Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Have A Question


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

I was reading the life and times of Blessed John Paul the Great on Wikipedia (Great source, I know), and it said he said that those with "deep-seated homosexual tendencies" are not allowed to be seminarians. What exactly are "deep-seated" homosexual tendencies? I've looked but nothing really explains it.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

I'd imagine that this would have to be dealt with on a case-by-case basis. My guess is that if it would make marriage problematic for you, then that would qualify.

Posted

http://www.ewtn.com/.../zpsychhomo.HTM

 

"Those with deep-seated homosexual tendencies identify themselves as homosexual persons and are usually unwilling to examine their emotional conflicts that caused this tendency. Strong physical attraction is present to other men's bodies and to the masculinity of others due to profound weakness in male confidence."

 

It is also by a case by case basis.

 

Posted (edited)

These seem to be good responses, but you'd probably get a more definitive response on the 'Ask an Expert' thread.

 

 

(edited to fix an edit that shouldn't have happened.   Grumpy at software!)

Edited by AnneLine
Posted

I was reading the life and times of Blessed John Paul the Great on Wikipedia (Great source, I know), and it said he said that those with "deep-seated homosexual tendencies" are not allowed to be seminarians. 

Is someone afraid of being rejected or something?

Posted

I second Freedom's post. Are you worried, FP? You are kind of just a little bit too fabulous.  :hehe2:

HisChildForever
Posted

I think it means that persons (well, men) who are very preoccupied with their same-sex attraction or struggle with it immensely aren't encouraged to join seminary. I bet the same rule of thumb would apply to heterosexual men who battle against their sexuality daily.

 

Is someone afraid of being rejected or something?

 

This was rude.

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

Seminary is hard enough without being sexually attracted to your peers, especially when you're encouraged to form strong brotherly relationships with them. "Deep seated homosexual tendencies" is probably purposefully vague, because when it comes to human feelings you can't use empirical analysis.  

 

Lots of people who study human behavior and sexuality embrace the theory that human sexuality exists on a spectrum, instead of purely black and white (homosexual/heterosexual). This idea allows for people to have different "degrees" of sexual inclinations. So some people who identify as homosexual may have an easier time resisting temptation than others (just as some heterosexuals have a harder time resisting temptation and having friendships with the opposite sex than others do). I know some seminarians who were accepted into seminary and either already had or later developed problems with sexuality (porn addictions, girlfriends on the side, inappropriate behavior toward females, etc). Most of them ended up leaving the seminary. 

Some theologians (I forget who precisely) also like to talk about how being a heterosexual man is a mandatory part of forming a proper relationship to the Church and ministering to others. So there's some variation on all sides of how to interpret the "deep seated" term.  Though ultimately it comes down to a case by case basis, involving the seminarian, the seminary, and the bishop. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie
Posted

I think it means that persons (well, men) who are very preoccupied with their same-sex attraction or struggle with it immensely aren't encouraged to join seminary. I bet the same rule of thumb would apply to heterosexual men who battle against their sexuality daily.

 

 

This was rude.

 

I think she was just kidding. I mean, FP is always talking about that girl he obviously has a major crush on. ;-)

Posted

I think it means that persons (well, men) who are very preoccupied with their same-sex attraction or struggle with it immensely aren't encouraged to join seminary. I bet the same rule of thumb would apply to heterosexual men who battle against their sexuality daily.

 

 

This was rude.

Um... not really

Posted

I think she was just kidding. I mean, FP is always talking about that girl he obviously has a major crush on. ;-)

Thank you!  Apparently I have to add "JK" after my post... sheesh!

 

FP totally left himself open for that one!  If it wasn't me, it would have been someone else, I can assure.

HisChildForever
Posted

I'm sorry to misread the tone, but I do know Miles has asked people not to poke fun at his sexuality so that's what I was going on.

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

I'm sorry to misread the tone, but I do know Miles has asked people not to poke fun at his sexuality so that's what I was going on.

Multiple times, at that.
PhuturePriest
Posted

Seminary is hard enough without being sexually attracted to your peers, especially when you're encouraged to form strong brotherly relationships with them. "Deep seated homosexual tendencies" is probably purposefully vague, because when it comes to human feelings you can't use empirical analysis.  

