KnightofChrist Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 Here's a question we talked about in class. Let's say you've been excommunicated but repented. While excommunicated you can't receive communion. Not receiving is also a violation of canon law. So can a temporal punishment cause you to be in mortal sin at death? If he receives absolution from the excommunication, then receives sacramental absolution, he could receive communion without committing mortal sin. I'm not sure that without absolution from the excommunication, that the violation of Canon Law would apply to the person. So I don't think that it would cause mortal sin for the person not to receive. I think in an emergency a priest may be able to get permission (before or even perhaps after) to give communion to a person who's been excommunicated but has repented and confessed to the priest.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 I never knew that. I was always told that if you committed a mortal sin, even if you repented and were driving the car on the way to confession, unless you had perfect contrition, you had a first class ticket to hell. I never thought that made a whole lot of sense, but they would say "Yes, you repented and are on your way to confession, but it's your fault for committing the sin in the first place, so you're still damned for it." Is this not true? I asked Tim Staples (Lead Apologist at Catholic Answers) in person one year, and he told me as long as you desired to go to confession and would go at the next possible opportunity, if you died, you were forgiven for it. But everyone else I have asked on the internet says differently, and I'm confused on the matter. Yeah, that's because repentance is the thing that makes it all work from our end. I mean, you go through the motions of Confession, but you aren't repentant even in the tiniest, slightest bit? I don't think that counts. Now, I think it'd be reasonable to guess that the person who repents of a mortal sin and doesn't make it to confession probably spends more "time" in purgatory, but ultimately sacraments are for our benefit, and God can do what he wants. :) But the sacraments are so important because (among many other reasons) they're sure sources of sacramental, sanctifying grace. It's like using directions to get to a new location vs wandering around and hoping that you come upon it.
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 My grandpa died without confessing, they where looking for a priest though but could not find one. The day after he died the holy priest whom came to do whatever the priests do over the dead body ( and he was fssp by the way and the whole family was there whom are all lapsed catholics and it was beautiful, we all got pray the lords prayer together), well anyway after the whatevers over his body the holy priest said to me that it was ok and that god knew he tried. And i got signs that he went to heaven the following days before his burial.
maximillion Posted February 15, 2014 Posted February 15, 2014 Like many other things, intention is the key here. If I died in mortal sin, unconfessed BUT had the intention of obtaining a pure heart by confession at the earliest opportunity, then I am forgiven. If I die unrepentant then I am dammed. I was taught this from my earliest days in school and as far as I am aware nothing has changed in the intervening time. The cases where one may have sinned and not be aware of it are as far as I know limited to certain cases where medical conditions obtain. If I am conscious in the usual sense of the meaning of that word and I commit mortal sin, I am guilty. I would need to be in some altered state where I was not aware of my own actions in order to do something horrendous and not be guilty. I am not stating any teaching or dogma here, just my own understanding.
Eliakim Posted February 15, 2014 Author Posted February 15, 2014 If I die unrepentant then I am dammed. Can we be so sure? Is it a *dogma* one is eternally damned?
KnightofChrist Posted February 15, 2014 Posted February 15, 2014 It is a truth taught to the Church by Christ. "The teaching of the Church affirms the existence of hell and its eternity. Immediately after death the souls of those who die in a state of mortal sin descend into hell, where they suffer the punishments of hell, ‘eternal fire.’ The chief punishment of hell is eternal separation from God, in whom alone man can possess the life and happiness for which he was created and for which he longs" - CCC 1035
Lilllabettt Posted February 15, 2014 Posted February 15, 2014 It is true that if a person does not repent of sin they have freely, fully chosen, they are damned. The point is that only God knows: 1. who has freely and fully chosen mortal sin and 2. of these, who among them is or is not repentant at the moment of death. The choice to know, love and serve God is an ongoing one. We don't choose God once and then become his robots. It would be horrible to live a life loving God and then turn against Him in the last moment - but the freedom of that choice is always in our power. That's why we pray for perseverance.
