AuthorOfMyLife Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 Hello, all! I have been a member of Vocation Station for a while, but I didn't my question was appropriate for them, so I came here. This is my question. I make and sell hand-embroidered scapulars (my Etsy shop is here: https://www.etsy.com/shop/StellaMarigoldArt), and I recently had an order from someone referring to herself as a "Pagan," with an email address including "Witches" and "Crone," and with a physical address that led me to a website that advocates and provides psychic readings, Tarot card readings, witchcraft lessons, and so forth. The website claims a devotion to Our Lady, but in a VERY non-Catholic and "new-age" way. (I am not going to be more specific than that, since she is my customer and I don't want to give away private information). My problem is that I'm really struggling with whether or not it is right to send her the scapular. I am aware that my scapulars, since they are not blessed before they are sold, are basically just pieces of embroidered cloth, but they still have the images of the Sacred Heart and the Immaculate Heart on them! What do you think is the best thing to do? A) Refund the money and keep the scapular B) Send the scapular, but inform her that I don't want her to try to purchase anything else from my shop C) Send the scapular and don't say anything Even if I refund the payment, I will have to explain, and I'm not sure what to say. "Sorry, you're involved in some pretty awful stuff and I don't want my scapular in your hands"?!? Also, to be perfectly honest, I'm a little afraid of what she might do to me if she gets angry (since she's so into magic). I don't dismiss this kind of thing as harmless. Thank you so much for reading all this, and thank you in advance for your advice!
brandelynmarie Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 (edited) D) After she pays for it, get it blessed & mail it to her :evil: Then pray for her like crazy! :amen: You'll never know what graces she would be open to... Edited October 20, 2014 by brandelynmarie
PhuturePriest Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 I am good friends with a Wiccan, and he is not vindictive and/or crazy enough to perform a negative magical spell on someone because they didn't do something he wanted. Then again, he isn't into psychic nonsense and tarot cards, so he isn't the same exact type of Wiccan. But yeah, Wiccans/Witches aren't actually as mean and vindictive as the stereotypes and stories suggest, with a witch boiling a deadly potion in her cauldron as she cackles evilly because the local guy at the tavern turned her down.
Gabriela Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 (edited) I understand the concern, and when I first opened the thread, my plan was to write: "DO NOT SEND IT!" But then I thought, "We often hide scapulars in the homes or belongings of heathens in order to bring them the grace of conversion, so obviously the power of the scapular is such that it can overcome even stubborn disbelief." So now I say: SEND IT! :like2: EDIT: And all the honor to you for your conscientious salesmanship! Edited October 20, 2014 by curiousing
AuthorOfMyLife Posted October 20, 2014 Author Posted October 20, 2014 Thank you all so much! Since I have to sew the cord into the scapular, I'm considering sewing a small Green Scapular between the panels! (in the spirit of your post, Brandelynmarie!) Futurepacker, I'm not saying she's automatically vindictive or mean; in fact, she seems very sweet. I just don't dismiss the possibility of resentment, and this person's website persona is very, very misguided. I'm going to go with your advice and SEND the scapular—and pray for her! Thank you again so much,, and thank you, Curiousing, for your kind words about my salesmanship! I will keep this in mind for future orders! God bless you!
Credo in Deum Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 I was going to say the same thing. D.) Send them green scapulars and then say the prayer!
Basilisa Marie Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 Sounds like there's a possibility you're offering her the seeds of conversion. If we all ignored people who needed conversion, no one would be Christian! :) And those scapulars are GORGEOUS!
