Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Swim Suit Competitions


Recommended Posts

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Gay men watch swim suit competitions? I thought stuff like that and beauty contests were for women only. I guess I could see maybe a transvestite man watching one for fashion tips like a woman might, but what reason would any man gay or straight have to watch a swim suit competition?

 

ed

 

 

Perhaps the man and his girlfriend or wife are making a decision on which swimwear would best suit him or her. :) But i fully get your point and it hit me like a good slap in the face from a good women, gracious thanks. But than also single men are supposed to look at single women, and single women are supposed to look at single men, and i'm not talking lustfully. But to add to my BRAIN WAVE swimsuit beachwalk thingy, there will be no married women or men on the beachwalk, this is singles only to avoid the whole lusting for a married person.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

I REBUKE MY IDEA, ALL BRAIN SIZES WELCOME. NOW IT TRUELY IS A BRAIN WAVE. :wave:

Posted

Swimsuit competitions are not porn in the same way that lust is not adultery.

Posted

I was arguing two things: 1. the analogy comparing beauty pageants and the women who participate in them to porn and prostitutes/strippers was gratuitous and extreme. 

In the same way Jesus linking lust in the heart and adultery is "gratuitous and extreme"?

PhuturePriest
Posted

First of all, I do not watch any swim suit competitions, nor do I go to the beach with the express purpose of ogling women.

 

I believe the spectators of swim suit competitions are, demographically, more female than male because I honestly cannot think of a single guy who would rather watch Miss America than the ball game.  And what would you know about most men who watch beauty pageants anyways? Do you know so many of them that you were able to poll them on the issue or are you just making presumptions?

 

Lastly, I happen to personally know three women who participate in beauty contests; some happen to have a swim suit event, some do not.  Therefore I think I can speak with some authority when I say you are making broad judgments about the character of people about whom you know nothing.  If you liken the competition to pornography or prostitution then you liken the participants as porn-stars and prostitutes, and that is the real problem I have with your argument.  These are two completely separate things: one is intrinsically evil, and the other is only 'evil' on a case-by-case basis. 

 

 

 

Now on that ground I would concede. 
Is it worldly? Yes. 
Is it mostly vain? Probably.
But is it pornographic? Definitely not.

 

Pornography means something like "the drawing of the harlot" (Terribly paraphrased, but very similar wording). In that sense, I suppose movies and online pornography isn't really pornography, because those are videos, not pictures and drawings.

Posted

Pornography means something like "the drawing of the harlot" (Terribly paraphrased, but very similar wording). In that sense, I suppose movies and online pornography isn't really pornography, because those are videos, not pictures and drawings.

Meh. That is kind of sloppy etymology.

pornography (n.) Look up pornography at Dictionary.com
1843, "ancient obscene painting, especially in temples of Bacchus," from French pornographie, from Greek pornographos "(one) depicting prostitutes," from porne "prostitute," originally "bought, purchased" (with an original notion, probably of "female slave sold for prostitution"), related to pernanai "to sell," from PIE root *per- (5) "to traffic in, to sell" (see price (n.)) + graphein "to write" (see -graphy). A brothel in ancient Greek was a porneion.

In reference to modern works by 1859 (originally French novels), later as a charge against native literature; sense of "obscene pictures" in modern times is from 1906. Also sometimes used late 19c. for "description of prostitutes" as a matter of public hygiene. The "Medical Archives" in 1873 proposed porniatria for "the lengthy and really meaningless expression 'social evil hospital' ...."
I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description [hard-core pornography]; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture involved in this case is not that. [U.S. Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart, concurring opinion, "Jacobellis v. Ohio," 1964]
In ancient contexts, often paired with rhypography, "genre painting of low, sordid, or unsuitable subjects." Pornocracy (1860) is "the dominating influence of harlots," used specifically of the government of Rome during the first half of the 10th century by Theodora and her daughters. Pornotopia (1966) was coined to describe the ideal erotic-world of pornographic movies.

SaintOfVirtue
Posted

In the same way Jesus linking lust in the heart and adultery is "gratuitous and extreme"?

 

Both lust of the heart and adultery are objectively lustful actions, so the comparison was apt.  A beauty pageant is not objectively lustful, therefore the comparison does not hold.

 

 

Pornography means something like "the drawing of the harlot" (Terribly paraphrased, but very similar wording). In that sense, I suppose movies and online pornography isn't really pornography, because those are videos, not pictures and drawings.

 

No, what you gave is the etymology of the word pornography, not the meaning.  The meaning incorporates much more than drawings as I am sure we are all well aware.  But for the sake of the argument, even if we were arguing semantics your conclusion would still be wrong because modern pornography is made using photography, videography, or cinematography.  See all these words share something in common, and that is the "ography" ending.  "Ography" is from the Greek root "graphien" which means to draw, write, or record.  So even though it may be a movie it's still a 'drawing', etymologically speaking.  It was drawn with sight (videography), or with light (photography), or moving light (cinematography).

