PhuturePriest Posted October 22, 2014 Author Posted October 22, 2014 This distinction totally falls apart the moment you get out of the soft rock - heavy rock continuum represented by, roughly and just off the top of my head, Barry Manilow to Motorhead. A lot of Irish folk and Irish punk-folk does not fit on that continuum, a lot of 'gypsy punk', a lot of more electronic genres certainly do not fit, chant and baroque as we mentioned. It simply does not make sense to categorize the vast majority of music in this manner. Well, isn't this certainly the biggest crisis in the world today. :| Music as a whole is hard to categorize. It will forever be up to opinion, really. Guns N' Roses is considered as hard rock as it gets, and for good reason. Ever heard Welcome to the Jungle? It's about as hard-hitting as you can get. And yet their most famous song is Sweet Child O' Mine, which is not nearly as intense nor hard-hitting, as it is after all what's called a power ballad. There is no ipso-facto way to categorize music. Enya is most certainly not rock music, and Iron Maiden is most certainly not rap. That's pretty much as factual as you can get when categorizing music without falling into opinion, really.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Well, isn't this certainly the biggest crisis in the world today. :| Music as a whole is hard to categorize. It will forever be up to opinion, really. Guns N' Roses is considered as hard rock as it gets, and for good reason. Ever heard Welcome to the Jungle? It's about as hard-hitting as you can get. And yet their most famous song is Sweet Child O' Mine, which is not nearly as intense nor hard-hitting, as it is after all what's called a power ballad. There is no ipso-facto way to categorize music. Enya is most certainly not rock music, and Iron Maiden is most certainly not rap. That's pretty much as factual as you can get when categorizing music without falling into opinion, really. Did you actually just ask if I have ever heard Welcome to the Jungle? :|
truthfinder Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 (edited) FP, could I get a ruling from you on this song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4HgAPpuTk8 Not the best recording. Edited October 22, 2014 by truthfinder
PhuturePriest Posted October 22, 2014 Author Posted October 22, 2014 Did you actually just ask if I have ever heard Welcome to the Jungle? :| I was asking rhetorically. I can't actually imagine a world where a 23+ north American man hadn't actually heard Welcome to the Jungle.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 FP, could I get a ruling from you on this song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4HgAPpuTk8 Not the best recording. Clearly that is light rock, just like Roy Orbison. :| I was asking rhetorically. I can't actually imagine a world where a 23+ north American man hadn't actually heard Welcome to the Jungle. Good save. <_<
truthfinder Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Clearly that is light rock, just like Roy Orbison. :| Good save. <_< Clearly. I had to pick a song without swearing, and a version that also didn't have swearing on the graphics. No guarantees for the comments though. Hadn't heard the Pogue video before.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Clearly. I had to pick a song without swearing, and a version that also didn't have swearing on the graphics. No guarantees for the comments though. Hadn't heard the Pogue video before. It is too bad that Shane McGowan could not keep himself together back when they were more popular. :P They had a really great thing going for a while. I cannot post it here, but I always listen to Fairytale of New York around Christmas time. :hehe: This is my favourite of theirs: http://youtu.be/gijSDXhnvlc
PhuturePriest Posted October 22, 2014 Author Posted October 22, 2014 Good save. <_< I can pull off a save if I feel like it. It might interest you that I originally said "25+", but then I thought "No, he's got to be younger than that because he's still in school." I thought 25+ because of your overall demeanor, plus your beard.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 I can pull off a save if I feel like it. It might interest you that I originally said "25+", but then I thought "No, he's got to be younger than that because he's still in school." I thought 25+ because of your overall demeanor, plus your beard. Truthfinder is still in school, and she is over 25. :|
truthfinder Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 I can pull off a save if I feel like it. It might interest you that I originally said "25+", but then I thought "No, he's got to be younger than that because he's still in school." I thought 25+ because of your overall demeanor, plus your beard. Um wow, too old to be in school. I'm now speechless, and am going to do drink an adult beverage. You still haven't responded to the song I posted.
truthfinder Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Truthfinder is still in school, and she is over 25. :| Not quite Nihil. I will still be in school when I'm 25 though.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Not quite Nihil. I will still be in school when I'm 25 though. For some reason I thought you were the same age as Katy.
