southern california guy Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 Do you have a problem with someone urinating in public? I think that the two are drastically different things..
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 To compare feeding a child with urinating is kind of ridiculous. Im just trying to make a connection to what Im saying is all. I believe women should be able to breastfeed where ever they want. Covered/uncovered i dont care. But at the same time, I have found myself feeling uncomfortable upon seeing an uncovered breast. Thats all Im saying. What I dont agree with is that I am somehow a horny man for being uncomfortable? Im trying to understand why you guys seem to be extremely judgmental on anyone who might have the smallest inclination of discomfort in that situation. Obviously the purpose of breastfeeding is not indented for sexual arousal. Neither is urination. But both are biologically necessary and neither are meant for arousal.
PhuturePriest Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 Im just trying to make a connection to what Im saying is all. I believe women should be able to breastfeed where ever they want. Covered/uncovered i dont care. But at the same time, I have found myself feeling uncomfortable upon seeing an uncovered breast. Thats all Im saying. What I dont agree with is that I am somehow a horny man for being uncomfortable? Im trying to understand why you guys seem to be extremely judgmental on anyone who might have the smallest inclination of discomfort in that situation. Obviously the purpose of breastfeeding is not indented for sexual arousal. Neither is urination. But both are biologically necessary and neither are meant for arousal. I understand that it makes you and others uncomfortable. But seeing as how you admit it's fine for women to breastfeed with or without a cover in public, I don't see what else you expect me or anyone else to say other than "Well, I guess that sucks." The more you're around something, the more comfortable it is for you. The more breastfeeding that goes on in public, the less weird it will be. The only way to solve this whole taboo with breastfeeding is to allow it to happen. So, I guess you and others who are unfortunately uncomfortable with it are just going to have to play through the pain until it's no longer an issue for you.
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 I think that the two are drastically different things.. I think its different only because you want it to be different. Both are biologically necessary and both require the use of body parts that are considered sexual therefore people are find it inappropriate when they are used, even in non sexual ways, in public. Why should a man care that people look at him all horny when he pees in public? You have to pee! Its biologically necessary! Why should he care what other people think? He isnt trying to be rude or arouse all the horny women. I understand that it makes you and others uncomfortable. But seeing as how you admit it's fine for women to breastfeed with or without a cover in public, I don't see what else you expect me or anyone else to say other than "Well, I guess that smells of elderberries." The more you're around something, the more comfortable it is for you. The more breastfeeding that goes on in public, the less weird it will be. The only way to solve this whole taboo with breastfeeding is to allow it to happen. So, I guess you and others who are unfortunately uncomfortable with it are just going to have to play through the pain until it's no longer an issue for you. You havent been reading what Ive said very carefully. Im uncomfortable seeing boobs pop out. For me its a modestly thing I guess.
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 Nevermind, I retract the urination example. I was discussing it with my bf and he made a good point...no other person is depending on your urination.
PhuturePriest Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 I think its different only because you want it to be different. Both are biologically necessary and both require the use of body parts that are considered sexual therefore people are find it inappropriate when they are used, even in non sexual ways, in public. Why should a man care that people look at him all horny when he pees in public? You have to pee! Its biologically necessary! Why should he care what other people think? He isnt trying to be rude or arouse all the horny women. You havent been reading what Ive said very carefully. Im uncomfortable seeing boobs pop out. For me its a modestly thing I guess. I'm aware that's why you're uncomfortable. I'm sorry it is. Life sucks sometimes, I guess. I don't know what you want me to say. It's a necessary thing, and many babies are freaked out by covers. You can't expect a mother to go into hiding when feeding her babies because her babies are freaked out by covers and people are freaked out by seeing her boobs.
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 I'm aware that's why you're uncomfortable. I'm sorry it is. Life smells of elderberries sometimes, I guess. I don't know what you want me to say. It's a necessary thing, and many babies are freaked out by covers. You can't expect a mother to go into hiding when feeding her babies because her babies are freaked out by covers and people are freaked out by seeing her boobs. Im not saying anyone should go into hiding, thats silly! I have no problem with any of it. If a boob gets flashed, it happens. If it makes me uncomfortable, Ill live. Im not asking anyone to change Im just saying it makes me uncomfortable and its not because Im a horny man. The only part of this conversation that I didnt like was that people were extremely uncaring of anyone else. While I agree that women shouldnt have to worry about that stuff, we have to realize that we live in a community with other people. And even if you think its totally fine you have to be aware of others. Just because you have the option of one path doesnt mean you have to talke it. If it would not be inconvenient for a mother to cover up or possibly breast feed in a discrete location, would it be a bad thing to have that as a viable option? I fully understand that sometimes it is unavoidable. Baby needs to eat! But in the event that a more private location is available, would it be wrong to expect a mother to utilize it? Or does that go against the "shut up its ok" rule?
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 it's just boobs. errrbody likes boobs. My family was visiting another family for the day and they had a newborn. The mother started breast feeding in the kitchen and didnt cover at all. She didnt even make the slightest attempt. It was her home and I am in NO WAY saying she cant AT ALL (she can breast feed in her own home....its ok.) (Did I mention Im not telling anyone where they can and cant breastfeed?) but I just remember being really shocked. It probably had more to do with the fact Im not used to it. My mother hasnt had babies to breast feed in a LONG time...and Im just not used to walking into a kitchen and seeing a boob. I think thats my problem. I just need to see more boobs.
