Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Pope Francis is cool.

 

I like that he smiles a lot. 

Posted

i hope you understand also the many bad things capitalism has done and the many people it has hurt. Capitalism is not all flowers and unicorns. the pope has valid points.


Name one that is particularly valid.


And the more I think about it the more I wonder how anyone could take something from a corpse. Not that I think it's a huge sin--just a very weird thing to do. I wish I didn't know about it. I don't think it's necessarily a good thing to reveal and discuss secret sins. I wonder how many rosaries will be filched from corpses in the future because of this example.
Posted

I'm not even sure if the question is really pertinent to your faith or devotion to the Church. Or maybe it is? 

 

It would be sort of awkward to ask if you like >insert any random Catholic<. Maybe you do. Maybe you don't. It shouldn't really change the way you treat them or, ideally, think about them. I think it would apply to the Pope even more, based on him traditionally having even greater authority and weight of custom. What's more important is recognizing his authority, and loving him as a brother in Christ. 

 

If something really irks you, why not take it in stride with patience. 

 

My two cents. :) 

havok579257
Posted

Name one that is particularly valid.


And the more I think about it the more I wonder how anyone could take something from a corpse. Not that I think it's a huge sin--just a very weird thing to do. I wish I didn't know about it. I don't think it's necessarily a good thing to reveal and discuss secret sins. I wonder how many rosaries will be filched from corpses in the future because of this example.

 

 

i am not derailing this thread by showing you capitalism is not without any faults.  there are topics in the debate table for that.  also if your convinced capitalism is a utopian form of government, then nothing anyone says will change your mind.

 

also your going overboard about the rosary thing.  you now think people are going to model a sin the pope commited.  if thats the case you must believe all catholics will support gay marriage, birth control, woman priests and so on because the news media tells us the pope supports such things.  your obviously have a real problem with the pope and anything he does wrong  like admitting past sins, your going to blow way out of peportion,  you need to pray on this.  we all as catholics should love and support all our popes.  no matter if they are more like Benedict or more like Francis.  

Posted

I don't hate him. He just doesn't sit well with me. I respect his office and love him as a Christian brother. But I don't think I have to like him. I'm keeping my mind open however and I hope he opens his mind to a having a more sophisticated understanding of economic principles.

I haven't equated capitalism with utopia. You said he had valid points against capitalism and I'd like to know what one would be. If I start a thread about it will you contribute?

Posted

No Catholic has to "like" the pope. Being pope is not a popularity contest. We do have to respect him as being the Holy Spirit's choice to lead the Church. And we have to pray for him. I suggest that the less you like him, the more you pray for him. 

 

As to critiques of capitalism, this is not the first pope to speak up. The last several have. I inaccurately recall a comment by (I believe) John Paul II to the effect that "capitalism without conscience is insert-negative-adjective" - the negative adjective was something like "unconscionable," but that's not the word the pope used. Capitalism is - at least theoretically - driven by greed. One of the main critiques is that capitalism is a dog-eat-dog competition that preys on the weaker dogs, so the rich get richer while the poor get poorer. No amount of profit is enough, corporations drive down workers' wages while increasing productivity, union busting, massive layoffs of workers while executives are rewarded for manipulating stock prices - all you have to do is read the newspaper or listen to the news. You can also watch movies - what was that movie starring Michael Douglas, playing Gordon Gecko the Wall Street executive, whose most famous line was "Greed is good"? Or listen to country music - any songs that deals with coal mines.

 

If you were looking for specifics, there are some starter ideas.  

Posted

I pity the fool who treads on the path of banning

blazeingstar
Posted

About the stolen cross, it seems that he did so in a mixture of empathy and grief for the man that meant so much to him, but had not received a single flower.  He ran out and got him a dozen roses and then, still distresed at the state of him took the cross.

 

Was it the best decision? No, but I think he legitimately feared that the good works of this man would be forgotten and wanted to keep something to ensure that he shared what he was taught. 

 

I think we can chalk it up to a very real move of grief and fear....how many of you would be saddened if you saw your mentor laid out, but no one had given them flowers or much honor, even though they were supposedly "well loved"? 

maximillion
Posted

Don't know him well enough to say if I like him or not........

 

I like some of the stuff he has said and I like that he seems to want a more simple life-style.

 

He certainly has caught the attention of the people, even non-Catholics are talking about him in a quite positive way - well, the ones round here are any way.

Posted

I put faith in no living man but Christ and that way I'm never disappointed. 

 

However, my guess is that it's not the Pope that bothers you so much, but the people that use him as an instrument to support their agenda.  There you have my sympathies. 

 

To discuss it further, I agree with Arfink that starting something in the debate table makes more sense... but please, wait until after lent.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

I think a big part of the reason why we all feel like we have to love the pope is that a sort of cult of personality has built up around the pope, starting with John XXIII, but really solidified with John Paul II.  And who can blame us - JPII was incredibly charismatic, and a pope for a long, long time. I remember a TON of "JPII WE LOVE YOU" stuff when I was in youth group, and a lot of us who grew up with a lot of "I LOVE THE POPE SO HARD" culture are now adults and have now dealt with at least one pope who kind of rubbed us a weird way, whether it be Benedict or Francis. Even if you didn't personally grow up with it, or are a convert, it's still in the water. The cult of personality isn't necessarily a bad thing at all, it's neutral. But moving away from the cult of personality isn't easy. 

