Lil Red Posted July 5, 2013 Posted July 5, 2013 Well, seeing as how Harry Potter is about wizards, and you said this series is better than Harry Potter, it's natural to assume this book series is about wizards. However, with a book title like "Wizard and Glass" that's another indicator it's about magic. I just don't like books involving guns, I guess. I don't mind modern-era books (Though fictional books based in the Medieval time are the best, and Harry Potter somewhat is with its lack of electricity and amesome castles), but I don't know, you just throw guns in a book and I get bored of it. lol. it's not "about guns" really. do people shoot guns? yes. but the story doesn't revolve around guns or magic. it revolves around a quest, really. About a gunslinger (kind of like a knight, and the last of his kind), on a quest to the Dark Tower, the nexus of time & space, because the world has "moved on" (the threads of time & space are starting to loosen), and to make it to the Dark Tower is to hopefully set things aright again. meh. anyway. do want you want. just don't prematurely judge and think a book is about one thing, when it's not. :) (kind of like how people assume Harry Potter is from the devil.)
OnlySunshine Posted July 5, 2013 Posted July 5, 2013 False. From snopes: http://www.snopes.com/humor/iftrue/potter.asp
Dr. Bombay Posted July 5, 2013 Posted July 5, 2013 Snopes is an infallible arbiter of the truth. Good to know. Can we read Playboy for the articles? I don't want to be one of those people who assume Playboy is from the devil. I'd like to think of myself as much more progressive and open minded. It is the 21st century after all.
PhuturePriest Posted July 5, 2013 Author Posted July 5, 2013 lol. it's not "about guns" really. do people shoot guns? yes. but the story doesn't revolve around guns or magic. it revolves around a quest, really. About a gunslinger (kind of like a knight, and the last of his kind), on a quest to the Dark Tower, the nexus of time & space, because the world has "moved on" (the threads of time & space are starting to loosen), and to make it to the Dark Tower is to hopefully set things aright again. meh. anyway. do want you want. just don't prematurely judge and think a book is about one thing, when it's not. :) (kind of like how people assume Harry Potter is from the devil.) I didn't particularly mean it's "about" guns. It just involves them, most likely heavily, since the guy is a "gunslinger" as you say. :P It's just not my genre of choice, really.
PhuturePriest Posted July 5, 2013 Author Posted July 5, 2013 You would probably enjoy Raymond E. Feist's series of books. The first two are called Magician: Apprentice and Magician: Master (originally released as one enormous book simply called Magician). Very much a medieval setting, much like medieval Europe (more prominently in earlier books), which is invaded by a human race from another world, whose culture rather resembles Imperial Japan. Sounds pretty good. I'll have to look those up! Do you know anything about a book series called Songs of the Earth by Elspeth Cooper? I saw what I think was the first book at a Barnes and Noble once and on the preview there was a prayer to a mythical God that greatly resembled the Hail Mary. I've been meaning to get it, but it looks like it heavily involves magic and its in a setting I described before.
PhuturePriest Posted July 5, 2013 Author Posted July 5, 2013 Snopes is an infallible arbiter of the truth. Good to know. Can we read Playboy for the articles? I don't want to be one of those people who assume Playboy is from the devil. I'd like to think of myself as much more progressive and open minded. It is the 21st century after all. The issue, good sir, is that not one of your lame arguments has any logical or statistical truth to them, whereas ours do. I do wonder if they taught you the art of debating and logical thought while you were in seminary.
Nihil Obstat Posted July 5, 2013 Posted July 5, 2013 Sounds pretty good. I'll have to look those up! Do you know anything about a book series called Songs of the Earth by Elspeth Cooper? I saw what I think was the first book at a Barnes and Noble once and on the preview there was a prayer to a mythical God that greatly resembled the Hail Mary. I've been meaning to get it, but it looks like it heavily involves magic and its in a setting I described before. I have not read it, but I do think I have heard of it a few times. Sounds very familiar. I think I have probably heard if referred to before, though probably not reviewed or anything.