blazeingstar Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 Hello, all! I have been a member of Vocation Station for a while, but I didn't my question was appropriate for them, so I came here. This is my question. I make and sell hand-embroidered scapulars (my Etsy shop is here: https://www.etsy.com/shop/StellaMarigoldArt), and I recently had an order from someone referring to herself as a "Pagan," with an email address including "Witches" and "Crone," and with a physical address that led me to a website that advocates and provides psychic readings, Tarot card readings, witchcraft lessons, and so forth. The website claims a devotion to Our Lady, but in a VERY non-Catholic and "new-age" way. (I am not going to be more specific than that, since she is my customer and I don't want to give away private information). My problem is that I'm really struggling with whether or not it is right to send her the scapular. I am aware that my scapulars, since they are not blessed before they are sold, are basically just pieces of embroidered cloth, but they still have the images of the Sacred Heart and the Immaculate Heart on them! What do you think is the best thing to do? A) Refund the money and keep the scapular B) Send the scapular, but inform her that I don't want her to try to purchase anything else from my shop C) Send the scapular and don't say anything Even if I refund the payment, I will have to explain, and I'm not sure what to say. "Sorry, you're involved in some pretty awful stuff and I don't want my scapular in your hands"?!? Also, to be perfectly honest, I'm a little afraid of what she might do to me if she gets angry (since she's so into magic). I don't dismiss this kind of thing as harmless. Thank you so much for reading all this, and thank you in advance for your advice! If someone is really willing to drop $50 bucks on a teeny bit of art when they could easily get said art for pennies then don't question it. It's none of your business. You make art....religious art, but art none the less. It's not cheap, either so the chance for "abuse" is pretty minimal
AuthorOfMyLife Posted October 20, 2014 Author Posted October 20, 2014 Sounds like there's a possibility you're offering her the seeds of conversion. If we all ignored people who needed conversion, no one would be Christian! :) And those scapulars are GORGEOUS! Thank you, Basilisa Marie! That's very kind of you! If someone is really willing to drop $50 bucks on a teeny bit of art when they could easily get said art for pennies then don't question it. It's none of your business. You make art....religious art, but art none the less. It's not cheap, either so the chance for "abuse" is pretty minimal You're absolutely right about making art--I was thinking the same thing this morning. I know my customers' private lives aren't my business, and I suppose if I sold hundreds of scapulars a week I wouldn't even notice it. However, since my scapulars take so long to make (5 hours for a $50 scapular, and so on), and therefore are sold in limited numbers at a time, I tend to pay attention to each sale! I just wanted to check to make sure I wasn't doing anything wrong by allowing her to have it.
blazeingstar Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 Thank you, Basilisa Marie! That's very kind of you! You're absolutely right about making art--I was thinking the same thing this morning. I know my customers' private lives aren't my business, and I suppose if I sold hundreds of scapulars a week I wouldn't even notice it. However, since my scapulars take so long to make (5 hours for a $50 scapular, and so on), and therefore are sold in limited numbers at a time, I tend to pay attention to each sale! I just wanted to check to make sure I wasn't doing anything wrong by allowing her to have it. No, infact, it would be quite wrong to deny her sales, mostly becuase you have no idea why she's purchasing it. It could be that her niece/friend/godchild wanted one. My friends at times have purchased Catholic things for me. One was a militant Church of Christ/Baptist who purchased a small Mary night light. I have a wiccan friend who gave me a saint card from a campus retreat at a monastery, she likes it and has one too. You have to remember that it is wrong to deprive a buyer of your product. For instance, this is why I say its wrong for cake makers to deny homosexual couples so long as the couple dosn't ask them to do anything against their faith like put two women on the cake. This is one of the reasons blessed items are not sold as blessed items. I am thoroughly agains any deception on your part, as it is a cruel trick.
cartermia Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 I say send it! Also, you just gave me a great idea for my mom's birthday present in November! She has been looking for a clothe brown scapular since hers became unwearable...
AuthorOfMyLife Posted October 20, 2014 Author Posted October 20, 2014 I say send it! Also, you just gave me a great idea for my mom's birthday present in November! She has been looking for a clothe brown scapular since hers became unwearable... A scapular is a wonderful present! And if any of my scapulars happen to interest you :) , I can easily make a copy of a scapular that has been sold, and I also make special commission scapulars (for example, I made one with St. Michael on it, and another with St. Bernadette).