Posted

JPII was incredibly charismatic, and a pope for a long, long time. I remember a TON of "JPII WE LOVE YOU" 

 

Yup. In summer bible school we sand a song called "JPII We love you"

havok579257
Posted

I don't hate him. He just doesn't sit well with me. I respect his office and love him as a Christian brother. But I don't think I have to like him. I'm keeping my mind open however and I hope he opens his mind to a having a more sophisticated understanding of economic principles.

I haven't equated capitalism with utopia. You said he had valid points against capitalism and I'd like to know what one would be. If I start a thread about it will you contribute?

 

if you start a topic in debate i will contribute.  

u have a beef 

just remeber like someone else mentioned, pope Francis is far from the first pope to criticism capitalism.  if you have a beef with Francis over his comments, you must also have issues with other recent popes and what they said about capitalism.  Do you have issues with other popes?  If not, then maybe its not the popes comments you have an issue with but just anything Francis says bothers you for some reason.  Just a possiblity maybe.

Posted

if you start a topic in debate i will contribute.  

u have a beef 

just remeber like someone else mentioned, pope Francis is far from the first pope to criticism capitalism.  if you have a beef with Francis over his comments, you must also have issues with other recent popes and what they said about capitalism.  Do you have issues with other popes?  If not, then maybe its not the popes comments you have an issue with but just anything Francis says bothers you for some reason.  Just a possiblity maybe.

 

Pliny, if posts like this make you want to talk about the capitalism thing, just go to the whole "I cringe when..." thread again.  There's some unfinished business there anyway.  Pleeeease don't start another thread on the subject.
 

Posted

About this pope...  I don't like the fact that his humility is so incredibly ostentatious that everyone is talking about it and running magazine covers proclaiming it.  It leaves me a little uneasy, like when movie stars adopt kids from Africa... Just not sure the intentions.

 

I also don't like the fact that people are liking him for all the wrong reasons.  You can look through the following research:

 

http://www.pewforum.org/2014/03/06/catholics-view-pope-francis-as-a-change-for-the-better/

 

At a high level it's saying that people are happier about the Pope, but that's primarily because they think he'll change church teaching.  He has not increased the number identifying as Catholic, frequency of mass or confession one bit - if anything mass or confession have dipped:

 

pope-francis-one-year-9.png

pope-francis-one-year-10.png

Posted

About this pope...  I don't like the fact that his humility is so incredibly ostentatious that everyone is talking about it and running magazine covers proclaiming it.  

 

Is that his fault? Im not sure the Pope can control who the media and people react to him or what they do and dont run in their magazines.

Posted

We all handle grief differently. When my Dad was in his coffin, I placed a stack of old cards in his suit coat. When digging out stuff to take to the mortuary, I found in his bottom sock drawer every Father's Day or thanksgiving, etc. card I had ever given him. I thought that he'd kept them for 20 years so he might want to keep them forever.

Then I spent the next several weeks sleeping on a deserted beach. Do you really think this priest would care that his rosary cross was taken? I kept my Dad's rosary. It didn't even make it to his casket.

Posted

Is that his fault? Im not sure the Pope can control who the media and people react to him or what they do and dont run in their magazines.

If you remember, he did a lot of things to separate himself from the office that were quite obvious and viewed as being humble, when the net effect was the opposite.  

 

The biggest act of humility is to willingly give up power.  Christ did it in becoming man.  To an infinitely lesser extent, Benedict did it by resigning as Pope.  There are very, very, very few remaining examples.

 

But wear black shoes and choose a private apartment (after lobbying for the position)?  Wow!  So humble! 

Ancilla Domini
Posted

The biggest act of humility is to willingly give up power.  Christ did it in becoming man.  To an infinitely lesser extent, Benedict did it by resigning as Pope.  There are very, very, very few remaining examples.

 

But wear black shoes and choose a private apartment (after lobbying for the position)?  Wow!  So humble! 

 

Another pope (I believe it was Pius XII but the name escapes me at the moment) lived in the papal palace, but slept on the floor. This, I believe, is a more humble action than refusing to live in the papal palace and having a simple private apartment.

havok579257
Posted

If you remember, he did a lot of things to separate himself from the office that were quite obvious and viewed as being humble, when the net effect was the opposite.  

 

The biggest act of humility is to willingly give up power.  Christ did it in becoming man.  To an infinitely lesser extent, Benedict did it by resigning as Pope.  There are very, very, very few remaining examples.

 

But wear black shoes and choose a private apartment (after lobbying for the position)?  Wow!  So humble! 

 

i think this is completely unfair.  So now people get upset because the pope is to humble.  Having a humble pope is no a bad thing.  To imply he is not being altruistic in his humbleness is absolutely wrong on your part unless you have evidence.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...