Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Swim Suit Competitions


Recommended Posts

Posted

Well, a swimsuit competition is not a runway show it. I repeat: people do not watch swimsuit competitions to check out the trending colors and patterns.
I think you are missing my point about brains.
Many, I would say most beauty pageant contestants have above average intellect.
The problem is that the beauty pageant is not a test of intellectual poise.
It is a test of poise while balancing on high heels, poise while being exposed in a bathing suit, and poise while schmoozing.
Beauty pageants exist because historically this is the poise women were expected to strive for and excel at. And so how natural that they receive scholarships for being good at it. Good at what? Looking good.

SaintOfVirtue
Posted

Well, a swimsuit competition is not a runway show it. I repeat: people do not watch swimsuit competitions to check out the trending colors and patterns.
I think you are missing my point about brains.
Many, I would say most beauty pageant contestants have above average intellect.
The problem is that the beauty pageant is not a test of intellectual poise.
It is a test of poise while balancing on high heels, poise while being exposed in a bathing suit, and poise while schmoozing.
Beauty pageants exist because historically this is the poise women were expected to strive for and excel at. And so how natural that they receive scholarships for being good at it. Good at what? Looking good.

 

 

Is any "beauty competition" really ever about trending colors and patterns?

I don't think so.  It's as much about the person wearing the clothes as it is the clothes themselves.  I am not condoning this; just pointing out the phenomena is not isolated to swim suits alone.

 

Further, there are plenty of other scholarship opportunities that women can and do win, so what's the problem with giving the winner of a beauty contest scholarship money?  It's not like it was their only option for a scholarship, they chose to participate.

Posted (edited)

Further, there are plenty of other scholarship opportunities that women can and do win, so what's the problem with giving the winner of a beauty contest scholarship money?  It's not like it was their only option for a scholarship, they chose to participate.


The problem is that the beauty pageant tradition is born of a historical expectation that the ideal woman will be pretty and attractive and talk inoffensive polite nonsense at parties. The message is: these are the things the ideal woman - actually the ideal wife - should do, so lets have a contest among the Misses (i.e., marriageable women) to see who can do it best.

There is not a similar tradition for men. No one had the idea to have a contest to see which man could do those things best.

A woman who is neat and clean but does not invest a lot of time or money in hair products, makeup or clothing and worse expresses a political opinion is never called a beauty queen, she is more likely to be called something else that starts with a "b."


ETA: **my point is that swimsuit competitions can be related to porn, and participating in or enjoying a beauty pageant is joining in a misogynistic ritual. Which, incidentally, porn is a misogynistic ritual. So in other words, its not right, don't do it. Edited by Lilllabettt
SaintOfVirtue
Posted

There is not a similar tradition for men. No one had the idea to have a contest to see which man could do those things best.


I can name several similar competitions for men, many of which predate beauty competitions:

1. Bodybuilding competitions
2. Bare-knuckle boxing
3. Cross-training competitions
4. Ironman competitions
5. Football


A woman who is neat and clean but does not invest a lot of time or money in hair products, makeup or clothing and worse expresses a political opinion is never called a beauty queen, she is more likely to be called something else that starts with a "b."


Well, I guess that depends on the company you keep, but I do not believe this is true of the general culture.


ETA: **my point is that swimsuit competitions can be related to porn, and participating or enjoying a beauty pageant is joining in a misogynistic ritual. Which, incidentally, porn is a misogynistic ritual. So in other words, its not right, don't do it.


This is about as valid an analogy as saying an Oreo cookie is Cocaine. In no way is merely looking at someone in a swim suit equatable to watching the debauchery that is porn. If it were we would have to veiw going to the beach, pool, or water park in the same light as porn.
Posted (edited)

the difference is that (most) people do not go to the beach in order to put themselves on display and (most) people do not go to the beach to look at a display. They go to enjoy the water or relax or read a book. A modest woman puts on a swimsuit and goes to the pool because she wants to swim damm it. She does not arrange her clothing and her body with the hope that people will look her up and down and rank order her with other people on the beach.

