Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

havok579257
Posted

Another pope (I believe it was Pius XII but the name escapes me at the moment) lived in the papal palace, but slept on the floor. This, I believe, is a more humble action than refusing to live in the papal palace and having a simple private apartment.

 

 

more humble in your opinion but not everyone else's.  

Posted

Are we really having a humble contest?

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I live in a crappy apartment. I am clearly the most humble.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Another pope (I believe it was Pius XII but the name escapes me at the moment) lived in the papal palace, but slept on the floor. This, I believe, is a more humble action than refusing to live in the papal palace and having a simple private apartment.

 

So now we get to judge what's truly humble or more humble?

 

I like Pope Francis. He sometimes says incredibly regrettable things and does something I can't defend (Like writing a foreword in a pro-liberation theology book), but I think he's a genuinely good person who is very humble. I don't think he's quite used to being the Pope yet, and I think soon enough he'll straighten out and hopefully not do or say regrettable things (Think telling the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate that they can no longer say the Latin Mass. Huge no-no for me). If he doesn't, the Church will live. If we can survive Popes like Borgia. we can survive a humble man who I believe is honestly doing everything in his power for the good of the Church. Do I agree with everything he is doing? No. Do I think telling a huge community that they can no longer say the Latin Mass was a good thing? No (I'm a Novus Ordo man, for the record). But I'm not the Pope. Unless he says something blatantly heretical like stating Jesus was a woman, it's not for me to judge his actions and statements, because I've never done and hopefully will never do his job.

 

One thing I completely agree with him on is his critique of capitalism. People in America preach capitalism like it's a religion, and they're offended by the suggestion that it's not perfect and easily corruptible. But to each his own about that.

 

In all, he's a very good man. I don't agree with everything he says and does, but I still love him, and you'd better believe I would be jumping up down and screaming like a schoolgirl if I was about to meet him.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Not The Philosopher
Posted

I live in a crappy apartment. I am clearly the most humble.

 

I live in my dad's basement.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I live in my dad's basement.

 


Sub-Zero_Fatality_MK2.png

KnightofChrist
Posted

I live in a van down by the river, eating a steady diet of government cheese, rolling doobies and I am a Motivational Speaker!

Posted

I live in a van down by the river, eating a steady diet of government cheese, rolling doobies and I am a Motivational Speaker!

 

Role model

Posted

Are we really having a humble contest?

 

It's not a contest, the comparison was simply for contrast to help illustrate what sacrifice and humility really are. 

 

Doing something that's not a real sacrifice and doing it ostentatiously is by definition not humble.  That doesn't make it bad.  It just means it's not humble. 

 

However, since we are in a world bereft of sacrifice, most don't know it when they see it.

Posted

I think this is a lot of opinion. Its ok to just not like someone. But I dont think you can really quantify personal taste to where you start saying that one is better than the other.

 

Its good if you like it.

Posted

I think this is a lot of opinion. Its ok to just not like someone. But I dont think you can really quantify personal taste to where you start saying that one is better than the other.

 

Its good if you like it.

Everything is opinion.  It's good if you like it.  lolz...

Posted

Everything is opinion.  It's good if you like it.  lolz...

 

No, not everything is opinion. But when it comes to whether or not we think a person is humble or not...that is opinion. 

 

First of all, none of us actually live with the Pope, we are just as much subject to media portrayals as anyone else. 

 

If you dont like the Pope, thats your choice and thats fine. But dont sit here and tell the rest of us that your version of humble is what is lagging in the current pope. I dont find that he has a lack of humility.

Posted

No, not everything is opinion. But when it comes to whether or not we think a person is humble or not...that is opinion. 

Well, If you read my posts you'll see I've been trying to focus on actions.  I can't judge any man or his intent, but certainly his actions taken at face value - as I've described - are more ostentatious than humble.

Posted (edited)

Well, If you read my posts you'll see I've been trying to focus on actions.  I can't judge any man or his intent, but certainly his actions taken at face value - as I've described - are more ostentatious than humble.

 

You've only seen the actions that are hair picked by the  media. I dont think you have a good enough idea to claim to have an all knowing stance on the issue. If you want to make a personal choice to dislike this pope, then whatevs. But dont talk like you have all the answers.

 

And actions can still be interpreting through a personal lens thus those conclusions can also be opinion. 

Edited by CrossCuT

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...