Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Cardinal Dolan And Vp Biden


Recommended Posts

Posted

I think you will find that for most law, you will find good reason and evidence beside a simple "it's just moral."

 

But of course, I should just have faith that the laws are for my own good, right? No evidence needed ;)

 

I agree that most (good) law is supported by good reason and evidence. And so is most morality. Morality and law have usually coincided in successful, productive cultures/societies.

 

As I read it the current culture/society, many people no longer see the good reason and evidence in morality, so they want to change the laws.

Posted

Correct. And it is supported by the fact that almost any law you look at has a practical purpose — safety, security, health. I would say that those reasons are good evidence that a law is useful besides just pointing to some vague "morality" reason.

You have just admitted that Luigi's post is correct. The enacting of laws is based upon opinion. Why is your opinion of what should be legal more valid than Luigi's? The problem with your posts so far is that you have just expressed your opinion without trying to say why you believe as you do. Luigi, as a Catholic, has the entire history of Catholic doctrine, moral theology, and the natural law teachings of the Church as a reason for believing what he does about this issue. You may not agree with those things, but at least Luigi has something that stands behind what he believes.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

You have just admitted that Luigi's post is correct. The enacting of laws is based upon opinion. Why is your opinion of what should be legal more valid than Luigi's? The problem with your posts so far is that you have just expressed your opinion without trying to say why you believe as you do. Luigi, as a Catholic, has the entire history of Catholic doctrine, moral theology, and the natural law teachings of the Church as a reason for believing what he does about this issue. You may not agree with those things, but at least Luigi has something that stands behind what he believes.

 

And Luigi has admitted that my post is correct, that most laws have good reason to be law.

 

I venture to guess that most of my opinions on what ought to be law will agree with your opinions on what ought to be law.  However, I am quite comfortable admitting that there is no ultimate "source" of morality beside the so called "collective good."  I have some personal theories that are tied to my understanding of biology that I won't get into. 

 

The issue is, however, that claiming God and faith as an ultimate source of morality and laws does not exempt one for presenting good reasons and evidence for those laws.  I am amazed at the apparent disdain for logic and reason when it is something that was allegedly a gift from God!

Posted (edited)

The issue is, however, that claiming God and faith as an ultimate source of morality and laws does not exempt one for presenting good reasons and evidence for those laws.  I am amazed at the apparent disdain for logic and reason when it is something that was allegedly a gift from God!

And over the centuries the Church has done that. The Church has always argued from a natural law perspective, and has always looked at the order of creation to determine if a particular action conforms to man's nature. That you do not agree with the Church is fine, but it would be helpful if you could explain how behavior that distorts the proper end of the conjugal act should be endorsed by the government.

Edited by Apotheoun
Fidei Defensor
Posted

And over the centuries the Church has done that. The Church has always argued from a natural law perspective, and has always looked at the order of creation to determine if a particular action conforms to man's nature. That you do not agree with the Church is fine, but it would be helpful if you could explain how behavior that distorts the proper end of the conjugal act should be endorsed by the government.

No one is distorting anything to do with "the conjugal act." Who said heterosexual couples can't procreate?  

 

I think what you mean to say is that the government shouldn't endorse an alternative lifestyle that you see as sinful.  The conjugal act can only ever occur between a man and a woman because a conjugal act is inherently linked to procreation.  However, two men or two women can have sexual relations, which no way affect you or your sacrament of marriage.

 

I wish Christians would spend more energy coming out against divorce. Divorce is arguably more destructive to the family unit than unconventional same-sex families are.

Posted

And over the centuries the Church has done that. The Church has always argued from a natural law perspective, and has always looked at the order of creation to determine if a particular action conforms to man's nature.

That's what I was trying to say. Thank you for being more articulate.

Posted

No one is distorting anything to do with "the conjugal act." Who said heterosexual couples can't procreate?  

 

I think what you mean to say is that the government shouldn't endorse an alternative lifestyle that you see as sinful.  The conjugal act can only ever occur between a man and a woman because a conjugal act is inherently linked to procreation.  However, two men or two women can have sexual relations, which no way affect you or your sacrament of marriage.