 

"Pornography consists in removing real or simulated sexual acts from the intimacy of the partners, in order to display them deliberately to third parties" ~CCC 2354

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I don't think it's modest

PhuturePriest
Posted

Meh. That is kind of sloppy etymology.

pornography (n.) Look up pornography at Dictionary.com
1843, "ancient obscene painting, especially in temples of Bacchus," from French pornographie, from Greek pornographos "(one) depicting prostitutes," from porne "prostitute," originally "bought, purchased" (with an original notion, probably of "female slave sold for prostitution"), related to pernanai "to sell," from PIE root *per- (5) "to traffic in, to sell" (see price (n.)) + graphein "to write" (see -graphy). A brothel in ancient Greek was a porneion.

In reference to modern works by 1859 (originally French novels), later as a charge against native literature; sense of "obscene pictures" in modern times is from 1906. Also sometimes used late 19c. for "description of prostitutes" as a matter of public hygiene. The "Medical Archives" in 1873 proposed porniatria for "the lengthy and really meaningless expression 'social evil hospital' ...."
I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description [hard-core pornography]; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture involved in this case is not that. [U.S. Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart, concurring opinion, "Jacobellis v. Ohio," 1964]
In ancient contexts, often paired with rhypography, "genre painting of low, sordid, or unsuitable subjects." Pornocracy (1860) is "the dominating influence of harlots," used specifically of the government of Rome during the first half of the 10th century by Theodora and her daughters. Pornotopia (1966) was coined to describe the ideal erotic-world of pornographic movies.

 

I would have looked it up, but I have a monitoring program on my computer that would flip out if I were to Google something like "Pornography". Surely you understand why I did not look it up in that case. Trust me, it really bothers me when I'm unable to give a completely correct and accurate explanation for something.

Posted

I would have looked it up, but I have a monitoring program on my computer that would flip out if I were to Google something like "Pornography". Surely you understand why I did not look it up in that case. Trust me, it really bothers me when I'm unable to give a completely correct and accurate explanation for something.

That is why you first navigate to http://www.etymonline.com. :proud: Nobody could possibly fault you for looking up references. :smile3:

PhuturePriest
Posted

That is why you first navigate to http://www.etymonline.com. :proud: Nobody could possibly fault you for looking up references. :smile3:

 

You'd be incredibly surprised.

Posted

Reasonable people, at any rate...

ChristinaTherese
Posted

That is why you first navigate to http://www.etymonline.com. :proud: Nobody could possibly fault you for looking up references. :smile3:

That's a fantastic website.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

I'm not yet convinced that a beauty pageant is comparable to pornography. However, it is degrading to women as it calls to focus their looks. People say "Oh, they wear bikinis to show off the bikinis." Really? Than why do people rate the girl and not the bikini? If it was about the bikini the judges would say "Your bikini looks great, I love it's colors, it just looks per. fect." But that's not what they say, is it? They say "You look great in this bikini", "Your figure is shown well in this bikini", etc. They don't mention the bikini as the focus, they focus on your body and mention the bikini.

 

And really, bikinis and bras and panties are not any different except bikini tops have no wires. If girls flip out because I accidentally walked in on them in their bra and panties, they should flip out just as much because I saw them in a bikini. You can tell me any different if you want, but that's how guys see them. I've asked guys if they think there's any difference between them, and they all say they don't look any different in their eyes. And these are good, devout, chaste young Catholic men, mind you. I would personally flip out if I had daughters and they were wearing bikinis. I have the same respect for other girls that I would have for my daughters.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

I'm not yet convinced that a beauty pageant is comparable to pornography. However, it is degrading to women as it calls to focus their looks. People say "Oh, they wear bikinis to show off the bikinis." Really? Than why do people rate the girl and not the bikini? If it was about the bikini the judges would say "Your bikini looks great, I love it's colors, it just looks per. fect." But that's not what they say, is it? They say "You look great in this bikini", "Your figure is shown well in this bikini", etc. They don't mention the bikini as the focus, they focus on your body and mention the bikini.

 

And really, bikinis and bras and panties are not any different except bikini tops have no wires. If girls flip out because I accidentally walked in on them in their bra and panties, they should flip out just as much because I saw them in a bikini. You can tell me any different if you want, but that's how guys see them. I've asked guys if they think there's any difference between them, and they all say they don't look any different in their eyes. And these are good, devout, chaste young Catholic men, mind you. I would personally flip out if I had daughters and they were wearing bikinis. I have the same respect for other girls that I would have for my daughters.

