PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 (edited) I'm unsure of which one I associate with. My parents are about as Republican as you can get, and agree with pretty much anything so long as a "conservative" or "real" Republican says it, and they denounce all other political philosophies and ideas. My sister and I were always a lot more open to other ideas, and my sister has ended up libertarian/conservative-esque whilst calling herself Independent, but I'm unsure of where I fall. I always thought I was a conservative, but it seems I conflict a lot with what conservatives think. It seems every republican/hardcore conservative holds dear to the idea that guns are an inherent human right, but I don't see how that makes any sort of logical sense. I honestly wouldn't flip out if guns were banned. The more radical conservatives think things such as welfare are an inherent evil, and I don't think that, either. I think those things should be done by the States rather than the Federal level, but I don't think they're inherently bad. I have heard that when it comes to welfare, there is a way to do this through private charity, but I've never heard an argument for how this could work. One thing I agree with libertarians on is the legalization of marijuana, but I've also heard libertarians advocate for the legalization of all drugs. I don't think a population on meth is a sound idea. In all, I'd like to hear peoples' opinions on issues (Guns or lack thereof, welfare, gay rights, drugs, economics, etc.) I don't want arguments and responses towards other posts. I don't want slander or name-calling. I just want your opinions and arguments for why your ideas are logically and practically sound. But really. I don't care if someone says they advocate the federal euthanization of puppies, don't argue with each other. P.S. An explanation on how private charity could work gets an A+. I really want to know the ideas behind that. Edited February 25, 2014 by FuturePriest387
PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Author Posted February 25, 2014 "Heard libertarians advocate all drugs" means I've heard a few libertarians advocate that, not as in "Bob down the street told me libertarians as a whole advocate legalization of all drugs". Sorry for the confusion.
Not The Philosopher Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I used to be a pretty hardcore libertarian - even going so far as to argue for anarchism in a political philosophy paper. Now I am a vague Burkean Tory of sorts. There should be a defeasable presumption in favor of preserving traditional institutions, and a defeasable presumption in favor of less regulation. Aside from that things are still feeling very open ended and mushy for me right now.
PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Author Posted February 25, 2014 I used to be a pretty hardcore libertarian - even going so far as to argue for anarchism in a political philosophy paper. Now I am a vague Burkean Tory of sorts. There should be a defeasable presumption in favor of preserving traditional institutions, and a defeasable presumption in favor of less regulation. Aside from that things are still feeling very open ended and mushy for me right now. I used to be a hardcore republican when I was really young (Think 10-15), and then I was all about Ron Paul and libertarianism, but thanks to the masterful arguments I've seen on Phatmass, I'm unsure of anything. I do know what political institution I like the best in theory and in practice, but the political institution I identify with isn't strictly conservative or liberal. It can go any way you want it to.
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I don't see any way for this not to end up in a debate... I think it would be more productive to talk about what you've read and various things you could read to help you answer those questions yourself. Are there any specific blogs you follow or books you've read that have had a big influence on you in this area? Are there books you really wanted to read and haven't yet? I will say that to get a complete picture you need to get a basis in political philosophy, history, and economics. Many people will spend time on one or maybe two and they'll end up with an incomplete picture of the issues, ie. you need at least three legs on a stool (and I think a good fourth leg would be theology - but that will have less weight in a secular conversation.)
Not The Philosopher Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 By "institution" I don't narrowly mean political parties, etc. but cultural/political traditions more generally.
Lilllabettt Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 history is the terrible story of man's attempt to find something besides god that will make him happy. e.g., ideologies. they all ultimately fail in some crucial facet - some more or less completely than others. we long for a perfect interlocking system. it evades us. a relatively successful ideology is the one that can admit that it is flawed. most can't do that and they go on to dehumanize and annihilate.
PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Author Posted February 25, 2014 I don't see any way for this not to end up in a debate... I think it would be more productive to talk about what you've read and various things you could read to help you answer those questions yourself. Are there any specific blogs you follow or books you've read that have had a big influence on you in this area? Are there books you really wanted to read and haven't yet? I will say that to get a complete picture you need to get a basis in political philosophy, history, and economics. Many people will spend time on one or maybe two and they'll end up with an incomplete picture of the issues, ie. you need at least three legs on a stool (and I think a good fourth leg would be theology - but that will have less weight in a secular conversation.) It can not be a debate by people practicing self-restraint and not arguing with other posts. Quite easy, in fact. By "institution" I don't narrowly mean political parties, etc. but cultural/political traditions more generally. Yeah. I identify as a Monarchist, but obviously in America I understandably won't be able to see such a political institution put in place.
