Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Agent Richard Dawkins, Job Well Done


Recommended Posts

Posted

written by an atheist in the telegraph:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/religion/10233530/Come-in-Agent-Dawkins-your-job-is-done.html

 

 

 

What I suspect must have happened was that, some time in the late Seventies, the leaders of the world’s great religions met in secret conclave to discuss the threat posed by the march of science. Appreciating that the unravelling of the genetic code would one day enable life to be created in a test tube, thereby usurping the primary function of the Creator, they came up with a wickedly ironic plan. They would recruit the world’s leading geneticist, and run him under deep cover as a double agent for Big Religa. His brief was first to win the slavish respect of the atheist community, as he did with his meisterwork The God Delusion; and then to pretend to go so infuriatingly and offensively doolally that atheists would find the faiths he derided infinitely more appealing than their fiercest foe, and flock to them. This plot he has carried out to the letter. I would now rather spend a year in a Cistercian monastery or a madrassa than a minute listening to Richard Dawkins.

 

haha so true, so true.

Posted

:hehe:

 

So very true...he is a rather excellent example that atheists can be obnoxious and bigoted too. 

Posted

I sometimes listen to him just for his accent and to hear the way he pronounces "evolution".

Posted

I sometimes listen to him just for his accent and to hear the way he pronounces "evolution".

You should stop wasting your time and watch Doctor Who instead.

Posted

You should stop wasting your time and watch Doctor Who instead.

 

Nothing beats David Tenant's voice.

Posted

Nothing beats David Tenant's voice.

 

But do you mean his accent in Doctor Who or his real accent?

Posted

But do you mean his accent in Doctor Who or his real accent?

 

That's not his real accent? :sad:

 

Oh right, I just remembered he's Scottish. Scottish accents are the bee's knees, so either one is awesome, really.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Watch Broadchurch. You'll hear his real accent, and it's fantastic.  I've heard they're having Peter Capaldi use his native accent, so we'll get a Scottish Doctor.  :)

 

I can't get enough of how the media is finally turning away from Dawkins worship.  

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

I don't get it. The writer is mad because Dawkins pointed something out that many, including Neil deGrasse Tyson (and Neil doesn't even call himself an atheist), blame on Islam (specifically the idea that the manipulation of numbers is the work of satan). The author bashes Dawkins for making this argument... but doesn't actually counter it. 

Posted

I don't get it. The writer is mad because Dawkins pointed something out that many, including Neil deGrasse Tyson (and Neil doesn't even call himself an atheist), blame on Islam (specifically the idea that the manipulation of numbers is the work of satan). The author bashes Dawkins for making this argument... but doesn't actually counter it. 

 

Someone wrote a retort to it in the comments section.

Posted

FALSE.

http://thedailybanter.com/2010/08/neil-degrasse-tyson-and-the-myth-of-islamic-anti-science/

 

 

The idea that fewer Muslims have nobel prizes that whitebred elite graduates of Trinity College who had the money, means, and connections to be successful in fields of science because "Islam is teh evil" is patently ridiculous.  It'd be the same as pointing out that fewer members of the Arab world have Nobel prizes than members of "Western Civilization"... basically because Western Civilization has a dominant hegemonic nature that still affects the global balance of such things, the best and brightest of the world leave their home countries to go to the more prestigious universities of Europe and America where research is more well funded and possible.  Same basic thing is at work when we look at the number of Muslims with nobel prizes, especially since the majority of Muslims live in the Arab world.

Posted

Who really cares about Nobel Prizes anyway? How important can they be if Obama, a man with a kill list, can be a Nobel Peace Prize winner?

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

FALSE.

http://thedailybanter.com/2010/08/neil-degrasse-tyson-and-the-myth-of-islamic-anti-science/

 

 

The idea that fewer Muslims have nobel prizes that whitebred elite graduates of Trinity College who had the money, means, and connections to be successful in fields of science because "Islam is teh evil" is patently ridiculous.  It'd be the same as pointing out that fewer members of the Arab world have Nobel prizes than members of "Western Civilization"... basically because Western Civilization has a dominant hegemonic nature that still affects the global balance of such things, the best and brightest of the world leave their home countries to go to the more prestigious universities of Europe and America where research is more well funded and possible.  Same basic thing is at work when we look at the number of Muslims with nobel prizes, especially since the majority of Muslims live in the Arab world.

