Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Dying In Mortal Sin Equals Eternal Hell?


Dying in Mortal Sin equals Eternal Hell?   

21 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Tried to create a poll on this question without luck. 

 

Is it official R C C dogma that one who dies in a state of unconfessed mortal sin always goes to hell for all eternity? 

 

Or is it just a teaching (not dogma) and so could be wrong? 

 

E

Posted

oh, I guess I did it right, or thank you to anyone that helped put it together. 

 

E

Posted

Catholics don't even say Hitler is in hell. 

 

 

 

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

No. Not unconfessed.  Unrepentant. There's a big difference. You can be repentant without having gone to confession. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie
Posted

No. Not unconfessed.  Unrepentant. There's a big difference. You can be repentant without having gone to confession. 

 

 

Opps that is what I thought the question ment...

 

 

Lesson leaned never drink and vote...EVER!

KnightofChrist
Posted

The Church does not know the names of the human souls in hell. But she teaches what Christ taught her, confession, and confession to others is required to receive repentance, and repentance is required for salvation. I John 1:9; Matt. 3:6; Mark 1:5; Acts 19:18.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

No. Not unconfessed. Unrepentant. There's a big difference. You can be repentant without having gone to confession.

In an emergency yes, if one is close to death or is in danger of death and confession is not possible. I am sure you know that as well as other Catholics here. I am not so sure our new friend does however. While he may identify as Catholic, most Catholics don't use the acronym R C C in reference to the Church. (Then go out of their way to unfilter it from the pm fiddler, when it changes it to Catholic Church.) Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

In an emergency yes, if one is close to death or is in danger of death and confession is not possible. I am sure you know that as well as other Catholics here. I am not so sure our new friend does however. While he may identify as Catholic, most Catholics don't use the acronym R C C in reference to the Church. (Then go out of their way to unfilter it from the pm fiddler, when it changes it to Catholic Church.)

 

There is of course the additional distinction between sins of grave matter committed without full culpability and those committed with it, but I'm sure as soon as we open that can of worms we'll start world war III.
 

;)

KnightofChrist
Posted

There is of course the additional distinction between sins of grave matter committed without full culpability and those committed with it, but I'm sure as soon as we open that can of worms we'll start world war III.

;)


Yes I am sure it would, it may already be too late, by mere fact you cracked the can by bringing it up lol :) . Because ignorance neither saves nor condemns, and no one can go through life with complete ignorance of every grave wrong they commit.
Posted

Yes I am sure it would, it may already be too late, by mere fact you cracked the can by bringing it up lol :) . Because ignorance neither saves nor condemns, and no one can go through life with complete ignorance of every grave wrong they commit.

 

Not so fast, schmott guy. ;) Ignorance isn't the only factor that reduces culpability.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Not so fast, schmott guy. ;) Ignorance isn't the only factor that reduces culpability.


True. However unless one is Christ or Mary we have all fallen short we have all transgressed. Whether that is compared to what the Church has taught us or the natural law written in the heart of every person by God. There is no way to reduce culpability to 0%, for every grave wrong, even after factoring in all other things that lessen culpability.
Posted

True. However unless one is Christ or Mary we have all fallen short we have all transgressed. Whether that is compared to what the Church has taught us or the natural law written in the heart of every person by God. There is no way to reduce culpability to 0%, for every grave wrong, even after factoring in all other things that lessen culpability.

 

I didn't say there was a way to get it to 0%, but thanks for the clarification. Thankfully being 0% culpable for sins in our lifetime isn't necessary for our salvation, or we'd all be screwed.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

If someone dies with mortal sin on their soul, the Church teaches they would be in hell.

 

However, a person might be forgiven of this mortal sin before death (even right before death, a moment before even) - without Confession, under certain conditions.

 

Of course, it's better to just go to Confession! and these special cases are not like if the person just doesn't want to confess - that shows unrepentance - unless right before death, they really repent of this too with much contrition.

 

In the end God knows how it all works but - with Confession, there is a certainty.

