Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Not To Disappoint You


Recommended Posts

Posted

Soft rock.

That would be a bit anachronistic. More like rock and roll.
PhuturePriest
Posted

That would be a bit anachronistic. More like rock and roll.

 

Whatever it is, it doesn't sound very good. It needs a lot more distortion, not to mention cowbell.

Posted

Slappo, did you mean siesta? I'm having a hard time believing that the Carmel had a daily fiesta. 

Err... yes fiesta with an S at the beginning.... *siesta.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

Whatever it is, it doesn't sound very good. It needs a lot more distortion, not to mention cowbell.

 

Obviously, your ears are not yet fully developed. It's partly your age and partly lack of experience/exposure to various genres of music. Experience takes time, and doesn't mean simply listening to a particular artist once or twice. Sometimes it takes a LONG time. I was easily old enough to be your mother before I truly appreciated Bob Dylan, despite the fact that one of his songs was sung in place of a valedictory address at my high school graduation. In some areas I am "gifted," in others I am a slow learner. Based on that, I'll ask you in 20 or 30 years what you think.

 

In the meantime, don't quickly dismiss music that you aren't familiar with. For example, to call (the late) Roy Orbison "soft rock" is not only incorrect but downright heretical. He's a legend.
 

Posted

Obviously, your ears are not yet fully developed. It's partly your age and partly lack of experience/exposure to various genres of music. Experience takes time, and doesn't mean simply listening to a particular artist once or twice. Sometimes it takes a LONG time. I was easily old enough to be your mother before I truly appreciated Bob Dylan, despite the fact that one of his songs was sung in place of a valedictory address at my high school graduation. In some areas I am "gifted," in others I am a slow learner. Based on that, I'll ask you in 20 or 30 years what you think.

In the meantime, don't quickly dismiss music that you aren't familiar with. For example, to call (the late) Roy Orbison "soft rock" is not only incorrect but downright heretical. He's a legend.


Translation: shut yo face.
PhuturePriest
Posted

Obviously, your ears are not yet fully developed. It's partly your age and partly lack of experience/exposure to various genres of music. Experience takes time, and doesn't mean simply listening to a particular artist once or twice. Sometimes it takes a LONG time. I was easily old enough to be your mother before I truly appreciated Bob Dylan, despite the fact that one of his songs was sung in place of a valedictory address at my high school graduation. In some areas I am "gifted," in others I am a slow learner. Based on that, I'll ask you in 20 or 30 years what you think.

 

In the meantime, don't quickly dismiss music that you aren't familiar with. For example, to call (the late) Roy Orbison "soft rock" is not only incorrect but downright heretical. He's a legend.
 

 

I enjoy soft music. Gregorian chant is one of my favorite genres.

Posted

I find it very difficult to characterize Gregorian chant as "soft". It is very strong, very purposeful music.

"Soft" is not the same as "no distorted guitars".

Posted (edited)

For instance this song is not 'soft' in any sense of the word, but there is no amplification, certainly no distortion.

 

 

http://youtu.be/a-CnWwbeetE

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Posted

Gogol Bordello is considered "gypsy punk" and makes extensive use of acoustic instruments.

 

http://youtu.be/SkkIwO_X4i4

PhuturePriest
Posted

I find it very difficult to characterize Gregorian chant as "soft". It is very strong, very purposeful music.

"Soft" is not the same as "no distorted guitars".

 

I like powerful music. This is my favorite classical-esque song:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BybTNK9HwWE

 

There are some soft songs I like, but I prefer powerful music that inspires passion and drive in a person.

Posted

I'm still not getting what you mean by "soft."

Posted

I'm still not getting what you mean by "soft."

Probably some criterion every bit as convoluted as his argument that rap does not technically count as music. ;)

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

I like powerful music. This is my favorite classical-esque song:

 

There are some soft songs I like, but I prefer powerful music that inspires passion and drive in a person.

I loved that song. It wasn't originally used in LOTR, however. It came from a movie by the same title made in 2000 about drug additions. The movie title means "funeral song for a dream" and there are many similar versions of it, like Lux Aeterna. The one above is speed up a little. Interesting piece of art though. 

Edited by veritasluxmea
PhuturePriest
Posted

I loved that song. It wasn't originally used in LOTR, however. It came from a movie by the same title made in 2000 about drug additions. The movie title means "funeral song for a dream" and there are many similar versions of it, like Lux Aeterna. The one above is speed up a little. Interesting piece of art though. 

 

The original isn't nearly as hard-hitting as this one is. This one is actually called "Requiem for a Tower", because it is different than the original.

Posted

Well, I'm getting that at some arbitrary level selected by FP, a piece of music shifts from "soft" to "hard" seemingly regardless of the meaning.  This seems more to be about loudness rather than any other meaning. 

Posted

I also know quite a bit of Irish Rebel music from the Troubles that depending on who's playing it would necessarily by this criteria be classified as either, regardless of the words - which are essentially propagandist.  Enough so that they are banned at numerous sporting events, on Aer Lingus, and royally upsets the BBC when one of the tamest rebel songs wins a poll of most important song.  They are catchy, though.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Well, I'm getting that at some arbitrary level selected by FP, a piece of music shifts from "soft" to "hard" seemingly regardless of the meaning.  This seems more to be about loudness rather than any other meaning. 

 

No, not loudness, I'm referring to the sound. The beginning guitar intro to Journeyman is incredibly soft and soothing, whereas the guitar riff to Aces High is very hard-hitting and intense. Soft vs. hard is a matter of not the volume, but the intensity of the music.

Posted

No, not loudness, I'm referring to the sound. The beginning guitar intro to Journeyman is incredibly soft and soothing, whereas the guitar riff to Aces High is very hard-hitting and intense. Soft vs. hard is a matter of not the volume, but the intensity of the music.

This distinction totally falls apart the moment you get out of the soft rock - heavy rock continuum represented by, roughly and just off the top of my head, Barry Manilow to Motorhead. A lot of Irish folk and Irish punk-folk does not fit on that continuum, a lot of 'gypsy punk', a lot of more electronic genres certainly do not fit, chant and baroque as we mentioned. It simply does not make sense to categorize the vast majority of music in this manner.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...