AuthorOfMyLife Posted October 20, 2014 Author Posted October 20, 2014 No, infact, it would be quite wrong to deny her sales, mostly becuase you have no idea why she's purchasing it. It could be that her niece/friend/godchild wanted one. My friends at times have purchased Catholic things for me. One was a militant Church of Christ/Baptist who purchased a small Mary night light. I have a wiccan friend who gave me a saint card from a campus retreat at a monastery, she likes it and has one too. You have to remember that it is wrong to deprive a buyer of your product. For instance, this is why I say its wrong for cake makers to deny homosexual couples so long as the couple dosn't ask them to do anything against their faith like put two women on the cake. This is one of the reasons blessed items are not sold as blessed items. I am thoroughly agains any deception on your part, as it is a cruel trick. I understand what you're saying, and I agree to some extent. However (and no offense meant as I know online communication is often unclear), your tone is confusing me. Are you saying I am deceiving her? Believe me, if I refused the sale (which I do not intend to do), I would tell her why. And if you are referring to sewing a Green Scapular into this scapular, I don't honestly intend to do that either, however, you should know that if you read Green Scapular literature, you can see it has been used for years to aid spouses, friends, children, etc., very often without that person's knowledge. Such an action does not seem to be considered a "cruel trick." Most importantly, I cannot agree that it is wrong to "deprive" a buyer of my product. No one has the "right" to own my scapulars. If my scapulars were the only scapulars in the world, then, yes, absolutely, I would need to share them freely for the sake of souls. But as it is, scapulars can be purchased in many, many shops online. They may not be hand-embroidered or as one-of-a-kind as mine, but they are available. I am not depriving anyone of the blessing of a scapular. I put a great deal of attention and affection into my work, and I am, above all, respectful of what the images represent. I have a right to withdraw items from my shop. I have a right to decline a special commission request. Customers may indeed be purchasing for someone else, but in that case the customer is at liberty to tell me so if he/she is not happy with my decision. Anyway… rant over... :) I do appreciate your input on this situation, and the input of all the responders here (thank you all!). I feel better about what I should do now.
blazeingstar Posted October 20, 2014 Posted October 20, 2014 I understand what you're saying, and I agree to some extent. However (and no offense meant as I know online communication is often unclear), your tone is confusing me. Are you saying I am deceiving her? Believe me, if I refused the sale (which I do not intend to do), I would tell her why. And if you are referring to sewing a Green Scapular into this scapular, I don't honestly intend to do that either, however, you should know that if you read Green Scapular literature, you can see it has been used for years to aid spouses, friends, children, etc., very often without that person's knowledge. Such an action does not seem to be considered a "cruel trick." Most importantly, I cannot agree that it is wrong to "deprive" a buyer of my product. No one has the "right" to own my scapulars. If my scapulars were the only scapulars in the world, then, yes, absolutely, I would need to share them freely for the sake of souls. But as it is, scapulars can be purchased in many, many shops online. They may not be hand-embroidered or as one-of-a-kind as mine, but they are available. I am not depriving anyone of the blessing of a scapular. I put a great deal of attention and affection into my work, and I am, above all, respectful of what the images represent. I have a right to withdraw items from my shop. I have a right to decline a special commission request. Customers may indeed be purchasing for someone else, but in that case the customer is at liberty to tell me so if he/she is not happy with my decision. Anyway… rant over... :) I do appreciate your input on this situation, and the input of all the responders here (thank you all!). I feel better about what I should do now. No, I didn't say you intended to deceive someone, but there were many posters who were perfectly content in ensuring you that you should hide a different scapular inside or have it blessed. Hiding statues and scapulars without a person's consent and knowledge is sacraligious and in my opinion idol worship. God dosn't work though things, He works through prayer. People, however, are so obsessed with occult like behavior....even Catholic websites encourage the burial of a St. Joseph statute to sell a house. I find that sort of nonsense disturbing. Actually, once you enter the free market place then it is wrong not to sell to a willing buyer, not to mention illegal on the macro level. Just because you're on the micro level doesn't give you the right to discriminate against someone. You don't really get the right to be judge and jury over your buyers. They can do whatever they want with your product. And honestly, if someone wanted to do wrong, they could easily trick you and get any email they wanted...like Fr.Joe or such. Yes, it's nice if they treat it well, but you've agreed that your product is worth X amount of dollars. If you're unhappy with non-catholics or such shopping, you should close your shop entirely.