Brother Vinny Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 So, we all settled that reading Harry Potter is not necessarily harmful?
Nihil Obstat Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 So, we all settled that reading Harry Potter is not necessarily harmful? You have been here long enough to know better. :proud:
Brother Vinny Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 You have been here long enough to know better. :proud: Is it okay to watch The Sopranos? It's about this Catholic family in New Jersey.
Nihil Obstat Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 Is it okay to watch The Sopranos? It's about this Catholic family in New Jersey. Speaking of mobsters, I read a really cool analysis by Dr. Peters about how John Gotti was denied a Catholic funeral.
Brother Vinny Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 Speaking of mobsters, I read a really cool analysis by Dr. Peters about how John Gotti was denied a Catholic funeral. Looks lengthy. Bookmarked for later.
Dr. Bombay Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 Can you believe these people that think organized crime is from the devil? This is the 21st century after all. What's a little criminal activity, especially if it's wildly entertaining?
Brother Vinny Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 Can you believe these people that think organized crime is from the devil? This is the 21st century after all. What's a little criminal activity, especially if it's wildly entertaining? Do you engage in watching or reading anything for entertainment? The face of the matter is, there's going to be sin involved somewhere. Drama is conflict, and the more passionate the conflict, the more engrossing the drama.
PhuturePriest Posted July 6, 2013 Author Posted July 6, 2013 Can you believe these people that think organized crime is from the devil? This is the 21st century after all. What's a little criminal activity, especially if it's wildly entertaining? Your trolling skills have deteriorated. I'm afraid you've lost your touch after a month of being here.
Brother Vinny Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 Your trolling skills have deteriorated. I'm afraid you've lost your touch after a month of being here. Is he trolling? He may have some valid concerns. I would like to know what sort of sin-free entertainment he enjoys, though.
Dr. Bombay Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 Do you engage in watching or reading anything for entertainment? The face of the matter is, there's going to be sin involved somewhere. Drama is conflict, and the more passionate the conflict, the more engrossing the drama. I am attempting to cut back on my media intake since I discovered the mesmerizing effect moving images have on the human brain, whether intentional or not. It puts you into a semi-hypnotic state and makes you much more susceptible to suggestion. Now, having said that I'm not advocating living in a cave and eating dirt. It's quite possible to be in the world without being of the world, which is what I believe Christians are called to be. However, evil does not have to be graphically portrayed in order for the point to be made. The problem with modern media is that it is too often and too graphically portrayed. Implying that the deed was done is just as effective as actually showing the deed being done, if you know what I mean. Let me give you an example using the horror genre, and this is something I wrote sometime ago on another forum. Modern horror is for the most part just that...horrible. When the original Dracula movie came out in the 30s, it was something else. The vampire was portrayed as evil, with no redeeming qualities. He could be repelled by a crucifix. Most importantly, good triumphed in the end. Today's horror genre, as a whole, takes a perverse pleasure in turning such conventions on their head. In the case of the vampire in particular, nowadays he ignores or even laughs at the crucifix. Your medieval superstitions are no match for the sleek, modern vampire. Feeding on human blood isn't portrayed as depraved, rather it's sexy. He walks in the sun. He's no longer the embodiment of pure evil, he's a conflicted soul. Sure, he kills human beings, but he's really torn up about it. He's not an ugly centuries old monster, he's a cute boy next door. And so forth. Similarly, other movie monsters can no longer be portrayed in terms of pure evil. The werewolf, the space alien, the serial killer, the ghost or demon. These characters are all multilevel and deeply nuanced. It is a reflection of our perverse society and how far we've fallen that it is rare for even the most horrific characters to be dismissed as pure evil who simply need to be destroyed. And in the end if they do need to be destroyed, we should feel some guilt about it because it's not really their fault they are the way they are. Bah. It's all relativistic nonsense and reflects a societal cowardice that we won't call a spade a spade. Now, this doesn't necessarily apply to Harry Potter, as there are other issues with that. The point is, though, that evil is often called good and vice versa in popular culture. Anyone who can't recognize that is not paying attention I'm afraid and dismissing legit concerns as fanaticism that sees Satan around every corner is less than helpful.
