Basilisa Marie Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 I question Wuerl's opinions on important things like Catechism #WhoCanActuallyRememberTheNumbers when it explicitly states those who do not follow the teachings of the Church are not to be administered Communion, and Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI sent a letter to all Bishops to remind them of this, and yet Wuerl (As far as I have read) seems to think this is open for debate. That's because it is open for debate. It's not Catechism #whatever, it's Canon 915 which says: Those who have been excommunicated or interdicted after the imposition or declaration of the penalty and others obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to holy communion. Now, the "obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin" is the tricky part. Burke argued that politicians who support pro-choice stances counted. Wuerl argued that communion was never meant to be used as a weapon, and that withholding communion doesn't work. Both made good arguments. Even though I personally sympathize with Wuerl's position, we also have to take Burke seriously because he is a canonist and church law is what he does. It doesn't make him infallible, but it means we should take him seriously. Their opposition to each other got really public in 2009ish, and it got a little nasty. But people apologized and whatnot. Wikipedia does a decent job of outlining how people try to interpret Canon 915 here (imho). The WitL page I linked has some links to other posts he made outlining some of went down between the two Cardinals.
PhuturePriest Posted December 21, 2013 Author Posted December 21, 2013 That's because it is open for debate. It's not Catechism #whatever, it's Canon 915 which says: Now, the "obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin" is the tricky part. Burke argued that politicians who support pro-choice stances counted. Wuerl argued that communion was never meant to be used as a weapon, and that withholding communion doesn't work. Both made good arguments. Even though I personally sympathize with Wuerl's position, we also have to take Burke seriously because he is a canonist and church law is what he does. It doesn't make him infallible, but it means we should take him seriously. Their opposition to each other got really public in 2009ish, and it got a little nasty. But people apologized and whatnot. Wikipedia does a decent job of outlining how people try to interpret Canon 915 here (imho). The WitL page I linked has some links to other posts he made outlining some of went down between the two Cardinals. I don't see how Wuerl could argue that the Eucharist is being used as a "weapon". If you support the murder of babies, your soul is not in a right state to receive the Eucharist, because you are not in good standing with the Church. To me, that's like saying "People in mortal sin should be able to receive the Eucharist, otherwise it's like we're using it like a weapon". I could be wrong, but that's how it sounds to me.
Basilisa Marie Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 I don't see how Wuerl could argue that the Eucharist is being used as a "weapon". If you support the murder of babies, your soul is not in a right state to receive the Eucharist, because you are not in good standing with the Church. To me, that's like saying "People in mortal sin should be able to receive the Eucharist, otherwise it's like we're using it like a weapon". I could be wrong, but that's how it sounds to me. Because by denying someone communion, some people think you're trying to punish or leverage a person into changing their minds... but when has that ever worked in recent years? Then you also have the issue of whether or not being a pro-choice politician is grave enough. Some people say yes, because they're a public figure and cause scandal and stuff, while others think that just being pro-choice isn't grave enough but being an abortion provider is. Plus, Canon 843 says: "sacred ministers cannot deny the sacraments to those who seek them at appropriate times, are properly disposed, and are not prohibited by law from receiving them" There might be a more relevant canon that I can't remember right now, but basically means it's up to the person seeking to receive communion to make sure he or she is properly disposed, not the priest. I mean, it'd be an impossible situation for the priest to know the hearts of everyone who approaches him for communion, so generally speaking it's not his responsibility. So in light of that, it'd have to be a grave exception to publicly deny someone communion. Which again begs the question - is being a pro-choice public figure grave enough? That's really what it comes down to. Some people say yes, others no, and for good reasons on both sides.
PhuturePriest Posted December 21, 2013 Author Posted December 21, 2013 Because by denying someone communion, some people think you're trying to punish or leverage a person into changing their minds... but when has that ever worked in recent years? Then you also have the issue of whether or not being a pro-choice politician is grave enough. Some people say yes, because they're a public figure and cause scandal and stuff, while others think that just being pro-choice isn't grave enough but being an abortion provider is. Plus, Canon 843 says: There might be a more relevant canon that I can't remember right now, but basically means it's up to the person seeking to receive communion to make sure he or she is properly disposed, not the priest. I mean, it'd be an impossible situation for the priest to know the hearts of everyone who approaches him for communion, so generally speaking it's not his responsibility. So in light of that, it'd have to be a grave exception to publicly deny someone communion. Which again begs the question - is being a pro-choice public figure grave enough? That's really what it comes down to. Some people say yes, others no, and for good reasons on both sides. Thank you for explaining it. But still, those "some people" could say the same for denying people communion because they're in mortal sin. They could say you're trying to "punish" or "leverage" them into changing their minds (What if they're unrepentant of their mortal sin and didn't intend to confess it, much like people with pro-choice positions?). It just seems weird to me that this is even being debated. If the case was instead rather people being in support of taking your child up to 10 years and shooting them in the head because you couldn't afford them, there would be no question as to whether or not those people should receive communion.This is the same situation but for babies in the womb, which I know you know is no different.