AuthorOfMyLife Posted October 21, 2014 Author Posted October 21, 2014 (edited) No, I didn't say you intended to deceive someone, but there were many posters who were perfectly content in ensuring you that you should hide a different scapular inside or have it blessed. Hiding statues and scapulars without a person's consent and knowledge is sacraligious and in my opinion idol worship. God dosn't work though things, He works through prayer. People, however, are so obsessed with occult like behavior....even Catholic websites encourage the burial of a St. Joseph statute to sell a house. I find that sort of nonsense disturbing. Actually, once you enter the free market place then it is wrong not to sell to a willing buyer, not to mention illegal on the macro level. Just because you're on the micro level doesn't give you the right to discriminate against someone. You don't really get the right to be judge and jury over your buyers. They can do whatever they want with your product. And honestly, if someone wanted to do wrong, they could easily trick you and get any email they wanted...like Fr.Joe or such. Yes, it's nice if they treat it well, but you've agreed that your product is worth X amount of dollars. If you're unhappy with non-catholics or such shopping, you should close your shop entirely. Okay, thank you for clarifying. Out of curiosity, do you have any specific link to the catechism, etc. that states that hiding statues, etc. is sacrilegious? I tried to look it up, but found nothing. You make a good point about things vs. prayer. This is why in my description of "what is a scapular," I emphasize that it isn't a magic charm, or a guarantee of salvation--it is a sacramental, an aid to devotion that isn't worth anything unless it is worn with the right intent. However, I still do not agree with you about what you are describing as discrimination. I would like to look into this more, and educate myself better. Certainly, I think that if someone purchases something directly from my shop, their case is different from someone who wants to request a custom order. I may be obliged to provide an item already paid for but I don't feel obliged to make something by special commission that I am not comfortable with. It isn't that I'm so scared that someone will abuse my work--and I know that a buyer with harm in mind could easily fool me. I just don't feel that making items/commission work available means the artist becomes completely helpless to make decisions about his/her work or abilities. I am not unhappy with non-Catholics shopping. I can't know who is a Catholic, who isn't, etc.--I don't want to know and don't try to find out. Unfortunately, in this case, I couldn't escape knowing about all the pagan/witchcraft involvement, since it was in the email, address, etc. And since I knew about it, I wanted to make sure I handled it properly. So wanting to do the right thing is what brought me here! [edited to correct spelling] Edited October 21, 2014 by AuthorOfMyLife
Gabriela Posted October 21, 2014 Posted October 21, 2014 Actually, once you enter the free market place then it is wrong not to sell to a willing buyer, not to mention illegal on the macro level. Just because you're on the micro level doesn't give you the right to discriminate against someone. By this logic, it would be wrong for me to not sell a rosary to someone who sent me an email saying, "Hey! I just saw the rosaries you make and I really want some for an upcoming event. I'm a Satanist and we like to hang rosaries around our ritual spaces where we desecrate the host in the most unimaginably vile and sacrilegious ways. Your glass rosaries would be perfect for smashing into the host with our combat boots. Can you send me 25 of them?" What ***Catholic*** authority would recommend that you sell rosaries to this person? Even if it were illegal to deny this person the work of your hands (which it is not), such a law would be unconscionable and so not bind Catholics. Judging by your posts of late, it sounds to me like your morality is grounded more in liberal economics and Randian egoism than it is in the One True Faith. How in the world you got the "Church Militant" tag I shall never understand. Combined with your generally confrontational tone, the content of your posts make it my personal opinion that your posts should be censored, or that your posting rights should be altogether revoked. At the very least, your "Church Militant" tag should be removed as shockingly misleading to lurkers and passers-by on PM.
Gabriela Posted October 21, 2014 Posted October 21, 2014 @AuthorOfMyLife: I think that you are doing the right thing, and I would not find it objectionable at all for you to sew a green scapular in between the panels of the brown one. Your goal is to convert this person, and that is a praiseworthy goal—our whole mission as Christians, actually. We have been hiding green scapulars in people's houses and belongings for over a century, and the practice has been a source of much consolation to the loved ones of pagans and of much conversion by pagans themselves, who, after the fact, were surely grateful for the intervention on behalf of their eternal souls. I think that you should follow your conscience, which is clearly well formed, and rest at ease doing whatever seems right to you in this matter.
