Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

I think there's a problem with children eating at Mass, in the pews, during Mass. But I am clearly in the minority, so...

 

Pope Francis is a very holy man. Most men aren't. I just wonder if knowing there's a breast exposed near them would distract them from what they're supposed to be doing at Mass. If not: No problem.

 

Will there be a pervert or two staring at you? Sometimes, probably. But in that case, no girl should ever wear a swimsuit, skirt, or anything that exposes any skin whatsoever. If perverts are going to sexualize bags of fat that feed children, there's nothing they're not going to sexualize, and you can't and shouldn't try to avoid it.

Archaeology cat
Posted

It's often more obvious what you're doing when you use a cover. I'd end up unintentionally flashing someone if I used a cover, because Leo hates being covered.

Posted

But if it is an infant, would you deny it food?

 

Why would feeding a baby distract anyone unless the baby was making a fuss?

 

Some people are easily distracted.

 

It's not about denying the baby food. It's about where the baby should be fed. I don't think anyone would argue you just shouldn't feed the kid. I'm wondering if anyone feels it'd be better if the child were fed in the narthex/cry room/wherever.

PhuturePriest
Posted

It's often more obvious what you're doing when you use a cover. I'd end up unintentionally flashing someone if I used a cover, because Leo hates being covered.

 

My sister breastfeeds her baby, and unless I'm talking to her and looking at her, I never even notice, even if I'm sitting right next to her.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Some people are easily distracted.

 

It's not about denying the baby food. It's about where the baby should be fed. I don't think anyone would argue you just shouldn't feed the kid. I'm wondering if anyone feels it'd be better if the child were fed in the narthex/cry room/wherever.

 

Short answer: no.

Posted

Will there be a pervert or two staring at you? Sometimes, probably. But in that case, no girl should ever wear a swimsuit, skirt, or anything that exposes any skin whatsoever. If perverts are going to sexualize bags of fat that feed children, there's nothing they're not going to sexualize, and you can't and shouldn't try to avoid it.

 

One doesn't have to be a pervert to be distracted by exposed breasts, or even the knowledge that there's an exposed breast under a cover. And I doubt you'd suggest we should start wearing swimsuits, (short?) skirts, or much-skin-exposing clothing at Mass.

 

Context, FP: It matters.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Some people are easily distracted.

 

It's not about denying the baby food. It's about where the baby should be fed. I don't think anyone would argue you just shouldn't feed the kid. I'm wondering if anyone feels it'd be better if the child were fed in the narthex/cry room/wherever.

 

If some people are easily distracted/are perverts, that's their issue, not the mother's or the child's. There's nothing wrong with breastfeeding at Mass, even in the pew, and even with no cover on.

 

As an aside, my sister says in the past year I've become an ardent and outspoken lactavist. :P

Edited by FuturePriest387
PhuturePriest
Posted

One doesn't have to be a pervert to be distracted by exposed breasts, or even the knowledge that there's an exposed breast under a cover. And I doubt you'd suggest we should start wearing swimsuits, (short?) skirts, or much-skin-exposing clothing at Mass.

 

Context, FP: It matters.

 

When did I ever say we should wear swimming suits to Mass? No, we shouldn't. But I also think we shouldn't wear jeans to Mass, either, and they're completely modest.

 

Again: if exposed breasts distract you, then that's unfortunately your issue. You can't expect a mother to get up and leave the church and miss parts of the Mass simply because some people have issues paying attention.

Archaeology cat
Posted

We need more male lactivists, FP. :)

PhuturePriest
Posted

We need more male lactivists, FP. :)

 

I'm proud to be one! :) The only issue is people assume I'm a lactavist because I want to see women's breasts, but oh well. :P

Posted

My friend has breastfed in front of me when I visit. She does use a cover, but if she didn't I wouldn't care. 

Archaeology cat
Posted

Can't say I ever assumed that

PhuturePriest
Posted

 

Can't say I ever assumed that

 

Not you in particular, but other people who aren't lactavists automatically assume male lactavists are lactavists because they like breasts.

 

It is odd, because all of the men completely obsessed with breasts that I've known/seen are some of the most ardent anti-breastfeeding in public group. I think it's because they associate breasts with sex rather than their actual purpose, so they see it like a woman taking her pants off.

Posted (edited)

Ha. I could go on a side rant about how women's bodies have been so sexualized and objectified  that men can go topless and women cannot in our culture, and the littlest bit of skin might make a man "stumble" buuuuuuut I'll just go sit over here. 

