Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

First Transgender Nun?


Recommended Posts

Credo in Deum
Posted

I think this is a private matter that was made public for no other reason than sensationalism. I think Tia, knowing the times we live in, should have practiced prudence and kept this private. I think the article cares little for the call to religious life and more about pushing the LGBT(insert letter here)'s agenda into the Church.

Posted

Props to Perigrina for the information! 

blazeingstar
Posted

I think this is a private matter that was made public for no other reason than sensationalism. I think Tia, knowing the times we live in, should have practiced prudence and kept this private. I think the article cares little for the call to religious life and more about pushing the LGBT(insert letter here)'s agenda into the Church.

 

Which is why the LGBTQ crowd is so dangerous.  This is not an issue for them to really be dealing with, yet they have sunk their tentacles into this situation and around this woman so that there is no hope of her ever living a normal life.  

Posted

But does hermaphroditism even exist? Do not DNA tell something about people's sex/gender? Do Church look at medical professionals in order to solve this problem?

 

There are conditions in which there are genitals of both sexes and conditions in which apparent sex does not match DNA.  These are physical conditions that require physical treatments.  Of course, the Church expects medical professionals to deal with them.

 

The article cited in the OP tries to make people think that this is comparable to people with a psychological condition in which they perceive themselves as a sex other than the one of their body.  The article is an example of blatant agenda pushing.

Posted

Which is why the LGBTQ crowd is so dangerous.  This is not an issue for them to really be dealing with, yet they have sunk their tentacles into this situation and around this woman so that there is no hope of her ever living a normal life.  

 

Irony overload :O

blazeingstar
Posted

Irony overload :o

 

Sexual organs are a private matter.  the LGBTQ crowd has made sex a public issue.  Quite frankly, it's not. 

 

This person has a legitimate claim to both genders.  At birth, adults decided that masculitity was the best choice.  Apparently, it's not.

 

Rather than handling this in a modest, quiet way, that would of allowed this woman to quielty live her life and transition to the gender that allows her to fill her vocation.  While her superiors could be aware, no one else needs to know.

 

But to the LGBTQ crowd this is seen as some kind of sick victory that a transgender man became a woman and is now discerning being a nun.  The problem is that she was never a man, and therefore never transgender.  If allowed to enter a convent it will be because she has risen above her physical abnormalities, not because she altered her body to go with her beliefs.

Posted

I dont think they are intending to make their sexual organs a public matter..thats more a result of them making their identity a public matter.

blazeingstar
Posted

I dont think they are intending to make their sexual organs a public matter..thats more a result of them making their identity a public matter.

 

In the case of hermaphodites, born with ambiguous genetalia, the gender situation is far different than a person who feels they are the other gender but has non-ambiguous genetlia. 

 

For instance, the little girl in Califiornia who's being raised as a boy could never enter a monistary.  She will always be a girl.  The saddest thing is that this pre-pubescent child is being forced deeper into gender roles and being praised for being "a natural boy" at things like waterskiing and karate, which are not gender-bound.

 

I degress.Transgender comes with the implication that a person was born with genetlia incompatible to their feelings.  This is not the case in this story and it is being overtaken as such.

Posted

It's not really transgender if you're a hermaphrodite.

 

In doubtful matters, charity?

Credo in Deum
Posted

It's not really transgender if you're a hermaphrodite.

In doubtful matters, charity?


Who are you and what have you done with Winchester!?
Anastasia13
Posted

Not the same as a transgender. Intersexed or indeterminate gender is considered a birth defect, and those born that way are allowed to have surgery to fix the defect.

I was about  to say...

 

Do you suppose the Churc  would check Tia`s DNA to see what her sex should have been?

fides' Jack
Posted

Since this is public, I would imagine that it's reasonable to say that Tia's condition would preclude him/her from entering a religious order.  There is so much misinformation out there that allowing it could cause public scandal, which the Church must avoid.

Posted

Who are you and what have you done with Winchester!?

 

I don't often have doubts. I pretty much know when people are assholes, so I don't have to resort to charity as often as stupid people.

Posted

Sexual organs are a private matter.  the LGBTQ crowd has made sex a public issue.  Quite frankly, it's not. 

 

 

Oh.  So the LGBT crowd made sodomy a crime?  Seems to me that it was the folks who started criminalizing private sexual behavior are the ones who made sex a public issue.

brandelynmarie
Posted

Since this is public, I would imagine that it's reasonable to say that Tia's condition would preclude him/her from entering a religious order. There is so much misinformation out there that allowing it could cause public scandal, which the Church must avoid.


If she would step out of the limelight, she could enter somewhere quietly & privately perhaps...
Posted

Some of the comments about her decision to be public seem unduly harsh. Medically it's quite rare for people to be born intersex, but intersex Catholics do exist, and for any faithful Catholic vocation is a burning question. What do we say to them? Everybody else gets room to talk on Vocation Station and is free to unload on blogs or give interviews to interested journos, but intersex Catholics have to keep their discernment super-private because it concerns genitals? Or what? Many people have written articles about entering convents with a disability or with a highly unusual background (the Dominican Sisters of Bethany have made a point of including ex-prisoners right from their foundation, for example) and even though these articles involved personal disclosure, no one censured the writers - they saw that the writers wanted to reach out to other people in their own position. What does it cost us to believe the best intentions of this woman, that she is devout and that she hopes others may be helped by her story?

Credo in Deum
Posted

If she would step out of the limelight, she could enter somewhere quietly & privately perhaps...


Bingo! I'm not saying I'm for or against Tia entering a convent. That is up to the Church to decide. What I am for is Tia doing exactly what you mentioned and getting herself out of the limelight, especially after reading the story and seeing how the media has clearly twisted it in order to push their LGBTQ agenda when they called a hermaphrodite a "transexual trailblazer". IMO the fact that Tia even allowed this interview is suspicious.
brandelynmarie
Posted (edited)

I'm guessing she feels supported by the LGTB community,, whereas a person not born intersexed has no clue what it's like for her...

That being said, propping Credo from down here. :)

Tia, if you happen to read this, praying for you that God's will be done in you & please pray for us! :pray: :amen:

Edited by brandelynmarie
brandelynmarie
Posted

Propping Beatitude, too. :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...