 

None of this is an excuse not to go to Confession though. The special cases are if a person can't go, etc. Or if they have no idea about it, and receive enough contrition, etc. If a person intends not to go thinking it doesn't matter, - that could be a rejection of the Sacrament, and unrepentance, or a rejection of the Church - in particular cases, God knows the person's soul, I'm just talking very generally.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

Thankfully being 0% culpable for sins in our lifetime isn't necessary for our salvation, or we'd all be screwed.


My point exactly. Because whether we are blessed to have the Gospel to follow and/or the natural law we're never going to live up to either, we will fall at times. We may not know every wrong we commit is wrong but there will always be wrongs we know are wrong. So there is always a need for some type of admission/confession of wrongs committed and some kind of repentance of those wrongs if we hope to be saved. Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

I submit Ludwig Ott's "Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma" for consideration:

 

p. 475:

"Immediately after death the particular judgment takes place, in which by a Divine Sentence of Judgment, the eternal fate of the deceased person is decided." 

 

This statement of faith was labeled "Sent. Fidei Proxima", a theological ranking on a dogmatic scale.  It means it is almost a statement of faith but not quite. 

 

Relatedly the Church can infallibly define moral issues, but not the penalties attached to denying Church teachings. 

Posted

Smells phishy to me.

KnightofChrist
Posted

I submit Ludwig Ott's "Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma" for consideration:

 

p. 475:

"Immediately after death the particular judgment takes place, in which by a Divine Sentence of Judgment, the eternal fate of the deceased person is decided." 

 

This statement of faith was labeled "Sent. Fidei Proxima", a theological ranking on a dogmatic scale.  It means it is almost a statement of faith but not quite. 

 

Relatedly the Church can infallibly define moral issues, but not the penalties attached to denying Church teachings. 

 

Church penalties such as excommunication are lifted at death. But one cannot hope to be saved if he dies while denying an article of Faith, which is a mortal sin. He who dies with unconfessed unrepented mortal sins cannot enter the Kingdom of Heaven, which nothing unclean can enter. Christ will look at them and say "I know you not, away from me..." This is the teaching of the Church, because this is what Christ taught and revealed to her.

Posted

Here's a question we talked about in class. Let's say you've been excommunicated but repented. While excommunicated you can't receive communion. Not receiving is also a violation of canon law. So can a temporal punishment cause you to be in mortal sin at death?

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

No. Not unconfessed.  Unrepentant. There's a big difference. You can be repentant without having gone to confession. 

 

I never knew that. I was always told that if you committed a mortal sin, even if you repented and were driving the car on the way to confession, unless you had perfect contrition, you had a first class ticket to hell. I never thought that made a whole lot of sense, but they would say "Yes, you repented and are on your way to confession, but it's your fault for committing the sin in the first place, so you're still damned for it." Is this not true? I asked Tim Staples (Lead Apologist at Catholic Answers) in person one year, and he told me as long as you desired to go to confession and would go at the next possible opportunity, if you died, you were forgiven for it. But everyone else I have asked on the internet says differently, and I'm confused on the matter.

Edited by FuturePriest387
KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

I never knew that. I was always told that if you committed a mortal sin, even if you repented and were driving the car on the way to confession, unless you had perfect contrition, you had a first class ticket to hell. I never thought that made a whole lot of sense, but they would say "Yes, you repented and are on your way to confession, but it's your fault for committing the sin in the first place, so you're still damned for it." Is this not true? I asked Tim Staples (Lead Apologist at Catholic Answers) in person one year, and he told me as long as you desired to go to confession and would go at the next possible opportunity, if you died, you were forgiven for it. But everyone else I have asked on the internet says differently, and I'm confused on the matter.

 

Mr. Staples is correct, if one repents and does indeed desire to go to confession, but dies before doing so his sins are forgiven. It's along the same thought of desiring to be baptized, but before one can he dies he is still receives baptism by that desire.  Of course for both examples should the person live and then not fulfill that desire the repentance is made void.

Edited by KnightofChrist

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...