arfink Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I tend to take what I would call the adapting/defeatist attitude. I know my opinions lie so far outside the norms of the GOP and DFL that it is essentially moot, and so I must give up on changing politics and instead seek to adapt myself to the reality of living in a country which is very polarized and uninterested in the things I am interested in.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 http://www.politicalcompass.org/test
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I would disagree with Hasan's idea of reading blogs as a way to inform yourself because until you get a better foundation in the underlying principles - no matter how much you think you get from the blogs - you won't really understand the content. You need to get a foundation and build on that first. I'd go as far back as you could and start there. Read some books on political philosophy, maybe something about the enlightenment philosophers or the history of political philosophy. I'm not sure if I'd recommend the original texts outside of a classroom environment, though. It would also be good to review America's founding, maybe the federalist papers and perhaps something that compares the US revolution with the French. There is a ton out there on economics, but I think that would be putting the cart ahead of the horse. when you read economics it helps to have some historical perspective to process it.
PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Author Posted February 25, 2014 I would disagree with Hasan's idea of reading blogs as a way to inform yourself because until you get a better foundation in the underlying principles - no matter how much you think you get from the blogs - you won't really understand the content. You need to get a foundation and build on that first. I'd go as far back as you could and start there. Read some books on political philosophy, maybe something about the enlightenment philosophers or the history of political philosophy. I'm not sure if I'd recommend the original texts outside of a classroom environment, though. It would also be good to review America's founding, maybe the federalist papers and perhaps something that compares the US revolution with the French. There is a ton out there on economics, but I think that would be putting the cart ahead of the horse. when you read economics it helps to have some historical perspective to process it. I haven't particularly read blogs or books about all the political philosophies, but I love history, and so have read an extensive amount on America's founding and the principals behind it. I highly disagree with the Founding Fathers on many of their ideas, as well as the philosophies that came from the French Revolution.
arfink Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I haven't particularly read blogs or books about all the political philosophies, but I love history, and so have read an extensive amount on America's founding and the principals behind it. I highly disagree with the Founding Fathers on many of their ideas, as well as the philosophies that came from the French Revolution. I've never really liked the French Revolution or the ideas that fueled it. Whether the ideas were fundamentally sound or not, it justified a kind of violence and almost mindless brutality that I don't believe can be justified.
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I don't have a whole lot of time at the moment so I would just like to point to you how welfare can happen absent government involvement. I would submit evidence by example of the Catholic Church. Created Hospitals, Started Public Education, Orphanages and Adoption Agencies were started by them, The Largest non-profit in the State of Kansas is a Catholic group who work with the poor to the tune of almost 300,000 people below the poverty line where they are able to pair them up with supporters and patrons to help them through rough times and sponsor them. I know a good number of Doctors who provided free care often for those who could just flat out not afford it otherwise. In Topeka each year Dentist get together to offer free dental care to those who need it. There are loads of charities who do great work and when people build real relationships with each other they become aware of these issues and the community responds. When Government takes over charitable donations tend to decrease to these groups making them dependent on Government funds and the issues become more hidden to the general public. This is where an understanding of history is helpful alongside economics and philosophy. Originally nearly all welfare and education were private, the majority coming from churches. Slowly the government crowded out these charities - not always with the best motives. For example, the motive for centralized public education was not to benefit the poor, but to reduce the power and influence of the Church among immigrants (especially Catholics, but Lutherans as well) by ensuring proper indoctrination. This was inspired in part I believe by a similar movement in germany called "kulturkampf." Horace Mann usually gets credit for this in the USA, but it's not terribly well documented.
arfink Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 (edited) This is where an understanding of history is helpful alongside economics and philosophy. Originally nearly all welfare and education were private, the majority coming from churches. Slowly the government crowded out these charities - not always with the best motives. For example, the motive for centralized public education was not to benefit the poor, but to reduce the power and influence of the Church among immigrants (especially Catholics, but Lutherans as well) by ensuring proper indoctrination. This was inspired in part I believe by a similar movement in germany called "kulturkampf." Horace Mann usually gets credit for this in the USA, but it's not terribly well documented. I have also often heard the theory that Prussian educational ideas were foundational in the systems instituted in the United States. These ideas were to produce a minimally-educated workforce at low cost that would have the necessary reading, writing, and basic math skills to be able to work factory shifts with very minimal additional training. I've never found fantastic sources for this though, so I'm a little dubious. You heard this before? Edited February 25, 2014 by arfink
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I've never really liked the French Revolution or the ideas that fueled it. Whether the ideas were fundamentally sound or not, it justified a kind of violence and almost mindless brutality that I don't believe can be justified. I don't like it either, but I think it's especially important to understand the ideas you don't like. The revolution didn't happen in a vacuum. It was supported by Rosseau's idea of a social contract and "sovereign" as well as various anti-catholic motives that were pervasive during the earlier reformation.