 

I wish Christians would spend more energy coming out against divorce. Divorce is arguably more destructive to the family unit than unconventional same-sex families are.

Obviously I am opposed to the government endorsing immoral activity as "legal", because that involves making everyone assent to something contrary to nature. It is not like I am advocating a change in what has always been recognized by our society as normative. But if the government tries to alter the historical understanding of marriage, which has formed the foundation of our society, by saying that two men can marry, or two women can marry, it obviously puts Christians into a situation where they must actively oppose the "law" and the government.

Posted (edited)

I wish Christians would spend more energy coming out against divorce. Divorce is arguably more destructive to the family unit than unconventional same-sex families are.

I am against divorce and I am against "same-sex marriage". Both are destructive.

Edited by Apotheoun
Fidei Defensor
Posted

Obviously I am opposed to the government endorsing immoral activity as "legal", because that involves making everyone assent to something contrary to nature. It is not like I am advocating a change in what has always been recognized by our society as normative. But if the government tries to alter the historical understanding of marriage, which has formed the foundation of our society, by saying that two men can marry, or two women can marry, it obviously puts Christians into a situation where they must actively oppose the "law" and the government.

I view it as an "in addition to" rather than "instead of." Traditional marriage is between a man and a woman. Two members of the same sex getting married is not traditional marriage.  What does it matter to anyone what other people do between themselves? You have to right to believe and act according to your own conscious but not the right to restrict others from doing the same. 

Posted

I completely disagree. All beliefs are personal. Anyone who lobbies one way or another for any law is trying to impose her personal beliefs on the general public. Government DOES legislate one version of morals over the other, every time it passes a law. That's why it's illegal to kill, steal, own slaves, use certain drugs,marry your first cousin, or have multiple spouses - those are all based on some version of morality. That's why government provides medical care, disability payments, housing, welfare, and food stamps - those are all based on some version of morality. That's why businesses are required to pay a minimum wage (a "decent living wage"), individuals are required to pay taxes (to provide services to those who can't provide for themselves), children are required to attend school until age 16, and men are required to register for the draft - those are all based on some version of morality.

 

The difference is that through most of American history, the vast majority of Americans (voters - the people whose opinions the government is supposed to enact into law) accepted basically the same version of morality. The culture is shifting now, and it's becoming increasingly difficult to find a commonly held version of morality on which to base laws.

 

I couldn't have said it better myself.   :proud:   For so long, Christians have backed down because we don't want to impose our beliefs on others, all the while passively accepting sinful practices to the point where our voices are being silenced and yet many of us still walk on egg shells so as not to offend anyone.  Anyone, like our VP who praises China's one child policy or supports Planned Parenthood, should be excommunicated.  Abortion is a grave sin and a sin of such gravity warrants excommunication.  If the liberal media wants to spin it so that it looks like the Church is unforgiving and unaccepting, we should just expect it and move on.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

For the record, I am a strong advocate against hypocrisy. If one doesn't believe the tenants of the Catholic Church, one shouldn't be or claim to be a Catholic.

Posted

And quite honestly, the original purpose of this thread wasn't to debate how laws are made and which morality is acceptable.  We are disappointed in a Cardinal of the Church who not only gave communion to a pro-abortion politician but also gave him special attention.  That goes against the laws of the Church and secular society has no say in that.

Posted

I view it as an "in addition to" rather than "instead of." Traditional marriage is between a man and a woman. Two members of the same sex getting married is not traditional marriage.  What does it matter to anyone what other people do between themselves? You have to right to believe and act according to your own conscious but not the right to restrict others from doing the same. 

It is not traditional, and based upon tradition it is not possible. The people pushing for the change know in the end that this will alter our society and will probably lead to the persecution of individuals who dissent from the change, and I think many of them are looking forward to that.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

And quite honestly, the original purpose of this thread wasn't to debate how laws are made and which morality is acceptable.  We are disappointed in a Cardinal of the Church who not only gave communion to a pro-abortion politician but also gave him special attention.  That goes against the laws of the Church and secular society has no say in that.

