FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 For my family, it's just what works for us. It obviously doesn't work and is not best for every family. People should be able to choose how they want to school their children, whether that be public school, private school, homeschooling, etc. There is definitely a purpose for public schools. It's just not what works for my family.
CrossCuT Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 I have never really noticed that home schoolers think they are better than other people. There are a TON of them at my parish some of them sing in the choir with me. They are very kind, considerate people. The only thing I have noticed is that they tend to be quiet...nothing wrong with that.
franciscanheart Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Not to get into a hissy fight, but I really HATE that phraze, especially when used by children, weither it be private, catholic/christian, charter or homeschool. They are no better and no worse than other children who's parents are readily involved in their education and upbringing.Homeschoolmom was right: I was being sarcastic.I don't have any negative opinions of children who are homeschooled or their parents. The same is true for families who utilize the public school systems in their areas or who put down money for private school education.Whatever works, man.
4588686 Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 We have a large concentration of home school families in our area - we are one of them. That home school children are not socialized is a myth. Between home school co-ops, church groups, sports, constant field trips, and other activities home school children are very well socialized. I believe it is also a myth that home school families are all religious. There are a good number of secular home school families and groups. We have made a lot of family friends through home schooling that we otherwise never had in public or private schools. We just get our day over with twice as a fast and are 6 months to a year ahead of other forms of schooling. Right, they are socialized with a pre-selected set of individuals and families who fall roughly within an approved ideological, socio-economic et cetera spectrum. Which is why people think home-schooled kids are weird. Because it seems like they've grown up in a bubble. Because they have grown up in a bubble. That's not necessarily wrong and it doesn't make home schooled kids bad people or anything. But you can often tell when somebody has been home schooled. They're often really conservative and really religious, and seem to have trouble relating to people who don't fall within that category. And that's fine. If you want to try to ensure that your kids is really religious and conservative then that's fine. But the idea that there isn't a tradeoff to that is just silly and kind of immature. Which is the tone that often marks these articles. "Oh no, home schooled kids aren't different, unless by different you mean 10 gagillion times better than all those non-homeschooled kids lol lol lol!!!" And before anybody attacks me, no. Public/regular Catholic schools aren't a normative model. I'm not saying that anybody who wasn't home-schooled is better than anybody who was. I'm saying that each leaves a kid with different strengths and different weaknesses.
4588686 Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 I went to a Catholic grade and middle school. That gave me different strengths and weaknesses than somebody who went to High School. And it was evident because I had been in kind of a bubble. Not as much as home schooled kids, but a bubble all the same.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 (edited) And before anybody attacks me, no. Public/regular Catholic schools aren't a normative model. I'm not saying that anybody who wasn't home-schooled is better than anybody who was. I'm saying that each leaves a kid with different strengths and different weaknesses. Not by any means. Edited May 31, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
Little Flower Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Right, they are socialized with a pre-selected set of individuals and families who fall roughly within an approved ideological, socio-economic et cetera spectrum. Which is why people think home-schooled kids are weird. Because it seems like they've grown up in a bubble. Because they have grown up in a bubble. That's not necessarily wrong and it doesn't make home schooled kids bad people or anything. But you can often tell when somebody has been home schooled. They're often really conservative and really religious, and seem to have trouble relating to people who don't fall within that category. And that's fine. If you want to try to ensure that your kids is really religious and conservative then that's fine. But the idea that there isn't a tradeoff to that is just silly and kind of immature. Which is the tone that often marks these articles. "Oh no, home schooled kids aren't different, unless by different you mean 10 gagillion times better than all those non-homeschooled kids lol lol lol!!!" And before anybody attacks me, no. Public/regular Catholic schools aren't a normative model. I'm not saying that anybody who wasn't home-schooled is better than anybody who was. I'm saying that each leaves a kid with different strengths and different weaknesses. Sometimes bubbles are good things. I've been homeschooled most of my life. I think being sheltered has protected me a lot. But on the other hand, I don't think that it stops me from relating to other people. One of my best friends is a public school kid. Its true that most of the rest of my friends are homeschooled but I think its more because those are the girls I have taken classes with than because I can only make friends with other homeschoolers. At public school kids make their friends with the kids in their classes too. I think that everyone has a certain personality, and that being homeschooled or not doesn't really change your personality much. Maybe if you're homeschooled you will tend to be a little quieter. I know some really shy homeschoolers. However, I also know really shy public schoolers. Personally, I'm really outgoing and talk all the time. I'm homeschooled. I talk to everyone not just homeschoolers. I have a job, and I have made friends with the kids that I work with (who have HORRIBLE morals, but I can still relate to them and talk to them!) But I agree with you. Being homeschooled does not define who you are as a person, and therefore does not make you any better or worse than any other kid on planet. Some homeschoolers are great, some are jerks, some are stupid and never learned anything, and some are brilliant. Same with public school kids. I think it mostly depends on your parents, and how much work they put into your education (for both homeschoolers and public schoolers)
PhuturePriest Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Basically because they're better than everyone else and we all know it. :|
PhuturePriest Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Right, they are socialized with a pre-selected set of individuals and families who fall roughly within an approved ideological, socio-economic et cetera spectrum. Which is why people think home-schooled kids are weird. Because it seems like they've grown up in a bubble. Because they have grown up in a bubble. That's not necessarily wrong and it doesn't make home schooled kids bad people or anything. But you can often tell when somebody has been home schooled. They're often really conservative and really religious, and seem to have trouble relating to people who don't fall within that category. And that's fine. If you want to try to ensure that your kids is really religious and conservative then that's fine. But the idea that there isn't a tradeoff to that is just silly and kind of immature. Which is the tone that often marks these articles. "Oh no, home schooled kids aren't different, unless by different you mean 10 gagillion times better than all those non-homeschooled kids lol lol lol!!!" And before anybody attacks me, no. Public/regular Catholic schools aren't a normative model. I'm not saying that anybody who wasn't home-schooled is better than anybody who was. I'm saying that each leaves a kid with different strengths and different weaknesses. I have no issues relating to people that aren't home-schooled. I don't even know many other kids that are home-schooled, and I don't talk to them at all, really. Being home-schooled has had zero negative effects on how I'm able to relate and talk to people. It could just be because I'm a really outgoing person at heart, but I love talking to anyone and everyone, and I don't have any issues with it.
