Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

In my defense, I was only uncomfortable when the WHOLE boob was saying hello.

 Thats the only time I have ever been uncomfortable. But its not enough for me to walk up and challenge the mother to a shouting match or tell her to leave.

 

 

Im more shocked that she is ok with her boob hanging free than the fact that I saw it.

 

:paperbag:

 

This may be TMI and really none of my business, but was she rather well endowed? In my experience women that are rather busty often seem to have a harder time getting their baby latched quickly and need to have more exposure to get situated (they generally fix their shirt or pull a blanket over once that's accomplished, but obviously not everyone does that otherwise this wouldn't be a discussion lol) I've had this happen around me, or been told that was what they had to do to make it work. I just avert my eyes until they are settled. I am very much accustomed to breastfeeding; I'm one of the oldest of 12 and my mom breastfed every last one of us (including tandem nursing twins---i know my exposure to this is NOT the norm). Even if they're not fully covered it doesn't weird me out (at least in private). That said, I still don't relish the idea of seeing someone's breast fully exposed. I feel like that is a very intimate thing, and even if they are comfortable enough with me to take those steps to feed their little one they deserve a bit of privacy while they get situated.

 

I mean, I get what you're saying, you get that weird "Uh, I can see your whole boob... where do I look" feeling. I just don't think most women nurse that way all the time.

southern california guy
Posted

I think that if you are going to allow a woman with babies into Mass, than you are going to be distracted by either a crying baby -- or a woman who is breastfeeding. I would personally choose the breastfeeding woman every time.

Even if some kid saw the womans breast so what? That is nothing bad. Everybody over the age of zero has seen a womans nipple. And if you incredibly have not -- the sight is not going to corrupt you. We could become as obsessive as the Muslims and require women to wear heavy garmets and veils over their faces.

I think that the truth is that "children" are becoming less acceptable. Especially large families -- with the mother taking care of the kids. Nowadays women are supposed to have careers and compete with men.

Posted

kid sees a breast? perfect time to desexualize breasts.

Posted

This may be TMI and really none of my business, but was she rather well endowed? In my experience women that are rather busty often seem to have a harder time getting their baby latched quickly and need to have more exposure to get situated (they generally fix their shirt or pull a blanket over once that's accomplished, but obviously not everyone does that otherwise this wouldn't be a discussion lol) I've had this happen around me, or been told that was what they had to do to make it work. I just avert my eyes until they are settled. I am very much accustomed to breastfeeding; I'm one of the oldest of 12 and my mom breastfed every last one of us (including tandem nursing twins---i know my exposure to this is NOT the norm). Even if they're not fully covered it doesn't weird me out (at least in private). That said, I still don't relish the idea of seeing someone's breast fully exposed. I feel like that is a very intimate thing, and even if they are comfortable enough with me to take those steps to feed their little one they deserve a bit of privacy while they get situated.

 

I mean, I get what you're saying, you get that weird "Uh, I can see your whole boob... where do I look" feeling. I just don't think most women nurse that way all the time.

 

Yes she was more well endowed.

 

And it was really only one time that I saw the whole boob...and I had the very reaction "Where do I look?" because I was having a conversation with her. I didnt want to let my feelings show on my face and I didnt want her to feel like I was sitting here watching her boob fall out of her shirt. It was just awkward. 

Posted

In my defense, I was only uncomfortable when the WHOLE boob was saying hello.

 Thats the only time I have ever been uncomfortable. But its not enough for me to walk up and challenge the mother to a shouting match or tell her to leave.

 

 

Im more shocked that she is ok with her boob hanging free than the fact that I saw it.

 

:paperbag:

 

yeah, I mean that is a little strange to me as well, but maybe her baby pulled off all of a sudden and she was waiting for her baby to go back to the boob? I don't know, obviously I wasn't there. But I'd rather give the mom the benefit of the doubt. 

Posted

yeah, I mean that is a little strange to me as well, but maybe her baby pulled off all of a sudden and she was waiting for her baby to go back to the boob? I don't know, obviously I wasn't there. But I'd rather give the mom the benefit of the doubt. 

 

Nah, she hadnt started yet but she opened up her shirt, did all the unhooking of various other clothing items and just let it hang there while she talked to me and got the baby situated. 

Posted

Yes she was more well endowed.

 

And it was really only one time that I saw the whole boob...and I had the very reaction "Where do I look?" because I was having a conversation with her. I didnt want to let my feelings show on my face and I didnt want her to feel like I was sitting here watching her boob fall out of her shirt. It was just awkward. 

 

when in doubt, look a nursing mom straight in the eye, only glancing left or right or up, but never down. :P then the awkwardness just starts again. :P

Posted

Nah, she hadnt started yet but she opened up her shirt, did all the unhooking of various other clothing items and just let it hang there while she talked to me and got the baby situated. 

 

aha, I understand. sometimes it's awkward for moms to get situated. :/ 

Posted

when in doubt, look a nursing mom straight in the eye, only glancing left or right or up, but never down. :P then the awkwardness just starts again. :P

 

Haha!

I will have more to contribute on this topic in maybe... 5+ years. I have no babies and no practical experience in the breast feeding department. I am just a dumb spectator. 

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

(including tandem nursing twins--

 

 

Major cool

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

http://youtu.be/jZE3BGKnZQ8

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Yes she was more well endowed.

 

And it was really only one time that I saw the whole boob...and I had the very reaction "Where do I look?" because I was having a conversation with her. I didnt want to let my feelings show on my face and I didnt want her to feel like I was sitting here watching her boob fall out of her shirt. It was just awkward. 

