Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

My sexual orientation does not define me

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

 

 

*** most of what is out there on chastity is Alcoholics Anonymous style 12-step approaches, which fail to address root problems in chastity in the same way AA fails to address root problems in alcoholics.

 

Both a.a. and n.a and s.a do address the supposed causes of alcoholism, drug addiction and lust. I think it is the 4 through to 9.  4th step being ' made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves' 5th step is 'admitted to god, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact natures of our wrongs. 6th step ' where entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.' 7th step ' humbly asked him to remove our short comings.' 8th ' made a list of all the persons we had harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all. 9th ' Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.

 

This is all pretty much the catholic churches view as well, 1 examine your concience, 2 confess your sins. 3. repent and make some kind of amends. The only difference is those at a.a and n.a don't receive what we catholic christians call absolution, same as the protestants, jews and muslims. The root problem could be a resentment/unforgiveness, drugs, alcohol, pride, jealousy, envy or any other sins that aren't lust.

 

A priest told me for lust plenty of exercise helps to let out that excess energy. Not plonk yourself in front of the television. Also st paul says something like ' How i wish you all to be like me but i know that is not possible, have many times of abstinence.' I assume he was talking to a married person or couple.

 

Onward christian souls. 

 

Jesus iz LORD.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

I think the Gay in the form of homosexual debate is rated XX and at the least X and should be removed from the G rated boards and moved to the 18+ board.

Posted

My sexual orientation does not define me

 

 

#privilege 

Posted

#privilege 

#entitlement

Posted

#entitlement

 

 

I guess it is.  Some people feel entitled not to be treated like poo in public spaces and from the law because of somebody's superstition.  

Posted

I guess it is.  Some people feel entitled not to be treated like poo in public spaces and from the law because of somebody's superstition.  

Maybe if you lived in Riyadh I'd agree with this ^^^. 

 

Posted (edited)

Maybe if you lived in Riyadh I'd agree with this ^^^. 

 

 

I have a good friend who is gay and from Riyadh.  What's your point?

Edited by Hasan
Posted

Wanting to have equal access to service at a public restaurant is not 'entitlement' it's a basic assertion of equality before the law.  Maybe you think that the law the was utilized to deconstruct Jim Crow was unnecessary and a bad idea.  Fine.  But that's an entirely separate conversation from claiming that somebody living in that legal context asking that the logic of those laws be applied equally is 'entitled.'

Posted

Wanting to have equal access to service at a public restaurant is not 'entitlement' it's a basic assertion of equality before the law.  Maybe you think that the law the was utilized to deconstruct Jim Crow was unnecessary and a bad idea.  Fine.  But that's an entirely separate conversation from claiming that somebody living in that legal context asking that the logic of those laws be applied equally is 'entitled.'

Gays run some of the biggest companies in the world.  They are all over daytime television with their own shows, they are a protected minority at most major companies (ie. quotas!)  and they just bullied the governor of a state into vetoing a bill that would have protected religious freedom.
 

Please, don't try to compare the "plight" of gays to the struggle of blacks under Jim Crow laws.  There is no comparison. 

 

Posted

Gays run some of the biggest companies in the world.  They are all over daytime television with their own shows, they are a protected minority at most major companies (ie. quotas!)  and they just bullied the governor of a state into vetoing a bill that would have protected religious freedom.
 

Please, don't try to compare the "plight" of gays to the struggle of blacks under Jim Crow laws.  There is no comparison. 

 

 

When did I compare the current situation of gay Americans to the situation of black Americans at the height of Jim Crow?  