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Lol, believe it or not, not all of the extracurricular activities that we do are with other homeschoolers. I'm in a theater troupe and have played in a soccer league where I was the only homeschooler for most of my childhood. There's a difference between being sheltered and being unaware. I appreciate my bubble. But I also appreciate my parents who have not shielded me from what the real world is like. And I've always hated that precedent that public highschool is an accurate representation of what the "real world" is like. Like, really?
PhuturePriest Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Lol, believe it or not, not all of the extracurricular activities that we do are with other homeschoolers. I'm in a theater troupe and have played in a soccer league where I was the only homeschooler for most of my childhood. There's a difference between being sheltered and being unaware. I appreciate my bubble. But I also appreciate my parents who have not shielded me from what the real world is like. And I've always hated that precedent that public highschool is an accurate representation of what the "real world" is like. Like, really? Blame Winchester for stealing all of my props today. Anyway, this. Exactly this. Not one thing in my entire life has been with a home-schooling or religious group. I do karate, I take singing lessons, I take dancing lessons (For now, anyway. He might kill me soon when he learns I lost my nine thousand notes he made me write), I did boy scouts for five years, etc. Just yesterday I did a private class for a student for an entire hour. He's forty, but I was able to teach him and answer his questions for an hour, which I would love to see the average high schooler do. I did most of the talking, and most high schooled kids I've seen are quiet and shy, and wouldn't teach you a class if you paid them (I'm a Saintly man, so my private lessons are free).
CrossCuT Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Right, they are socialized with a pre-selected set of individuals and families who fall roughly within an approved ideological, socio-economic et cetera spectrum. Which is why people think home-schooled kids are weird. Because it seems like they've grown up in a bubble. Because they have grown up in a bubble. That's not necessarily wrong and it doesn't make home schooled kids bad people or anything. But you can often tell when somebody has been home schooled. They're often really conservative and really religious, and seem to have trouble relating to people who don't fall within that category. And that's fine. If you want to try to ensure that your kids is really religious and conservative then that's fine. But the idea that there isn't a tradeoff to that is just silly and kind of immature. Which is the tone that often marks these articles. "Oh no, home schooled kids aren't different, unless by different you mean 10 gagillion times better than all those non-homeschooled kids lol lol lol!!!" And before anybody attacks me, no. Public/regular Catholic schools aren't a normative model. I'm not saying that anybody who wasn't home-schooled is better than anybody who was. I'm saying that each leaves a kid with different strengths and different weaknesses. I think it really depends on each child and how long they have been home schooled during their life. One could be home schooled all the way through high school and still maintain a healthy social experience. But I do agree that home schooling can definitely lead to bubble development. Sometimes bubbles are good things. I've been homeschooled most of my life. I think being sheltered has protected me a lot. But on the other hand, I don't think that it stops me from relating to other people. One of my best friends is a public school kid. Its true that most of the rest of my friends are homeschooled but I think its more because those are the girls I have taken classes with than because I can only make friends with other homeschoolers. At public school kids make their friends with the kids in their classes too. I think that everyone has a certain personality, and that being homeschooled or not doesn't really change your personality much. Maybe if you're homeschooled you will tend to be a little quieter. I know some really shy homeschoolers. However, I also know really shy public schoolers. Personally, I'm really outgoing and talk all the time. I'm homeschooled. I talk to everyone not just homeschoolers. I have a job, and I have made friends with the kids that I work with (who have HORRIBLE morals, but I can still relate to them and talk to them!) But I agree with you. Being homeschooled does not define who you are as a person, and therefore does not make you any better or worse than any other kid on planet. Some homeschoolers are great, some are jerks, some are stupid and never learned anything, and some are brilliant. Same with public school kids. I think it mostly depends on your parents, and how much work they put into your education (for both homeschoolers and public schoolers) I wouldnt ever want to consider myself "sheltered" as a home schooler and neither should you. It has a negative connotation and the whole idea ruffles my feathers. I have a strong dislike for that mentality where people purposefully SEEK shelter from the world (I am not suggesting that you do). For example, a friend of mine went to Franciscan University so that she could "hide away". Or that town in Florida (Ave Maria?) that considered itself "Catholic Town". Both ideas to me are awful. As Catholics we should NEVER willfully hide from the world. We need to reach out our arms to others, immerse them in what gives us our joy; our Catholic faith! We need to understand our world so that we are better equipped to defend our morals and our faith against any attacks going on. We need to be IN this world, but not OF the world.
