Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Burke Replaced By Wuerl? Really?


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

 

I'm not just saying something nice because he is my Archbishop, but I know that Cardinal Weurl is very genuine. A few years ago, I was a Confirmation sponsor for a cousin… because of where my cousin sat, I had my wheelchair parked next to the middle aisle. After Mass, as he was processing out, the Cardinal made a point to greet me cheerfully and say, "it was very good to be with you."

 

 

I have no doubts as to his genuine nature. I question his position on Canon Law, but I think overall he'll avoid giving us Bishops that would make Mahoney proud.

Posted

That's because it is open for debate.  It's not Catechism #whatever, it's Canon 915 which says: 
 

 

Now, the "obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin" is the tricky part. Burke argued that politicians who support pro-choice stances counted. Wuerl argued that communion was never meant to be used as a weapon, and that withholding communion doesn't work.  Both made good arguments. Even though I personally sympathize with Wuerl's position, we also have to take Burke seriously because he is a canonist and church law is what he does. It doesn't make him infallible, but it means we should take him seriously. Their opposition to each other got really public in 2009ish, and it got a little nasty. But people apologized and whatnot.  Wikipedia does a decent job of outlining how people try to interpret Canon 915 here (imho). 

 

The WitL page I linked has some links to other posts he made outlining some of went down between the two Cardinals.  

 

From what Basilisa is saying it sounds like Wuerl has an issue with Canon 915 itself, otherwise if a Catholic politician uses their office to repeatedly publically support what is gravely contrary to morality then I don't know who else might fit the criteria.
 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

From what Basilisa is saying it sounds like Wuerl has an issue with Canon 915 itself, otherwise if a Catholic politician uses their office to repeatedly publically support what is gravely contrary to morality then I don't know who else might fit the criteria.
 

 

It's not an issue with Canon 915 itself, it's the interpretation of Canon 915, specifically what really counts as a grave enough matter. That's where the issue lies, not whether or not Canon 915 is good.  

 

Hmm, maybe it's also an issue with the application of Canon 915. I know Wuerl argues that in the case of pro-choice politicians, withholding communion doesn't "work" to change their hearts. I think he'd also draw a distinction between a bishop deciding to withhold communion and a bishop urging a person to not approach communion unless he or she is properly disposed. I also think he might be in favor of withholding communion from someone whom he had already spoken to privately and urged him or her not to receive...but even then, given his actions with that one priest, I still think he really values a person's own responsibility for the state of their soul, and would save publicly denying a person communion for the gravest of cases. 

Posted

But her reasoning is solid, and probably similar to Wuerl's.  It's basically the same answer my canon law professor gave my class when we asked him about the situation.  The priest was acting from good intentions, sure, but he made a quick decision. By denying the woman communion, the priest was making an objective judgment about the state of the woman's soul.  By doing so, he was also making the statement that he had some kind of responsibility to make that call, to judge whether or not she was fit for communion. That's a dangerous position for a priest to be in, because his actions effectively state, "I am responsible for the state of your soul."  It's an impossible responsibility for a priest to bear, so in reality pushing the responsibility of making sure our souls are properly disposed for communion (where sin is concerned) onto the communicant is actually protecting the priest from having to make calls he really isn't equipped to make.   Sure, in that situation you could probably easily extrapolate, but the action has all kinds of implications for other situations.  It's not a good practice to start doing. And even with extrapolating you can't know for sure unless she told him specifically what she was doing with her partner.  The priest can make a call when it comes to barring non-Catholics from communion because that involves an objective fact.  But it's up to the person receiving communion to know whether or not he or she is in a state of sin, not the minister. 


Basically she explained to us why the priest didn't make the right decision.  Plus it doesn't look like the priest was removed, but reprimanded. 

This is a quote from the Archdiocese on the issue: 

 

From this article: http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/archdiocese-of-washington-reprimands-priest-for-denying-communion-to-a-lesb

 

Was probably similar to Wuerl's?  How do you know?  You aren't even aware what happened to the priest, lol.

