CrossCuT Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 Whether nature, nurture, or choice, you are usually pleasantly amusing. ;). My mom thinks so too
arfink Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 How would an anarcho-capitalist society deal with this issue? By the collapse of a cooperative and technologically advanced culture. We'd definitely stop consuming very quickly.
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 cooperative You must have a different understanding of cooperation. I tend to think that threats of initiation of violence destroy cooperation.
arfink Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 If all cooperation is completely voluntary in an anarcho-capitalist system, how can there be any cooperation when difficult situations arise?
Anomaly Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 You must have a different understanding of cooperation. I tend to think that threats of initiation of violence destroy cooperation. Cooperation: An act or instance of working or acting together for a common purpose or benefit. Cooperation may or may not be intentional or voluntary. Even with Ponies.
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 If all cooperation is completely voluntary in an anarcho-capitalist system, how can there be any cooperation when difficult situations arise? What do you mean by "difficult situations"? I work with 13 other people on a regular basis. None of them were forced to take the job they took, which involves risks to life and health in the short and long term. If they don't perform their duties, they might be sanctioned or fired, but they will not be threatened with violence. Soldiers often volunteer for war. War seems pretty difficult. Catholic Charities, to my knowledge, doesn't threaten people with violence if they don't donate. They are so effective that governments enlist their help. They deal with difficult situations, too.
4588686 Posted May 7, 2014 Author Posted May 7, 2014 Partners is a better word. They're willing participants. I'd love to know which politicians actually believe in anthropogenic climate change, rather than just using it as a tool to gain power. I have a hard time believing that most of them have read the summary of the studies, much less the study itself. I've read a bit here and there. I've always seen the cynicism going the other way. Environmental groups don't have the cash that coal companies do. So you have a political apparatus/campaign that understands that global warming is a serious issue but they'll still decide to come out pro-coal because they need the money or need to appear strong on jobs. I've seen that numerous times. I've never seen anybody feign concern over climate change.
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 Cooperation: An act or instance of working or acting together for a common purpose or benefit. Cooperation may or may not be intentional or voluntary. Even with Ponies. I think there's a distinction to be made between working with someone and working under them. "Cooperation" is mutual. If it's forced, that mutuality is damaged. Someone might well choose to submit to an attacker, but I wouldn't really call that "cooperation". I know it's commonly used to signify obedience to an authority figure under threat of violence. I think that's a real coup for the thugs.
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 I've always seen the cynicism going the other way. Environmental groups don't have the cash that coal companies do. So you have a political apparatus/campaign that understands that global warming is a serious issue but they'll still decide to come out pro-coal because they need the money or need to appear strong on jobs. I've seen that numerous times. I've never seen anybody feign concern over climate change. I'm sure there are as many motivations as there are people involved. I wouldn't expect that one always catches a feint. That's why people keep doing it. Concern doesn't necessarily equal understanding.
arfink Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 What do you mean by "difficult situations"? I work with 13 other people on a regular basis. None of them were forced to take the job they took, which involves risks to life and health in the short and long term. If they don't perform their duties, they might be sanctioned or fired, but they will not be threatened with violence. Soldiers often volunteer for war. War seems pretty difficult. Catholic Charities, to my knowledge, doesn't threaten people with violence if they don't donate. They are so effective that governments enlist their help. They deal with difficult situations, too. Being sanctioned or fired is a form of violence against them, as without pay they will be unable to procure the things needed to survive. If you're being made to cooperate by having a paycheck held over your head, then your cooperation is not completely voluntary. We see lots of instances of voluntary cooperation, but we see many instances too where people refuse to voluntarily cooperate to the detriment of other people besides themselves. In these situations a legal system of lawful coercion and even violence seems to be necessary. Human beings have relied on this method for centuries and have found nothing else to replace it yet.
Anomaly Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 I think there's a distinction to be made between working with someone and working under them. "Cooperation" is mutual. If it's forced, that mutuality is damaged. Someone might well choose to submit to an attacker, but I wouldn't really call that "cooperation". I know it's commonly used to signify obedience to an authority figure under threat of violence. I think that's a real coup for the thugs. Sorry, but the nature of current human society has created necessary interdependence which is complex and not always obvious. Your hypothetical constraints of only voluntary cooperation regardless of the perception of a need or crisis does not nullify the existence of the problem that faces society as a whole, with little or no apparent effect on individuals. Only small and stratified communities that can limit their effects to small voluntary participants and small geographical areas are possible in your scenario. Good luck with that. Either tune in or drop out. It's easy to broadly condemn the general policy while referencing the few problems. But again, that tendency is human nature as well.