Basilisa Marie Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 Also: This post includes an interview with Wuerl where he talks about his side of things.
Basilisa Marie Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 Thank you for explaining it. But still, those "some people" could say the same for denying people communion because they're in mortal sin. They could say you're trying to "punish" or "leverage" them into changing their minds (What if they're unrepentant of their mortal sin and didn't intend to confess it, much like people with pro-choice positions?). It just seems weird to me that this is even being debated. If the case was instead rather people being in support of taking your child up to 10 years and shooting them in the head because you couldn't afford them, there would be no question as to whether or not those people should receive communion.This is the same situation but for babies in the womb, which I know you know is no different. No problem! :) I totally think you're well within your rights to be a Burke man, but I think it's important to understand that both sides have some good reasons for what they think. I think part of the issue is the difference between being in support of people having the choice to do an evil action and committing the evil action yourself. Obviously doing the action yourself is more grave, but whether or not supporting the choice to do it is that much less grave? Then you've got the people who just support having the legal choice, while others actually think it's a good thing to do. It kinda sounds like semantics, but I think it's a distinction worth making. It's all sinful, but the person who just thinks people should have the option would be easier to "convert" than the person who thinks it's great. At least, that's what I think. And that's the crux - how well can we know someone to be urepentant of mortal sin in a public fashion, and where do the bishops wish to draw the line on the issue? Personally I think we're better off to have bishops making calls themselves on a case by case basis. All this East Coast bishops calling out politicans publicly is a bit weird to me, a West Coast kid. My bishop met with our pro-choice Catholic governor privately and worked out relevant religious exceptions to laws she was trying to pass. There wasn't a big stink about denying her communion. But then, she also wasn't trying to use her Catholicism as a political bargaining chip to gain voters, either. Yeah, I know it's weird, which is why it was such a big deal when the two cardinals were publicly opposed to each other. Ultimately at the moment it's up to the local bishop to make the call, and I know Wuerl once pointed out that Nancy Pelosi isn't a member of his flock (she's from San Francisco I think?) so it probably wasn't his jurisdiction, at least where her particular case was concerned.
Basilisa Marie Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 I am for Apollos. Hush you, making us all look bad.
PhuturePriest Posted December 21, 2013 Author Posted December 21, 2013 I am for Apollos. My Helios could kick your Apollos' arse any day.
Kateri89 Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 I met Cardinal Wuerl once when he was still just a meager Bishop. He presided over my cousin's confirmation. That's all I know about him. :idontknow:
mortify ii Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 Whose genius idea was this and did they spend more than half a millisecond looking at Wuerl's shady record? Signed, a Burke fanboy. The Holy Father is shifting the balance within the curia and he has the authority to do so. Other conservatives such as Piacenza and Bagnasco are also out.
Luigi Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 In a celebrity-obsessed world, everyone gets treated as a celebrity. Bishops are not professional athletes for us to like or not like. Nor are they celebrities for us to compare the performances of, nor are they politicians to vote for or against. We're supposed to pray for the Church and the enlightenment of the pope, the cardinals, the bishops and them.
Aloysius Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 well the congregation for bishops is a rotating position... Burke remains head of the Apostolic Signatura and member of a few other congregations. I'm not as much of a fan of Wuerl as Burke, but for reasons other than the communion for politicians thing as generally I'm not all gung-ho about using canon 915 on politicians... if a bishop wants to do so, it's their right and I support it, but if they don't do it heavy handedly I'm ok with that too.
NotreDame Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 What do you guys think of how Wuerl got rid of the priest that denied communion to the lesbian at the funeral?
Maggyie Posted December 21, 2013 Posted December 21, 2013 What do you guys think of how Wuerl got rid of the priest that denied communion to the lesbian at the funeral? denying communion can never be a split-second decision. Which in that priest's case, it was. Even in the case of our politicians, whose misdeeds are in the public record, their shepherd reaches out to them beforehand and educates them on a personal, man-to-man basis first. Then if they persist, something can happen. Even if someone says to the priest, "I'm lesbian and over there is my partner" you can't just make a split second decision like that. You can't just assume that they're having sex or that they really understand the Church's teaching. Although you can probably guess, it's a bad idea to take a guess about the state of someone's soul when you have a funeral starting in 15 minutes. If someone comes up to you and says "by the way, I'm a Methodist or a Jewish person" you could make a split-second decision because that's a fact, sin doesn't come into it. Although of course you would do it with kindness and an explanation. Also keep in mind Scripture says "if you eat and drink unworthily, you bring judgment on yourself." Not, "if you administer Communion to an unworthy person, you bring judgment on yourself." The primary onus is on the person presenting themselves. They know their conscience and their status in the eyes of God. The whole point of this exercise is not about "protecting the Host" it's about protecting the soul of the person who may commit sacrilege in this manner. So that's a long way of saying I don't think the Cardinal really made a mistake with this situation.
KnightofChrist Posted December 22, 2013 Posted December 22, 2013 The Blessed Sacrament should be protected, and protected to a much greater extent than He is currently protected today. It is a mistake of the bishops to have relativistic and contradictory positions on protecting or not so much protecting the Blessed Sacrament. If a person should be barred in one diocese because of certain public, grave and unrepented sins, then said person should not have the freedom to just shop for a diocese that will allow them to receive profanely.
