Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Attn: Catholic Scouts And Former Scouts


Recommended Posts

Chestertonian
Posted (edited)

Excellent. Now I just need to find some kind of tax-funded organization that exclusively organizes and hosts pajama parties for young ladies. For science.

 

There must also be pillows-a-plenty.

Edited by Chestertonian
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Girls join too?

Is that Rasputin? 

Chestertonian
Posted

Is that Rasputin? 

 

ya, he's kinda a hero of mine.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

ya, he's kinda a hero of mine.

The drunk, philandering, Russian Orthodox-heretic? :|

Chestertonian
Posted

The drunk, philandering, Russian Orthodox-heretic? :|

 

Say what you will about him, but there's no denying that he had an amazing beard.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Say what you will about him, but there's no denying that he had an amazing beard.

This much is true.
Then again, the same can be said about Dosteovsky.
Nihil Obstat
Posted (edited)

.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Chestertonian
Posted (edited)

This much is true.
Then again, the same can be said about Dosteovsky.

 

 

Or Leo Tolstoy for that matter. Dostoyevsky's beard was better, though.

Edited by Chestertonian
CatholicCid
Posted

I dont see how gay scouts would frown on the formation of character, self-reliance, and citizenship, which is the stated goal of the Boy Scouts of America. 

 

You make it sound as though gay scouts would not have any desire for such a pursuit, or is it just that they are incapable of being morally sound individuals by any means?

Sorry, I to forgot to make the orientation vs. behavior distinction. In your reference to "gay scouts", I would view that as an active behavior or lifestyle, not simply an orientation. Those suffering from such an orientation (Scouts with Same-Sex Attraction) should, and God willing, do desire such a pursuit and will seek it out. Those who actively engage in and pursue any intrinsically disordered behavior, however, need to turn from that lifestyle to truly and fully seek out a pursuit of virtue (or to be able to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetime).

GregorMendel
Posted

Your statement that individuals with same-sex attraction are not able to make ethical and moral choices is what I take offense to.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

Sorry, I to forgot to make the orientation vs. behavior distinction. In your reference to "gay scouts", I would view that as an active behavior or lifestyle, not simply an orientation. Those suffering from such an orientation (Scouts with Same-Sex Attraction) should, and God willing, do desire such a pursuit and will seek it out. Those who actively engage in and pursue any intrinsically disordered behavior, however, need to turn from that lifestyle to truly and fully seek out a pursuit of virtue (or to be able to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetime).

 

I'm a bit confused by this position as well. Since when did we agree with the moral philosophy of the LDS? The Scouts is a gov funded/supported organization. Tom and Steve's decision to have sex 0, 10, or 12039120392 times has 0 effect on my life as an American citizen. 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

Your statement that individuals with same-sex attraction are not able to make ethical and moral choices is what I take offense to.

Then, I suppose my clarification was not clear because that is not what I posted. Individuals who actively engage in an intrinsically disordered lifestyle are hindered by such a lifestyle when attempting to make ethical and moral choices. To actively pursue a lifestyle that is immoral (intrinsically disordered) would hinder one's choices in the moral order.

 

An analogy: A man running a marathon on an injured foot is hindered in his running of the marathon. Without attempting to heal his injury, he will be hindered, to some degree, in running the marathon.

 

Using the distinctions I made in post #29, it should be clear that I view individuals with same-sex attraction as individuals who are not actively engaging in a homosexual lifestyle. Therefore, they would not be hindered in the same manner as someone who is actively engaged in such a lifestyle.

Edited by CatholicCid
CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

I'm a bit confused by this position as well. Since when did we agree with the moral philosophy of the LDS? The Scouts is a gov funded/supported organization. Tom and Steve's decision to have sex 0, 10, or 12039120392 times has 0 effect on my life as an American citizen. 

 

I am not aware of LDS moral philosophy; My thoughts are based on Catholic moral theology. I am also unaware as to how the Scouts are funded by the government. Could you provide more information as to how the BSA is a government funded organization? Also, what does such funding mean considering the BSA is a private institution, not a public institution?

 

Anyway, I am simply responding to the Scout's recent decision as a Catholic Scout myself, as per the request of the OP.

 

The mission of the Boy Scouts of America is to prepare young people to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetimes by instilling in them the values of the Scout Oath and Law. The Scout Oath includes attempting to do my duty to God and also to keep oneself morally straight. To a Catholic Scout, these two parts of the oath would seem to require following Christ and His Church. To a Catholic Scout, engaging in an active homosexual lifestyle would be violating my duty to God and would be swerving from the morally straight path. Therefore, it does not seem possible that an active homosexual could truthfully take the Scout Oath and, therefore, could not be a member of the Scouts. 

