Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Have A Question


Recommended Posts

Posted

I do know Miles has asked people not to poke fun at his sexuality so that's what I was going on.

Pardon me for missing his posts about his sexuality and excuse me for not being a "FP Groupie!"

Posted

i don't think we should assume everyone else has our particular sense. 

[mod]Here's a small idea, let's not try to bypass the filter while making personal attacks. -BG[/mod]... thanks.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Pardon me for missing his posts about his sexuality and excuse me for not being a "FP Groupie!"

 

 

You don't have to be a phatmass groupie. :) Just be a holy roman catholic to the best of your abilities according to grace, and be open to grow and learn like a vine towards the sun, striving for truth. Sorry if i offended you it was not my intention, i apologise, please forgvie me.

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

Freedom is back, ladies and gents.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Yikes!  I haven't seen such insecurities in my life, there are professionals to help with this kind of stuff.

 

You're a very special breed of troll. Good luck in the convent.

Posted

Going back to the OP, I wouldn't be concerned about this too much. It isn't a problem at most places. Although, yes, I have seen biased seminary staff who would kick out guys they suspect of being gay. But then again, if that kind of thing is happening at your seminary you likely have lots of other problems with the formation program there as well (like profiling men instead of forming them), and this would be but a small concern.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Deep seeded homosexual desire means to me and i may be wrong, means this " an innate desire for a sexual relationship with another person/s of the same sex."

 

 

I had to fix what i said please forgive. I think it's more like this " the innate sexual desire for person or persons of the same sex." Unsure if there even has to be action attributed to these desires and not sure either whether it has to do we thoughts or feelings or both when it comes to the seminary. So all in all i'm unsure. But i stand with my definition for homo sexual tendencies, i heard it somewhere or other a few times, once was from a priest.

Posted

Going back to the OP, I wouldn't be concerned about this too much. It isn't a problem at most places. Although, yes, I have seen biased seminary staff who would kick out guys they suspect of being gay. But then again, if that kind of thing is happening at your seminary you likely have lots of other problems with the formation program there as well (like profiling men instead of forming them), and this would be but a small concern.

 

respectfully, as linked earlier, the church explicitly teaches the following:

 

the Church, while profoundly respecting the persons in question[9], cannot admit to the seminary or to holy orders those who practise homosexuality, present deep-seated homosexual tendencies or support the so-called "gay culture"[10].

 

So a rector who denies admittance or asks someone to leave based on these characteristics is being obedient to Rome and acting in the spirit of the previous two Pontiffs. 

Posted

Pardon me for missing his posts about his sexuality and excuse me for not being a "FP Groupie!"

 

Exactly...posting this kind of question kinda lends itself to jokes.  

 

Now it appears that Freedom has gone to far, which is a shame, because the initial post (as with this one) was funny.

 

Back to the topic at hand.  Our culture is oversexed and under-loved.  I think that more than half of young people who claim homosexuality have very light tendency...the need to be love and accepted and the societal coercion that sexual love is the strongest kind of love and where all non-familial love should lead.  

 

"Deep seated" tendencies, I think, are those born from a true sexual desire that is not well tempered just like in heterosexual men and women.

Posted (edited)

Does this also include men who have strong heterosexual attractions in the seminary?

 

Im assuming that we are talking about the purity aspect. Of course being gay is not a sin, its acting on it. So even if a particular male who was interested in the seminary had homosexual attraction with no intention of acting on it would be ok?

 

The problem would be if he INTENDS to act on it or may have a hard time controlling his desires just like a heterosexual male might have a hard time controlling his desires but still has an interest in the seminary.

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted

On a theological level, homosexuality is dealt with differently than hetero because the church teaches that homosexual attraction is intrinsically different from heterosexual attraction.  From the same link:

 

The Catechism distinguishes between homosexual acts and homosexual tendencies.

Regarding acts, it teaches that Sacred Scripture presents them as grave sins. The Tradition has constantly considered them as intrinsically immoral and contrary to the natural law. Consequently, under no circumstance can they be approved.

Deep-seated homosexual tendencies, which are found in a number of men and women, are also objectively disordered and, for those same people, often constitute a trial. Such persons must be accepted with respect and sensitivity.