Eliakim Posted February 15, 2014 Author Posted February 15, 2014 ok, this is what the Church officially teaches, but it does not have the authority to make this dogma, and frankly even this teaching itself cited by the CCC may very well be outside the Church's authority to bind and loose and power of the keys as I explained in my other post "The Church does not have the authority to d a m n." The Church used to teach usery was a mortal sin too (I am aware of the labrynth arguments some Catholics who deny this will stretch to employ, but it's true the Church can correct non-infallible teachings). Could it be that the Church is just acting very cautiously by teaching those who die in mortal sin are damned for all eternity? One really couldn't blame the Church for doing this since Christ uses language that seem to support this notion (though not explicitly). True there won't be liars and sexually immoral in the Kingdom, but how this occurs is not revealed to us. E
Lilllabettt Posted February 15, 2014 Posted February 15, 2014 Well, this is a teaching of the ancient Church. The orthodox don't have the legal distinction between mortal and venial sins. They have the same concept though - intentional, deliberate sin is symptomatic of a separation from the Church, that separation being synonymous with loss of salvation.
Eliakim Posted February 15, 2014 Author Posted February 15, 2014 Well, this is a teaching of the ancient Church. The orthodox don't have the legal distinction between mortal and venial sins. They have the same concept though - intentional, deliberate sin is symptomatic of a separation from the Church, that separation being synonymous with loss of salvation. Again the decision to state someone is "outside the Church" is never infallible. And every time the hierarchy did this it ipso facto went outside its own jurisdiction. At most the Church can declare it believes someone to be outside the Church but never infallibly that anyone truly is. It can declare things to be sins and then retract/loose ordinances (binding and loosing) but not inflict penalty beyond temporal punishments. This eternal penalty belongs to Christ alone. E
Basilisa Marie Posted February 15, 2014 Posted February 15, 2014 No, it's not outside its jurisdiction, it's just that Church leaders are not going to add a massive caveat of "oh but remember God has the final say and only God truly knows a person's heart at the moment of their death!" every single time they say something. You can say someone is currently outside the Church without saying that they're certainly going to Hell. They're two separate, but related, issues.
arfink Posted February 15, 2014 Posted February 15, 2014 If he receives absolution from the excommunication, then receives sacramental absolution, he could receive communion without committing mortal sin. I'm not sure that without absolution from the excommunication, that the violation of Canon Law would apply to the person. So I don't think that it would cause mortal sin for the person not to receive. I think in an emergency a priest may be able to get permission (before or even perhaps after) to give communion to a person who's been excommunicated but has repented and confessed to the priest. Well, the interesting thing about that is, most forms of excommunication are automatic forms for things like divorce and remarriage and abortion. And in virtually every diocese in the world, the local ordinary is given permission to lift that excommunication, and I believe at least in every diocese in the United States the bishops have agreed to allow this power to their priests in the confessional, usually with some fairly simple caveats. So, that's pretty cool.
LouisvilleFan Posted February 16, 2014 Posted February 16, 2014 I never knew that. I was always told that if you committed a mortal sin, even if you repented and were driving the car on the way to confession, unless you had perfect contrition, you had a first class ticket to hell. I never thought that made a whole lot of sense, but they would say "Yes, you repented and are on your way to confession, but it's your fault for committing the sin in the first place, so you're still damned for it." Is this not true? I asked Tim Staples (Lead Apologist at Catholic Answers) in person one year, and he told me as long as you desired to go to confession and would go at the next possible opportunity, if you died, you were forgiven for it. But everyone else I have asked on the internet says differently, and I'm confused on the matter. It's simply a matter of God extending the grace of Confession outside of the sacrament, and we all know this is no problemo for the One who created the sacraments.
BarbTherese Posted February 17, 2014 Posted February 17, 2014 God can indeed do ALL things : Hosea Chapter 11 "[8] How shall I deal with thee, O Ephraim, shall I protect thee, O Israel? how shall I make thee as Adama, shall I set thee as Seboim? my heart is turned within me, my repentance is stirred up. [9] I will not execute the fierceness of my wrath: I will not return to destroy Ephraim: because I am God, and not man" Ephraim and Israel had been unfaithful to God. Adama and Sebolm were destroyed with Sodom and Gomorrah. (Hosea Chapter 12 :"[12] Ephraim hath compassed me about with denials, and the house of Israel with deceit") While God can indeed do all things, we are gifted with the Sacrament of Reconciliation to prove that He can indeed do all things. Only God can see into the depths of the human heart and Final Judgement (Heaven or Hell) is God's alone. The Church can certainly outlay for us the conditions for a mortal sin which alone can condemn a person to Hell in the eyes of God, but that Final Judgement is God's alone. A human being of some kind can state that they think a person is/might be in the state of mortal sin - and with wisdom and prudence should realise their fallibility in the matter.