Edited by CatholicCid
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

I am not aware of LDS moral philosophy; My thoughts are based on Catholic moral theology. I am also unaware as to how the Scouts are funded by the government. Could you provide more information as to how the BSA is a government funded organization? Also, what does such funding mean considering the BSA is a private institution, not a public institution?

 In 2008 the senate passed a law ordering the secretary of treasury to mint and sell up to 350,000 Scout themed coins to the public and to donate the profits to the Scouts. A good chunk of scouting units are chartered by government funded institutions like public schools.

Check out these gems:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Support_Our_Scouts_Act

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/2554

 

...and the LDS is connected to the scouts. That's why I mentioned them in my post.

 

 

 


Anyway, I am simply responding to the Scout's recent decision as a Catholic Scout myself, as per the request of the OP.

 

The mission of the Boy Scouts of America is to prepare young people to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetimes by instilling in them the values of the Scout Oath and Law. The Scout Oath includes attempting to do my duty to God and also to keep oneself morally straight. To a Catholic Scout, these two parts of the oath would seem to require following Christ and His Church. To a Catholic Scout, engaging in an active homosexual lifestyle would be violating my duty to God and would be swerving from the morally straight path. Therefore, it does not seem possible that an active homosexual could truthfully take the Scout Oath and, therefore, could not be a member of the Scouts.

I don't have a problem with the Scouts excluding certain groups from their organization.  I feel it's unfair that they do this with government support and funding from our tax money. 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

What does sexual preferences really have to do with an origination primarily made up with and for prepubescent boys?

 

 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

What does sexual preferences really have to do with an origination primarily made up with and for prepubescent boys?

 

Eagle Scouts are high school guys. 

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

Bishop responds to Boy Scouts’ decision on admission of homosexual members 

Bishop Robert Guglielmone of Charleston, the episcopal liaison of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops to the National Catholic Committee on Scouting, has responded to the Boy Scouts of America’s approval of a resolution stating that “No youth may be denied membership in the Boy Scouts of America on the basis of sexual orientation or preference alone.” ... â€œChurch teaching is very clear that the homosexual inclination is not sinful and that same-sex attraction is not immoral,” added Bishop Guglielmone, “but that what we’re dealing with here is the distinction between the inclination and the conduct. The standards remain the same as they always have for scouts. Homosexual activity will not be condoned.”

 

http://www.catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=17978&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+CatholicWorldNewsFeatureStories+%28Catholic+World+News+%28on+CatholicCulture.org%29%29

 

 

 

Edited by CatholicCid
CatholicCid
Posted

 In 2008 the senate passed a law ordering the secretary of treasury to mint and sell up to 350,000 Scout themed coins to the public and to donate the profits to the Scouts. A good chunk of scouting units are chartered by government funded institutions like public schools.

Check out these gems:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Support_Our_Scouts_Act

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/2554

 

...and the LDS is connected to the scouts. That's why I mentioned them in my post.

 

 

 

I don't have a problem with the Scouts excluding certain groups from their organization.  I feel it's unfair that they do this with government support and funding from our tax money. 

 

To be fair, it seems that the government is willingly giving the money to support the Scouts, knowing full well their beliefs.

 

Given your example of the coins, the profits were donated to the Scouts. As to public institutions chartering the organization, if I recall correctly, they know full well what they are receiving and actually are agreeing to following the Scouting program as laid out by the BSA. Just because public institutions find the Scouting program useful and desire to make that program available to the youths in their charge does not mean that the program itself must be fitted to the public institutions desires. If there are irreconcilable beliefs, then the public institutions should not charter such an organization.

 

And, again, I am still lost on the LDS connection. Catholics are also connected to the Scouts (hence this thread).

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

To be fair, it seems that the government is willingly giving the money to support the Scouts, knowing full well their beliefs.

 

Given your example of the coins, the profits were donated to the Scouts. As to public institutions chartering the organization, if I recall correctly, they know full well what they are receiving and actually are agreeing to following the Scouting program as laid out by the BSA. Just because public institutions find the Scouting program useful and desire to make that program available to the youths in their charge does not mean that the program itself must be fitted to the public institutions desires. If there are irreconcilable beliefs, then the public institutions should not charter such an organization.

 

And, again, I am still lost on the LDS connection. Catholics are also connected to the Scouts (hence this thread).

 

The government is using our money to donate to this organization. Our tax money is used to fund the Treasury, isn't it? How exactly did they fund the minting of these coins? This isn't the only time our government has done something like this, either. Do you also support the Scouts' dealing with atheist children? I'm fine with this organization excluding whoever it wants. I'm not fine with them using our tax money.

 

The LDS is the single biggest doner to the Scouts. The Scouts didn't always have this policy against gays/atheists/whoever else they don't like.

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...