FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 Reflecting time. I've been thinking lately, and maybe y'all can give some input unto this. Our life is made up of choices we and others around us have made, so what if we could change a choice we made that would make our life a lot different than it is now? I'm not even talking about a huge knowingly life defining choice. Even a little choice that ultimately changed your life for the better or worse. What compels us to make those choices, and does God already know those tiny choices that we will make? If it will unknowingly change our life for the worse, what is the force that makes us make those choices? If they are ultimately bad, why would God allow us to make them? Maybe that falls under "Why does God let bad things happen?", but I don't necessarily mean that. Sorry if this is weirdly phrased.
PhuturePriest Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 (edited) Reflecting time. I've been thinking lately, and maybe y'all can give some input unto this. Our life is made up of choices we and others around us have made, so what if we could change a choice we made that would make our life a lot different than it is now? I'm not even talking about a huge knowingly life defining choice. Even a little choice that ultimately changed your life for the better or worse. What compels us to make those choices, and does God already know those tiny choices that we will make? If it will unknowingly change our life for the worse, what is the force that makes us make those choices? If they are ultimately bad, why would God allow us to make them? Maybe that falls under "Why does God let bad things happen?", but I don't necessarily mean that. Sorry if this is weirdly phrased. Well, I'm not really able to answer the question as a whole, but yes, God knows we will make those tiny choices since God knows everything that has happened and everything that will come to be. Edited April 12, 2013 by FuturePriest387
dUSt Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 I don't know about all that, but I wish I could go back and change my choice of reading this thread.
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted April 12, 2013 Author Posted April 12, 2013 I don't know about all that, but I wish I could go back and change my choice of reading this thread. Lol... Sorry.
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted April 12, 2013 Author Posted April 12, 2013 God gives up free will and most of us abuse it. Right. I get that. But what about if we truly don't know that a choice we made would change our life for the worse? Then again, is it really for the worst, or is God having another opportunity to work in our lives and purify us, etc? Maybe I'm WAY overthinking this.
PhuturePriest Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 Right. I get that. But what about if we truly don't know that a choice we made would change our life for the worse? Then again, is it really for the worst, or is God having another opportunity to work in our lives and purify us, etc? Maybe I'm WAY overthinking this. Life is life. Sometimes we make good decisions, sometimes we make bad ones. Just pray and ask God to help you make the right decision, and of course you can ask friends about it as well.
Papist Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 Right. I get that. But what about if we truly don't know that a choice we made would change our life for the worse? Then again, is it really for the worst, or is God having another opportunity to work in our lives and purify us, etc? Maybe I'm WAY overthinking this. Perhaps you are over-thinking. We don't have crystal balls to see what happens from our choice. There's no guarantees. Our choice must obey our conscience, and our conscience must be formed properly. Also, if our choice is turning out to the the wrong one, we must check our silly pride and admit it and make the proper corrections/reparations.
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted April 12, 2013 Author Posted April 12, 2013 Perhaps this should have stayed in a thought bubble... Haha. But thank you, Papist and FP. I see what you're saying.
PhuturePriest Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 Perhaps this should have stayed in a thought bubble... Haha. But thank you, Papist and FP. I see what you're saying. If everything I thought stayed in the thought bubble, we wouldn't have such amazing threads like The World Is Full of Sheep to re-read for comic relief!
CrossCuT Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 I like to think that we have tons of choices we can choose from in every aspect of our life. The choice is ALWAYS ours (free will) but God knows which one we will take and where it will lead us. He knows the outcome of every angle but its us that choose it. God also allows bad things happen so that a greater good can come out of it. Example: Jesus dying on the cross.
Basilisa Marie Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 Reflecting time. I've been thinking lately, and maybe y'all can give some input unto this. Our life is made up of choices we and others around us have made, so what if we could change a choice we made that would make our life a lot different than it is now? I'm not even talking about a huge knowingly life defining choice. Even a little choice that ultimately changed your life for the better or worse. What compels us to make those choices, and does God already know those tiny choices that we will make? If it will unknowingly change our life for the worse, what is the force that makes us make those choices? If they are ultimately bad, why would God allow us to make them? Maybe that falls under "Why does God let bad things happen?", but I don't necessarily mean that. Sorry if this is weirdly phrased. God knows all possible outcomes of all possible choices and combinations and choices, and which choices we will make. Some of these choices that we make are propelled by grace, others temptation, and still others...I don't know. I know my parents asked me if I wanted to skip a grade back in the beginning of third grade, because everything was so easy for me. If I had chosen to skip a grade, my life would be completely different than how it is now, since I chose to stay. What compelled me to make that choice? Staying with my friends? I don't think that was grace or temptation, yet it made a HUGE difference for me. I wouldn't have become friends with the same people, I wouldn't have gone to the college I went to, I wouldn't have met my boyfriend... Ultimately God respects our free will and doesn't force us to make any of our decisions, and works with the decisions that we do make. We're the ones who still have to make the decisions that ultimately land us in heaven or Hell, even if God already knows what the results of those decisions are.