 

Lots of people who study human behavior and sexuality embrace the theory that human sexuality exists on a spectrum, instead of purely black and white (homosexual/heterosexual). This idea allows for people to have different "degrees" of sexual inclinations. So some people who identify as homosexual may have an easier time resisting temptation than others (just as some heterosexuals have a harder time resisting temptation and having friendships with the opposite sex than others do). I know some seminarians who were accepted into seminary and either already had or later developed problems with sexuality (porn addictions, girlfriends on the side, inappropriate behavior toward females, etc). Most of them ended up leaving the seminary. 

Some theologians (I forget who precisely) also like to talk about how being a heterosexual man is a mandatory part of forming a proper relationship to the Church and ministering to others. So there's some variation on all sides of how to interpret the "deep seated" term.  Though ultimately it comes down to a case by case basis, involving the seminarian, the seminary, and the bishop. 

 

I can definitely see your points. When I visited the seminary and visited the dorms in particular, there was a really intimate brotherly atmosphere there. I can imagine it would be very difficult if you struggled with homosexuality to be in such a setting without feeling temptations.

 

But still, I met a seminarian or two that struck me as possibly homosexual, so as you say, it is most likely a case-by-case basis.

Posted

I'm sorry to misread the tone, but I do know Miles has asked people not to poke fun at his sexuality so that's what I was going on.

 

Uh oh... I did not know that. My apologies, FP!

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

Thank you!  Apparently I have to add "JK" after my post... sheesh!

 

FP totally left himself open for that one!  If it wasn't me, it would have been someone else, I can assure.

 

 

Yes you do need to ad J/K after a joke unless it's a direct Q.Why did the chicken cross the road? A. To get to the otherside meaning a direct question answer joke, i don't think we should assume everyone else has our particular sense. No pun intended.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Deep seeded homosexual desire means to me and i may be wrong, means this " an innate desire for a sexual relationship with another person/s of the same sex."

PhuturePriest
Posted

Thank you!  Apparently I have to add "JK" after my post... sheesh!

 

FP totally left himself open for that one!  If it wasn't me, it would have been someone else, I can assure.

 

You assume everyone has the same urge to make fun of another's sexuality? That seems a little judgmental to me.

Sexuality isn't something to joke about. It's a serious issue. Whether I'm afraid of being rejected or not due to alleged homosexual tendencies is none of your business and nothing to joke about.

Posted

FP - I know JPII brought up the subject for the first time in a while, but was a little vague about it, so B16 later gave more specific instruction to seminaries that had a larger impact than JPII's.

 

This is a document on the subject from during B16's papacy.  I don't know if it's the main one or the only one on this subject from his papacy, but I think section 2 might give a bit more detail on your question:

 

http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccatheduc/documents/rc_con_ccatheduc_doc_20051104_istruzione_en.html

 

Having been around and discerning a bit back then, I'll save the details and just say that this rule was needed.  It certainly has changed the makeup of some seminaries as I understand it.  I think you'd be correct in assuming that it's handled on a case by case basis and it's probably implemented a little differently with each order/seminary.

 

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

I can definitely see your points. When I visited the seminary and visited the dorms in particular, there was a really intimate brotherly atmosphere there. I can imagine it would be very difficult if you struggled with homosexuality to be in such a setting without feeling temptations.

 

But still, I met a seminarian or two that struck me as possibly homosexual, so as you say, it is most likely a case-by-case basis.

 

True, but it's also important to note that some men who "seem" gay might not be, and others who don't, are.  And even if they were gay, it's something between them and their spiritual director(s).  If they think he can handle seminary, then good for him. :)  It's not easy being a gay Catholic and trying to find your "place" in the Church.  

 

The document ND links to has Benedict further explaining how gay men can or cannot discern a vocation to the priesthood, but it still leaves room open for interpretation. Especially in the second to last paragraph of section three, does he intend "deep seated" to mean something that serves as a source of temptation to a certain degree? Does he intend it to mean any kind of residual attraction at all? The strictest interpretation would probably go with the latter, a more lax the former.  In practice, it probably depends on the people involved.  I'd even go so far as to say that the ambiguity is intentional, so that bishops and spiritual directors have room for good pastoral care, whether that be confirming the vocation or not. 

 

It also brings up an important point about vocations that some people often forget - vocations are about your desire AND the Church confirming that vocation. If you're actually called to a particular vocation, the Church will confirm it. If the Church doesn't confirm it, then you're not called to that vocation, no matter how much you want it.  It's a two-way street. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...