Now if a woman strips down to a swimsuit and goes to the beach so that people will look at her exposed body, that is called stripping, and it is a short stop away from porn and prostitution. I hope you do not go to the beach to look at the people there. But most men who watch beauty pageants do it to look at the exposed bodies of women. The women who walk in the competition, the judges, the people who make the show and the people who watch it all understand that very well.

If you watch the swimsuit competition to see the trendy swimsuits, good for you. But you are still participating in a fundamentally misogynistic enterprise.

Edited by Lilllabettt
ChristinaTherese
Posted

:offtopic: But I'm saying this anyway.

 

Lilllabettt, I've generally thought of myself as not a feminist at all. But... I keep reading what you have to say (and reading one of my characters before life happened and I gave up on NaNoWriMo) and thinking that feminism really has some good points. Just not all obnoxious militant feminism. Kind of like what I'm against throws the baby out with the bathwater but there is some bathwater that it would be good to throw out all the same.

 

Anyway.... This is still kind of :offtopic:

Posted

Then why do gay men watch it?

 

Checkmate, atheists.

 

Gay men watch swim suit competitions? I thought stuff like that and beauty contests were for women only. I guess I could see maybe a transvestite man watching one for fashion tips like a woman might, but what reason would any man gay or straight have to watch a swim suit competition?

 

ed

Posted

I have a feeling that if St. Paul knew about swimsuit competitions, he would have some choice things to say about worldliness.

Posted (edited)

:offtopic: But I'm saying this anyway.
 
Lilllabettt, I've generally thought of myself as not a feminist at all. But... I keep reading what you have to say (and reading one of my characters before life happened and I gave up on NaNoWriMo) and thinking that feminism really has some good points. Just not all obnoxious militant feminism. Kind of like what I'm against throws the baby out with the bathwater but there is some bathwater that it would be good to throw out all the same.
 
Anyway.... This is still kind of :offtopic:


Yeah ... there is nothing wrong with authentic feminism. Many things women take for granted today were won for us by feminists. Edited by Lilllabettt
SaintOfVirtue
Posted

Now if a woman strips down to a swimsuit and goes to the beach so that people will look at her exposed body, that is called stripping, and it is a short stop away from porn and prostitution. I hope you do not go to the beach to look at the people there. But most men who watch beauty pageants do it to look at the exposed bodies of women. The women who walk in the competition, the judges, the people who make the show and the people who watch it all understand that very well.

 

First of all, I do not watch any swim suit competitions, nor do I go to the beach with the express purpose of ogling women.

 

I believe the spectators of swim suit competitions are, demographically, more female than male because I honestly cannot think of a single guy who would rather watch Miss America than the ball game.  And what would you know about most men who watch beauty pageants anyways? Do you know so many of them that you were able to poll them on the issue or are you just making presumptions?

 

Lastly, I happen to personally know three women who participate in beauty contests; some happen to have a swim suit event, some do not.  Therefore I think I can speak with some authority when I say you are making broad judgments about the character of people about whom you know nothing.  If you liken the competition to pornography or prostitution then you liken the participants as porn-stars and prostitutes, and that is the real problem I have with your argument.  These are two completely separate things: one is intrinsically evil, and the other is only 'evil' on a case-by-case basis. 

 

 

I have a feeling that if St. Paul knew about swimsuit competitions, he would have some choice things to say about worldliness.

 

Now on that ground I would concede. 
Is it worldly? Yes. 
Is it mostly vain? Probably.
But is it pornographic? Definitely not.

Posted (edited)

Lastly, I happen to personally know three women who participate in beauty contests; some happen to have a swim suit event, some do not.  Therefore I think I can speak with some authority when I say you are making broad judgments about the character of people about whom you know nothing.  If you liken the competition to pornography or prostitution then you liken the participants as porn-stars and prostitutes, and that is the real problem I have with your argument.  These are two completely separate things: one is intrinsically evil, and the other is only 'evil' on a case-by-case basis.


I make no judgment of the particular character of women involved in beauty pageants, neither do I judge porn stars or prostitutes, since their conscience is their business and not mine. A woman who exposes her body so that she may profit from the approbation of onlookers is a stripper. I do not judge strippers either.

