ToJesusMyHeart Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 From the article below: "A transgender trailblazer is hoping to be accepted into the Catholic church - as a nun. Tia Pesando was living as a man named Ted. She tells her story in the book, God Doesn’t Hate You. If she does become a nun, she would be the first transgender one in the world. Tia Pesando, who wants to become a nun, speaks with CTV News in London, Ont. on Monday, July 7, 2014. Born a hermaphrodite - somebody with hormones and at times biological parts of both genders - she says she always felt trapped. “I'm on a hormone replacement regiment to balance things,†she says. Now, living as a woman, Pesando wants to enter into a domain that's reserved exclusively for females. So far, the Catholic Church has been silent. Two years ago Pesando heard God calling her and she knew she had to take her transformation farther. “I’m very convinced of the reality of God and the importance of such a calling,†she says. http://london.ctvnews.ca/call-to-religious-life-strong-for-transgender-londoner-1.1903042
ToJesusMyHeart Posted July 16, 2014 Author Posted July 16, 2014 Perhaps belongs in Debate. I guess we'll see.
Nunsense Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 There was a thread about something similar (not exactly the same situation) before... Gender Reassignment
Credo in Deum Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 (edited) My prediction: the Church will state this person does not have a calling. This person will not take this as an answer from God and will protest. The populace and a majority of Catholics who are ignorant of the faith -and who think people become religious as easy as applying for a job at Target- will claim this is bigotry and that we are try to ruin this person's dreams. The End. Edited July 16, 2014 by Credo in Deum
CatherineM Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 Not the same as a transgender. Intersexed or indeterminate gender is considered a birth defect, and those born that way are allowed to have surgery to fix the defect.
cmaD2006 Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 There is a similar question in Q&A right now. Also I think one of the Church Scholars had answered that the issues are different -- one issue is when it is a flat out reassignment from male/female or female/male or where the person is choosing to dress as the opposite sex without any reassignment surgery/hormones. It is a different distinct issue when there is a physical issue where there is gender ambiguity. That's definitely not the same as "transgender".
cmaD2006 Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 ... and CatherineM said it much more succinctly and in a better way than I did. And I forgot to say that I thought the Church allowed someone with a gender ambiguity to correct it. Heh that's why she's a Church Scholar and I'm not :)
Nihil Obstat Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 Hermaphroditism is an extremely difficult topic from a theological/philosophical perspective. I thank God I do not have to carry that particular cross.
ToJesusMyHeart Posted July 16, 2014 Author Posted July 16, 2014 Not the same as a transgender. Intersexed or indeterminate gender is considered a birth defect, and those born that way are allowed to have surgery to fix the defect. Is it different since this person waited until after high school to "correct" the birth defect and become female? In the video at the top of the article I posted they say "she lived most of her life as a man." So it wasn't like she was born with indeterminate gender and it was immediately "corrected."
Nihil Obstat Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 Is it different since this person waited until after high school to "correct" the birth defect and become female? In the video at the top of the article I posted they say "she lived most of her life as a man." So it wasn't like she was born with indeterminate gender and it was immediately "corrected." I would be venturing way into speculative territory here, but perhaps in their attempt to correct the indeterminate gender at birth, they 'picked wrong', in some sense. Perhaps, at least.
ToJesusMyHeart Posted July 16, 2014 Author Posted July 16, 2014 I would be venturing way into speculative territory here, but perhaps in their attempt to correct the indeterminate gender at birth, they 'picked wrong', in some sense. Perhaps, at least. Could be! Thanks for daring to venture.
cmaD2006 Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 I would be venturing way into speculative territory here, but perhaps in their attempt to correct the indeterminate gender at birth, they 'picked wrong', in some sense. Perhaps, at least. Heh. I almost went there too. Same line of reasoning that I went down. But we don't know the full story right?
cmaD2006 Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 Is it different since this person waited until after high school to "correct" the birth defect and become female? In the video at the top of the article I posted they say "she lived most of her life as a man." So it wasn't like she was born with indeterminate gender and it was immediately "corrected." Actually one of the keys that you posted was the word hermaphrodite. That is the difference between "living most of her life as a man" and being a physical man vs. "living most of her life as a man" and being a person whose gender is indeterminate (hermaphrodite).