 

However, as people view your comments, I would encourage them to watch this debate between William F. Buckley and James Baldwin and note the similarities between your argument and Buckley's.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oFeoS41xe7w

Posted

as it was attempted to be established on another thread, we should not go overboard on comparing blacks and gays, because they each have their own struggles, but NOR should we try to minimize that struggle.  the number of gay suicides is staggering, the amount of rejection out there is huge... to point to the fact that there is generally a swing in the major culture and the media towards a more gay-accepting atmosphere, that there are very successful gay people out there, none of that should be used as a means to try to minimize the fact that they do face extreme hardships especially in their formative years of life... while black people were discriminated against by the white society at large, gay people often find themselves discriminated against, shunned, sent to torturous gay-change-"therapy" camps or disreputable "therapists", etc.  It's a far different thing, but there are parallels in terms of trying to avoid discrimination... and as the Catechism of the Catholic Church says regarding homosexuals, " Every sign of unjust discrimination in their regard should be avoided"

 

in a broader way, we should not conflate the overturning of jim crow laws with the other anti-discrimination laws in the civil rights act as in their relation to property rights they are two different things.  jim crow laws required segregation by law, and as such absolutely had to be overturned for the sake of actually making sure private owners of businesses had the freedom to operate their businesses as they liked.  the anti-discrimination provisions require that any place open to the general public should not discriminate... it's an entirely different thing than just merely overturning jim crow and some private-property-absolutists tend to argue that it infringes upon private property rights.  I don't really go that far, because I recognize that especially in our system many times private businesses are organized in such a way that goods and services that would permit someone to have a dignified life relative to the society at large are in a way monopolized by private entities to the point where being discriminated against by them would be just as bad as being discriminated against by the government.  if Wal-Mart alone, for instance, didn't allow blacks, or mexicans, or gay people, to shop in their stores... those people's basic living standards in America would immediately become second-class just as bad as if they were banned by the force of government.  thankfully our culture, and actually through the ideology of free market profiteering, has become very much against any sign of discrimination.... to the point where huge segments of the BUSINESS COMMUNITY were the ones that "bullied" the governor of Arizona into vetoing that law.  it is great that the business community is so culturally against discrimination that we don't have to solely and absolutely rely on the crutch of government enforced anti-discrimination laws.

Posted (edited)

as it was attempted to be established on another thread, we should not go overboard on comparing blacks and gays, because they each have their own struggles, but NOR should we try to minimize that struggle.  the number of gay suicides is staggering, the amount of rejection out there is huge... to point to the fact that there is generally a swing in the major culture and the media towards a more gay-accepting atmosphere, that there are very successful gay people out there, none of that should be used as a means to try to minimize the fact that they do face extreme hardships especially in their formative years of life... 

 

I think this sums up pretty much all that needs to be said (except possibly for the fact that was deceitful of Franciscanheart not to let us know that she is the CEO of a company with her own TV show ;) ).

 

On a serious note, the insinuation that 'gays' are really very powerful and capable of bullying governments into doing exactly what they want is an insinuation that accompanies pretty much every sort of prejudice against minority groups. Yes, some gay people are very successful. It's easy enough to come out if you're a sporting celebrity (as happened with a British athlete at the Winter Olympics) or a Hollywood star who already has a large following and plentiful income. It's not so easy if you're just some high school kid who's worried about bullies or his family not wanting to know him any more. Discriminatory laws don't really affect celebrities (of which 'out' gay people constitute a minority anyway - it's not as if they have this monopoly on TV and high finance). They affect ordinary people on the street.

 

Straight people are not persecuted. My religious freedoms as a Catholic are not compromised in any way simply because gay couples want to access the same public services as I do. I don't need a gay couple to be turned away from a restaurant or a hotel in order to be secure in my faith. But for my faith to matter, I have to take the part of the above-mentioned high school kid, because too many kids in that situation do, as Al has said, attempt to take their own lives. I don't think it's such a radical idea that there is a correlation between living in the kind of world where people see it as perfectly legitimate to sit around debating whether or not you're entitled to receive service in a cafe and feeling that maybe you'd rather be dead than live in a world like that.