CrossCuT Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 God knows all possible outcomes of all possible choices and combinations and choices, and which choices we will make. Some of these choices that we make are propelled by grace, others temptation, and still others...I don't know. I know my parents asked me if I wanted to skip a grade back in the beginning of third grade, because everything was so easy for me. If I had chosen to skip a grade, my life would be completely different than how it is now, since I chose to stay. What compelled me to make that choice? Staying with my friends? I don't think that was grace or temptation, yet it made a HUGE difference for me. I wouldn't have become friends with the same people, I wouldn't have gone to the college I went to, I wouldn't have met my boyfriend... Ultimately God respects our free will and doesn't force us to make any of our decisions, and works with the decisions that we do make. We're the ones who still have to make the decisions that ultimately land us in heaven or Hell, even if God already knows what the results of those decisions are. I think thats a perfect answer
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted April 12, 2013 Author Posted April 12, 2013 God knows all possible outcomes of all possible choices and combinations and choices, and which choices we will make. Some of these choices that we make are propelled by grace, others temptation, and still others...I don't know. I know my parents asked me if I wanted to skip a grade back in the beginning of third grade, because everything was so easy for me. If I had chosen to skip a grade, my life would be completely different than how it is now, since I chose to stay. What compelled me to make that choice? Staying with my friends? I don't think that was grace or temptation, yet it made a HUGE difference for me. I wouldn't have become friends with the same people, I wouldn't have gone to the college I went to, I wouldn't have met my boyfriend... Ultimately God respects our free will and doesn't force us to make any of our decisions, and works with the decisions that we do make. We're the ones who still have to make the decisions that ultimately land us in heaven or Hell, even if God already knows what the results of those decisions are. This pretty much answered what I was saying. I agree.
MIKolbe Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 Right. I get that. But what about if we truly don't know that a choice we made would change our life for the worse? Then again, is it really for the worst, or is God having another opportunity to work in our lives and purify us, etc? Maybe I'm WAY overthinking this. Maybe this is why St. Paul says to pray without ceasing? There are many choices we make that can affect our lives for better or for worse without us knowing (at decision time) if these decisions are as important as they really are. So what do you do? I guess you pray for guidance..in all areas of your life. Ask for the gifts of knowledge, understanding, and wisdom.... If a decision, made in 'good faith', becomes one of the decisions that changes your life for the worse; maybe evaluate for whom it is worse and for whom it might be better and why. Or, simply know this is where the Father has placed you; know that he loves you; trust in Him; and take up your cross.
AnneLine Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 (edited) FCC, really think this is a good thread and a really great topic to think and pray over. Loved what people have been saying, especially Basilisa Marie and MIKolbe's comments. I also love the concept (from St. Ignatius) that one can get kinda crazy by trying to make the 'right' choice or the 'best' choice -- if one prayerfully chooses to make the 'better' choice at each point, one hopefully will start to see a 'better' trend. If a problem starts to emerge, one can prayerfully back-track and refocus and choose differently. But some choices are hard to un-choose, obviously, so especial prayer and discernment is needed at those times. And that, too, is what admitting a mistake and starting over again... and God's forgiveness in the sacrament of penance.... and the ability to forgive oneself and others in our human interactions... is all about. But not easy... OH no. But it is the right choice. One step, one choice at a time.... Edited April 12, 2013 by AnneLine
beatitude Posted April 12, 2013 Posted April 12, 2013 I used to be quite preoccupied with this, but not any more. Every life is made up of millions of choices, big and small, and some will be significant and others not so significant at all - but we will never know which is which. Ultimately, it doesn't matter. I envisage each choice as being like a thread. God is weaving the tapestry from all our threads. The specific choices we make will affect how the tapestry looks in the end - but however it looks, it's going to be beautiful. For sure. When there are infinite variations on beautiful the specifics don't matter so much. :) We think of choices too much in terms of 'right' and 'wrong'. Sometimes we just have a whole bunch of good options, and there is no wrong choice. We narrow God down too much when we think that there must be one solitary right thing to do that will alter the course of our existence forever. This is how finite minds think. He's not finite.
HisChildForever Posted April 13, 2013 Posted April 13, 2013 We're the ones who still have to make the decisions that ultimately land us in heaven or Hell, even if God already knows what the results of those decisions are. It sort of freaks me out that at this moment God knows I'm going to ______ [insert eternal life or damnation here].
Basilisa Marie Posted April 14, 2013 Posted April 14, 2013 It sort of freaks me out that at this moment God knows I'm going to ______ [insert eternal life or damnation here]. Yeah, but the good thing is we always have the option of repentance and accepting forgiveness for our sin, up until the last millisecond of our consciousness in our lives. There's no "whoops sorry game over you've chosen the wrong path and now it's impossible to fix it." It took me a long time to realize that that's not how it works, especially when trying to "figure out" what your vocation is. Also: God might live in the 10th dimension. :)http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Q_GQqUg6Ts
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now