Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Chaste Same-sex Relationship


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Tardis, I don't know if you know of the website spiritualfriendship.org, they explore the possibility of the sort of thing you are talking about. There's a couple other websites too, but that one tends to be the best, in my opinion. I have a friend who I am pretty sure is in a similar sort of relationship, and I've given some thought to this idea, in terms of his situation and in general. My own two cents (which are rather meaningless, considering I'm not involved) is that this sort of thing could very much become a near occasion of sin, but that isn't to say it's a sin itself. However, all the great saints of the spiritual life (I'm thinking especially of St. Teresa of Avila) talk of the importance of eliminating these near occasions for spiritual perfection. 

 

Regardless, I wish you nothing but the best; know that you are in my prayers. I can't really imagine the sort of loneliness that you and others have faced, knowing myself I'm probably not strong enough to carry that cross, and I have tremendous respect for you and others who do. 

 

Edit: Ha! This is what I get for not reading before I post. Oh well. This won't be the last redundant post I make on phatmass. 

Edited by Amppax
Posted

Tardis, I don't know if you know of the website spiritualfriendship.org, they explore the possibility of the sort of thing you are talking about. There's a couple other websites too, but that one tends to be the best, in my opinion. I have a friend who I am pretty sure is in a similar sort of relationship, and I've given some thought to this idea, in terms of his situation and in general. My own two cents (which are rather meaningless, considering I'm not involved) is that this sort of thing could very much become a near occasion of sin, but that isn't to say it's a sin itself. However, all the great saints of the spiritual life (I'm thinking especially of St. Teresa of Avila) talk of the importance of eliminating these near occasions for spiritual perfection. 

 

Regardless, I wish you nothing but the best; know that you are in my prayers. I can't really imagine the sort of loneliness that you and others have faced, knowing myself I'm probably not strong enough to carry that cross, and I have tremendous respect for you and others who do. 

 

Edit: Ha! This is what I get for not reading before I post. Oh well. This won't be the last redundant post I make on phatmass. 

 

Not redundant but a good post  :blowkiss: 

Posted

Not redundant but a good post  :blowkiss: 

 

Haha, thanks Father!

Posted

I appreciate all of the responses.  

 

I am quite aware of the occasion for sin. Believe me, it wasn't something I just jumped into for no good reason.

 

The loneliness, though, is what prompted me to look into the possibility.  I was not created to be alone. And while I am aware that God made man and woman for each other, I was not created for that particular purpose. I can find love, however. Non-erotic love. With another man. Hence the chastity. We are both chaste. 

 

I understand the apprehension. But its a very gray area. Just keep in mind that I am not sexually active, and we both look to God for our strength to be close friends without falling to the temptations of the flesh.

 

I appreciate the prayers and know I am praying for all of you as well.

 

 

Just date.

Lilllabettt
Posted

Just date.

 

 

this is me inviting you to elaborate on what you mean by your advice to "just date" so that the publicly identified catholic priest who propped your post can be crystal clear about what he is cheering on.

Posted

this is me inviting you to elaborate on what you mean by your advice to "just date" so that the publicly identified catholic priest who propped your post can be crystal clear about what he is cheering on.

 

 

Embark on a romantic relationship.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

this is me inviting you to elaborate on what you mean by your advice to "just date" so that the publicly identified catholic priest who propped your post can be crystal clear about what he is cheering on.

Ah, I am not the only one who was a bit taken aback.

Posted

Ah, I am not the only one who was a bit taken aback.

 

Same here. 

Posted

Something's just not kosher about this

Lilllabettt
Posted

Ah, I am not the only one who was a bit taken aback.

 

 

1. Thank you for chiming in. Seriously much appreciated.

2. I strive not to get out my jump to conclusions mat. Prudence is a judgment call, after all. We all have different ideas do we not.

Posted

I'm always on the mobile edition where you can't see props.

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

Interesting that this would come up. A movie recently came out called Desire of the Everlasting Hills. It's actually very well done documentary done by the Courage apostolate. The style and execution is actually beautifully done.

