Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Chaste Same-sex Relationship


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

The one thing you wont ever have to experience is the seclusion and loneliness that Tardis experiences since you are already in happy relationship with someone you love and care for. So I wouldnt jump too far to say you two are similar. 

Edited by CrossCuT
KnightofChrist
Posted

Tardis, I hope I do not cause offense by saying this... but I believe this attempt at finding middle ground between your love for faith, and love for your friend will in the end hurt you and your friend. Thinking of someone as a boyfriend or as girlfriend when they are not actually our boyfriend or girlfriend is something that should be avoided. Even for a heterosexuals such a arrangement would risk being unhealthy. Because many times reality comes crashing in and people get hurt because what the wanted to believe what that thought was not reality.  

The Bus Station
Posted

As long as he's not an underwear model ...

Nihil Obstat
Posted

The one thing you wont ever have to experience is the seclusion and loneliness that Tardis experiences since you are already in happy relationship with someone you love and care for. So I wouldnt jump too far to say you two are similar. 

Why does everyone have so much trouble understanding how comparisons work? To compare an aspect shared by two situations is meaningful only if those two situations are in other relevant wants dissimilar. What I said was, and I quote: "there is a major similarity between a married person and a person attracted to the same sex."

Frankly it is starting to bother me how often people imply that comparisons of this sort are somehow lacking if the two situations being compared are not perfectly identical in every relevant way.

Posted

I didnt say you were not similar. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

You implied the comparison was deficient because we do not share a particular, irrelevant, similarity.

Posted (edited)

No I was pointing out that while the situation of entering into a possible forbidden relationship is completely different in the sense that he cannot ever form a romantic relationship with someone he cares for where as you can. So even while you can throw out two situations that have a "forbidden" love aspect to them, his is significantly different than your own in that the option will never be available. You could presumably leave your current wife, get a divorce/annulment, and seek to continue the relationship you developed with the other person if you so chose.

 

And maybe im being overly sensitive but it came off as very disingenuous to me. 

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted

No I was pointing out that while the situation of entering into a possible forbidden relationship is completely different in the sense that he cannot ever form a romantic relationship with someone he cares for where as you can. So even while you can throw out two situations that have a "forbidden" love aspect to them, his is significantly different than your own in that the option will never be available. You could presumably leave your current wife, get a divorce/annulment, and seek to continue the relationship you developed with the other person if you so chose.

 

And maybe im being overly sensitive but it came off as very disingenuous to me. 

 

Relax, you're being oversensitive and completely (well not completely, but mostly) missing his point. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

If I could simply "get an annulment", then I would not at this moment be married, and therefore my example would no longer apply.

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

I consider him my "boyfriend," in the world of my mind..

I am quite aware of the occasion for sin. Believe me, it wasn't something I just jumped into for no good reason..

I consider him my boyfriend in that we are only "seeing" each other.

I simply wanted to share with my phamily something that is part of my life, something that I have prayed about, something that allows me to share my love with someone else without destroying my soul.

My friend no one puts themselves in an occasion of sin because they perceive evil, but rather because they perceive a good. I'm sure St. Peter went to the trial with St. John, not with the intent to deny Christ, but rather because he saw an opportunity to do something good for Him. However due to human weakness he fell, like all of us do when we put ourselves in an occasion of sin, because at the end of the day there isn't a "good" reason to put ones self in such an occasion.

I quoted the parts above because I believe they show the "red flags" so to speak regarding the situation. I believe you have shown by your own words that this is more than a strong friendship, and that you know it can be an occasion of sin for you. I hope you will take some more time and pray about this and I hope you seek the advice of your spiritual director or parish priest in this matter.

God bless. Edited by Credo in Deum
Nihil Obstat
Posted

It bears mentioning - I have been taught specifically that intentionally putting oneself in a near occasion of mortal sin is itself mortally sinful.

Credo in Deum
Posted

You have been taught correctly.

Fidei Defensor
Posted (edited)

It bears mentioning - I have been taught specifically that intentionally putting oneself in a near occasion of mortal sin is itself mortally sinful.

If I had an unquenchable sex drive and was purposely throwing him into bed, then I would consider it a mortally sinful occasion of sin. This is not the case. Hanging out with him isn't an occasion to sin. I said I was aware that it could be one, but it's not always one.

 

I don't mind using the term boyfriend because it describes what the relationship essentially is — emotional support, companionship, helping each other achieve greater holiness through prayer and the sacraments. I realize most of you don't like me using that word, but it's my prerogative. 

 

I should reiterate that he is also a Catholic, he also attends Mass regularly, he is a prayerful person. It's not as if I just chose any old person off the street and said "hey, lets have a gay relationship!"

 

At the same time, I understand what it being said. But I take a different view of life, that I have one worth living and my love is worth sharing with others, including the possibility of a relationship with another man, albeit a very different relationship than how a relationship is traditionally understood.

Edited by tardis ad astra
Posted

Yea I kinda told myself something similar about a yoga instructor I was seeing, just going to be platonic... yea... platonic... 

Credo in Deum
Posted

Yea I kinda told myself something similar about a yoga instructor I was seeing, just going to be platonic... yea... platonic... 

 

You downward facing dog, you. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Do you two have spiritual directors? Something like that might be especially helpful in a complex situation like yours. It's good that the two of you are practicing Catholics and have similar priorities like maintaining chastity. But having a third party can really help keep everyone accountable. It's sometimes hard to see the reality of any relationship from the inside, especially if something does go wrong. Even just making sure you yourself have one can be great. :)

LittleWaySoul
Posted

Do you two have spiritual directors? Something like that might be especially helpful in a complex situation like yours. It's good that the two of you are practicing Catholics and have similar priorities like maintaining chastity. But having a third party can really help keep everyone accountable. It's sometimes hard to see the reality of any relationship from the inside, especially if something does go wrong. Even just making sure you yourself have one can be great. :)

This is a reeeeeally good idea! :smile3:

Posted

Do you two have spiritual directors? Something like that might be especially helpful in a complex situation like yours. It's good that the two of you are practicing Catholics and have similar priorities like maintaining chastity. But having a third party can really help keep everyone accountable. It's sometimes hard to see the reality of any relationship from the inside, especially if something does go wrong. Even just making sure you yourself have one can be great. :)

 

Good idea as long as the SD is not "too pastoral"   :evil: 

OnlySunshine
Posted

Good idea as long as the SD is not "too pastoral"   :evil: 

 

Everytime someone uses the word "pastoral," my mind immediately goes to cows grazing in the pasture.  :hehe2:

 

Dutch-Cow-Shutterstock.jpg

Posted

My mind goes to

 

[youtube]http://youtu.be/t2VY33VXnrQ[/youtube]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...