Winchester Posted June 26, 2014 Posted June 26, 2014 I said it because it's ridiculous enough on it's its face to deserve the question. Orwell identified as a democratic socialist. This is distinct and separate from Marxism. I get that you would ask a question, it just makes no sense to chalk it up (sarcastically) to sarcasm. Unless you believe that all forms of communism are totalitarian in nature. I suppose if one equated the USSR to communism (there was absolutely nothing communist in the USSR, since the property of the state was never owned by the people but instead by the members of the state who had power (just like the US)), you might see an opportunity for sarcasm. Since Marx essentially argued for the means of production to be communally owned through cooperation among individuals, he was quite close to democratic socialism. Socialists share the same class conflict outlook as communists. It's not enough of a decision to warrant your employment of sarcastically inquiring about sarcasm.
John Ryan Posted June 27, 2014 Author Posted June 27, 2014 (edited) I also think you are confusing the Social Democrats with Democratic Socialism. At the fin-de-siècle the terms were probably interchangeable. However, "social democracy" has become associated with third way movements in Europe and "democratic socialism" for those who want revolutionary change brought about through democratic procedures. Interestingly, old Karl himself acknowledged the necessity of a despotic state to bring about Communism's goals. https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-manifesto/ch02.htm Of course, under Communism, the despotic attacks against property rights and economically untenable measures remain, while the promised stateless utopia never arrives. The absurd lie of Marxism involves getting people to subjugate to a despotic state and economic disaster in return for the promise of freedom from state despotism and economic utopia in the indefinite future. It's tragic that so many fell for this lie. If you read Marx, it's clear he wasn't just all about peace'n'luv. I reject your logic because you have equated all socialist governmental activity with "despotism", which ends up being nothing but a vulgar slur. Marx never envisioned a despotic government, where a single individual or some sort of junta controlled the masses. Marx envisioned a revolution where the masses of proletarians take control of the government in a form of radical democracy and begin the transition to socialism. You can assert that a democratic government abolishing private property is inherently despotic, but you can only expect people who already believe in a right to the private ownership of the means of production to agree with you. Socialists do not believe in capitalist private property and therefore understand its abolition as liberation for the masses. Edited June 27, 2014 by John Ryan
Socrates Posted June 28, 2014 Posted June 28, 2014 That's what I said. And I confirmed it. Marx acknowledged that not only would the implementation of Communism involve a powerful state (even if it was supposed to be temporary), but that it would need to take "despotic" actions against property rights. Our resident Commies would have us believe that a "real" Communist state would be some gentle benign thing that would be respectful of property rights, though Marx's own words prove this false. Since Marx essentially argued for the means of production to be communally owned through cooperation among individuals, he was quite close to democratic socialism. Any state could be said to involve "cooperation among individuals" (recalls Barney Frank's inane remark that "government is simply the name we give to things we choose to do together") Even in Marx's theory, Communism involves a state (which he defined as "the proletariat organized as the ruling class") taking violent action against "the bourgeois." Tyranny by any other name . . .
Socrates Posted June 28, 2014 Posted June 28, 2014 I reject your logic because you have equated all socialist governmental activity with "despotism", which ends up being nothing but a vulgar slur. Marx never envisioned a despotic government, where a single individual or some sort of junta controlled the masses. Marx envisioned a revolution where the masses of proletarians take control of the government in a form of radical democracy and begin the transition to socialism. You can assert that a democratic government abolishing private property is inherently despotic, but you can only expect people who already believe in a right to the private ownership of the means of production to agree with you. Socialists do not believe in capitalist private property and therefore understand its abolition as liberation for the masses. I reject your illogic. Marx himself said that the implementation of Communism would involve the state making "despotic inroads on the rights of property." (Marx's own words. And if that is a bad translation, feel free to link me to a better one. I pulled that off a Marxist site.) And I would argue that any state which can forcibly redistribute property as being in fact despotic, no matter how benignly you try to spin this. It in effect gives the state absolute power over everyone's possessions. Appealing to the idol of "Democracy" does not change this. Democracy and despotism are not necessarily mutually exclusive. A majority can easily decide to violate the rights of the minority. (Or as someone, I believe Ben Franklin, put it, "Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner.") Presumably, the "bourgeois" have no say in how the Communist state forcibly re-organizes and re-distributes property. Marx advocated one group of people ("the proletariat") committing violence against another group of people ("the bourgeois.") You can assert that a Communist government abolishing private property is inherently righteous but you can only expect people who already believe in the rightness of the Communist state to agree with you. Non-socialists believe in the right to private property, and therefore understand its forcible abolition as state tyranny over all.
Winchester Posted June 29, 2014 Posted June 29, 2014 Any state could be said to involve "cooperation among individuals" (recalls Barney Frank's inane remark that "government is simply the name we give to things we choose to do together") If you include "Do this or I throw you in a cage" as "cooperation", then I suppose you're right.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now