 

http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/rel_isl_num_of_mus-religion-islam-number-of-muslim

The bolded section is incorrect. But you're right. He did provide a rebuttal. I'm interested in a more detailed explanation, which I'm sure is available. 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

There is an icky attitude shared by some Muslims about modern science mostly being a product of the "West", which comes with it a sort of bitterness towards achievements that build upon the discoveries of Islamic Golden Age. I do not know if we can determine whether this mentality is a cause or result of the problem (or both). So, yes, I guess it'd be intellectually lazy to throw the Nobel prize figures up and make a conclusion solely based on that.

Enter:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk%3AAl-Ghazali#Criticism

Here is what i'm referring to specifically. Tyson blames a statement made by Ghazali for the lack of scientific achievement in the Muslim world after the 12th century. The Muslim responses I've seen argue that Tyson misunderstood the quote. 

 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/rel_isl_num_of_mus-religion-islam-number-of-muslim

The bolded section is incorrect. But you're right. He did provide a rebuttal. I'm interested in a more detailed explanation, which I'm sure is available. 

add up all the arab countries, there are more Muslims in the Arab world... though I suppose technically you'll need to exclude Iran and such, but not having done the math myself I still think it's more, and for the purposes of my statement I was kind of using a broad definition of "the Arab world" that would include not only any country that's a member of the Arab league but also any other place in the Middle East for which my statements about the hegemony of the west would apply... the Arab/Persian world, shall we say.

Posted

There is an icky attitude shared by some Muslims about modern science mostly being a product of the "West", which comes with it a sort of bitterness towards achievements that build upon the discoveries of Islamic Golden Age. I do not know if we can determine whether this mentality is a cause or result of the problem (or both). So, yes, I guess it'd be intellectually lazy to throw the Nobel prize figures up and make a conclusion solely based on that.

Enter:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk%3AAl-Ghazali#Criticism

Here is what i'm referring to specifically. Tyson blames a statement made by Ghazali for the lack of scientific achievement in the Muslim world after the 12th century. The Muslim responses I've seen argue that Tyson misunderstood the quote. 

 

well an historical question about 12th century onward is its own question, the Dawkins statement is still idiotic even if you went all out to blame Islam for some historical stagnation of science there.  if the Arab world had become the dominant hegemonic force in the world instead of the West, they would likely dominate their equivalent of Nobel prizes, and I imagine their scientific tradition would've developed and discovered many things if it was the central political force in the world.

 

and of course there are some Muslims who have an icky attitude towards science, as there are Christians in the Bible belt who have an icky attitude as well.  of course that wouldn't be much of a problem for Dawkin's position, but it puts things in perspective for us... there are plenty of Muslims who are totally into science and there is no data to suggest that Islam is in any way keeping modern Muslim people in general from getting Nobel Prizes, and plenty of evidence to suggest that people who have the means to go to Trinity College are entirely advantaged.

 

maybe you could say there are no Salafis with nobel prizes in science, you could also say there are no Geocentrist Traditionalist Catholics or Biblical Literalist Creationists with nobel prizes in science, woopidity doo Captain Obvious!  there are plenty of paths either religious or cultural that a person can go down which will result in them not having a life dedicated to science and getting a nobel peace prize... but Islam in general is not one of those things.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

add up all the arab countries, there are more Muslims in the Arab world... though I suppose technically you'll need to exclude Iran and such, but not having done the math myself I still think it's more, and for the purposes of my statement I was kind of using a broad definition of "the Arab world" that would include not only any country that's a member of the Arab league but also any other place in the Middle East for which my statements about the hegemony of the west would apply... the Arab/Persian world, shall we say.

 

If I'm not mistaken, the estimates I've read claim fewer than 20% of Muslims live in the "Arab" world. 

Posted

If I'm not mistaken, the estimates I've read claim fewer than 20% of Muslims live in the "Arab" world. 

 

I've read statistics that indicate that about 20% of Muslims are Arab. North Africa, South-East Asia and places like Pakistan and Bangladesh seem to be forgotten. The Arab Muslim is just the stereotype - much like the stereotype of the American Fundamentalist when people think of Christianity. 

Posted

ah you are correct, I'm not sure if you counted Turkey, Iran, and Pakistan... but in general you're right.  even so the statement about Western dominance still applies to Bangladesh, and of course to Africa (which I think I wasn't really thinking about when I said that)... so how about the Arab/Persian/African world lol...either way it's a minor point, but you're right to correct my overly simplistic statement nonetheless.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...