 

A while ago a very dear friend (who is lesbian, and an ex-Catholic, and who has attempted suicide twice) showed me this video, which she was very moved by. Even though she's British, so the cultural milieu she grew up in was different. she said the video still depicted her childhood and teenage experiences better than she could explain them to me in words. It does not make easy watching (there is a suicide-attempt scene in there, just so you are warned) but it really does force you to look at things through a new pair of eyes. We need that fresh sight, otherwise we will have no insight into what people are actually meaning when they talk about discrimination and persecution. For kids who have experiences similar to those shown in the video, it doesn't matter so much that a gay person has a talk show on TV, it matters that there is nowhere they feel truly welcome.

 

It's one thing for orthodox Catholics to believe that marriage must be open to creating new life. It's quite another for us to try and minimise and belittle other people's experiences of discrimination in order to strengthen that point.

Edited by beatitude
PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

I think this sums up pretty much all that needs to be said (except possibly for the fact that was deceitful of Franciscanheart not to let us know that she is the CEO of a company with her own TV show ;) ).

 

On a serious note, the insinuation that 'gays' are really very powerful and capable of bullying governments into doing exactly what they want is an insinuation that accompanies pretty much every sort of prejudice against minority groups. Yes, some gay people are very successful. It's easy enough to come out if you're a sporting celebrity (as happened with a British athlete at the Winter Olympics) or a Hollywood star who already has a large following and plentiful income. It's not so easy if you're just some high school kid who's worried about bullies or his family not wanting to know him any more. Discriminatory laws don't really affect celebrities (of which 'out' gay people constitute a minority anyway - it's not as if they have this monopoly on TV and high finance). They affect ordinary people on the street.

 

Straight people are not persecuted. My religious freedoms as a Catholic are not compromised in any way simply because gay couples want to access the same public services as I do. I don't need a gay couple to be turned away from a restaurant or a hotel in order to be secure in my faith. But for my faith to matter, I have to take the part of the above-mentioned high school kid, because too many kids in that situation do, as Al has said, attempt to take their own lives. I don't think it's such a radical idea that there is a correlation between living in the kind of world where people see it as perfectly legitimate to sit around debating whether or not you're entitled to receive service in a cafe and feeling that maybe you'd rather be dead than live in a world like that.

 

A while ago a very dear friend (who is lesbian, and an ex-Catholic, and who has attempted suicide twice) showed me this video, which she was very moved by. Even though she's British, so the cultural milieu she grew up in was different. she said the video still depicted her childhood and teenage experiences better than she could explain them to me in words. It does not make easy watching (there is a suicide-attempt scene in there, just so you are warned) but it really does force you to look at things through a new pair of eyes. We need that fresh sight, otherwise we will have no insight into what people are actually meaning when they talk about discrimination and persecution. For kids who have experiences similar to those shown in the video, it doesn't matter so much that a gay person has a talk show on TV, it matters that there is nowhere they feel truly welcome.

 

It's one thing for orthodox Catholics to believe that marriage must be open to creating new life. It's quite another for us to try and minimise and belittle other people's experiences of discrimination in order to strengthen that point.

 

My only complaint about that amazing video is they called the play "Romeo and Julio", rather than something more historically accurate like Julius or Julian.

 

With that out of the way now, I've seen that video before, but it struck me more this time for some reason. The way gay people are bullied is simply unconscionable.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Lilllabettt
Posted

My religious freedoms as a Catholic are not compromised in any way simply because gay couples want to access the same public services as I do.

 

I guess you have not been asked to suffer yet. Good for you? Or bad for you - because it is a privilege. But nevermind. You will probably have the opportunity in the future.

Posted

I guess you have not been asked to suffer yet. Good for you? Or bad for you - because it is a privilege. But nevermind. You will probably have the opportunity in the future.



What a crock of shit
Lilllabettt
Posted (edited)

i'll send you a bill, my snazzy gay friend

Edited by Lilllabettt
Posted

What even is this thread

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...