Sorry, it's my fault for derailing the thread  :pinch:

Posted

For the record, I am a strong advocate against hypocrisy. If one doesn't believe the tenants of the Catholic Church, one shouldn't be or claim to be a Catholic.

I respect you for that, and I agree, if a person rejects the tenets of the faith they should have the decency to leave the Church.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

It is not traditional, and based upon tradition it is not possible. The people pushing for the change know in the end that this will alter our society and will probably lead to the persecution of individuals who dissent from the change, and I think many of them are looking forward to that.

Based on your tradition.  Again, its not replacing something, its allowing something to co-exist. Its not your business to prevent others from free exercise of their own beliefs. No one is attempting to take away the sacrament of marriage. Allowing same-sex couples to be legally recognized with secular marriage licenses has no bearing on your religious and institutional marriages.  

 

And let me know when heterosexual married couples start getting persecuted and everyone is forced to marry someone of the same sex. I'd like to observe that.

Posted

Sorry, it's my fault for derailing the thread  :pinch:

 It's all right, it happens all too often here.  I've been guilty of it myself   :proud:

Posted

Based on your tradition.  Again, its not replacing something, its allowing something to co-exist. Its not your business to prevent others from free exercise of their own beliefs. No one is attempting to take away the sacrament of marriage. Allowing same-sex couples to be legally recognized with secular marriage licenses has no bearing on your religious and institutional marriages.  

 

And let me know when heterosexual married couples start getting persecuted and everyone is forced to marry someone of the same sex. I'd like to observe that.

Actually it is not just my tradition, although I thank you for making me seem more important than I am; instead, it is the common Western tradition in which America participates.

Posted

Thanks for the responses everyone, and for keeping this a low-key discussion.

 

Out of curiosity, it seems to me that on Facebook and elsewhere, Catholics and non-Catholic Christians are the ones bearing the brunt of "you're a hater" via gay marriage supporters - I wonder why Jewish and Islamic faiths (that also speak against gay marriage) are being ignored?

 

 

Because they aren't nearly as powerful.  At least within those issues.  Islamic organizations have very little clout in the US to begin with as very few politicians are eager to be linked to them.  Those that have the ,ost clout that I can think of deal with non-discrimination issues.  They are reasonably powerful Jewish organizations but most of the ones that I can think of either focus on issues regarding Israel or issues regarding the plight of Jewish minorities in hostile nations which is a pretty non-controversial issue.  At least in the US.  When Hungarian officials try to compile a list of Jewish residents I think most people in the US agree that the US should use it's clout to tell them to knock that the duck off.  

Posted

Based on your tradition.  Again, its not replacing something, its allowing something to co-exist. Its not your business to prevent others from free exercise of their own beliefs. No one is attempting to take away the sacrament of marriage. Allowing same-sex couples to be legally recognized with secular marriage licenses has no bearing on your religious and institutional marriages.  

 

And let me know when heterosexual married couples start getting persecuted and everyone is forced to marry someone of the same sex. I'd like to observe that.

It's based on more than his tradition, or mine, or yours. It's based on anthropology - on the way that human beings have lived on all continents throughout all time. Homosexuality has also existed, but has seldom been approved - it was fairly widespread in a few cities in ancient Greece and Rome, but it was never condoned by law. Governing bodies can change the law just because they're able to, but it won't change the way human nature, or human society.

 

A change in the law won't necessarily force hetrosexuals to marry homosexuals, but it will impact heterosexuals who are opposed to homosexual marriage - Will a Catholic justice of the peace have to marry two homosexuals? Will my tax dollars pay survivor benefits to a homosexual widow? Will my tax dollars be spent on any kind of government-provided spousal benefits? Then I am being forced to support homosexual marriage in ways that I oppose. It would be the same as forcing me to support chattel slavery, to which I am also opposed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...