PhuturePriest Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 Im not saying anyone should go into hiding, thats silly! I have no problem with any of it. If a boob gets flashed, it happens. If it makes me uncomfortable, Ill live. Im not asking anyone to change Im just saying it makes me uncomfortable and its not because Im a horny man. The only part of this conversation that I didnt like was that people were extremely uncaring of anyone else. While I agree that women shouldnt have to worry about that stuff, we have to realize that we live in a community with other people. And even if you think its totally fine you have to be aware of others. Just because you have the option of one path doesnt mean you have to talke it. If it would not be inconvenient for a mother to cover up or possibly breast feed in a discrete location, would it be a bad thing to have that as a viable option? I fully understand that sometimes it is unavoidable. Baby needs to eat! But in the event that a more private location is available, would it be wrong to expect a mother to utilize it? Or does that go against the "shut up its ok" rule? I think this is the main problem that everyone runs into when they aren't parents, and I say that not being a parent myself. :P But my sister has a baby, and I'm amazed at just how busy she always is taking care of him and doing everything for him. If a mother is more comfortable breastfeeding in private (Indeed, my cousin's wife doesn't like breastfeeding in public, even though she uses a cover), that's completely fine! But even if it is a viable option for every mother in a particular situation and place, I don't think expecting her to go and do it in private is good, because that's reaffirming the idea that breasts are sexual and should be kept private at every possible opportunity, and that breastfeeding is some secret shameful thing other people shouldn't have to suffer through being around.
Selah Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 Im not a man, so I dont think the "Im horny lulz" example applies here. And besides, thats incredibly sexist too. To assume the only problem men can have with it is that they are horny? *facepalm* That. Was. My. Point. And of course women should be modest. As should men. But really, if society held men to the same standards we hold women, my God but the bsing would not end. Do you not think it's incredibly sexist to think that the only thing a woman's body is good for is sex? Perhaps you do not think it, but in our culture, that idea exists. All one has to do is look at the entertainment industry.
Selah Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 But in all fairness, with that logic, you should be yelling at me for being a lactavist, because it's me having (very) strong beliefs about breastfeeding mothers. I'm a man (sort of) "getting involved", if you will, on the argument. So, are men not allowed to have opinions on breastfeeding, or are they allowed so long as they believe women can breastfeed wherever and however they want? Well, if "getting invlolved" means making women cover up so they don't "stumble" or making them breastfeed secluded, then...no, they don't get to have a say. But really that goes for women, too. If they get all horrified and try to stop a mother from breastfeeding, then they're pretty much in the same boat.
PhuturePriest Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 Well, if "getting invlolved" means making women cover up so they don't "stumble" or making them breastfeed secluded, then...no, they don't get to have a say. But really that goes for women, too. If they get all horrified and try to stop a mother from breastfeeding, then they're pretty much in the same boat. Okay. I just wanted to see what you meant specifically is all. "Getting involved" can either men simply having an opinion, or being very forceful and stopping people from breastfeeding in public.
Selah Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 Okay. I just wanted to see what you meant specifically is all. "Getting involved" can either men simply having an opinion, or being very forceful and stopping people from breastfeeding in public. 'sokay ^_^
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 (edited) I think at the end of the day, people dont have a lot of exposure to breast feeding moms so they are a little thrown off when they see it. People feel how they feel but at the end of the day the mother doesnt always have the choice of going somewhere more private for the sake of modesty. Baby has to eat when a baby has to eat. Edited March 25, 2014 by CrossCuT
Lil Red Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 I think at the end of the day, people dont have a lot of exposure to breast feeding moms so they are a little thrown off when they see it. I totally hear what you are saying. It's not as common place to have a lot of babies and kids around that are breastfeeding in the average American town, so it can be jarring to someone to see a mom breastfeeding.
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 I totally hear what you are saying. It's not as common place to have a lot of babies and kids around that are breastfeeding in the average American town, so it can be jarring to someone to see a mom breastfeeding. In my case, seeing a mom breastfeeding is pretty normal. I saw my mom breastfeed ALL THE TIME when I was growing up with 5 younger siblings. But even in our own home my mom covered herself. Its usually when I see a boob pop out is when im like "Oh snap, look away!" Mostly because I feel like the mom doesnt want me staring and her exposed chest! Like in the case when the mom was non-covered breast feeding in her kitchen while talking to me...her boob was exposed. I was like "Om.g dont look at the boob! Dont look at the boob! She will think Im rude if I stare at her boob that is hanging out of her shirt! AHHH"
Winchester Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 This is why the Jurassic Park scenario is our only hope. We're up to five pages because people have issues with feeding kids. "I'm really not sure about all this breathing going on IN MASS!"
Not The Philosopher Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 This is why the Jurassic Park scenario is our only hope. We're up to five pages because people have issues with feeding kids. "I'm really not sure about all this breathing going on IN MASS!" With the power of the internet we may soon have the technology to make such an experiment possible: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZlPoPMbiffU
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2014 Posted March 25, 2014 This is why the Jurassic Park scenario is our only hope. We're up to five pages because people have issues with feeding kids. "I'm really not sure about all this breathing going on IN MASS!" Totes. Im only prolife until the baby is born. Keep the baby at all costs but once it pops out Ill have nothing to do with it anymore. If it cant feed itself then too bad! I have a huge problem with feeding babies...like the biggest problem.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now