 

On a practical level, homosexuality is a concern during formation where heterosexuality isn't because its' a bunch of guys living together, sharing rooms, bathrooms, etc.  Identifying, policing, preventing heterosexual activity using time-tested methods in use at any all-boys or all-girls dorm would be easier than identifying/policing homosexual activity.

 

There are lots and lots more reasons why the church needed to pay renewed attention to this subject.  If you are young and/or sheltered enough that you aren't really aware of these reasons, then just consider yourself lucky - it's a gift.  If you are genuinely curious PM and I'll forward you more reading.  I think the OP's question has been answered sufficiently and I'm not really comfortable discussing this subject on an open thread here.

Posted (edited)

I just think its lame. :(

 

You could have the most pious, devout individual who DOES have homosexual attraction and even though he would never dream of acting on it he would be put under scrutiny for entering? And possibly denied?

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted (edited)

I just think its lame. :(

 

You could have the most pious, devout individual who DOES have homosexual attraction and even though he would never dream of acting on it he would be put under scrutiny for entering? And possibly denied?

 

Well, as fallen individuals "never dreaming" of sinning doesn't preclude sinning.  Our Intellect should inform the will, but all too often our will is driven instead by our passions.   I would imagine he who wrote the church document would say that someone who has an attraction that is "intrinsically disordered" certainly is not free from the worst of these passions.

 

One could argue that this would be less of a concern for someone who has progressed to a certain degree in their spiritual life, perhaps from the purgative to the illumanitive stage and has no longer has attachment to mortal sin or these disordered passions.   This might be why the church teaches that one must be free from this attraction for three years - to be sufficiently detached.

 

On the whole, when admitting individuals to the seminary and then to the priesthood, the concerns of the Church come before the concerns for the individual - nobody has a right to be admitted or ordained. So I'll just repeat that if you are young enough that you don't understand the need for this and it's motivation, consider yourself lucky. 

Edited by NotreDame
Posted

I just think its lame. :(

 

You could have the most pious, devout individual who DOES have homosexual attraction and even though he would never dream of acting on it he would be put under scrutiny for entering? And possibly denied?

 

Feelings and actions are 2 different things.  I think that the "never dreaming of acting upon them" would really negate the whole "deep seated tendencies" by way of "tendencies".  When my dog turns over the trash, counter surfs and otherwise terrorizes my house my brain says give her a swift kick in the ribs as she maws on the last of my bread, but I would NEVER act on that.

Posted

Well, as fallen individuals "never dreaming" of sinning doesn't preclude sinning.  Our Intellect should inform the will, but all too often our will is driven instead by our passions. 

 

Lets get one thing clear, we are ALL fallen individuals.

And let me remind you that having homosexual tendencies is NOT a sin. Of course we can all sin...that isnt something specific to homosexuals. A homosexual can sin just as readily as a heterosexual. 

Posted

Feelings and actions are 2 different things.  I think that the "never dreaming of acting upon them" would really negate the whole "deep seated tendencies" by way of "tendencies".  When my dog turns over the trash, counter surfs and otherwise terrorizes my house my brain says give her a swift kick in the ribs as she maws on the last of my bread, but I would NEVER act on that.

I think thats a good example.

Even though you have these thoughts to kick your dog you dont! And no one is preventing you from owning a dog because you have these thoughts.

Posted

I think thats a good example.

Even though you have these thoughts to kick your dog you dont! And no one is preventing you from owning a dog because you have these thoughts.

 

But they would (and should) if they thought I would ever cross the line.  The probem with sexual issues is that we don't understand them all that well and it can be very frustrating to try and decipher what is an idea and what could be acted upon is a hard process.  With preisthood it is better to err on the side of caution, whereas with animals the stakes are not quite so high.

Posted

Lets get one thing clear, we are ALL fallen individuals.

And let me remind you that having homosexual tendencies is NOT a sin. Of course we can all sin...that isnt something specific to homosexuals. A homosexual can sin just as readily as a heterosexual. 

 

In this post you have argued against things I did not say, while ignoring what I did say.  I was just trying to respond to your question and help give some context to and explanation for the church document and how it might be applied in a certain hypothetical.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...