Most women who participate in beauty pageants give little thought to what they symbolize about how society treats women. Ignorance is their excuse.

But a woman who participates in a swimsuit competition ignorant of the fact that people will be staring at her exposed body and ranking it among other similarly exposed females is a woman who is 1. unaccountably naive and/or 2. in desperate need of moral formation. Edited by Lilllabettt
SaintOfVirtue
Posted (edited)

I make no judgment of the particular character of women involved in beauty pageants, neither do I judge porn stars or prostitutes, since their conscience is their business and not mine. A woman who exposes her body so that she may profit from the approbation of onlookers is a stripper. I do not judge strippers either.

 

Because categorizing a woman who participates in a beauty competition as being on the same moral level as a porn-star isn't passing judgement on them at all.

Edited by SaintOfVirtue
Posted

Because categorizing a woman who participates in a beauty competition as being on the same moral level as a porn-star isn't passing judgement on them at all.


no. I do not assign a "moral level" to porn stars or beauty pageant contestants. Good grief.
I also do not "categorize" women. We categorize things, never people.
Categorizing women is an act of misogyny. Hey. Do you know of any activities where women are systematically categorized?
SaintOfVirtue
Posted (edited)

no. I do not assign a "moral level" to porn stars or beauty pageant contestants. Good grief.


Apparently, you don't remember writing this:
 

But a woman who participates in a swimsuit competition ignorant of the fact that people will be staring at her exposed body and ranking it among other similarly exposed females is a woman who is 1. unaccountably naive and/or 2. in desperate need of moral formation.

 

I also do not "categorize" women. We categorize things, never people.
Categorizing women is an act of misogyny. Hey. Do you know of any activities where women are systematically categorized?

 

Actually you do, you just don't realize it.  So far in this discussion you have categorized beauty contestants as ignorant, naive, immoral, and any person who 'categorizes women' as a misogynist.

Edited by SaintOfVirtue
Posted

So far in this discussion you have categorized beauty contestants as ignorant, naive, immoral, and any person who 'categorizes women' as a misogynist.


:facepalm:
HisChildForever
Posted (edited)

Because categorizing a woman who participates in a beauty competition as being on the same moral level as a porn-star isn't passing judgement on them at all.

 

I think the focus is more on the beauty pageant than the women who participate in them. Let me make a rough comparison. A lot of women adore Planned Parenthood because they think the organization is all about women power and freedom. But underneath that shiny promise we see darkness, pain, tragedy, sexism, objectification. Likewise, the beauty pageant, take Miss America, is a happy, American tradition. But beneath that is this message or undercurrent that Lilllabettt is referring to -- that the Stepford Wife is the real American woman.

Edited by HisChildForever
SaintOfVirtue
Posted

I was arguing two things: 1. the analogy comparing beauty pageants and the women who participate in them to porn and prostitutes/strippers was gratuitous and extreme.  2.  beauty pageants are not intrinsically evil; it doesn't matter if it's a swim suit or a ballroom gown.

 

I still think that to say it promotes the Stepford Wife view of women is inaccurate, but, all things considered, that is a much more reasonable analogy.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

There is not a similar tradition for men. No one had the idea to have a contest to see which man could do those things best.

 

 

 

There will be men on my cat walk, and it is about finding out what swimwear would best suit any particular person and there will be one piece swimwear available. It won't be a competition, although this thread was about swimwear competitions so i am hijacking my own thread. :LOL: Perhaps there will be voting though just on nothing in particular just whom the crowd chooses.

 

 

 

P.S. all profits beyond wages including my own will go to charitable organisations and a scholastic fund for each winner of each competition although i don't wan't it to be a competition but it could be, i just wan't a beach catwalk, but not like those fancy smancy french catwalks which are impractical clothing although i won't shy away from allowing a some designer swimwear, even swimwear with bling, but the main stay will be ordinary swim wear, and the beachwalk will be sponsered by swimwear companies.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

 damm it. 

 

 

Don't say that please, it is immodest, and i'm being honest. No pun intended.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...