blazeingstar Posted October 21, 2014 Posted October 21, 2014 By this logic, it would be wrong for me to not sell a rosary to someone who sent me an email saying, "Hey! I just saw the rosaries you make and I really want some for an upcoming event. I'm a Satanist and we like to hang rosaries around our ritual spaces where we desecrate the host in the most unimaginably vile and sacrilegious ways. Your glass rosaries would be perfect for smashing into the host with our combat boots. Can you send me 25 of them?" What ***Catholic*** authority would recommend that you sell rosaries to this person? Even if it were illegal to deny this person the work of your hands (which it is not), such a law would be unconscionable and so not bind Catholics. Judging by your posts of late, it sounds to me like your morality is grounded more in liberal economics and Randian egoism than it is in the One True Faith. How in the world you got the "Church Militant" tag I shall never understand. Combined with your generally confrontational tone, the content of your posts make it my personal opinion that your posts should be censored, or that your posting rights should be altogether revoked. At the very least, your "Church Militant" tag should be removed as shockingly misleading to lurkers and passers-by on PM. Well, I don't have the citations, but having gone to a decently rated business school I can assure you that any company on the free market in America protects the rights of minorities, gender, race, religion and sexuality. Perhaps it's different in other countries. But, America, yeah. The recent legal battle over making wedding cakes for homosexual weddings shows that in the eyes of the law you cannot. What you cannot be compelled to do is something against your religion, eg. create a cake with two brides, sell abortofacients, create a rosary with the devil at the end, etc. I am unsure of "by comission" work. I only know the law for work that has been created and is in the open market. However, given the nature of wedding cakes my guess is that taken to court you would have to create the objects the buyer requested if that is, indeed, what you are in business for. Why you are not allowed to sell blessed objects is really made clear in scenarios like this. Glass rosaries, in the end, are just beads with crosses. If every image of Jesus had to be treated with the utmost respect, then their's going to be a bunch of youth group kids who are really, really disappointed because I'm pretty sure plastering Jesus on a tee shirt is not very respectful of His image. This is precisely why we have blessed and unblessed objects.
blazeingstar Posted October 21, 2014 Posted October 21, 2014 @AuthorOfMyLife: I think that you are doing the right thing, and I would not find it objectionable at all for you to sew a green scapular in between the panels of the brown one. Your goal is to convert this person, and that is a praiseworthy goal—our whole mission as Christians, actually. We have been hiding green scapulars in people's houses and belongings for over a century, and the practice has been a source of much consolation to the loved ones of pagans and of much conversion by pagans themselves, who, after the fact, were surely grateful for the intervention on behalf of their eternal souls. I think that you should follow your conscience, which is clearly well formed, and rest at ease doing whatever seems right to you in this matter. Wrong. wrong. wrong. This is treating a blessed object as a magical talisman. The scapulars don't have magical powers to act alone. What can make a difference is the person who intends to convert remembering that there is an object in Joe Pagan's home. The object itself has no powers to change a person. This is why the promises of the brown scapular have no meaning unless one actually adheres to what Mary has laid out in the depths of their heart, not just on the surface.
AuthorOfMyLife Posted October 21, 2014 Author Posted October 21, 2014 Well, I don't have the citations, but having gone to a decently rated business school I can assure you that any company on the free market in America protects the rights of minorities, gender, race, religion and sexuality. Perhaps it's different in other countries. But, America, yeah. The recent legal battle over making wedding cakes for homosexual weddings shows that in the eyes of the law you cannot. That's too bad about the citations. I would have liked to see them. I haven't read much about the wedding cake issue, however, I would like to point out that just because something is legal doesn't make it right (abortion, anyone?), and by association, just because something is considered illegal by our government doesn't make it wrong. The courts of law have no guarantee of infallibility. All I can say is, I would fight for the right NOT to make something for someone if I felt it would be abused. I don't care what the law might say--no one has the right to demand something NON-ESSENTIAL of my time, talent, and energy. (I say "non-essential" because it would be different if I were offering an essential service of say, a medical nature--If I am a doctor and Joe Pagan has heart attack, I believe I'd be obliged to give him essential health care). Wrong. wrong. wrong. This is treating a blessed object as a magical talisman. The scapulars don't have magical powers to act alone. What can make a difference is the person who intends to convert remembering that there is an object in Joe Pagan's home. The object itself has no powers to change a person. This is why the promises of the brown scapular have no meaning unless one actually adheres to what Mary has laid out in the depths of their heart, not just on the surface. Again, this is why I explain to people that scapulars are not amulets but sacramentals that are an aid to holiness if used with the right intent. This is also why I do not have items blessed before I sell them. I send a note with my orders letting customers know the items are not blessed, and suggesting they have a priest bless them.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now