Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

How Many People Know That Marx...


Recommended Posts

Posted

I love how people who know nothing about actually living under a communist system like to promote it.

Posted

I don't believe he's promoted the statist versions of socialism or communism. I understand that Marx believed the state would be necessary for a transition (like many believed the One Ring would be needed to defeat Sauron), but even that error is far different from arguing in favor of those animals.

Posted

Not by any kind of governmental policy.  Willfully giving away one's wealth is not the same thing.

 

How about workers just take back all the products, machines and things they have created with their sweat and labor, and we leave the money where it is. Money will not matter very much if we switch to labor-voucher or abolish money altogether. 

 

I don't believe he's promoted the statist versions of socialism or communism. I understand that Marx believed the state would be necessary for a transition (like many believed the One Ring would be needed to defeat Sauron), but even that error is far different from arguing in favor of those animals.

 

The State that Marx envisioned leading the transition is not the same State that existed in Soviet Russia, though. Marx advocated a fiercely democratic state that would lead the transition. At least in my reading of Marx, a vibrant democracy would have to come before socialist policies are enacted. I am not aware of any Leninist concept of a vanguard in Marx.

Posted


Oh, don't give that stereo typical atheist response.  You're better than that, Hasan. 

 

Where did you get this idea?

 

stewie_zps011a290a.jpg

Credo in Deum
Posted

Where did you get this idea?

stewie_zps011a290a.jpg


Wut?

Confused_Mr._shue.gif
Posted

Orwell was actually a staunch communist himself! Orwell believed that the answer to 1984 was real communism.

 

Was this sarcasm?

 

No.  Double speak and nuance are two different things.  

 

No.  Being nuanced is different than being disingenuous.

Posted

Was this sarcasm?

 

 

 

 

Not every communist believes in the state version of communism.

 

 

 

Posted

Was this sarcasm?

 

 

 

 

No.  It's pretty common knowledge that the man who wrote Homage to Catalonia was a socialist.  

Posted

Not every communist believes in the state version of communism.

 

 

I'm talking about Orwell, who was not a communist, so I'm not sure the point here. 

 

No.  It's pretty common knowledge that the man who wrote Homage to Catalonia was a socialist.  

 

Yes, common knowledge that he was a democratic socialist, never a marxist-socialist or communist.

Posted

I'm talking about Orwell, who was not a communist, so I'm not sure the point here. 

 

 

 

Then why ask if he was being sarcastic? Why not simply show the contradictory evidence that Orwell didn't support communism? Unless your evidence is that he wrote a satire on totalitarianism employing communist rhetoric in order to maintain hierarchy that communists reject. 

 

My understanding is that Orwell was a democratic socialist, a different animal from a communist. But certainly reconcilable. 

Posted

 

 

Yes, common knowledge that he was a democratic socialist, never a marxist-socialist or communist.

 

 

Democratic Socialism is as much a derivative of 'Marxist-Socialism' as Leninism is.  Arguably more so since it came to force in Germany via Karl Kautsky who had a much stronger claim to being a rightful 'disciple' of Marx than Lenin or Stalin did.  You're trying to create clear boundaries where none exist.  Marx was not a completely consistent theoretician.  

Posted

My understanding is that Orwell was a democratic socialist, a different animal from a communist. But certainly reconcilable. 

 

It depends what you mean by "communism". With the advent of the Soviet Union and Marxist Leninism, many Marxists who would have previously considered themselves communists, began to use other terms to distinguish themselves from Leninism. Social Democracy became a common label, used by Kautsky. Eventually, however, social democracy became associated with a third-way ideology in Europe. Communism, Anarchism and Socialism are quite interchangeable in many contexts. Orwell could be labeled equally, a communist, an anarchist, or a socialist. 

 

In a letter to the Tribune, George Orwell wrote: 

 

Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also"…. It was Marx who brought it to life. And ever since he did so the motives of politicians, priests, judges, moralists and millionaires have been under the deepest suspicion–which, of course, is why they hate him so much.
Posted

Orwell was actually a staunch communist himself! Orwell believed that the answer to 1984 was real communism.

 

Karl Marx does believe in the abolition of private property, by which he understands to be the primary "means of production". Marx believed that modernity and industrialism had destroyed idyllic peasant life. There was no going back, and we do not really want to go back, for we should have to give up all the gains of modernity. That being said, I do not imagine Marx would have a problem with a person growing vegetables on their land, or a kid setting up a lemonade stand. Marx's criticism of capitalism is that it exploits the labor power of others. So long as you do the labor yourself, I cannot envision Marx condemning it.

 

 

Tell that to all the Latin American faithful and Latin American Jesuit Priests who are both staunch communists and staunch Catholics. I do not accept the Church's condemnation of socialism in its encyclicals, because all it does is condemn vulgar representations of communism/socialism. Condemning boogeyman socialism is not the same as real socialism, which was actually practiced in the New Testament Church.

 

Yes, I'd agree with this also. Of course people favouring Capitalism use those encyclicals to spin the issues to their advantage. But with the growth of the church in Latin America, and the shrinking elsewhere, I wonder what impact and relationship socialist ideas will have on the church. It seems fairly clear, and this is seen in the Popes change of focus, that there will definitely be a reordering of attention towards the issues of poverty and social action. The US and Europe led the agendas for the worldwide church up until this point, mostly focusing on doctrine and secularization. I sense this will faze slightly into the background as other priorities come into play. It may well change things a great deal if their are more Cardinals appointed from wider afield in the future. The balance at the moment is unfair. The recent visit of Gustavo Gutierrez to the Vatican and reports that the Pope is closely connected with the concerns of Liberation theology are maybe other signs of a shift.
 