NotreDame Posted December 22, 2013 Posted December 22, 2013 denying communion can never be a split-second decision. Which in that priest's case, it was. Even in the case of our politicians, whose misdeeds are in the public record, their shepherd reaches out to them beforehand and educates them on a personal, man-to-man basis first. Then if they persist, something can happen. Even if someone says to the priest, "I'm lesbian and over there is my partner" you can't just make a split second decision like that. You can't just assume that they're having sex or that they really understand the Church's teaching. Although you can probably guess, it's a bad idea to take a guess about the state of someone's soul when you have a funeral starting in 15 minutes. If someone comes up to you and says "by the way, I'm a Methodist or a Jewish person" you could make a split-second decision because that's a fact, sin doesn't come into it. Although of course you would do it with kindness and an explanation. Also keep in mind Scripture says "if you eat and drink unworthily, you bring judgment on yourself." Not, "if you administer Communion to an unworthy person, you bring judgment on yourself." The primary onus is on the person presenting themselves. They know their conscience and their status in the eyes of God. The whole point of this exercise is not about "protecting the Host" it's about protecting the soul of the person who may commit sacrilege in this manner. So that's a long way of saying I don't think the Cardinal really made a mistake with this situation. It's a long explanation that you think the priest made a mistake. You never discussed Wuerl at all.
Basilisa Marie Posted December 22, 2013 Posted December 22, 2013 (edited) It's a long explanation that you think the priest made a mistake. You never discussed Wuerl at all. But her reasoning is solid, and probably similar to Wuerl's. It's basically the same answer my canon law professor gave my class when we asked him about the situation. The priest was acting from good intentions, sure, but he made a quick decision. By denying the woman communion, the priest was making an objective judgment about the state of the woman's soul. By doing so, he was also making the statement that he had some kind of responsibility to make that call, to judge whether or not she was fit for communion. That's a dangerous position for a priest to be in, because his actions effectively state, "I am responsible for the state of your soul." It's an impossible responsibility for a priest to bear, so in reality pushing the responsibility of making sure our souls are properly disposed for communion (where sin is concerned) onto the communicant is actually protecting the priest from having to make calls he really isn't equipped to make. Sure, in that situation you could probably easily extrapolate, but the action has all kinds of implications for other situations. It's not a good practice to start doing. And even with extrapolating you can't know for sure unless she told him specifically what she was doing with her partner. The priest can make a call when it comes to barring non-Catholics from communion because that involves an objective fact. But it's up to the person receiving communion to know whether or not he or she is in a state of sin, not the minister. Basically she explained to us why the priest didn't make the right decision. Plus it doesn't look like the priest was removed, but reprimanded. This is a quote from the Archdiocese on the issue: “When questions arise about whether or not an individual should present themselves for communion, it is not the policy of the Archdiocese of Washington to publicly reprimand the person. Any issues regarding the suitability of an individual to receive communion should be addressed by the priest with that person in a private, pastoral setting.†From this article: http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/archdiocese-of-washington-reprimands-priest-for-denying-communion-to-a-lesb Edited December 22, 2013 by Basilisa Marie
PhuturePriest Posted December 22, 2013 Author Posted December 22, 2013 But her reasoning is solid, and probably similar to Wuerl's. It's basically the same answer my canon law professor gave my class when we asked him about the situation. The priest was acting from good intentions, sure, but he made a quick decision. By denying the woman communion, the priest was making an objective judgment about the state of the woman's soul. By doing so, he was also making the statement that he had some kind of responsibility to make that call, to judge whether or not she was fit for communion. That's a dangerous position for a priest to be in, because his actions effectively state, "I am responsible for the state of your soul." It's an impossible responsibility for a priest to bear, so in reality pushing the responsibility of making sure our souls are properly disposed for communion (where sin is concerned) onto the communicant is actually protecting the priest from having to make calls he really isn't equipped to make. Sure, in that situation you could probably easily extrapolate, but the action has all kinds of implications for other situations. It's not a good practice to start doing. And even with extrapolating you can't know for sure unless she told him specifically what she was doing with her partner. The priest can make a call when it comes to barring non-Catholics from communion because that involves an objective fact. But it's up to the person receiving communion to know whether or not he or she is in a state of sin, not the minister. This reminds me of when a young man went up to communion in Spain. He took the Eucharist in his hands and then promptly through it on the ground. The priest did the logical thing and dragged him out of the church by his ear, screaming at him the entire way to the door. I want to party with that priest. :P
Seven77 Posted December 22, 2013 Posted December 22, 2013 I'm not just saying something nice because he is my Archbishop, but I know that Cardinal Weurl is very genuine. A few years ago, I was a Confirmation sponsor for a cousin… because of where my cousin sat, I had my wheelchair parked next to the middle aisle. After Mass, as he was processing out, the Cardinal made a point to greet me cheerfully and say, "it was very good to be with you."
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now