arfink Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I don't like it either, but I think it's especially important to understand the ideas you don't like. The revolution didn't happen in a vacuum. It was supported by Rosseau's idea of a social contract and "sovereign" as well as various anti-catholic motives that were pervasive during the earlier reformation. That's true. Although, in as much as I have studied any philosophy, I am more of a student of epistemology and metaphysics than political philosophy. I just seems more important to me, because you can derive most of the rest from that point.
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I have also often heard the theory that Prussian educational ideas were foundational in the systems instituted in the United States. These ideas were to produce a minimally-educated workforce at low cost that would have the necessary reading, writing, and basic math skills to be able to work factory shifts with very minimal additional training. I've never found fantastic sources for this though, so I'm a little dubious. You heard this before? Interesting. I haven't heard it put quite that way. Protestant German schools led academia for a long time (I think up until WWII) so if they were the ones doing most of the writing I'm not sure they'd attribute that as a motive even if it was the case. The next best sources of scholarship were Britain and the US. 19th century Germany did however have a big influence on non-marxist socialist thought and Germany implemented many non-marxist socialist ideas that lasted up until WWI. Honestly, good catholic scholars have had their hands full the last 100 years, so not surprising they didn't get around to this. There's this write-up on kulturkampf I found and maybe it has some of the answers: http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08703b.htm
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 That's true. Although, in as much as I have studied any philosophy, I am more of a student of epistemology and metaphysics than political philosophy. I just seems more important to me, because you can derive most of the rest from that point. Well, as I said about building a foundation, going back to pure philosophy is ideal, but not everyone gets the chance (or would be willing to.) for someone like yourself you could probably read a quick summary of Rousseau's social contract and see where he went wrong and how it influenced the french revolution.
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 I haven't particularly read blogs or books about all the political philosophies, but I love history, and so have read an extensive amount on America's founding and the principals behind it. I highly disagree with the Founding Fathers on many of their ideas, as well as the philosophies that came from the French Revolution. Which ideas if you don't mind me asking?
mortify ii Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 Forget silly factions and labels and just be Catholic. I'm getting to the point where I feel democracy is overrated ; )
arfink Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 Well, as I said about building a foundation, going back to pure philosophy is ideal, but not everyone gets the chance (or would be willing to.) for someone like yourself you could probably read a quick summary of Rousseau's social contract and see where he went wrong and how it influenced the french revolution. This is actually where I tend to run into trouble, because I read works like that at face value using my more underlying understanding and then find that I can't converse with people who are well studied in political philosophy and don't see the underlying stuff. :P The basic level of understanding then becomes very different between me and the typical lover of politics, which generally results in me being frustrated by mis-matched jargon and accused of being a dunce. :P
NotreDame Posted February 25, 2014 Posted February 25, 2014 Forget silly factions and labels and just be Catholic. I'm getting to the point where I feel democracy is overrated ; ) Well, all the study should be in the pursuit of truth, not the justification of a pre-determined ideological system. This is actually where I tend to run into trouble, because I read works like that at face value using my more underlying understanding and then find that I can't converse with people who are well studied in political philosophy and don't see the underlying stuff. :P The basic level of understanding then becomes very different between me and the typical lover of politics, which generally results in me being frustrated by mis-matched jargon and accused of being a dunce. :P If I had to guess, that's probably because they are really more political scientists than political philosophers. But even if you never use it in conversation, understanding it still has value.
PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Author Posted February 25, 2014 http://www.politicalcompass.org/test I am apparently one with Ghandi when it comes to political leanings. :P
PhuturePriest Posted February 25, 2014 Author Posted February 25, 2014 I honestly wasn't satisfied with the way that quiz came out, though. I don't disagree that I care more about people than I do about money, but I feel as if I got that result because the wording in a lot of those questions wasn't right, and there wasn't a "middle-ground' button to push, either.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now