Era Might Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 Popes dissolved the allegiance of Catholics to the kings of England long ago. But to be honest it does not even require a pope to do that, because no Catholic is bound to support something that is contrary to the natural moral law or divine revelation. For example: "gay marriage" laws - which of course have no legal standing because they are contrary to the moral norm - do not bind Catholics. And even without the exercise of papal or episcopal authority Catholics are - in conscience - duty bound to resist such enactments. The same holds with positive laws that are contrary to the good, which would include rulers - whether kings or presidents - no one is bound in conscience to support a person who has no real right to execise authority. lolwut? Sounds like a form of secular donatism, only the pure and righteous can wield power legitimately.
Basilisa Marie Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 I'm just glad Apo has found someone else to pick on. :P
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 It must be wonderful to have such a talent for identifying and condemning the sins of others. Lack of judgment is not a virtue. Catholics are required to judge the actions of others, and if those actions do not conform to the moral law or to what has been divinely revealed, we are to point that out (as an act of charity), while simultaneously avoiding any action that might make us complicit in the actions of that individual.
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 I'm just glad Apo has found someone else to pick on. :P I don't pick on you, and that is true even when we disagree on certain points. You are a fellow Catholic, and that unites us in the body of Christ.
Anselm Posted July 24, 2013 Author Posted July 24, 2013 Erm, no, British Catholics were absolved by Pius V from their allegiance to Elizabeth I, not all future British monarchs.
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 lolwut? Sounds like a form of secular donatism, only the pure and righteous can wield power legitimately. Not at all. It is called . . . following the moral law. The midwives in disobeying Pharaoh did just what I am saying all Catholics are required to do. We must fear God more than man. After all, human rulers can only kill the body they cannot damage our souls,
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 (edited) Erm, no, British Catholics were absolved by Pius V from their allegiance to Elizabeth I, not all future British monarchs. No Catholic can be required to give allegiance to a heretic ruler. By the way, that is why I said it does not take papal or episcopal action to dissolve the allegiance owed to a ruler. It is sad when Western Catholics are ignorant of their own scholastic tradition. Edited July 24, 2013 by Apotheoun
Era Might Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 Not at all. It is called . . . following the moral law. The midwives in disobeying Pharaoh did just what I am saying all Catholics are required to do. We must fear God more than man. After all, human rulers can only kill the body they cannot damage our souls, okey dokey. Let me know when you plan your raid on Harper's Ferry.
Anselm Posted July 24, 2013 Author Posted July 24, 2013 So does that mean that no Catholic should serve in the armed forces of any country without a Catholic absolute monarch? As a former officer of the Royal Navy do you think that means that I'm excommunicated?
Era Might Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 No Catholic can be required to give allegiance to a heretic ruler. Catholics are so required every day...the fact that you accept U.S. laws means you are giving allegiance to heretic rulers.
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 okey dokey. Let me know when you plan your raid on Harper's Ferry. I don't remember the midwives undertaking an attack on pharaoh; instead, they simply refused to obey his command. Perhaps he killed them for their refusal to obey, scripture does not say. All a Catholic is required to do is to conscientiously object (i.e., not obey the false law), while also working to overturn the law through peaceful means (at least until those means have been exhausted).
Anselm Posted July 24, 2013 Author Posted July 24, 2013 No Catholic can be required to give allegiance to a heretic ruler. By the way, that is why I said it does not take papal or episcopal action to dissolve the allegiance owed to a ruler. It is sad when Western Catholics are ignorant of their own scholastic tradition. Consequently you must surely believe that you have a duty to move to a country with a Catholic head of state? 'Scholar Emeritus'? Laughable.
Era Might Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 I don't remember the midwives undertaking an attack on pharaoh; instead, they simply refused to obey his command. Perhaps he killed them for their refusal to obey, scripture does not say. All a Catholic is required to do is to conscientiously object (i.e., not obey the false law), while also working to overturn the law through peaceful means (at least until those means have been exhausted). lolwut? You just made my point...one can, in fact, accept the authority of a heretic, even if they don't accept individual laws or actions.
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 Catholics are so required every day...the fact that you accept U.S. laws means you are giving allegiance to heretic rulers. Actually I do not obey heretic rulers. I obey the laws of the United States that conform to the moral law. I don't obey laws contrary to right reason or the moral norm. Now, do I want the government of the United States to be Catholic? Sure. Is it something I foresee happening any time soon? No, and partially because the Catholics who have been elected to public office are rarely if ever really Catholic (e.g., Nancy Pelosi, Joe Biden, et al.).
Anselm Posted July 24, 2013 Author Posted July 24, 2013 So which laws do you believe contravene your personal interpretation of the moral law?
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 (edited) lolwut? You just made my point...one can, in fact, accept the authority of a heretic, even if they don't accept individual laws or actions. Actually, and I don't blame you for not knowing much about your own Western tradition (catechesis has been terrible for decades), but a Catholic does not obey a heretical ruler; instead, he obeys the directives issued by such a person as long as they conform to the moral law. So the heretic, if he issues directives that conform to the moral norm is "obeyed" only in the sense that a given directive is good and true. Or to put it more precisely it is the directive (i.e., the law - and in this case the natural and immutable moral law) that is motivating the obedience and not the person who issues the directive, who may be an utter and complete heretic or moral deviant (the latter case can even apply to Catholic rulers who have privately deviated from the moral law). As long as the positive law conforms to the moral norm a Catholic is bound to obey it. Conversely if the law enacted is contrary to the moral law, not only is a Catholic duty bound to not observe it, he is also require to work for its abolition. Edited July 24, 2013 by Apotheoun
Anselm Posted July 24, 2013 Author Posted July 24, 2013 Can you send me a copy of your moral law? It'd be terribly handy to have around.
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 So which laws do you believe contravene your personal interpretation of the moral law? Abortion laws, and laws that support euthansia. Also laws that recognize "gay marriage." It is not hard to determine the "laws" that contravene the primary precepts of the moral law. It becomes more difficult when positive laws affect the secondary or tertiary precepts of the moral norm. That is where the guidance of the Church is indispensable.
Socrates Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 G.W. Bush, a lot to live up to? If he wants to be a war-mongering half-wit, yes. I don't understand why they didn't name him Barrack Hussein, after our own illustrious king, modern messiah, hope of mankind, and flawless model for rulers everywhere. Let the flame wars commence!
Apotheoun Posted July 24, 2013 Posted July 24, 2013 Hey, don't pick on him, Barack Obama won the Nobel Peace Prize, and he has the honor of being the first Peace Prize winner with a kill list.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now