 

Look, to evaluate Wuerl you need to evaluate how he and his organization dealt with the issue.  Maggie didn't do this and neither have you.  In the context of doing so, what the priest did is irrelevant, except in evaluating the Cardinal and the ADW's response.

 

I have some skin in the game with Wuerl at the moment and am not going to pass judgement or have any opinion quite yet, but y'all need to be a little more intellectually rigorous if you are going to have opinions on these types of things.  

Posted

Was probably similar to Wuerl's?  How do you know?  You aren't even aware what happened to the priest, lol.

 

Look, to evaluate Wuerl you need to evaluate how he and his organization dealt with the issue.  Maggie didn't do this and neither have you.  In the context of doing so, what the priest did is irrelevant, except in evaluating the Cardinal and the ADW's response.

 

I have some skin in the game with Wuerl at the moment and am not going to pass judgement or have any opinion quite yet, but y'all need to be a little more intellectually rigorous if you are going to have opinions on these types of things.  

 

Au contraire, "what the priest did" is extremely relevant, given that the end result is public knowledge. Basically one party complains that the priest did the right thing and the cardinal should have backed him up. The other party points out that the priest's actions were rash, foolish, possibly violated the woman's canonical rights and were entirely counter-productive. The Cardinal apologized for the big mess the priest made and that certainly is what I would have done in this situation.

 

I don't read sites like Whispers in the Loggia (an ecclesiastical Page Six and therefore a disgrace). I make a great effort to ignore this sort of "news" which honestly has zero impact on the life of the ordinary Christian in living the Gospel and saving his soul.

 

I have been doing some reading about 19th century St Petersburg society and the fact that many of its characteristics are replicated in the church today is wretched. It's all about who's in, who's out, what does it mean. Factions, ideology, power-struggle. Do you suppose at my particular judgment or yours, our opinions of bishops and the correct application of various canons will mean anything? Keep in mind that we do not know the day or the hour, and at any moment your life and mine may draw to a hasty close. The one thing we don't have enough of is time - God has numbered our days and even at this moment life is slipping away from you and from me. The greatest possible urgency is necessary and yet we waste our time on gossip and matters that don't concern us.

Posted

 ...to evaluate Wuerl you need to evaluate how he and his organization dealt with the issue.... In the context of doing so, what the priest did is irrelevant, except in evaluating the Cardinal and the ADW's response.

 

Au contraire, "what the priest did" is extremely relevant,

 

Re-read my post. You are Au-contrairing something I never said.

 

And I feel the same way about evaluating pontifical appointments in terms of gaining some sense of broader "meaning" on the direction of the Church. 

 

But evaluating these guys as individuals, especially when you have to deal them and their very large and far-reaching organizations and authority, can be important because their decisions affect a lot of people.

PhuturePriest
Posted

It's not an issue with Canon 915 itself, it's the interpretation of Canon 915, specifically what really counts as a grave enough matter. That's where the issue lies, not whether or not Canon 915 is good.  

 

Hmm, maybe it's also an issue with the application of Canon 915. I know Wuerl argues that in the case of pro-choice politicians, withholding communion doesn't "work" to change their hearts. I think he'd also draw a distinction between a bishop deciding to withhold communion and a bishop urging a person to not approach communion unless he or she is properly disposed. I also think he might be in favor of withholding communion from someone whom he had already spoken to privately and urged him or her not to receive...but even then, given his actions with that one priest, I still think he really values a person's own responsibility for the state of their soul, and would save publicly denying a person communion for the gravest of cases. 

 

I saw this and thought it might please you. I don't know if you know JReducation on CAF? He's a very prominent poster who is a Franciscan Brother, and he's a really wise and insightful man. He made this post on a thread about this on CAF:
 

Is it always necessary to look for a political or a hidden motive behind everything that our Church does? At what point do we cease to be Catholic?

Part of being a member of a family is not just biology and adoption. The most important part of being a member of a family is love and trust. If there is an absence of love and trust, if family members always suspect that other members have some scheme up their sleeves or if family members knowing that every human being is different can't apply this same rule to their own and allow them be different, how does such a unit constitute a family?

__________________
Fraternally,

Br. JR, FFV

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...