 

http://everlastinghills.org/movie/

http://www.ncregister.com/daily-news/review-desire-of-the-everlasting-hills/

 

One of the speakers, Paul, does briefly allude to having a companion in his life that he apparently once had a sexual relationship with. But he does not go into specifics about it except for the fact that their relationship actually improved with chastity. But very little else is said about it, what their living arrangements are or the nature of their relationship (it's not exlusively what the documentary was about so that's probably why). But I think it's good to see things like this come up because we have plenty of resources about chastity and boundaries of companionship for heterosexual men and women, but I haven't seen a lot for people with same sex attraction.

 

I think as a Church, are entering into some new and uncharted territory about how to socially address Catholics (who actually want to be practicing Catholics) with same sex attraction.

 

Up until now, for the most part I've seen either:

1. the approach of heterodox parishes that want to be inclusive but aren't authentic and compromise the teachings of the Church. But like a soft parent, they fail to protect their child, and in the end, the child no longer takes you all that seriously.

 

2. Catholics that are uncomfortable and socially constipated about the whole thing, don't want to discuss it and pretty much tell SSA Catholics more or less that they need to be chaste but don't offer a lot of support about it. Many would just as soon see them quietly swept under a rug to live lives of loneliness and isolation.

 

Nothing can take the place of the sacraments, but at the end of the day, everyone still needs companionship and to know that they are loved by other human beings, and we need to find better ways to address this.

 

Some of the Catholics in The Third Way (another movie about chastity -- http://www.blackstonefilms.org/films/the-third-way/) make very good points -- many Catholics with these inclinations flock to the gay scene to fulfill a need for belonging, family, and companionship. Catholics and parishes need to find a better way to openly discuss and provide a social alternative to that.

 

Anyway, I just thought I'd pass along both films because I had recently seen them and gave me a lot to think about. I will pray for you, my friend Tardar Sauce, it's not just a grey area for you but for a lot of us.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Posted

Tardis,

 

While I support your decision I do understand the sentiments of the others when they say that being so close to someone will naturally nurture stronger emotional feelings of attraction. While I do not find anything sinful about the love you have for another person, I do understand that you feel physical relationship with the same sex it is wrong and that you feel you are called to a chaste life. I do not believe that anyone should be alone if they do not wish to be but I hope that your decision does not weight down on your spiritual life and cause you pain in that sense. I am definitely someone who knows what it is like to feel the pain of being at odds with what you grew up believing and it can be a tough thing to handle emotionally. But you seem pretty settled in your thoughts and that I am glad that it is something you put a lot of thought into! Shows you are a very intelligent and mature individual. I commend you! 

 

:love:

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Well, it seems that the 'strange prop' is gone now. :P

Posted

Something's just not kosher halal about this

fixed for you

Posted

fixed for you


Don't be anti-Semetic
ChristianGirlForever
Posted

Just wanted to say that a relationship between two people in love is still a relationship whether they are sleeping together or not. Maybe it's viewed differently in the homosexual world. I don't know.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Well, here are my thoughts on the subject if anyone wants them.

I am a guy, heterosexual, and married. Obviously married people can still find other people attractive. That in and of itself is not a problem. We have a fair number of mutual friends, and objectively speaking I would say that some of them are quite attractive. Again, this is not a problem in and of itself.

What would be a problem would be if I found one friend who is not my wife to be particularly attractive, and were to then seek out that person's company in ways that go beyond the already-established uncontroversial friendship.

It would be very seriously wrong for me to form some kind of intimate attachment to this other person, even if the relationship was never physical. This would be emotional infidelity.

The way I see it, there is a major similarity between a married person and a person attracted to the same sex. That is, both groups must exercise self-control with regards to their attractions. For a married man, he must recognize the fact that he can never establish a romantic/intimate relationship with a woman who is not his wife. I think that likewise a man who is attracted to other men cannot be encouraged to establish a romantic relationship, even a non-physical one, with another man. I believe that chastity requires, according to their specific states in life, that these attractions are not encouraged. They need not be denied; we do not have to pretend we do not experience them. But we should not entertain them, because such encouragement IMO constitutes an offense against chastity.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...