Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

blazeingstar
Posted (edited)

Its ok not to get it. :(

 

There's nothing to get.  Thats the thing.  You're all about correlation, causation and evidence.  A photo is not evidence to condemn and compare the two women.  As free people, we should be disgusted that this comparison has been made, no matter our political leanings.

 

If anything, from this picture we should learn that not everyone gets the freedoms we are afforded.

 

I once spoke to a woman who worked in a school teaching ESL.  Some of the children wouldn't speak to her and found her frightening.  She's just about the gentelest, kindess, sweetest person ever so I asked why as she told her story.  After much time working with the group and asking, one little boy burst into tears and cried, "Pappa, pappa," and pointed to her crucifix.  The little boy's grandmother explained that her son, his father had been crucified for stealing food and the reminder was too much.

 

She went out and purchased a miraculous medal to wear, and then purchased some for the family.  She told the story of Jesus that they'd never heard before (they were from Africa).  She apologized for causing them hurt that they related such a tragic and unnecessary death to Jesus.

 

Now Jesus wasn't at all like an African man in the 1950's.  It would be unfair to say that He was.  The crucifix reminded those who had a tramautic encounter.

 

So perhaps, if anything, the woman in the photo should be more careful to those who have been attacked or killed by terrorists and shouldn't of posed in a way that could be construde as going into battle.  However, I don't think the pose was anything symbolic like crucifixion is.

Edited by blazeingstar
Posted

This is not evidence, this is not fact Blazey. Its just something interesting to think about. Im not claiming anything by posting this.

 

clam_down_by_sketchinetch-d5t7afk.png

blazeingstar
Posted (edited)

This is not evidence, this is not fact Blazey. Its just something interesting to think about. Im not claiming anything by posting this.

 

 

 

Well, I'm not really upset, and posting giant pictures is a really poor defence and a straw man.

 

And sorry, you are claiming something, you're claiming I don't "get it" that this is a good talking point about extremism.  The photo isn't a talking point about extremism, it's a tirade against an everyday conservative woman who did something funny, something that liberals hate.  Talking point about extremism....how about comparing the Aribic photo to call of duty?  How about comparing the photo to one of the occupy wall st protesters who stole food from the homeless?  How about comparing the photo to the president with the phone in one hand, pen in the other, calling troops away from the very people that this woman murdered, and signing laws that take money from the chic'fil'a girl?  Anything would be a better conversation piece.

 

You seem stuck in the fact that this is some kind of evidence of American extremism.  But all it is is a happy 20 something girl with a flag, gun and Bible who has no intention of ever hurting a fly, nevermind blowing herself to bits.

 

Edited by blazeingstar
Posted

You seem stuck in the fact that this is some kind of evidence of American extremism.  

no

blazeingstar
Posted

no

 

Err ummmm....then how is it "irony" (your first reply)

 

And less than 20 minutes ago you wrote

 

Posted Today, 06:17 PM

. Its a parallel meant to make you think about some of common characteristics of extremists groups.

 

If you're going to have a point, please just try remember what you just wrote a whole 58 minutes ago.

Posted

I know what Ive said. I cant help it that youve come to the wrong conclusion 

blazeingstar
Posted (edited)

I know what Ive said. I cant help it that youve come to the wrong conclusion 

 

Believe it or not, I do get what you're saying.  You are treating this as some sort of case study/talking point for radicalization and extremism by paralleling these two women.

 

What I'm saying is that thesis/talking point/parallel is invalid and a dangerous attitude towards vilifying a segment of the American culture you may not agree with.

 

So basically, I'm saying, you're wrong.  These pictures show nothing besides tendency towards the internet to be mean-spirited towards someone who acts differently than them and to imply all sorts of terrible things about that person, dehumanizing them.

Edited by blazeingstar
Posted

My arabic sux and my mom's vision is poor. Together we were able to gather that it's about a woman being raped in a bullet-proof cop car. I don't think that's accurate. 

 

lol that's kinda what I got with the help of google translate.

 

It's likely referring to something else.

Posted

thanks for trying though, you two. :) 

Posted

 . . 

And sorry, you are claiming something, you're claiming I don't "get it" that this is a good talking point about extremism.  . . .

 

"Extremism" is a really stupid word.  Often, it's used to simply mean any disagreement with acceptable liberal/progressive opinion, and discredit opposing views by lumping together those with un-pc views with murderous crazies.

 

 

A member of a mass-murdering terrorist organization, a peaceful person who's strongly pro-life or supportive of 2nd amendment rights, and a devout Catholic who actually believes Church teachings on sexual morality are "extremists" all, and all eeevvvilllll.

 

It's a way to replace rational argument with mindless labels.

Perhaps we should restrict the word to only refer to people into extreme sports and such.

Posted

So why are we supposed to care about this silly picture anyway, much less spend three pages arguing about it?

 

This is as dumb as the "Republican Jesus" thread.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...