Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Climate Change Study Finds U.s. Is Already Widely Affected


Recommended Posts

Winchester
Posted

And here is a second one:

 

You and I are both farmers. I work one field, and you work another. Between us, 100% of the food for the local population is being grown. Normally this works very well, people come to us, we give them the extra food so they can eat too, and carry on our merry way.

 

Then one say the field you're working on doesn't make any food. Suddenly the field I work on has all the food. But I refuse to give you any, because my responsibility is only to give food to the people who don't have a field.

 

I think in that case you would have the right to make me reasonable, by use of force if I was particularly obstinate, as I am withholding something that is so critical to life that by simply being human, you have a right to it.

If I took only enough to sustain my life, would I not owe you restitution as soon as I could make it?

Posted (edited)

^^ Not necessarily.

Edited by arfink
Winchester
Posted

^^ Not necessarily.

 

So you argue that such rights exist independent of the declaration of others.

Posted

I don't see wages as any different from any other trade.

 

I don't know how to deal with the belief that resources are commonly owned prior to being claimed. It's impossible for everyone to have right of use, impossible to gain universal consent.

 

I wouldn't say that they are owned since property is a social institution.  Your defense seems consequentialist.  It would be impossible to create a system of property that attains universal consent.  That's absolutely true.  But then how is the institution justified?  That's no different than the imposition of the state system.  

Winchester
Posted (edited)

I wouldn't say that they are owned since property is a social institution.  Your defense seems consequentialist.  It would be impossible to create a system of property that attains universal consent.  That's absolutely true.  But then how is the institution justified?  That's no different than the imposition of the state system.  

States make ownership and use claims on property that's already in use. That's a difference. It also claims property not by the means of use, but by declaration. It tends to draw lines on a map and then ignore prior possession.

 

It's possible that you would only acknowledge possession and not acknowledge rights at all. This would mean there is no good or evil. That's a distinct possibility. I wouldn't see the point in discussing this with me, then. It's established that I don't believe in aggression so I'm no threat to you. You would be better off trying to convince someone like Vitamin. He'd kill you for crossing a border in order to cut someone's lawn, or for possessing a plant he didn't think you should have. Those are the people I'd be worried about. They're lunatics.

Edited by Winchester
Posted

I just want to clarify that I support killing Hasan on general principal.  Thank you.

Winchester
Posted

Good point.

Posted

States make ownership and use claims on property that's already in use. That's a difference. It also claims property not by the means of use, but by declaration. It tends to draw lines on a map and then ignore prior possession.

 

It's possible that you would only acknowledge possession and not acknowledge rights at all. This would mean there is no good or evil. That's a distinct possibility. I wouldn't see the point in discussing this with me, then. It's established that I don't believe in aggression so I'm no threat to you. You would be better off trying to convince someone like Vitamin. He'd kill you for crossing a border in order to cut someone's lawn, or for possessing a plant he didn't think you should have. Those are the people I'd be worried about. They're lunatics.

 

I think the problem everyone is raising to you Winchester is not whether or not you believe in non-aggression, but what the proper response to people who don't is.  It becomes confusing when you start talking about self-defense, when you can just as easily argue that the self-defender is initiating aggression as you could the "criminal"(for lack of a better word) in any of the scenarios mentioned above.  

RC Patriot
Posted

Man, with all these accurate predictions of climate change, you'd think they could get the weather report right.

Posted

Man, with all these accurate predictions of climate change, you'd think they could get the weather report right.

 

 

Meteorologist predict the weather.  Climatology is a different field.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...