CatholicsAreKewl Posted September 25, 2013 Posted September 25, 2013 (edited) well an historical question about 12th century onward is its own question, the Dawkins statement is still idiotic even if you went all out to blame Islam for some historical stagnation of science there. if the Arab world had become the dominant hegemonic force in the world instead of the West, they would likely dominate their equivalent of Nobel prizes, and I imagine their scientific tradition would've developed and discovered many things if it was the central political force in the world. That's a good point, but we can't forget that not all of the key achievements from the Golden Age of Islam were actually by Muslims. Israel with a population of 7.9 million claims 4 nobel science laureates (twice the amount of all Muslims). The Muslim population in the United States, France, and the United Kingdom alone is higher than this number. The population of Israelis is much lower than the global population of Muslims. We're not even taking into account all Jews, only Israelis. I understand that i'm not proving anything by throwing these numbers out, but its painfully obvious that there's some sort of problem (whether or not its relevant to religion is another thing). maybe you could say there are no Salafis with nobel prizes in science, you could also say there are no Geocentrist Traditionalist Catholics or Biblical Literalist Creationists with nobel prizes in science, woopidity doo Captain Obvious! there are plenty of paths either religious or cultural that a person can go down which will result in them not having a life dedicated to science and getting a nobel peace prize... but Islam in general is not one of those things. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Muslim_Nobel_Laureates The problem exists for all Muslims, not just Salafis. There are only two Muslims named in the science portion of the article above. Now, we could argue that the problem exists among Salafis specifically because of their religious beliefs. I agree with you that it's hard to generalize the beliefs of all Muslims. Edited September 25, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
Aloysius Posted September 25, 2013 Author Posted September 25, 2013 well it's not really a 'problem' among Salafis, unless you hold that the only thing significant one can do with one's life is to be a great scientist. you might as well suggest that it's a problem among automobile mechanics, actors, baseball players, or desert hermits that none of them got nobel science prizes... they have devoted their lives to something entirely different than science. Israel factors into the Western economic hegemony, it's basically the British colony of Palestine handed over to the Jewish diaspora community. don't take that as a statement of judgment against them and open up any can of worms about whether Israel should've been created, btw, it's just a basic economic reality. I guess my point is that the problem is the economic and political disparity. How many Africans in Africa, for instance, are nobel science laureates? I imagine not many... and anyone who does get to a high enough level in science from such a place will immediately find a way to get themselves to a Western University where research funding is available... but even that is difficult for people who are highly intelligent and devoted, acceptance at top level universities is difficult even for a smart student in America or Europe, and that difficulty is multiplied for smart students in countries where Islam is dominant.
Aloysius Posted September 25, 2013 Author Posted September 25, 2013 I guess the main point is that there are many intelligent Muslim scientists... I know a few students in Egypt who are Muslim and are studying science or engineering at university, many of who have their greatest ambition to go to MIT. as I understand the grading system here, their grades probably could've put them in the running if they were American students, but there are many more hurdles they will have to get over before they could make it to MIT and end up as researchers with a great deal of grant money available to achieve something unique and great in the scientific world worthy of a Nobel prize. the Muslims I know here who don't go far into any academic fields I would say do so because their chances of getting careers by that route are slim, none of them seem to have any idea that they don't want to do science because of some Islamic reason, more they don't want to do science because there's not much of a chance for them to succeed or get a job.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted September 26, 2013 Posted September 26, 2013 well it's not really a 'problem' among Salafis, unless you hold that the only thing significant one can do with one's life is to be a great scientist. you might as well suggest that it's a problem among automobile mechanics, actors, baseball players, or desert hermits that none of them got nobel science prizes... they have devoted their lives to something entirely different than science. Israel factors into the Western economic hegemony, it's basically the British colony of Palestine handed over to the Jewish diaspora community. don't take that as a statement of judgment against them and open up any can of worms about whether Israel should've been created, btw, it's just a basic economic reality. I guess my point is that the problem is the economic and political disparity. How many Africans in Africa, for instance, are nobel science laureates? I imagine not many... and anyone who does get to a high enough level in science from such a place will immediately find a way to get themselves to a Western University where research funding is available... but even that is difficult for people who are highly intelligent and devoted, acceptance at top level universities is difficult even for a smart student in America or Europe, and that difficulty is multiplied for smart students in countries where Islam is dominant. If I'm not mistaken, there are no black nobel prize winners in science related fields. Excellent point (the best counter-argument I've read so far). I think it's very possible that the problem is related to economic and political disparity. Culture could play into it as well. From what I've observed (and I think you'll find this to be the case in Egypt too), college students are pressured to become either engineers, doctors, lawyers, or businessmen. Choosing a career path for monetary or status related reasons might also have something to do with it.
John Ryan Posted September 26, 2013 Posted September 26, 2013 I am not quite sure why anybody takes Richard Dawkins seriously. I respect him as a zoologist, even though I think his selfish gene theory is the wrong way to understand evolutionary change, but his atheistic beliefs are nonsensical. His arguments are boorishly childish. He is the Rush Limbaugh or Glenn Beck of Atheism.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted September 26, 2013 Posted September 26, 2013 (edited) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LGm0iWPC80 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zkS1B0huWX4 Dawkins says dumb things but I like watching his unedited interviews with theists. The first one is with the author of The Dawkins Delusion and the second video is with George Coyne, former directer of the Vatican Observatory. Edited September 26, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now