Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Credo in Deum
Posted

WFSHCHASA

Weak Fallen Sinful Human Capable of Having All Sorts of Attractions.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

There may be a theoretical ambiguity, but I have never seen anyone understanding SSA to mean a non-sexual attraction.  There seems to be an accepted convention that it refers to sexual attraction. 

 

In contrast, I have witnessed numerous misunderstandings and confusion with the other words associated with this topic: homosexual, gay, sodomy.
 

I think the destructive part of phrase "same sex attraction" is the assumption that it's a) a bad kind of attraction and b) it necessarily leads to sin.

AugustineA
Posted

Gee wiz, these threads are just buzzin. I don't know if it's the culture on PM or the demographics, but anyhow. I think.. 

 

If in most cases its expression leads to disordered moral sin, there is a valid argument to be had over whether it is intrinsically bad or not (I), or whether impulses can be morally judged based on their degree of potentiality (2). Though some people may argue that sodomy is a moral sin, but the impulse of SSA is varied and doesn't in most cases lead to sodomy (3), an argument which I would also like to see made convincingly and in full compliance with Church teaching, if made (4). 

 

Any arguments should also be made (at least as it is clear in my mind) with clear conviction that an the moral character of an impulse, if it has a moral character, does not project the same moral judgement onto the person, unlike the act or expression of the impulse which clearly does. Finally, any real discussion on the topic ought to differentiate between an impulse and thought (5), where an impulse is a thought and where the thought is the expression of an impulse, in relation to SSA. Although this is a much less sophisticated argument to make than say argument 1, 4 or particularly 2. 

 

And then if, when all that is done, we can burn it and simply read the scriptures.. But if you can make even 2 out of the 5 arguments there using the Catechism, Scripture, St. Aquinas, or Augustine, I will prop you, make coffee and thoroughly enjoy your post. :D

 

 

 

Posted

I think the destructive part of phrase "same sex attraction" is the assumption that it's a) a bad kind of attraction and b) it necessarily leads to sin.

 

According to the Catechism, the tendency to have this attraction is "objectively disordered", so there is some justification for considering it a bad kind of attraction.  But is not bad in the sense of sinful and it is important to be clear about that.  It is also important to be clear that the attraction does not necessarily lead to sin.  We should never assume that people with this attraction are sinning or are about to sin because of it.  I do not see anything in the phrase itself that encourages such a wrong idea, although I have encountered people who think it.  I suspect that people who think that the attraction always leads to sin would think that no matter terminology was used.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...