Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

ok, episode 4 watched.  ack, the abandoned factory.  and the way the "miracle" at the end is presented in the dark moonlight creeps me out way more than I thought it would.

 

I liked the conversation on the bridge at sundown - particularly when the sun was going behind the distant factory buildings.

Edited by chrysostom
Posted (edited)

NO SPOILERS!

I just watched the first episode yesterday! It left a LOT of questions...so I guess Ill have to keep watching if I want to satisfy my curiosity. 

The artwork is very pretty..its very soft...the only way I can describe it. I still dont feel I understand the genre enough to appreciate the subtleties but I am trying! 

 

I watched the first episode on Netflix  but it was dubbed! Bleh! I dont generally like the dubbed versions because they feel so out of place. 

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted

Sorry! I am using hulu and it is subbed which is good. I get the impression that the main character's voice work is quite good.

Posted

I use hulu MOST of the time however Netflix has a few subbed animes that I like and I dont have to watch commercials!!!!

 

So I tried netflix but their version is not subbed. Ill probably just go back to hulu!

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Yeah, I have always found dubs to be awkward. I like to watch a program as close as I can to the intention of the people who made it. For me a dub breaks that connection.

Madoka is very much a genre inversion and deconstruction. In a perfect world one might watch archetypical examples first, like Cardcaptor Sakura or Sailor Moon, but I think the themes are universal enough that it is accessible either way.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Some 250 animators redid an episode of Sailor Moon, each one animating one shot in their own style. It's pretty crazy:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=orhh6TZ6qCE

LittleWaySoul
Posted

I want in on this thread.

 

even though I haven't read all eight pages; i have to take an exam tomorrow

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I want in on this thread.

 

even though I haven't read all eight pages; i have to take an exam tomorrow

Meh. We never stay on topic anyway. What anime do you like?

LittleWaySoul
Posted

Meh. We never stay on topic anyway. What anime do you like?

I haven't watched many, but I know that I like anime! I've got a bunch on my to-watch list. I'm in the middle of Haibane Renmei right now, and I believe that was actually your suggestion, Nihil. So we'll see where I go from there! :smile3:

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Excellent show. I would recommend that to anyone.

Posted

Meh. We never stay on topic anyway. What anime do you like?

 

Its all Nihils fault anyway.

 

 

 

BUt I am determined to continue watching Madoka once I get a chance. THen we can talk about girl stuff.

Posted

I have watched through episode 4 of Madoka! 

 

[spoiler] Im still not 100% sure what the grand plot is, but I have to say I was pretty shocked when Mami get her head bitten off...I felt like I was watching Attack on Titan for a second haha!

But I can see now what you were saying earlier about wanting to discuss feminist themes in regards to this show. Its (so far) encompassed completely by female roles...females who have a pretty cray task of killing the witches. One interesting thing is the contrast in the show with their school lessons. Some of the lessons are super gender specific in that the teacher tells the girls they need to find good men and be a good wife and what not. Im sure that was put in on purpose! 

 

I feel like so far they have been setting it up to be predictable in that the scary girl who they think is bad is actually the best one who is trying to do good and not presenting the Magical Girls duties in a sugary light. I guess Mami wasnt either, but she wanted them to be Magical Girls pretty badly...although not really saying why. Was it because she was lonely? Homura seems to want to prevent new magical girls because of something that hasnt been revealed to me yet. We shall see! [/spoiler]

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I have watched through episode 4 of Madoka! 

 

[spoiler] Im still not 100% sure what the grand plot is, but I have to say I was pretty shocked when Mami get her head bitten off...I felt like I was watching Attack on Titan for a second haha!

But I can see now what you were saying earlier about wanting to discuss feminist themes in regards to this show. Its (so far) encompassed completely by female roles...females who have a pretty cray task of killing the witches. One interesting thing is the contrast in the show with their school lessons. Some of the lessons are super gender specific in that the teacher tells the girls they need to find good men and be a good wife and what not. Im sure that was put in on purpose! 

 

I feel like so far they have been setting it up to be predictable in that the scary girl who they think is bad is actually the best one who is trying to do good and not presenting the Magical Girls duties in a sugary light. I guess Mami wasnt either, but she wanted them to be Magical Girls pretty badly...although not really saying why. Was it because she was lonely? Homura seems to want to prevent new magical girls because of something that hasnt been revealed to me yet. We shall see! [/spoiler]

[spoiler]

With regards to the gender specific lessons you are seeing, I believe that is a specific trope, i.e. a female teacher transitioning from young adult to middle aged, and who is highly insecure about herself, especially her romantic options. I have seen it a handful of times, but it was really highlighted in Toradora. Whether or not it relates to the rest of Madoka... I had not thought about it. Perhaps? If we look at the magical girl trope as a whole as being about a young girl transitioning from childhood through pubescence, then that teacher trope could be seen as being a bit of a window into the future for these girls.

I have a feeling that there are some pretty interesting themes to be discussed with regards to the magical girls, these young innocent girls, fighting "witches". The perception of a witch in fiction is typically a sort of old crone. Almost the opposite of an innocent young girl. Maybe a corruption of innocent femininity? The old crone type of witch is especially common in European literature, and I think they make that connection with the witch Walpurgis. That is coming up, but not really a spoiler. Kind of a subtle reference, but worth looking into.

Considering the concept of a witch being a corruption of femininity and innocence, definitely pay attention to the nature of witches as presented in the show. I cannot say more than that just yet.

[/spoiler]

Posted

I shall press on and let you know how far I get!

Nihil Obstat
Posted

You can finish it by the end of today if you are a TRUE BELIEVER! :|

Posted

Ill do my best! Im going to go on a run since the sun is shining so nicely! When I finally resign to sit on my bum for the rest of the night I will throw Madoka up on the screen! :)

Posted

Watched up through episode 11...things be trippin

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Yeah it is.

Posted

Still only on episode 5.  I'm busy.  :/

Posted

Still only on episode 5.  I'm busy.  :/

 

I found the first 5 episodes to be a bit dull...waiting for that part where they explain why Im watching. I think they left the mystery dragging a bit...but once you get to episode 10 they reveal the truth of the matter. 

 

Most of my suspicions about the characters intentions and integrity were right minus 1 person, Mami. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...