Edited by Selah
PhuturePriest
Posted

Ha. I could go on a side rant about how women's bodies have been so sexualized and objectified  that men can go topless and women cannot in our culture, and the littlest bit of skin might make a man "stumble" buuuuuuut I'll just go sit over here. 

 

Well, rest assured that there's at least one male lactavist in North America who doesn't care how you choose to breastfeed. :P

Archaeology cat
Posted

Not you in particular, but other people who aren't lactavists automatically assume male lactavists are lactavists because they like breasts.
 
It is odd, because all of the men completely obsessed with breasts that I've known/seen are some of the most ardent anti-breastfeeding in public group. I think it's because they associate breasts with sex rather than their actual purpose, so they see it like a woman taking her pantaloons off.

unfortunately true.

Something I've noticed about children in mass in General (and breastfeeding in particular) is that the child is expected to change to make the adults comfortable. Shouldn't the adults be mature enough to accept young children and their needs?
PhuturePriest
Posted

unfortunately true.

Something I've noticed about children in mass in General (and breastfeeding in particular) is that the child is expected to change to make the adults comfortable. Shouldn't the adults be mature enough to accept young children and their needs?

 

I have never thought about it that way before, but that is a very profound observation. Why do adults feel kids should conform to keep themselves comfortable, especially younger kids and babies? It makes no logical sense when you think about it. 

Archaeology cat
Posted

Obviously we teach our kids how to act at Mass, but I always expect age appropriate things. I mean, Leo climbs up the pew and says "hiya!" To the priest and blows kisses. He's just a wee thing, though, and obviously Kieran (6) doesn't still do things like that.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Obviously we teach our kids how to act at Mass, but I always expect age appropriate things. I mean, Leo climbs up the pew and says "hiya!" To the priest and blows kisses. He's just a wee thing, though, and obviously Kieran (6) doesn't still do things like that.

 

If/when I'm a priest one day, if that happens to me, I'm going to laugh hysterically. Although a child doing that would scandalize a lot of people I know, I don't think it would bother me very much. :P

Posted

If some people are easily distracted/are perverts, that's their issue, not the mother's or the child's.

 

I hear this phrase "that's their problem" a lot on Phatmass. Like anyone ever getting distracted by another person at Mass is responsible for not having a stronger mind, like the person making a scene (I'm not talking about breastfeeding here) or making noise has zero responsibility to be considerate to others around him/her. That's really rude and selfish, I think.

 

The reason I found the breastfeeding mother kind of surprising is because it always rather surprises me when people do anything at Mass but pray. That's what Mass is for. And I'm of the opinion that churches are supposed to be quiet places, so when the whole parish starts chatting loudly after Mass, I'd say it's not some poor distracted person's fault for getting distracted: The people making noise in church are to blame.

 

What this all really boils down to is this, I think: What responsibility do we have to others for ensuring they can pray in a reverent and silent environment at church? And at what point does the responsibility to accommodate someone making a scene/noise fall on the distractable person, because the scene-making/noisy person's need is greater than theirs? (I can see breastfeeding falling into the latter camp, though I do think maybe a nice compromise would be covering oneself up or going to the narthex/cry room, at least in a parish where people aren't comfortable with breastfeeding at Mass.)

 

I don't think the line of responsibility for such things is clearly drawn in most parishes, and I think that causes a lot of frustration and anger between camps who view Mass and church differently. Some treat church as a gathering place (the after-Mass chatters), whereas others treat the church strictly as a place of prayer (the after-Mass pray-ers who insist upon going outside to chat). Some treat Mass as just any other place where physical needs should never be denied or postponed or removed (like maybe breastfeeders or parents who give their kids cheerios to eat in the pews), whereas others treat Mass as a unique place and time to focus solely on spiritual things (like people who think physical needs at Mass should be handled elsewhere). Whatever the different views of Mass and church that underlie disagreements about how we ought to behave in church, I think they ought to be explicitly discussed in parishes so that parishioners can reach an agreement (and maybe a compromise) on how people will behave at church in their parish, for the sake of peace. Otherwise those of a minority opinion are likely to feel rudely treated, and foment ill will or, worse yet, leave.

 

That's a broader issue, of course, but I can see breastfeeding being one specific instance of where such disagreements might arise. So what I'm trying to do here is figure out where that line of responsibility/consideration is on the breastfeeding issue. And it seems most people don't think breastfeeding counts as making a scene or being distracting. I wonder, though, if a minority of people who do find this distracting would feel there's a "tyranny of the majority" effect going on in their parishes.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...