 

 

if someone exposes her body, hoping that said onlookers will look her up and down and give her money because they approve of what she has shown them by exposing herself, that is called stripping.

 

how is what women do in a swimsuit competition different?

 

the bikini debate is rather beside the point, see post #25. Most women who wear a bikini to the beach do so because they like to sunbathe/ swim in that kind of suit. That may be a prudent choice or not, but its beside the point. Women in a swimsuit competition are not exposing themselves because its their favorite way to swim, they are exposing themselves because they hope that people will see their bodies, rank them higher than the bodies of other similarily exposed women, and award them money for it.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

It could certainly be considered soft core pornography.  Porn isn't always super explicit sexual acts. 

 

If swimsuit competitions really were about comparing "poise" or even physical fitness (as Miss America contests claim), there are still other, better ways of doing that without hypersexualizing the contestants. Why not make fitness more like talent, or even standardize it with a one-piece swimsuit? They explicitly changed the rules to allow skimpier suits in an attempt to pull in more ratings and reach the "younger crowd."  The Evening Wear may be about beauty and poise.  The swimsuits are about sex. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

And really, bikinis and bras and panties are not any different except bikini tops have no wires. If girls flip out because I accidentally walked in on them in their bra and panties, they should flip out just as much because I saw them in a bikini. 

 

Bikini tops have wires just as often as bras do, :)  Or do not, for that matter. 

 

And women react that way because it's simple - in one context she's choosing to reveal an amount of her body because it's an appropriate context, and others are likely doing the same, so there's not as much focus on her. In the other context, she's not choosing to reveal that same amount because it's an inappropriate context, and she's alone so all the focus is on her. 

 

It's not just about a percentage of skin that's being shown.  Intention, action, and circumstance are the three parts of how we "measure" if something is sinful. 

 

The same idea could be applied to swim suit competitions.  Wearing a swimsuit, or even a bikini, may or may not be wrong. The intention behind wearing said swimsuit may or may not be wrong.  But what most of this thread seems to have been concerned with is whether or not the circumstance (beauty pageants) in which the swimsuits are being worn is appropriate. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie
PhuturePriest
Posted

Bikini tops have wires just as often as bras do, :)  Or do not, for that matter. 

 

And women react that way because it's simple - in one context she's choosing to reveal an amount of her body because it's an appropriate context, and others are likely doing the same, so there's not as much focus on her. In the other context, she's not choosing to reveal that same amount because it's an inappropriate context, and she's alone so all the focus is on her. 

 

It's not just about a percentage of skin that's being shown.  Intention, action, and circumstance are the three parts of how we "measure" if something is sinful. 

 

The same idea could be applied to swim suit competitions.  Wearing a swimsuit, or even a bikini, may or may not be wrong. The intention behind wearing said swimsuit may or may not be wrong.  But what most of this thread seems to have been concerned with is whether or not the circumstance (beauty pageants) in which the swimsuits are being worn is appropriate. 

 

If a girl wants to argue that wearing a bikini is acceptable because it makes it easier to swim, that's a different argument (I can see how wearing almost nothing would make it easier. :P). However, in the context of beauty pageants, they are drawing attention to their bodies, as you said, so it is not appropriate.

SaintOfVirtue
Posted

I'm not yet convinced that a beauty pageant is comparable to pornography. However, it is degrading to women as it calls to focus their looks.

It's pretty obvious that calling focus to a woman's looks is not objectively degrading. If it were complimenting a woman on her looks would be degrading as well.

 

if someone exposes her body, hoping that said onlookers will look her up and down and give her money because they approve of what she has shown them by exposing herself, that is called stripping.

Your logic does not hold, this is yet another False Analogy.

how is what women do in a swimsuit competition different?

How is it different? Are you kidding me?
The women in the swim suit competitions don't walk through the audience letting themselves be groped and they don't dance around poles simulating sex acts. Quite an obvious difference I'm not sure how you missed it.
Posted (edited)

you may be sheltered, Saintof Virtue. Most strip clubs have a "no touch" policy and most strippers are not pole dancers.

The main difference I see between performance in a swimsuit competition and a performance in a strip club is that the strip club makes the sexual suggestion explicit in the behavioral space while the swimsuit competition mentalizes it. Which, as Slappo pointed out, is no true distinction from the Christian perspective - lust in the heart is truly adultery despite the fact that it is mentalized. It is really only a question of degree, e.g., a strip club performance usually involves removal of the bikini top, while the swim suit competition has them keep it on. Although in many clubs that is illegal and they wear small triangles which are not too different from a swimsuit. In both performances the audience is someone who is watching and judging the woman's exposed body.

Edited by Lilllabettt

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...