GeorgiiMichael Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 If you don't homeschool your kids, you're an immodest trollop.
Basilisa Marie Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 (edited) I went to public school all the way through, and am glad of it, because my parish had quality faith formation and youth group, and my high school gave me a lot more opportunities than I would have gotten through homeschooling or attending Catholic schools in my area (band and music education, foreign languages, AP courses, sports, clubs, etc). As I said, FOR MY AREA. That's what matters to me - my parents did what they could to make sure I had all the opportunities I needed to succeed. I know homeschool kids who are Christian and non-Christian. I know homeschool kids who are unsocialized and perfectly socialized. I know homeschool kids who are elitist jerks and ones that are kind to others. I know Catholic school kids who are socialized and unsocialized, practicing their faith and not, elitist jerks and kind. I know public school kids who are properly and improperly socialized, practicing and not practicing a faith, kind and unkind. What matters is doing what's best for your kids in whatever your individual situation is. It's totally possible to do all three options the right way and the wrong way, so it's wrong to make assumptions based on what kind of school a kid had. Do I think Catholic parents have a greater responsibility to make sure their kids aren't little snits, no matter what kind of school they attend? Yeah. I can't tell you how frustrating it is to go to public school and be treated like a weirdo because you're Catholic, then get treated like second class by your peers at Church because you don't attend Catholic school because THEIR parents go on and on about how Catholic school and homeschool is so much better. So TLDR: Do what's best for your situation and your kids, don't assume another's decision is wrong because every situation is unique, and make sure no matter how you're having your kids educated that you teach them to treat everyone kindly. Edited May 31, 2013 by Basilisa Marie
CrossCuT Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Haha funny story...I went to a private catholic high school and 90% of my graduating class were little snits. Doesnt matter where you send them too...if you dont bring them up right they are gonna be snits. I like that word hahahahahah
BostonMarine Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Whether or not you support homeschooling, whether or not you were homeschooled, the article linked to in the original post is bursting at the seams full of snide, snotty, we're-better-than-you remarks about other forms of education. The author takes all the worst stereotypes about public or private educational institutions and uses them as a snide ad hominem attack to justify why homeschool education is above reproach. In fact, the author is villianizing public education in the exact same way she critizes people for villianizing homeschooling. Better they learn what? That the crowd knows best? That their interests are boring and a waste of time? That they need to wear a certain thing and buy a certain thing in order to be worth people’s time? Better they learn now not to stand up for themselves? The suggestion here is that the schools are managed by "the crowd" (implying uninformed, group-think outbursts shape public educational curriculum), that student interests are never catered to (because we all know no school in America has clubs for students to choose from, electives and AP courses, choices of languages, opportunities for student questions or inquiry, or variety of sports), and that the only take-away students get at schools is judgemental cliques which look down on students for their branding of clothing purchases and how to be submissive. Again, these types of snide remarks by the author that are lathered all over her article are the exact same category of ill-informed generalizations and stereotypes about the school system that she's criticizing people for making about homeschooling. Not exactly a compelling means to make an argument.
Brother Adam Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 Right, they are socialized with a pre-selected set of individuals and families who fall roughly within an approved ideological, socio-economic et cetera spectrum. As opposed to the approved ideology. Which is why home schooling is banned. It doesn't make for good patriots/robots.
Papist Posted May 31, 2013 Author Posted May 31, 2013 Whether or not you support homeschooling, whether or not you were homeschooled, the article linked to in the original post is bursting at the seams full of snide, snotty, we're-better-than-you remarks about other forms of education. The author takes all the worst stereotypes about public or private educational institutions and uses them as a snide ad hominem attack to justify why homeschool education is above reproach. In fact, the author is villianizing public education in the exact same way she critizes people for villianizing homeschooling. The suggestion here is that the schools are managed by "the crowd" (implying uninformed, group-think outbursts shape public educational curriculum), that student interests are never catered to (because we all know no school in America has clubs for students to choose from, electives and AP courses, choices of languages, opportunities for student questions or inquiry, or variety of sports), and that the only take-away students get at schools is judgemental cliques which look down on students for their branding of clothing purchases and how to be submissive. Again, these types of snide remarks by the author that are lathered all over her article are the exact same category of ill-informed generalizations and stereotypes about the school system that she's criticizing people for making about homeschooling. Not exactly a compelling means to make an argument. I don't see how you got that. She is commenting on the questions she received from others when she started considering pulling her kids out of public school.
Tufsoles Posted May 31, 2013 Posted May 31, 2013 I think the homeschool/ socialization issue really depends on the situation. I have found that many HS kids are fine socially.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now