been neutral, where I've had to "mute" my Catholic mind - this is when I've been consulted by patients with mental illness and or substance abuse, not co-workers. When a young man opened up about a date he had that evening with a gentleman that seemed like the right person, or when a young woman confided that she had unprotected sex, took Plan B, and what now? These are the kinds of situations where I'm put in a difficult position. As a Catholic, I'm not to advocate a homosexual relationship or contraception/abortifacients, but as a mental health professional, I'm to be as open-minded and accepting as possible. I'm not about to refer someone to Planned Parenthood, but it's also not my place to tell them that premarital sex and contraception are immoral. Is it possible that Biden is a legitimate Catholic who's trying to separate his faith life from his professional career? Especially a career that's meant to listen to and welcome everyone's perspectives and opinions, even when so many of them conflict?

 

It seems that's been my approach with all the gay marriage talk right now. As a Catholic, I won't support it and I'll vote against it. But other than my personal religious reasons, is it really right to impose my religious beliefs on people who don't share them - especially since marriage is both secular and religious, so long as religious institutions aren't forced to perform these kinds of ceremonies, how is it okay for my religious beliefs to influence a secular issue.

 

I'm really not sure what I think about it, it's just been on my mind.

 

 

  

 

Who cares? lol.

 

he doesn't want to rock the boat!  it sounds like he is ashamed of his faith!
 

Debra Little
Posted (edited)

 

Edited by Debra Little
Debra Little
Posted (edited)

 

Edited by Debra Little
God the Father
Posted

If you think the redefinition of an institution as ubiquitous as marriage "won't affect straight people at all," then you need to take a breath for a moment.

 

A recalibration of that nature changes everything.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Really, I am under no obligation to anyone but myself. However, I choose to be decent, to be kind, to love.  I don't need a god to tell me to do that.  If the only reason you are a good person is because your god tells you, then I contend that it is I who is moral because I don't need incentives.

 


He does  tell you. He implanted his laws on all men's hearts.  Even you the atheist has them right there.  YOu just don't acknowledge him.  Very sad indeed.  So then you go to the logical leap, false logic of well because "your a Christian you need God to tell you and that is your sole motivation".

 

  You spoke of obligation and the meaning of being a human being.  Forgive me for taking that to mean there was something outside yourself, a common decency, above us such that our rights are not just what some like minded group decides to give us or take away from us and morality is completely subjective.  If there is nothing above us there really is no obligation and how do you know that hitler and stalin weren't doing what they thought was right and were compelled to do by some evolutionary process that made them who they are?  I saw an interesting piece on public tv once about how they bread agressiveness in to black foxes and docility in to others.  Over time  they got angry foxes and docile foxes simply by picking the most angry and docile out of the litters.  So what makes the angry ones worse foxes?
 

Edited by thessalonian

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...