Posted

 

It depends what you mean by "communism". With the advent of the Soviet Union and Marxist Leninism, many Marxists who would have previously considered themselves communists, began to use other terms to distinguish themselves from Leninism. Social Democracy became a common label, used by Kautsky. Eventually, however, social democracy became associated with a third-way ideology in Europe. Communism, Anarchism and Socialism are quite interchangeable in many contexts. Orwell could be labeled equally, a communist, an anarchist, or a socialist. 

 

In a letter to the Tribune, George Orwell wrote: 

 

Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also"…. It was Marx who brought it to life. And ever since he did so the motives of politicians, priests, judges, moralists and millionaires have been under the deepest suspicion–which, of course, is why they hate him so much.

 

 

Fair enough.

Posted

Then why ask if he was being sarcastic? Why not simply show the contradictory evidence that Orwell didn't support communism? Unless your evidence is that he wrote a satire on totalitarianism employing communist rhetoric in order to maintain hierarchy that communists reject. 

 

My understanding is that Orwell was a democratic socialist, a different animal from a communist. But certainly reconcilable. 

 

I said it because it's ridiculous enough on it's face to deserve the question.  Orwell identified as a democratic socialist.  This is distinct and separate from Marxism. 

 

Democratic Socialism is as much a derivative of 'Marxist-Socialism' as Leninism is.  Arguably more so since it came to force in Germany via Karl Kautsky who had a much stronger claim to being a rightful 'disciple' of Marx than Lenin or Stalin did.  You're trying to create clear boundaries where none exist.  Marx was not a completely consistent theoretician.  

 

Democratic socialism was not a derivative of marxism.  In Britain it was formalized largely by the Fabian society which was independent of marxism and later became the independent labour party, where most identifying themselves as "democratic socialists" resided.

 

 

It depends what you mean by "communism". With the advent of the Soviet Union and Marxist Leninism, many Marxists who would have previously considered themselves communists, began to use other terms to distinguish themselves from Leninism. Social Democracy became a common label, used by Kautsky. Eventually, however, social democracy became associated with a third-way ideology in Europe. Communism, Anarchism and Socialism are quite interchangeable in many contexts. Orwell could be labeled equally, a communist, an anarchist, or a socialist. 

 

In a letter to the Tribune, George Orwell wrote: 

 

Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also"…. It was Marx who brought it to life. And ever since he did so the motives of politicians, priests, judges, moralists and millionaires have been under the deepest suspicion–which, of course, is why they hate him so much.

 

 

Kautsy's use of the term democratic socialism had nothing to do w/ disowning leninism, which didn't exist at the time...

 

Orwell never quite developed a distinct politically ideology - at least not one he professed - and I think his writing (and his readers) have benefited from that.  However, there's no reason he'd be called anything but what he called himself:  a democratic socialist. 

 

Frankly, we've now seen you try to paint Marx as a fan of private property and Orwell as a communist.  Is there anything you wont' turn on it's head to make Marxism look good?

Posted

I said it because it's ridiculous enough on it's face to deserve the question.  Orwell identified as a democratic socialist.  This is distinct and separate from Marxism. 

 

 

Democratic socialism was not a derivative of marxism.  In Britain it was formalized largely by the Fabian society which was independent of marxism and later became the independent labour party, where most identifying themselves as "democratic socialists" resided.

 

 

Kautsy's use of the term democratic socialism had nothing to do w/ disowning leninism, which didn't exist at the time...

 

Orwell never quite developed a distinct politically ideology - at least not one he professed - and I think his writing (and his readers) have benefited from that.  However, there's no reason he'd be called anything but what he called himself:  a democratic socialist. 

 

Frankly, we've now seen you try to paint Marx as a fan of private property and Orwell as a communist.  Is there anything you wont' turn on it's head to make Marxism look good?

 

Kautsky exchanged numerous polemics with Lenin and Trotsky.  His polemics with Lenin continued after the Bolsheviks had attained power and Lenin's political vision had been implemented in the USSR.  So you're just flatly wrong about that.  No ambiguity. 

Posted

I also think you are confusing the Social Democrats with Democratic Socialism.  

Posted

Not that the two aren't related and don't share many common sources.

Posted

I don't believe he's promoted the statist versions of socialism or communism. I understand that Marx believed the state would be necessary for a transition (like many believed the One Ring would be needed to defeat Sauron), but even that error is far different from arguing in favor of those animals.

 

Interestingly, old Karl himself acknowledged the necessity of a despotic state to bring about Communism's goals.

 

The proletariat will use its political supremacy to wrest, by degree, all capital from the bourgeoisie, to centralise all instruments of production in the hands of the State, i.e., of the proletariat organised as the ruling class; and to increase the total productive forces as rapidly as possible.

 

Of course, in the beginning, this cannot be effected except by means of despotic inroads on the rights of property, and on the conditions of bourgeois production; by means of measures, therefore, which appear economically insufficient and untenable, but which, in the course of the movement, outstrip themselves, necessitate further inroads upon the old social order, and are unavoidable as a means of entirely revolutionising the mode of production.

 

https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-manifesto/ch02.htm

 

Of course, under Communism, the despotic attacks against property rights and economically untenable measures remain, while the promised stateless utopia never arrives.

 

The absurd lie of Marxism involves getting people to subjugate to a despotic state and economic disaster in return for the promise of freedom from state despotism and economic utopia in the indefinite future.

 

It's tragic that so many fell for this lie.

 

If you read Marx, it's clear he wasn't just all about peace'n'luv.

Posted

Interestingly, old Karl himself acknowledged the necessity of a despotic state to bring about Communism's goals.

 

 

That's what I said.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...