Nihil Obstat Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 Heh. I almost went there too. Same line of reasoning that I went down. But we don't know the full story right? I want to avoid trying to come to any concrete conclusions, because stories of this sort are particularly susceptible to spin and distortion.
1054 Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 It would be interesting to know if Tia considers herself transgendered or whether that was included by the journalist. In my mind the pastoral care for a transgendered individual and a hermaphrodite would be quite different, but then that is pure speculation as I have no personal experience in this matter. It seems to me the only quotation where she mentions the LGBT community is: “Forgiveness needs to begin somewhere,†she says. “It needs to begin with us, all of us, those in the LGBT community and those of the Christian faith.†From the article we don't know whether she says this in response to a specific question asked or because she feels part of this community. I suppose the answers on how she views her situation would most likely be included in her book...
blazeingstar Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 This is where I think the "lgbtq" community has gone too far. This poor person was born with ambiguous genitalia. There must be other tests, like DNA that would help determine what sex is the legitimate one. Even so, with the questions, there is the right to choose. Parents should not be making the decision.
CrossCuT Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 (edited) I have no problems with it. Theyve had a hard card handed to them but I dont see why it would make them less able to devote their spiritual life to Christ in the form of a religious calling. Edited July 16, 2014 by CrossCuT
Perigrina Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 This is a good example of how the media distorts things. This person is not a "transgender trailblazer." Portraying this person's condition as transgenderism is a way to cloud the issue. Transgenderism is a psychological disorder analogous to anorexia - the person's self perception does not match reality. http://online.wsj.com/articles/paul-mchugh-transgender-surgery-isnt-the-solution-1402615120 Quote The transgendered suffer a disorder of "assumption" like those in other disorders familiar to psychiatrists. With the transgendered, the disordered assumption is that the individual differs from what seems given in nature—namely one's maleness or femaleness. Other kinds of disordered assumptions are held by those who suffer from anorexia and bulimia nervosa, where the assumption that departs from physical reality is the belief by the dangerously thin that they are overweight. With body dysmorphic disorder, an often socially crippling condition, the individual is consumed by the assumption "I'm ugly." These disorders occur in subjects who have come to believe that some of their psycho-social conflicts or problems will be resolved if they can change the way that they appear to others. Such ideas work like ruling passions in their subjects' minds and tend to be accompanied by a solipsistic argument. Quote You won't hear it from those championing transgender equality, but controlled and follow-up studies reveal fundamental problems with this movement. When children who reported transgender feelings were tracked without medical or surgical treatment at both Vanderbilt University and London's Portman Clinic, 70%-80% of them spontaneously lost those feelings. Some 25% did have persisting feelings; what differentiates those individuals remains to be discerned. Quote A 2011 study at the Karolinska Institute in Sweden produced the most illuminating results yet regarding the transgendered, evidence that should give advocates pause. The long-term study—up to 30 years—followed 324 people who had sex-reassignment surgery. The study revealed that beginning about 10 years after having the surgery, the transgendered began to experience increasing mental difficulties. Most shockingly, their suicide mortality rose almost 20-fold above the comparable nontransgender population. This disturbing result has as yet no explanation but probably reflects the growing sense of isolation reported by the aging transgendered after surgery. The high suicide rate certainly challenges the surgery prescription.
Hemma Posted July 16, 2014 Posted July 16, 2014 I was thinking about how important it could be to become a nun instead of a monk. There's not necessarily a big difference in the style of living. However if it is clear to the person that she feels attracted (if any) to men and not to women, she shouldn't enter a male convent. Sorry if this is too practically in thinking.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now