Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Not The Philosopher
Posted

What even is this thread

 

It's kind of a thing

Posted (edited)

There's really no way to respond to all the posts without spending all evening, so just to be clear...

 

I have trouble acknowledging the idea of any secular "victimhood" of gays in the USA while they are trying to put Christians in jail for not wanting to photograph their weddings or make them wedding cakes - and while they are trying to block laws that would protect Christians from this type of prosecution. 

 

Certainly where I live it would be more dangerous and damaging to one's secular career and social standing to come out as a conservative Catholic than as an active homosexual, so it should be kept in mind that discrimination in this sense is relative.

 

Now from a Catholic perspective... Is same-sex attraction a difficult cross to bear?  I don't know personally, but I would imagine that it certainly is.  Yet everyone has their unique crosses to bear and our sanctity comes not through wallowing in these - our temptations, sins, and burdens - but in embracing the freedom offered by Christ. 

 

So while I'm certainly sympathetic, rather than affirming the cross, I'd prefer to affirm Christ so all know that He is an option for all our varying troubles.  As I mentioned in my first post on this thread, rather than dividing us up based on our various crosses, my gay catholic friends and I and so many other good Catholics can at least be united in our common goals of chastity and sanctity.   

Edited by NotreDame
Fidei Defensor
Posted

I'm attracted to other men and it's not a cross to bear. Why? Because I don't believe love between human beings is wrong.

Posted

I'm attracted to other men and it's not a cross to bear. Why? Because I don't believe love between human beings is wrong.

 

I'm not trying to pick on you but I hate when people say this. I'm not against love between any pair or group of people I just don't think it's appropriate to express that love seckshually within most contexts.

 

For example, I'm against incest even between two consenting adults, and against polygyny between 3 or more consenting adults. Especially with the latter I think its possible that the people in the party may love each other and care a great deal about each other (as homosexuals are capable of sacrificial love as well).

 

Do you agree that there are relationships wherein sexual expression is wrong?

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I'm not trying to pick on you but I hate when people say this. I'm not against love between any pair or group of people I just don't think it's appropriate to express that love seckshually within most contexts.

 

For example, I'm against incest even between two consenting adults, and against polygyny between 3 or more consenting adults. Especially with the latter I think its possible that the people in the party may love each other and care a great deal about each other (as homosexuals are capable of sacrificial love as well).

 

Do you agree that there are relationships wherein sexual expression is wrong?

 

Sadly, this is the first thing that's always brought up when love is mentioned. 

 

I believe two consenting adults have the right to express their love however they should choose, sexually or otherwise.

Lilllabettt
Posted

why 2 consenting adults and not 3?

Posted

Sadly, this is the first thing that's always brought up when love is mentioned. 

 

I believe two consenting adults have the right to express their love however they should choose, sexually or otherwise.

 

I'm not surprised it's the first thing, because religious folk are supposed to be fans of this whole "love" thing, even if we're poor at putting it into practice, so the accusation that we must be somehow against love engages our defenses.

 

Whether or not they should have the right, do you mean to say if some adult man tells you he's in a facebook official relationship with his uncle you're gonna think that's just sweet?

Posted

To confuse the sexual act with love is one of the most common errors of our day.

Posted

I'm not surprised it's the first thing, because religious folk are supposed to be fans of this whole "love" thing, even if we're poor at putting it into practice, so the accusation that we must be somehow against love engages our defenses.

Whether or not they should have the right, do you mean to say if some adult man tells you he's in a facebook official relationship with his uncle you're gonna think that's just sweet?


Why do you care?
Fidei Defensor
Posted

why 2 consenting adults and not 3?

 

Because I don't believe that every issue has to be turned into a slippery slope.  Two consenting adults is common sense.

 

To confuse the sexual act with love is one of the most common errors of our day.

 

Sexual acts are one facet of love.

 

I'm not surprised it's the first thing, because religious folk are supposed to be fans of this whole "love" thing, even if we're poor at putting it into practice, so the accusation that we must be somehow against love engages our defenses.

 

Whether or not they should have the right, do you mean to say if some adult man tells you he's in a facebook official relationship with his uncle you're gonna think that's just sweet?

 

What two consenting adults choose to do is not my business; my personal opinion has no place.

Posted

Let three people marry. Why does it matter to you?

Posted

Why do you care?

 

 

Honest question? Because I believe in the gospel and I desire the salvation of all peoples. i.e. because my imaginary sky daddy says so or one of your other one-liners.

 

 Two consenting adults is common sense.

 

 

No it's not. No one gets to play the common sense card anymore

Posted
What two consenting adults choose to do is not my business; my personal opinion has no place.

 

I'm asking how you would feel if someone close to you was in a polygamous or incestuous situation how you would feel about it. Because how we feel about things matters even if our feelings are not logical and/or contradict how we believe things should work.

 

If you don't want to answer that question than don't.

Posted

Why does every conversation on homosexuality here have to devolve into arguments about gay marriage and discrimination? 

 

If everybody here on this catholic board really believes what they are so fond and eager to point out - that only homosexual acts, not SSA by itself, are sinful - then the charitable thing would be to spend a lot more time talking about the challenges of chastity...

 

Unfortunately the only people that want to talk about that are the consecrated virgins... Too bad I've slow-danced one too many times and watched one-too-many romantic comedies to play any part in those threads.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

Honest question? Because I believe in the gospel and I desire the salvation of all peoples. i.e. because my imaginary sky daddy says so or one of your other one-liners.

 

 

No it's not. No one gets to play the common sense card anymore

 

Quite honestly, I don't care what any number of consenting adults do with one another. I choose to view marriage as a contract between two consenting adults, but I guess that's just me.  Of course, I also don't think marriage has to involve selling my offspring, so I must be modern.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I'm asking how you would feel if someone close to you was in a polygamous or incestuous situation how you would feel about it. Because how we feel about things matters even if our feelings are not logical and/or contradict how we believe things should work.

 

If you don't want to answer that question than don't.

 

I wouldn't give a damn because it's not my business.

Posted

I wouldn't give a beaver dam because it's not my business.

 

Fair enough. I don't by into individualism that hard.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

The whole idea that marriage is a sacred institution that needs protecting makes no sense. Protection from what?

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

The whole idea that marriage is a sacred institution that needs protecting makes no sense. Protection from what?

 

From dirty, cordial non-Catholics from Texas like you.

Edited by FuturePriest387
The Bus Station
Posted
Now from a Catholic perspective... Is same-sex attraction a difficult cross to bear?  I don't know personally, but I would imagine that it certainly is.  Yet everyone has their unique crosses to bear and our sanctity comes not through wallowing in these - our temptations, sins, and burdens - but in embracing the freedom offered by Christ. 

 

So while I'm certainly sympathetic, rather than affirming the cross, I'd prefer to affirm Christ so all know that He is an option for all our varying troubles.  As I mentioned in my first post on this thread, rather than dividing us up based on our various crosses, my gay catholic friends and I and so many other good Catholics can at least be united in our common goals of chastity and sanctity.   

 

Well said, ND.  This is why I don't get too involved in serious discussion about homosexuality on here.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...