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 It can not be a debate by people practicing self-restraint and not arguing with other posts. Quite easy, in fact. OK, I'm glad you have such faith in phatmass posters... beyond that, any thoughts on the rest of my post?
PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Author Posted February 25, 2014 OK, I'm glad you have such faith in phatmass posters... beyond that, any thoughts on the rest of my post? I haven't particularly read any economic books. My sister had me read parts of a few economic books that were hardcore libertarian, but I can't remember what they were called.
4588686 Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 we long for a perfect interlocking system. it evades us. a relatively successful ideology is the one that can admit that it is flawed. most can't do that and they go on to dehumanize and annihilate. 'The history of the world is a sad attempt to construct ideologies that cannot admit that they are flawed and imperfect, unlike my ideological system which was given to man by God and is infallible."
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I haven't particularly read any economic books. My sister had me read parts of a few economic books that were hardcore libertarian, but I can't remember what they were called. What about politics and history? And do you have anything like a "wish list" of books you'd like to buy and read?
PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Author Posted February 25, 2014 'The history of the world is a sad attempt to construct ideologies that cannot admit that they are flawed and imperfect, unlike my ideological system which was given to man by God and is infallible." Now, now, Hasan. Play nice and utilize this opportunity to indoctrinate me to the Dark Side of the Force.
Lilllabettt Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 'The history of the world is a sad attempt to construct ideologies that cannot admit that they are flawed and imperfect, unlike my ideological system which was given to man by God and is infallible." not debating as per op's request
4588686 Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I personally have recently gotten into the pragmatists. I'd recommend Richard Rorty and Richard Posner. I'd also recommend looking into Kuhn. For politics I'd recommend Ivo Andric, a great Conservative Bosnian-Croatian writer. I'd also recommend reading Paul Krugman's blog, Jacobin Magazine, Bleeding Heart Libertarians, Crooked Timber. Herbert Gintis is an economist I really like. He writes some interesting reviews on Amazon http://www.amazon.com/review/R26YBOD86NQRGB
4588686 Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I'd also recommend reading Marx. Although I'd stay away from self-avowed Marxists, who tend to be painfully dogmatic and tedious.
Aloysius Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 while I support Ron Paul in many ways and of course was a delegate to the Republican National Convention for him, I am definitely a distributist in a way that wholly conflicts with economic libertarian purism. I take from libertarianism a good starting principle that state intervention is inherently a form of violence, even when it's building a library it's doing it by violence (taxes are enforced by the threat of violently imprisoning you if you don't pay them, for instance), and generally therefore move towards a more voluntarist society in which we can find any and all ways possible to do these things without violence. however, I go much further than simply "fraud" and "stealing" as the only economic evils/injustices that need the violence of the state to intervene to correct... as one could see in my battles on the living wage thread (where both sides got in some good points). I think eventually with technological advancements we will be able to do away with state violence to a greater extent than we do today, but ultimately state violence is justified in enforcing justice... not just stopping murders, but also when the economic systems that have been artificially constructed by humanity in our society end up violating basic natural law, like the universal destination of the resources of the earth, for instance. I believe there are forms of violence people sometimes do with economics even when they're disguised as supposedly free contracts, and those forms of violence do need the state to intervene with the symbolic violence of the state (actual violence if it needs to send people to jail) as far as drug laws go, they should not be directed at forbidding drugs from being purchased and/or consumed, but at forbidding the kinds of anti-social behaviors that can result from those drugs being consumed. when people burden society with their drug habits, then they should be able to be forcibly put into detox or rehab. companies that sell drugs that result in people doing bad things in society should be liable for huge lawsuits... which means you'd see some companies spring up to allow people to do drugs in supervised places where they're separated from society like some of those medical clinics that pop up to try to help junkies not be in such dangerous situations... generally for hard drugs, though, you couldn't sell outright them because you'll end up sued for the hospital bills of all the people overdosing and such. the current criminalization approach just makes everything that much worse, and comes from a generally wrong idea about government IMO.
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I don't have a whole lot of time at the moment so I would just like to point to you how welfare can happen absent government involvement. I would submit evidence by example of the Catholic Church. Created Hospitals, Started Public Education, Orphanages and Adoption Agencies were started by them, The Largest non-profit in the State of Kansas is a Catholic group who work with the poor to the tune of almost 300,000 people below the poverty line where they are able to pair them up with supporters and patrons to help them through rough times and sponsor them. I know a good number of Doctors who provided free care often for those who could just flat out not afford it otherwise. In Topeka each year Dentist get together to offer free dental care to those who need it. There are loads of charities who do great work and when people build real relationships with each other they become aware of these issues and the community responds. When Government takes over charitable donations tend to decrease to these groups making them dependent on Government funds and the issues become more hidden to the general public.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now