PhuturePriest Posted October 22, 2014 Author Posted October 22, 2014 Um wow, too old to be in school. I'm now speechless, and am going to do drink an adult beverage. You still haven't responded to the song I posted. It's a matter of averages. Most people finish college by the time they're 22, and if they go for a masters degree, 24. Some people are older, and that's fine. They're simply not in the majority, so it's safe to assume if someone is in college they're likely younger than 25.
PhuturePriest Posted October 22, 2014 Author Posted October 22, 2014 FP, could I get a ruling from you on this song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4HgAPpuTk8 Not the best recording. Folk music sounds just as deficient with an Irish accent as it does an American one. Is that the response you wanted? :|
PhuturePriest Posted October 22, 2014 Author Posted October 22, 2014 Folk music sounds just as deficient with an Irish accent as it does an American one. Is that the response you wanted? :| For some reason I thought you were the same age as Katy. And yes, I was just meaning to antagonize you and your pro-folk music stance with that post. :P
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 (edited) I was asking rhetorically. I can't actually imagine a world where a 23+ north American man hadn't actually heard Welcome to the Jungle. I can. :proud: Millions of American men over 23 have not only never heard Welcome to the Jungle, but have never heard that song title. This also applies to millions of American women, including myself. :cans: It's easy to think of our own experiences as typical. (I'm guilty of that.) But, the longer I live, and the more I have read and traveled, the variations in human experience, and my own ignorance about the lives of others, helps keep me humble. Edited October 22, 2014 by IgnatiusofLoyola
truthfinder Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Folk music sounds just as deficient with an Irish accent as it does an American one. Is that the response you wanted? :| I'm concerned then that you classify that song as folk music, because it is essentially delighting in the shooting down of British soldiers. And it was the "got to be" in your other post that pushed me over. Where I did my undergrad, most students were over 22, some of them were WELL over 22. University demographics are changing, maybe for the better.
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 I can. :proud: Millions of American men over 23 have not only never heard Welcome to the Jungle, but have never heard that song title. This also applies to millions of American women, including myself. :cans: It's easy to think of our own experiences as typical. (I'm guilty of that.) But, the longer I live, and the more I have read and traveled, the variations in human experience, and my own ignorance about the lives of others, helps keep me humble. Corrections to my own post: I can. :proud: I wouldn't be surprised if Millions of North American men over 23 have not only never heard Welcome to the Jungle, but have never heard that song title. This also applies to millions of North American women, including myself. :cans: It's easy to think of our own experiences as typical. (I'm guilty of that.) But, the longer I live, and the more I have read and traveled, the variations in human experience, and my own ignorance about the lives of others, helps keep me humble.
PhuturePriest Posted October 22, 2014 Author Posted October 22, 2014 I'm concerned then that you classify that song as folk music, because it is essentially delighting in the shooting down of British soldiers. And it was the "got to be" in your other post that pushed me over. Where I did my undergrad, most students were over 22, some of them were WELL over 22. University demographics are changing, maybe for the better. Folk music in all cultures delight in things which are undoubtedly bad. Don't we have children's songs about the black death? I'm sorry those choice words made you angry. I'm used to the traditional Catholic college culture, where everyone goes to college immediately and gets engaged before junior year.
truthfinder Posted October 22, 2014 Posted October 22, 2014 Folk music in all cultures delight in things which are undoubtedly bad. Don't we have children's songs about the black death? I'm sorry those choice words made you angry. I'm used to the traditional Catholic college culture, where everyone goes to college immediately and gets engaged before junior year. There's a difference between gleefully, and usually in veiled language, recalling events of the distant past and singing songs which are basically propaganda. I'm glad you understand the difference in college cultures. I'm not entirely sure I've met anyone who did ring by spring. I'll admit that US college culture is undoubtedly very different than in Canada.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now