Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

A Question Concerning Harry Potter


Recommended Posts

Posted

FP: STD is a Sacred Theology Doctorate (I'm too lazy to look up the exact Latin). I'll find that "the more you know" meme later, it's late.

Also, I'll just leave this here:

"To summarize: What we have is an informal, brief, obscurely worded opinion, in a private letter that may or may not have been written by Ratzinger himself, apparently declining to comment on a book that he may or may not have perused about a series of books he may or may not have ever laid eyes on."

From: http://www.decentfilms.com/articles/harrypotterandthepope

PhuturePriest
Posted

I'm going to assume this is an attempt at humor.

 

"Attempt" implies that I failed, which I most certainly did not.

PhuturePriest
Posted

FP: STD is a Sacred Theology Doctorate (I'm too lazy to look up the exact Latin). I'll find that "the more you know" meme later, it's late.

Also, I'll just leave this here:

"To summarize: What we have is an informal, brief, obscurely worded opinion, in a private letter that may or may not have been written by Ratzinger himself, apparently declining to comment on a book that he may or may not have perused about a series of books he may or may not have ever laid eyes on."

From: http://www.decentfilms.com/articles/harrypotterandthepope

 

 

"Attempt" implies that I failed, which I most certainly did not.

Posted

Clearly, there are church leaders on both sides of the debate. Guess we'll have to leave this one up to our individual consciences.

 props

Brother Vinny
Posted

BTW, would those who argue Harry Potter should be avoided make the same argument against Star Wars?  If not, why not?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I can't stop anyone from watching t.v and/or movies, just be righteous about what you watch and don't fill your heart and mind with doo doo . Listen to this song, it is about being a righteous movie watcher.

 

http://youtu.be/jspGh30k7DI

 

Please listen to the whole song, i have watched your franciscan priest on this matter before, i will watch it again just for you.

I do hope you recognize the gigantic irony contained in this post. :hehe: I just wanted to point that out.

Dr. Bombay
Posted

He did not believe in the immaculate conception. So he has been wrong...

 

Also I have read other lists of virtues and vices from he era and they include laughter and clapping...

 

I would not say that Aquinas is right nor wrong I merely think that he is talking about a different subject that's name has changed in time but the text remains.

 

Yes, I'm aware of Aquinas and the Immaculate Conception.  As he himself would tell you his theological suppositions ceased to have relevance once the Church pronounced a matter infallibly.

 

The distinction he makes between studiousness and curiosity is quite clear for anyone who cares to take the time to read it, modern definitions notwithstanding.

Posted

"Attempt" implies that I failed, which I most certainly did not.


No, you definitely failed.
PhuturePriest
Posted

No, you definitely failed.

 

Only if you are below my glorious sense of humor.

Brother Vinny
Posted

Still awaiting an answer on my Star Wars question.

 

Maybe Harry Potter came too late into my life, since I never really wanted to be a wizard, but you can bet your sweet bippy I wanted to be a Jedi.  I remember 10-year-old me, fresh from seeing The Empire Strikes Back at the theater, trying my hardest to will a balled pair of socks up into my hand.  They never budged,  It was a hard lesson about the difference between reality and make-believe.

 

The differences between the Force and Harry Potter's magic are mostly superficial.  So why don't we see the same arguments leveled against Star Wars that we do Harry Potter?

PhuturePriest
Posted

Still awaiting an answer on my Star Wars question.

 

Maybe Harry Potter came too late into my life, since I never really wanted to be a wizard, but you can bet your sweet bippy I wanted to be a Jedi.  I remember 10-year-old me, fresh from seeing The Empire Strikes Back at the theater, trying my hardest to will a balled pair of socks up into my hand.  They never budged,  It was a hard lesson about the difference between reality and make-believe.

 

The differences between the Force and Harry Potter's magic are mostly superficial.  So why don't we see the same arguments leveled against Star Wars that we do Harry Potter?

 

Because Harry Potter uses wands and cool pointy hats and capes. Duh.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Star Wars is actually philosophically worse than Potter, because it's pretty similar to a lot of Eastern philosophy.  Becoming "one" with the Force, Only Sith deal in absolutes,  etc.  Harry Potter is about choosing to be good, the evils of bigotry, and the power of love and sacrifice. :)   But Star Wars has lightsabers and the Force instead of wands and magic, so it's automatically okay.   :hehe2:

Posted

Star Wars is actually philosophically worse than Potter, because it's pretty similar to a lot of Eastern philosophy.  Becoming "one" with the Force, Only Sith deal in absolutes,  etc.  Harry Potter is about choosing to be good, the evils of bigotry, and the power of love and sacrifice. :)   But Star Wars has lightsabers and the Force instead of wands and magic, so it's automatically okay.   :hehe2:

 

This is relevant to my interests.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Star Wars is actually philosophically worse than Potter, because it's pretty similar to a lot of Eastern philosophy.  Becoming "one" with the Force, Only Sith deal in absolutes,  etc.  Harry Potter is about choosing to be good, the evils of bigotry, and the power of love and sacrifice. :)   But Star Wars has lightsabers and the Force instead of wands and magic, so it's automatically okay.   :hehe2:

 

Precisely. It also completely replaces God with the Force and Midichlorians. It also says anger is bad, even though the Church teaches there is just anger.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

Star Wars is actually philosophically worse than Potter, because it's pretty similar to a lot of Eastern philosophy.  Becoming "one" with the Force, Only Sith deal in absolutes,  etc.  Harry Potter is about choosing to be good, the evils of bigotry, and the power of love and sacrifice. :)   But Star Wars has lightsabers and the Force instead of wands and magic, so it's automatically okay.   :hehe2:

 

No, Star Wars is SUPER Catholic! At least, according to my high school religion teacher (one of them anyway).  Yay syncretistic relativism! :|

PhuturePriest
Posted

Star Wars is actually philosophically worse than Potter, because it's pretty similar to a lot of Eastern philosophy.  Becoming "one" with the Force, Only Sith deal in absolutes,  etc.  Harry Potter is about choosing to be good, the evils of bigotry, and the power of love and sacrifice. :)   But Star Wars has lightsabers and the Force instead of wands and magic, so it's automatically okay.   :hehe2:

 

I'm with you, but what do you mean when you say the Sith only deal in absolutes?

Brother Vinny
Posted

I'm with you, but what do you mean when you say the Sith only deal in absolutes?

 

It's a (patently ridiculous) quote made by Obi-Wan to Anakin in Revenge of the Sith.

Dr. Bombay
Posted

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wgpytjlW5wU

 

"Whoever is not with me is against me, and whoever does not gather with me scatters." --Matt. 12:30

 

 

Huh.  I guess Jesus Christ is a Sith.

 

 

I'm sure it's just a coincidence.  Nothing to see here.  Move along, move along.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Lol at there being 11 pages though Miles' question was answered on page one. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wgpytjlW5wU

 

"Whoever is not with me is against me, and whoever does not gather with me scatters." --Matt. 12:30

 

 

Huh.  I guess Jesus Christ is a Sith.

 

 

I'm sure it's just a coincidence.  Nothing to see here.  Move along, move along.

 

Sith are cooler.

 

Lol at there being 11 pages though Miles' question was answered on page one. 

 

Win.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...