Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Attn: Catholic Scouts And Former Scouts


Recommended Posts

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

The government is using our money to donate to this organization. Our tax money is used to fund the Treasury, isn't it? How exactly did they fund the minting of these coins? This isn't the only time our government has done something like this, either. Do you also support the Scouts' dealing with atheist children? I'm fine with this organization excluding whoever it wants. I'm not fine with them using our tax money.

 

The LDS is the single biggest doner to the Scouts. The Scouts didn't always have this policy against gays/atheists/whoever else they don't like.

It sounds as if your disagreement with who the government donates to would be better directed at the government than the Scouts. The government is free to withhold such donations and chartering such organizations. Those who make such donations, however, must feel that that which the Scouts offer outweighs those issue they might disagree on the Scouts with. 

 

And, yes, I do support the Scout's dealing with atheist (and agnostic) children. The BSA is an organization operating with an inherent belief in God. It is a core belief. Rejecting such a belief prevents one from fully entering into Scouting because Scouting inherently includes a belief in God (as demonstrated by the oath).

 

And, again, I fail to understand the LDS and BSA connection. The Scouts were founded in 1910. Both LDS and Catholic Churches began chartering troops within several years of the founding, if not in 1910 itself. Could you provide a bit of articulated history on the ban itself? I'm not sure if they've ever 'altered' their morals on this matter (especially for donations, as you seem to be implying). 

Edited by CatholicCid
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

It sounds as if your disagreement with who the government donates to would be better directed at the government than the Scouts. The government is free to withhold such donations and chartering such organizations. Those who make such donations, however, must feel that that which the Scouts offer outweighs those issue they might disagree on the Scouts with. 

 

And, yes, I do support the Scout's dealing with atheist (and agnostic) children. The BSA is an organization operating with an inherent belief in God. It is a core belief. Rejecting such a belief prevents one from fully entering into Scouting because Scouting inherently includes a belief in God (as demonstrated by the oath).

 

And, again, I fail to understand the LDS and BSA connection. The Scouts were founded in 1910. Both LDS and Catholic Churches began chartering troops within several years of the founding, if not in 1910 itself. Could you provide a bit of articulated history on the ban itself? I'm not sure if they've ever 'altered' their morals on this matter (especially for donations, as you seem to be implying). 

 

In 1910, the BSA wasn't as concerned with pushing a religious agenda. The Cold War changed things. During that time the organization got taken over by the Christian right, especially the Mormon Church. I have no issue with your support of the BSA's policies. I'm more concerned about the morality behind our government collecting money from people for the BSA and the BSA telling those same people that their children can't join.

 

 

 

It sounds as if your disagreement with who the government donates to would be better directed at the government than the Scouts. The government is free to withhold such donations and chartering such organizations.

My disagreement is with both. We might have different ideas of how the government should work. If this is true, it would be silly for us to continue debating. However, I'm curious to find out if you'll meet me at the other side with your logic. Let's say there is a Muslim organization that doesn't allow Catholics to join. Do you believe the government has the right to support/fund this organization in the same way?

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

In 1910, the BSA wasn't as concerned with pushing a religious agenda. The Cold War changed things. During that time the organization got taken over by the Christian right, especially the Mormon Church. I have no issue with your support of the BSA's policies. I'm more concerned about the morality behind our government collecting money from people for the BSA and the BSA telling those same people that their children can't join.

 

 

 

My disagreement is with both. We might have different ideas of how the government should work. If this is true, it would be silly for us to continue debating. However, I'm curious to find out if you'll meet me at the other side with your logic. Let's say there is a Muslim organization that doesn't allow Catholics to join. Do you believe the government has the right to support/fund this organization in the same way?

I would disagree that the BSA is suddenly pushing a religious agenda. It has always been an organization founded with a belief in God. 

 

As to your concern of morality, I again think it should be focused on the government who is making the donations/chartering organizations and not the Scouts who are operating as they always have. The BSA is a private institution, meaning they can operate as they want. If the government does not want to donate to them, then they should not do so. It seems wrong to argue that the BSA must change when it is, again, a private institution that is legally allowed to operate as it does.

 

 

Unrelated, but interesting side-note, there are Muslim Scouting troops.

 

Back on topic, if there is a private organization, then they are allowed to regulate their membership as they deem fit. Whether or not the government should make donations to such an organization is an entirely different topic. I would base my judgment on whether or not the government should donate to the organization (to operate as it does) based on the merits of the organization. I would not demand that the private organization be forced to become a public, government-run organization cause the government sees merit in making donations so that the organization can continue it's work.

Edited by CatholicCid
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

I would disagree that the BSA is suddenly pushing a religious agenda. It has always been an organization founded with a belief in God.

 

Really? Did they always have this exclusionary policy?

 


 

As to your concern of morality, I again think it should be focused on the government who is making the donations/chartering organizations and not the Scouts who are operating as they always have.

I imagine you nudging and winking when you say "government donations". The BSA is allowed to use Tax funded facilities and our government has initiated tax funded donation efforts to support the Scouts. There are other ways the government funds/supports the scouts as well.

 

 


The BSA is a private institution, meaning they can operate as they want. If the government does not want to donate to them, then they should not do so. It seems wrong to argue that the BSA must change when it is, again, a private institution that is legally allowed to operate as it does.

You're right. I'm arguing that the government should not allow them to use publically funded facilities/give them money indirectly.

 


Unrelated, but interesting side-note, there are Muslim Scouting troops.

Interesting.

 


Back on topic, if there is a private organization, then they are allowed to regulate their membership as they deem fit. Whether or not the government should make donations to such an organization is an entirely different topic. I would base my judgment on whether or not the government should donate to the organization (to operate as it does) based on the merits of the organization. I would not demand that the private organization be forced to become a public, government-run organization cause the government sees merit in making donations so that the organization can continue it's work.

I might not have made my position clear. I do not believe the BSA should become a public, government-run organization. My argument is that it shouldn't be funded/supported by the state if it has these policies.

CatholicCid
Posted

Really? Did they always have this exclusionary policy?

 

 

I imagine you nudging and winking when you say "government donations". The BSA is allowed to use Tax funded facilities and our government has initiated tax funded donation efforts to support the Scouts. There are other ways the government funds/supports the scouts as well.

 

 

 

You're right. I'm arguing that the government should not allow them to use publically funded facilities/give them money indirectly.

 

 

Interesting.

 

 

I might not have made my position clear. I do not believe the BSA should become a public, government-run organization. My argument is that it shouldn't be funded/supported by the state if it has these policies.

 

On an unrelated note, I do not nudge or wink  :farmer:

 

As to the policy, I would imagine it has always been inherent given the Oath and had to only be more formally pronounced once it became a societal issue. 

 

And, as to the last of your comments, I would again suggest your real complaints should be with the government that is making such donations and chartering such organizations, not the organizations themselves. The BSA has done nothing wrong in this regard. And, I am consciously using donation and chartering as the terms over funding/supporting, because, as you noted, the Scouts do receive funds from other sources. Even without federal donations, the BSA would continue to exist. Why, then, has the government donated to and chartered this organization for so long? I suggest there is a reason.

 

The reason public institutions charter troops is because they must see that the values taught and strengths provided by the BSA are worthwhile. When a troop is chartered, the organization chartering the troop agrees (contractually) to follow the BSA policies. In return, the BSA assists and guides the formation and running of the troop. The BSA provide a program and clearly state their policies and objectives. If the government is willing to "fund" this organization, there must be the belief that the goods presented by the BSA outweigh the "bad." If one believes that the BSA do more harm than good, then that should be discussed with their representative who is promoting donations to the BSA.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...