Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I know I have a major issue with spaghetti sauce allergies.

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

SSA sounds like some shameful disease or disability, and while I get the desire to differentiate one's self from a culture that makes your sexual identity your only identity, I don't think SSA is the right term. Why do we need to invent a word for it? What's wrong with people saying "I'm Catholic and gay" instead of "I'm a Catholic with SSA?" Heck, even calling it by an acronym further removes you away from the issue. It seems to me that more heterosexuals are concerned with coming up for a replacement word for gay than non-heterosexuals. Why is that? Are we separating someone's sexuality from their total identity as a person to help them, or to let us ignore that they're gay? 

 

idk, I just don't see the big need for "SSA."  If people who are gay want to say they have SSA I won't argue, but I don't think it's right for me, as a heterosexual person, to be telling people what the right labels for themselves are. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie
Fidei Defensor
Posted

I prefer to just say that I'm gay because people know what that means.

Posted

But...but...the quote in the OP was about the fact that "attraction" as a concept need not always be sexualized, hence our difficulty.

 

Attraction can refer to sexual attraction, but does not necessarily.  I do not see what is the problem with using it in an expression in which everyone knows it refers to a sexual attraction.  I suppose we could call it "same sex sexual attraction" "SSSA" but I am not convinced that this is really adding anything useful.

Lilllabettt
Posted

SSA sounds like some shameful disease or disability

 

 

 

pardon? what diseases or disabilities would you consider shameful, exactly? 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

pardon? what diseases or disabilities would you consider shameful, exactly? 

 

Poor wording on my part. Not that diseases or disabilities are inherently shameful, but that SSA sounds like a disease or disability that also happens to be shameful. 

Posted

SSA sounds like some shameful disease or disability, and while I get the desire to differentiate one's self from a culture that makes your sexual identity your only identity, I don't think SSA is the right term. Why do we need to invent a word for it? What's wrong with people saying "I'm Catholic and gay" instead of "I'm a Catholic with SSA?" Heck, even calling it by an acronym further removes you away from the issue. It seems to me that more heterosexuals are concerned with coming up for a replacement word for gay than non-heterosexuals. Why is that? Are we separating someone's sexuality from their total identity as a person to help them, or to let us ignore that they're gay? 

 

idk, I just don't see the big need for "SSA."  If people who are gay want to say they have SSA I won't argue, but I don't think it's right for me, as a heterosexual person, to be telling people what the right labels for themselves are. 

 

The word "gay" has other problems.  For one thing, it is can be used to describe both a person engaged in sinful activity or a person with an attraction that is not a sin.  This can lead to a lot of confusion.

Posted

pardon? what diseases or disabilities would you consider shameful, exactly? 

 

gonorrhea

Nihil Obstat
Posted

gonorrhea

d4c.gif

Not The Philosopher
Posted

I generally find this topic to be a weird sort of non-debate.

If you are writing an academic paper, or helping to draft an official church document of some kind, it generally behooves you to be as precise as possible, at the expense of some clunkiness.

 

In terms of how language - particularly English - is actually spoken by real people, attempts to make it as rational and precise as possible, or otherwise just bend it to your will, have generally proven futile. In the case of gay vs. ssa, I feel no particular commitment to either term. There are things I dislike about both of them. So I tend to just use whatever is most artful, or whatever will bring the least amount of confusion in the situation I'm in. In any event, neither term is found in Scripture or Apostolic Tradition. This isn't exactly consubstantial.

 

Anyway, eventually the LGBTQ label will grow too dense and collapse into a singularity and we will no longer debate these things.

The Bus Station
Posted

Uranian

 

wut

Anastasia13
Posted

But...but...the quote in the OP was about the fact that "attraction" as a concept need not always be sexualized, hence our difficulty.

Sass

Same sex sexual activity?

The Bus Station
Posted

ASSS  Attractive sexual same sex meow

Lilllabettt
Posted

 

 

Anyway, eventually the LGBTQ label will grow too dense and collapse into a singularity and we will no longer debate these things.

 

to prove your point

the new designation is LGBTQIA (intersexual and asexual)

get with the program bro

Lilllabettt
Posted

gonorrhea

 

 

you're a doctor. deal with it.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

to prove your point

the new designation is LGBTQIA (intersexual and asexual)

get with the program bro

 

Recently, a man asked me if I was LGBTQ.

 

I told him I pity the person who is so confused about their sexuality that they think they're lesbian, gay, bisexual, transexual, and questioning. Though if I were that confused, I would definitely be very questioning about myself as a person.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Credo in Deum
Posted

Sass
Same sex sexual activity?

imagejpg1-2.jpg
Posted

I would just like to add that “same sex attraction” is ambiguous in a way that is destructive. The type of attraction is not specified, only the object of the attraction. All people should have some level of same sex attraction because we need relationships with people of the same sex.The question is the end and effect of that attraction, not the object.

Posted

I would just like to add that “same sex attraction” is ambiguous in a way that is destructive. The type of attraction is not specified, only the object of the attraction. All people should have some level of same sex attraction because we need relationships with people of the same sex.The question is the end and effect of that attraction, not the object.

 

There may be a theoretical ambiguity, but I have never seen anyone understanding SSA to mean a non-sexual attraction.  There seems to be an accepted convention that it refers to sexual attraction. 

 

In contrast, I have witnessed numerous misunderstandings and confusion with the other words associated with this topic: homosexual, gay, sodomy.
 

Posted

If you are writing an academic paper, or helping to draft an official church document of some kind, it generally behooves you to be as precise as possible, at the expense of some clunkiness.

 

I have written a lot of academic papers and read a lot of Church documents, so that explains why that is the style I gravitate towards.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...