Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

We manage very well. I simply can't see why GWB was elected once, let alone twice.

Posted

We manage very well. I simply can't see why GWB was elected once, let alone twice.

All you have to do is look at who he was running against. At least he didn't contract syphilis, killed several wives, and create his own Church. That kind of insanity can only be done by a megalomaniac king.  

Posted

I'd be the last to defend Henry VIII but you appear to be clutching at straws if you think that the two figures are comparable.

Posted (edited)

I'd be the last to defend Henry VIII but you appear to be clutching at straws if you think that the two figures are comparable.

No human beings can be compared in an absolute manner, but England has had plenty of bad monarchs. Has America had bad presidents? Yes, but again our system limits their length of rule and in doing so frees us from the corruption of a hereditary monarchy. Now, England isn't really a true monarchy any more, because its monarchs are impotent, and if they ever tried to exercise real power . . . on that day the British monarchy would end.

Edited by Apotheoun
franciscanheart
Posted

:popcorn:

Posted

Quite frankly I would take George W. Bush as a president again over George III, Elizabeth I, Henry VIII, or any number of other British monarchs.

Posted

No human beings can be compared in an absolute manner, but England has had plenty of bad monarchs. Has America had bad presidents? Yes, but again our system limits their length of rule and in doing so frees us from the corruption of a hereditary monarchy. Now, England isn't really a true monarchy any more, because its monarchs are impotent, and if they ever tried to exercise real power . . . on that day the British monarchy would end.

 

Therefore your previous argument fails; you mention the failings of past monarchs but then point out that they no longer have any real power. The USA twice, in recent years, elected an idiot and gave him huge power.

 

I honestly had no idea that there was any contention over the idea that George W Bush is a bit thick. :p

Posted

I honestly had no idea that there was any contention over the idea that George W Bush is a bit thick. :P

 

He seems in okay shape to me. Jeb Bush's the pudgy one.

franciscanheart
Posted

Therefore your previous argument fails; you mention the failings of past monarchs but then point out that they no longer have any real power. The USA twice, in recent years, elected an idiot and gave him huge power.

So if you were an American, you'd be a Democrat, eh? So noted. :like:
Posted (edited)

Therefore your previous argument fails; you mention the failings of past monarchs but then point out that they no longer have any real power. The USA twice, in recent years, elected an idiot and gave him huge power.

 

I honestly had no idea that there was any contention over the idea that George W Bush is a bit thick. :P

The British monarchs haven't had any real power since Victoria. Although they (the future kings or queens) could try to exercise their old powers because the unwritten constitution of the UK would not prevent that. Nevertheless, as I already said, if a British King (or Queen) tried to exercise real power today, the monarchy would come to an end at that very moment. But that begs the question, why have a powerless monarch at all? The British monarchy is nothing more than a tourist attraction. People in the US (and other countries) like to visit the Magic Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, where they see people dressed up in funny costumes and can gossip about the royals who have no real jobs or responsibilities.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted (edited)

Actually, I think the new British heir to the throne is named after... the Pope.    Jorge=George.     ;)  :evil:

Edited by AnneLine
Posted

You're getting rather annoyed, aren't you? There's no need to be rude just because I pointed out how stupid GWB is.

HisChildForever
Posted

:popcorn:

Posted

You're getting rather annoyed, aren't you? There's no need to be rude just because I pointed out how stupid GWB is.

Not at all, I'm having fun. My life doesn't revolve around George W. Bush (or any president of the United States for that matter). I don't read up on Bush's family to see what babies are being born, and whether his kids and grandkids are dropping their draws in Las Vegas. That's for the British to do with their royal family (if you can actually call it a family . . . it seems more like a business to me).

Posted

I should add that . . . I come to Phatmass to have fun, and that is all. After all, there haven't been any serious debates at the phorum in four or five years (e.g., look at the comical "debate" on Catholic virgins in the Debate Table). It is rare that anything serious happens at Phatmass these days.

Posted

Oh you're right, I can't possibly leave the house in the morning without checking the Court Circular in the Times.

Spem in alium
Posted

Actually, I think the new British heir to the throne is named after... the Pope.    Jorge=George.     ;)  :evil:

 

:winner: 

 

Huzzah!

Posted (edited)

The British monarchs haven't had any real power since Victoria. Although they (the future kings or queens) could try to exercise their old powers because the unwritten constitution of the UK would not prevent that. Nevertheless, as I already said, if a British King (or Queen) tried to exercise real power today, the monarchy would come to an end at that very moment. But that begs the question, why have a powerless monarch at all? The British monarchy is nothing more than a tourist attraction. People in the US (and other countries) like to visit the Magic Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, where they see people dressed up in funny costumes and can gossip about the royals who have no real jobs or responsibilities.

 

I don't think being a figurehead necessarily means the monarchy should be abolished. It's a deep part of English culture and history. And they can do much useful stuff...I doubt they are twiddling their thumbs all day.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

Oh you're right, I can't possibly leave the house in the morning without checking the Court Circular in the Times.

It looks that way.   :evil:

Posted

:pirate2:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...