Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

A Question Concerning Harry Potter


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

I was told that J.K. Rowling admitted some of the spells used in Harry Potter are actual real spells. Can anyone confirm this? I'm quite skeptical about it.

Posted

Only if you have an authorized license from the state of New Jersey or Delaware.

Dr. Bombay
Posted

I know the idea for the book just dropped into her head.  One wonders where exactly it dropped from, but I think we all know the answer to that do we not?  Indeed we do.

The whole enterprise stinks of sulfur from top to bottom and that's all that needs to be said about such Illuminati trash.

Posted

I was told that J.K. Rowling admitted some of the spells used in Harry Potter are actual real spells. Can anyone confirm this? I'm quite skeptical about it.

 

I have heard the same. and i would not be surprised if it were true but its not like if wiggle a twig and shout them anything would happen.

 

Besides real spells or not it is made up story so you won't endanger your soul by reading them.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

I was told that J.K. Rowling admitted some of the spells used in Harry Potter are actual real spells. Can anyone confirm this? I'm quite skeptical about it.

 

There's no truth to that.

Dr. Bombay
Posted

Yes.  Drink this corn syrup flavored popular beverage my pretty.  It's only got a bit of rat poison in it.  You won't endanger your body by drinking it.  :rolleyes:

Posted

Harry Potter is immodest. :|

PhuturePriest
Posted

Yes.  Drink this corn syrup flavored popular beverage my pretty.  It's only got a bit of rat poison in it.  You won't endanger your body by drinking it.  :rolleyes:

 

There's nothing objectionable to Harry Potter.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

She was a Classics major, and has said that most of them she either got from a botany textbook or are just garbled Latin.  

 

Actual, real spells involve rituals, not simple magic words. And if you ever look at the "New Age" section of a bookstore, all the "spellbooks" just have bad poetry in English.  

 

Not that I'm saying go look at the New Age section of your local bookstore.  Don't do that.   :hehe2:

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

I know the idea for the book just dropped into her head.  One wonders where exactly it dropped from, but I think we all know the answer to that do we not?  Indeed we do.

The whole enterprise stinks of sulfur from top to bottom and that's all that needs to be said about such Illuminati trash.

 

A soon as you mentioned the Illuminati, everything you have ever said was placed into the "Ignore" category in my brain. If you want an actual secret organization that is actually a threat to the Catholic Church, you should focus your attention on the Freemasons. 

 

The Illuminati did exist, but there is no evidence of their current existence. 

 

Unless you count Dan Brown novels. But that's only so much garbage as well.

Dr. Bombay
Posted

There's nothing objectionable to Harry Potter.

 

Of course not.  There's nothing objectionable in Game of Thrones either.  What's wrong with a little evil after all?  As long as it's enmeshed round a cracklin neat story, we all good. :console:

Basilisa Marie
Posted

I know the idea for the book just dropped into her head.  One wonders where exactly it dropped from, but I think we all know the answer to that do we not?  Indeed we do.

The whole enterprise stinks of sulfur from top to bottom and that's all that needs to be said about such Illuminati trash.

 

Troll Level: 43. 

Dr. Bombay
Posted

A soon as you mentioned the Illuminati, everything you have ever said was placed into the "Ignore" category in my brain. If you want an actual secret organization that is actually a threat to the Catholic Church, you should focus your attention on the Freemasons. 

 

The Illuminati did exist, but there is no evidence of their current existence. 

 

Unless you count Dan Brown novels. But that's only so much garbage as well.

 

Of course there's no evidence of their current existence.  Duh.  Do you think they're stupid?  I've never, nor would I ever, accuse those people of being stupid.

Lack of evidence is, in fact, the only evidence we need.  QED

 

Furthermore, the Freemasons are a front group, as are the Lions Clubs, Odd Fellows, Mormons and such other of those ilk.  They are practiced at the art of deceit, masquerading even as an angel of light while carrying out their wicked designs in secret.  Much like the author of Harry Potter, which brings us full circle does it not?  Indeed it does.  

Dr. Bombay
Posted

Troll Level: 43. 

 

I assure you, madam, I am not trolling.

 

 

I'm formulating a hypothesis in my spare time.  Sometimes I post ideas.  I've reached a few conclusions but nothing firm as of yet.

Posted

Of course not.  There's nothing objectionable in Game of Thrones either.  What's wrong with a little evil after all?  As long as it's enmeshed round a cracklin neat story, we all good. :console:

THERE'S A STORY IN GAME OF THRONES??????? I THOUGHT IT WAS JUST A LIST OF MURDERS AND SUCH!

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Of course there's no evidence of their current existence.  Duh.  Do you think they're stupid?  I've never, nor would I ever, accuse those people of being stupid.

Lack of evidence is, in fact, the only evidence we need.  QED

 

Furthermore, the Freemasons are a front group, as are the Lions Clubs, Odd Fellows, Mormons and such other of those ilk.  They are practiced at the art of deceit, masquerading even as an angel of light while carrying out their wicked designs in secret.  Much like the author of Harry Potter, which brings us full circle does it not?  Indeed it does.  

 

Give an actual reason on why Harry Potter is bad. And don't say "magic". Magic doesn't exist. Objecting to the presence of magic in Harry Potter is like objecting to The Force in Star Wars. It's fantasy and there's no sin in using it, unless you'd like to accuse J.R.R. Tolkien of being a bad Catholic.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

Give an actual reason on why Harry Potter is bad. And don't say "magic". Magic doesn't exist. Objecting to the presence of magic in Harry Potter is like objecting to The Force in Star Wars. It's fantasy and there's no sin in using it, unless you'd like to accuse J.R.R. Tolkien of being a bad Catholic.

 

Don't be so quick to say that...I have an Acquaintance who is, worships the old Druid gods and such and she spoken of her spell books and fellow pagans that are witches... Magic is out there it happens to merely be a guise of devil work not like you nicely compared to the force in StarWars that is a mystical power one special people can manipulate.

Posted

Which book are you on now FP? :)

I havent been keeping up with asking!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

PhuturePriest
Posted

Don't be so quick to say that...I have an Acquaintance who is, worships the old Druid gods and such and she spoken of her spell books and fellow pagans that are witches... Magic is out there it happens to merely be a guise of devil work not like you nicely compared to the force in StarWars that is a mystical power one special people can manipulate.

 

Magic in fantasy is not the same as magic in reality. You can't pick up a little wand and make flames and spells shoot out of it because you said the right words. That type of magic is harmless.

 

Which book are you on now FP? :)

I havent been keeping up with asking!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

I read them all, I just forgot my thread existed so I forgot to update!

Posted

Of course there's no evidence of their current existence.  Duh.  Do you think they're stupid?  I've never, nor would I ever, accuse those people of being stupid.

Lack of evidence is, in fact, the only evidence we need.  QED

 

Furthermore, the Freemasons are a front group, as are the Lions Clubs, Odd Fellows, Mormons and such other of those ilk.  They are practiced at the art of deceit, masquerading even as an angel of light while carrying out their wicked designs in secret.  Much like the author of Harry Potter, which brings us full circle does it not?  Indeed it does.  

 

I actually know a number of ex-Mormons, some of whom are very very close friends. I wouldn't place them on par with the Freemasons though, and certainly not for the majority of individuals.

 

For that matter, if it's lack of evidence we need, and not actual evidence, why not freak out about the Knights of Columbus for their secrets?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...