Dr. Bombay Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 Do you engage in watching or reading anything for entertainment? The face of the matter is, there's going to be sin involved somewhere. Drama is conflict, and the more passionate the conflict, the more engrossing the drama. I am attempting to cut back on my media intake since I discovered the mesmerizing effect moving images have on the human brain, whether intentional or not. It puts you into a semi-hypnotic state and makes you much more susceptible to suggestion. Now, having said that I'm not advocating living in a cave and eating dirt. It's quite possible to be in the world without being of the world, which is what I believe Christians are called to be. However, evil does not have to be graphically portrayed in order for the point to be made. The problem with modern media is that it is too often and too graphically portrayed. Implying that the deed was done is just as effective as actually showing the deed being done, if you know what I mean. Let me give you an example using the horror genre, and this is something I wrote sometime ago on another forum. Modern horror is for the most part just that...horrible. When the original Dracula movie came out in the 30s, it was something else. The vampire was portrayed as evil, with no redeeming qualities. He could be repelled by a crucifix. Most importantly, good triumphed in the end. Today's horror genre, as a whole, takes a perverse pleasure in turning such conventions on their head. In the case of the vampire in particular, nowadays he ignores or even laughs at the crucifix. Your medieval superstitions are no match for the sleek, modern vampire. Feeding on human blood isn't portrayed as depraved, rather it's sexy. He walks in the sun. He's no longer the embodiment of pure evil, he's a conflicted soul. Sure, he kills human beings, but he's really torn up about it. He's not an ugly centuries old monster, he's a cute boy next door. And so forth. Similarly, other movie monsters can no longer be portrayed in terms of pure evil. The werewolf, the space alien, the serial killer, the ghost or demon. These characters are all multilevel and deeply nuanced. It is a reflection of our perverse society and how far we've fallen that it is rare for even the most horrific characters to be dismissed as pure evil who simply need to be destroyed. And in the end if they do need to be destroyed, we should feel some guilt about it because it's not really their fault they are the way they are. Bah. It's all relativistic nonsense and reflects a societal cowardice that we won't call a spade a spade. Now, this doesn't necessarily apply to Harry Potter, as there are other issues with that. The point is, though, that evil is often called good and vice versa in popular culture. Anyone who can't recognize that is not paying attention I'm afraid and dismissing legit concerns as fanaticism that sees Satan around every corner is less than helpful.
Dr. Bombay Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 And before anyone mentions it, I realize the 1930s Dracula portrayed the Count as a sort of mysterious, exotic character, but that was merely a mask for his pure evil. The silent film Nosferatu much more effectively portrayed the vampire as both spiritually and physically repugnant.
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted July 6, 2013 Posted July 6, 2013 Everyone from Father Robert Baron to Michael Voris praises The Lord of the Rings. J.R.R. Tolkien was an incredible Catholic. Do not judge him because you choose not to understand magic and its harmlessness in fiction. I haven't judged anyone, just giving my honest opinion. What is the opinion of the Pope and the Magesterium of the church as a whole and not individuals. Magic is not a toy, it is in serious opposition of the truth. Magicians are mentioned a couple of times in the new testament and both times where opposed to the gospel of the Lord,one even with the same name as Jesus i think it was something like Ba-Jesus. And in the old.testament,. i think it is leviticus, we are warned against such divinations, including magic. This is not a joke about fun, this is about faith,hope,love and peace, and such things are opposed to faith,hope,love and peace. Onward Chrisitan souls. JESUS iz LORD.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now