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 Being sanctioned or fired is a form of violence against them, as without pay they will be unable to procure the things needed to survive. If you're being made to cooperate by having a paycheck held over your head, then your cooperation is not completely voluntary. We see lots of instances of voluntary cooperation, but we see many instances too where people refuse to voluntarily cooperate to the detriment of other people besides themselves. In these situations a legal system of lawful coercion and even violence seems to be necessary. Human beings have relied on this method for centuries and have found nothing else to replace it yet. I should have been more specific: it's not an initiation of violence. I was merely addressing your apparent belief that nobody can voluntarily cooperate in difficult situations without a third party forcing them. Yes, in order to get paid for a job, you have to do that job. Does that strike you as inherently unjust? Are you saying that it's lawful to force people to help others? Could I put a gun to your head to make you help me search a burning house?
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 Sorry, but the nature of current human society has created necessary interdependence which is complex and not always obvious. Your hypothetical constraints of only voluntary cooperation regardless of the perception of a need or crisis does not nullify the existence of the problem that faces society as a whole, with little or no apparent effect on individuals. Only small and stratified communities that can limit their effects to small voluntary participants and small geographical areas are possible in your scenario. Good luck with that. Either tune in or drop out. It's easy to broadly condemn the general policy while referencing the few problems. But again, that tendency is human nature as well. It's a normative stance. Expediency does not justify aggression. I'm well aware of human nature, and I didn't say that anything was nullified. I simply don't condone evil in the name of the greater good, and I view aggression as inherently evil. Nothing I've said denies interdependence, it just rejects that there is a special class of human exempt from the moral laws that bind everyone else.
arfink Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 I should have been more specific: it's not an initiation of violence. I was merely addressing your apparent belief that nobody can voluntarily cooperate in difficult situations without a third party forcing them. Yes, in order to get paid for a job, you have to do that job. Does that strike you as inherently unjust? Are you saying that it's lawful to force people to help others? Could I put a gun to your head to make you help me search a burning house? You're over simplifying again. The use of violence as a means of obtaining cooperation is not inherently immoral or unjust. I'm not saying it's ALWAYS lawful to force people to help others, but there are situations where justice would demand that.
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 You're over simplifying again. The use of violence as a means of obtaining cooperation is not inherently immoral or unjust. I'm not saying it's ALWAYS lawful to force people to help others, but there are situations where justice would demand that. Describe one.
4588686 Posted May 7, 2014 Author Posted May 7, 2014 Yes, in order to get paid for a job, you have to do that job. Does that strike you as inherently unjust? Are you saying that it's lawful to force people to help others? Could I put a gun to your head to make you help me search a burning house? No, but, and I think this is where we branch of normatively, you start at the point after primitive accumulation of capital at which point violence is already an integral part of the system and then want to perpetuate that system as thought it's sui generis or the wage relationship between people is somehow natural. It's not clear to me why, given the normative claims of anarcho-capitalism, people have any initial right to accumulate the common resources of the world to their private use unless they have the continued and universal consent of humanity. I think that property is a useful institution. But I don't deny the inherent violence of it.
arfink Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 Describe one. OK, imagine this. You enter my house and take all my food. Then you decide you'd also like my wife or children to come with you. I and the friendly local police officer who I summon to my abode tell you not to, and you refuse to cooperate. I think we're more than justified to use force on you to make you cooperate.
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 No, but, and I think this is where we branch of normatively, you start at the point after primitive accumulation of capital at which point violence is already an integral part of the system and then want to perpetuate that system as thought it's sui generis or the wage relationship between people is somehow natural. It's not clear to me why, given the normative claims of anarcho-capitalism, people have any initial right to accumulate the common resources of the world to their private use unless they have the continued and universal consent of humanity. I think that property is a useful institution. But I don't deny the inherent violence of it. I don't see wages as any different from any other trade. I don't know how to deal with the belief that resources are commonly owned prior to being claimed. It's impossible for everyone to have right of use, impossible to gain universal consent.
arfink Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 And here is a second one: You and I are both farmers. I work one field, and you work another. Between us, 100% of the food for the local population is being grown. Normally this works very well, people come to us, we give them the extra food so they can eat too, and carry on our merry way. Then one say the field you're working on doesn't make any food. Suddenly the field I work on has all the food. But I refuse to give you any, because my responsibility is only to give food to the people who don't have a field. I think in that case you would have the right to make me reasonable, by use of force if I was particularly obstinate, as I am withholding something that is so critical to life that by simply being human, you have a right to it.
Winchester Posted May 7, 2014 Posted May 7, 2014 OK, imagine this. You enter my house and take all my food. Then you decide you'd also like my wife or children to come with you. I and the friendly local police officer who I summon to my abode tell you not to, and you refuse to cooperate. I think we're more than justified to use force on you to make you cooperate. It sounds like I initiated violence. I thought you were going to create a situation in which violence had not been initiated. Self defense was never at issue.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now