Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What Even


Recommended Posts

Posted

Looks like a yogurt cup.

Spem in alium
Posted

Oi. 

 

That's just...  :blink:

 

I can kind of understand why they would be useful in nursing homes and the like, but still...

DiscerningCatholic
Posted

Looks like a yogurt cup.

 

That's EXACTLY what I said!!! I eat these

 

yocrunch.jpg

 

for breakfast sometimes and they look exactly like those communion things.

 

 

I can kind of understand why they would be useful in nursing homes and the like, but still...

 

That's what they made pyxes for.

 

One woman in the comments was complaining about how bland they tasted. I was just like, "'Kay, did you buy this for your 'communion' service or for your preschoolers?"

Spem in alium
Posted

That's what they made pyxes for.

 

One woman in the comments was complaining about how bland they tasted. I was just like, "'Kay, did you buy this for your 'communion' service or for your preschoolers?"

Yeah, I know, but in terms of people in homes/hospitals being able to receive under both species, I think it's interesting. Not necessarily right, just interesting.

It does look a lot like a yoghurt cup. Totally agree with your reaction to the blandness comment. And the whole part about taste testing the grape juice...?

 

ChristinaTherese
Posted

From a Protestant point of view (and I'm nearly positive that they are Protestant, judging by the page you gave), it makes sense. It eliminates the problem of pouring grape juice into a bunch of tiny cups (which is the common way to do things) and would just streamline the process. It's horribly grating from a Catholic perspective, but you have to remember that they don't have the Eucharist. They have bread and grape juice. When you look at things that way, it's still irreverent and annoying but it makes more sense. Commenting on the taste of the juice and bread would only make sense there, too, because that's all they have. Christ-less bread and grape juice (or wine, but it's generally grape juice at the churches I grew up in, and when there's a choice people seem to often prefer the juice).

 

By the way, upon a quick look further, they must be Protestant. They talk about the King James (KJV)....

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

The Prots use this type approach in a lot of mega churches where they might have several thousand at a service and everybody gets their own cup. It really is a bit of work, I grew up in a small church of only about 200 families...On communion Sundays the ladies would be pouring grape juice into all the little 1/4 ounce cups...From a Protty prospective it just makes sense.

Spem in alium
Posted (edited)

From a Protestant point of view (and I'm nearly positive that they are Protestant, judging by the page you gave), it makes sense. It eliminates the problem of pouring grape juice into a bunch of tiny cups (which is the common way to do things) and would just streamline the process. It's horribly grating from a Catholic perspective, but you have to remember that they don't have the Eucharist. They have bread and grape juice. When you look at things that way, it's still irreverent and annoying but it makes more sense. Commenting on the taste of the juice and bread would only make sense there, too, because that's all they have. Christ-less bread and grape juice (or wine, but it's generally grape juice at the churches I grew up in, and when there's a choice people seem to often prefer the juice).

 

By the way, upon a quick look further, they must be Protestant. They talk about the King James (KJV)....

 

 

The Prots use this type approach in a lot of mega churches where they might have several thousand at a service and everybody gets their own cup. It really is a bit of work, I grew up in a small church of only about 200 families...On communion Sundays the ladies would be pouring grape juice into all the little 1/4 ounce cups...From a Protty prospective it just makes sense.

Right. It definitely makes more sense that way!

Edited by Spem in alium
Posted

The Mormon church also uses something like this only with water. They pass around little metal trays that hold lots of little plastic cups of water. The trays have an opening in the middle and a space down below to hold the used cups. You take a cup and drink the water then drop the cup in the opening.

ChristinaTherese
Posted

Its Protestant.  Any Catholic that would say "grape juice" needs a lot of catechesis!!

 

this is interesting

 

http://www.kingdom.com/Personalized-Candy-Bar-Wrappers-p/cbwa.htm

Not to mention any Catholic that would put Our Lord into a little plastic cup... or just leave Him around for people to take... or... or... or.... That website just exudes Protestantness.

dominicansoul
Posted

"Para Asistencia en Espanol llamar..."

 

 

:cry:

Posted

Not to mention any Catholic that would put Our Lord into a little plastic cup... or just leave Him around for people to take... or... or... or.... That website just exudes Protestantness.

 

yup

 

I hope Id never see this in a Catholic Church either

 

KL3TIER-2.jpg?1362489461

 

Three-tier Acrylic Lectern

 

Three-tier style acrylic lectern features 6-column base with a middle shelf with plenty of space for sermon notes and a glass of water

 

 

You know youre in for a lot of long homilies if father needs a place to put a drink! :P

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

You know youre in for a lot of long homilies if father needs a place to put a drink! :P

 

About a week and a half ago I was serving at a wedding Mass, we DID need to go get the concelebrating Fr.
(uncle of the groom) a glass of water because his throat was so dry. And he kept coughing and was worried he wouldn't get through the vows.

Posted

Please! Let's not give some pastor's any ideas.

Posted (edited)

I suppose it's a good idea if you're totally into consumerizing the communion experience and don't mind shoveling piles of money into some spirituality-exploiting corporation just so you can then dump tons of non-biodegradable plastic into America's rapidly rising landfills.

 

You know, if that's your thing.

Edited by curiousing
Posted

And by the way, if that's what "the Kingdom" is like, I think I'd better email Satan for that contract.

Posted

I suppose that could work to safely transport consecrated elements to parishes without priests. Or how about if we have a bad pandemic and can't safely congregate.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

I suppose that could work to safely transport consecrated elements to parishes without priests. Or how about if we have a bad pandemic and can't safely congregate.

 

I could definitely see the possibility for lots of dropped hosts and fragments...I mean opening those little creamers without spilling a drop is tough enough.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...