Didacus Posted February 17, 2014 Posted February 17, 2014 Catholics don't even say Hitler is in hell. Nor Judas for that matter.
Norseman82 Posted February 17, 2014 Posted February 17, 2014 Although technically true "on paper", as others have pointed out, we don't know if the other conditions (full consent and knowledge) necessary to make a sin mortal are present, or whether the person has a last-minute conversion, or whether God shows mercy. Nevertheless, it can be a useful way of getting people to think twice before committing a serious sin, as anyone who has ever been taught by older nuns can attest.
BarbTherese Posted February 17, 2014 Posted February 17, 2014 (edited) A beautiful passage from Hosea. Background: Ephraim and Israel had been unfaithful to God and He was angry and possibly considering for them the same fate as Sodom and Gomorrah. Admah and Zeboiim were destroyed with Sodom and Gomorrah. Hosea Ch 11 http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0839/__PTB.HTM "8 How could I give you up, O Ephraim, or deliver you up, O Israel? How could I treat you as Admah, or make you like Zeboiim? My heart is overwhelmed, my pity is stirred. 9I will not give vent to my blazing anger, I will not destroy Ephraim again; For I am God and not man, the Holy One present among you; I will not let the flames consume you. " His Judgement and His Mercy are in God's Hands and I don't think He is confined to human rules of any kind "For I am God and not man". https://www.ewtn.com/library/CHRIST/DIVMERCY.TXT St. Bernard (d.1153) taught that "God is not the Father of Judgement, but only the Father of Mercy, and punishment comes from our own selves." St. Thomas Aquinas (d. 1274) taught that God's mercy is the chief motive of all His external activity. St. Gertrude the Great (d.1302) was even taught the identical chaplet to the Mercy of God as was Sr. Faustina. St. Catherine of Siena (d.1380) prayed, "Oh, Divine Mercy!. . . On every side which I turn my thought I find nothing but mercy." Dom Marmion, O.S.B. the great Benedictine Abbot (d.1923) wrote, "There is in God one perfection which is perhaps the key of all that befalls us here below: it is mercy. Mercy is love in the face of misery; if there were no misery, there would be no mercy. . . we shall be in Heaven the living witnesses of the Divine Mercy." _______________ But I do agree with Norseman82, if one was taught by nuns especially pre V2, one would in all likelihood shake and tremble much before even considering an act that might be seriously sinful. I thank God for my pre V2 education by nuns as much grief as it brought me, it taught me from an early age self discipline :) Edited February 17, 2014 by BarbaraTherese
Norseman82 Posted February 24, 2014 Posted February 24, 2014 [media] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=54cR-FRN1rI [/media]
Eliakim Posted March 6, 2014 Author Posted March 6, 2014 No, it's not outside its jurisdiction, it's just that Church leaders are not going to add a massive caveat of "oh but remember God has the final say and only God truly knows a person's heart at the moment of their death!" every single time they say something. You can say someone is currently outside the Church without saying that they're certainly going to Hell. They're two separate, but related, issues. Please show me 2 or 3 solid Early Church Fathers or of medieval period that showed the thought process that those outside the Church are not necessarily going to hell. Although technically true "on paper", as others have pointed out, we don't know if the other conditions (full consent and knowledge) necessary to make a sin mortal are present, or whether the person has a last-minute conversion, or whether God shows mercy. Nevertheless, it can be a useful way of getting people to think twice before committing a serious sin, as anyone who has ever been taught by older nuns can attest. So it's "useful" to scare people when it is not fully explained.
PhuturePriest Posted March 6, 2014 Posted March 6, 2014 Please show me 2 or 3 solid Early Church Fathers or of medieval period that showed the thought process that those outside the Church are not necessarily going to hell. So it's "useful" to scare people when it is not fully explained. Saint Thomas Aquinas believed that the soul enters the body 40 days after conception. Obviously, he was wrong. It wasn't his fault; he just said what he had been taught and led to believe. Many early Church Fathers believed in heresies, because the heresies were not yet established as heresies yet and they didn't know any better. Obviously, a Church Father or Doctor of the Church saying something doesn't automatically make it theologically correct.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now