 

Yeah, that makes a lot more sense now. I never really had that problem, but there were times when a little extra effort was needed to keep things under wraps (sick kid, poor shirt choice, random public area with no seating, etc. my baby carrier became a lifesaver in those situations.)

havok579257
Posted

I think there's a problem with children eating at Mass, in the pews, during Mass. But I am clearly in the minority, so...

 

Pope Francis is a very holy man. Most men aren't. I just wonder if knowing there's a breast exposed near them would distract them from what they're supposed to be doing at Mass. If not: No problem.

 

 

do you have children?  since you have a problem with children eating at mass tell me how you would explain to a hungry child to suck it up and wait till mass is over?

 

i am a man and a woman breastfeeding does not bother me.  any man who has issues with it must be staring, its that simple.  even when breastfeeding without a cover the most you will see is parts of the breast and not the whole thing and the only way your getting a good look is if your staring.  any man who is so weak he is incapable of paying attention at mass because 1/5 of a breast is showing has deep sexual issues.  

 

also do we think men are so pathetic that we need to starve a child just so a man will not get a glimpse of a breast and then be unable to look away for 30 minutes.  do we assume men as so weak, they see part of a breast then lose all bodily control and can not do anything else but stare?

 

also i take huge issues with people who say the mother should just go to the bathroom or such to feed the baby.  i mean as a grown adult would you take your food into a public bathroom and eat your dinner there?  we all know public bathrooms are so clean.  well if its not good enough for an adult why on earth do we think its ok for a baby?

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

The bathrooms in the church should be as clean as a whistle but i get your point. Staring at anyone for to long is rude anyway.

havok579257
Posted

The bathrooms in the church should be as clean as a whistle but i get your point. Staring at anyone for to long is rude anyway.

 

 

how should the bathrooms be clean and a whistle?  does no one in church use a bathroom?

Posted

do you have children?  since you have a problem with children eating at mass tell me how you would explain to a hungry child to smell of elderberries it up and wait till mass is over?

 

i am a man and a woman breastfeeding does not bother me.  any man who has issues with it must be staring, its that simple.  even when breastfeeding without a cover the most you will see is parts of the breast and not the whole thing and the only way your getting a good look is if your staring.  any man who is so weak he is incapable of paying attention at mass because 1/5 of a breast is showing has deep sexual issues.  

 

also do we think men are so pathetic that we need to starve a child just so a man will not get a glimpse of a breast and then be unable to look away for 30 minutes.  do we assume men as so weak, they see part of a breast then lose all bodily control and can not do anything else but stare?

 

also i take huge issues with people who say the mother should just go to the bathroom or such to feed the baby.  i mean as a grown adult would you take your food into a public bathroom and eat your dinner there?  we all know public bathrooms are so clean.  well if its not good enough for an adult why on earth do we think its ok for a baby?

I think youre being overly dramatic and extreme.

 

No one is saying the baby has to go eat off the floor in a shit covered bathroom

No one is saying that a man will masturbate in church because he sees a boob

 

Good grief. 

 

Is it so hard to understand what we live in a world filled with feelings? Everyone has feelings. You cant just tell them to stop having feelings.

But if someones feelings arent the same as your feelings you say "fuck 'em"?

 

Thats not very nice.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

how should the bathrooms be clean and a whistle?  does no one in church use a bathroom?

 

 

are you a health nazi? without being to grotty though right. To be obsessed about cleanliness,health,fitness,strength etc is not good and in the catechism is classified as the CULT OF THE BODY.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
havok579257
Posted

are you a health nazi? without being to grotty though right. To be obsessed about cleanliness,health,fitness,strength etc is not good and in the catechism is classified as the CULT OF THE BODY.

 

 

gee i didn;t know one was so obsessed with health if he doesn't think public bathrooms are a good place to eat.  

havok579257
Posted

I think youre being overly dramatic and extreme.

 

No one is saying the baby has to go eat off the floor in a poo covered bathroom

No one is saying that a man will masturbate in church because he sees a boob

 

 

 

 

actually this is exactly what some people act like.  that us men are so weak that a woman needs to be overly extreme in her modesty.  some on these boards go overboard and make it seem us men are so weak that if we see any part of the female human body we will immediatly fall into sin.  i mean there are pictures with mary breastfeeding Jesus and her breast is exposed.  should we worry about this also.  i get so sick of hearing how pathetic us men are and how we have no self control and are incapable of resisting any temptation, even when its not something sexual like breastfeeding.

 

also its not about a baby eating off a floor in the bathroom or not.  would you take your own plate and eat in a public bathroom?  if you would never do it how can a person ask someone else to do it.

Posted

actually this is exactly what some people act like.  that us men are so weak that a woman needs to be overly extreme in her modesty.  some on these boards go overboard and make it seem us men are so weak that if we see any part of the female human body we will immediatly fall into sin.  i mean there are pictures with mary breastfeeding Jesus and her breast is exposed.  should we worry about this also.  i get so sick of hearing how pathetic us men are and how we have no self control and are incapable of resisting any temptation, even when its not something sexual like breastfeeding.

 

also its not about a baby eating off a floor in the bathroom or not.  would you take your own plate and eat in a public bathroom?  if you would never do it how can a person ask someone else to do it.

 

Heck yeah! MAN POWER!

Im totally behind you. I dont think all men should be constantly treated like they are uncontrollable, sex hungry pigs. Its ridic.

 

And no, I do not expect a mother to feed her child in a dirty bathroom. Why would I? Did I say that? As far as I know, Im in complete support of breastfeeding anywhere...they can go breastfeed on the moon for all I care if it would suit their fancy.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...